QUAERITUR: communal recitation of office in parishes during Triduum

From a reader:

 

In preparation for Holy Week I (for the first time ever) read PASCHALES SOLEMNITATIS and noted that in paragraph 40 it states that "It is recommended that there be a communal celebration of the Office of Readings and Morning Prayer on Good Friday and Holy Saturday."  I would like to have the opportunity to do this in my parish, although to my knowledge it has not been done in the past.  eBreviary actually provides the prayers in PDF form for these days free of charge.  I am considering asking our pastor if he would permit such a communal celebration in our parish chapel.  Would I be off base in doing so?  Is there anything that I need to take into account if we are given permission to go forward (i.e., is Morning Prayer on Good Friday and Holy Saturday at the same time as always – or is it prayed the night before [I am somewhat confused how these prayers relate to Tenebrae]?).

I don’t think it is off-base to ask to do something that is recommended by the Church.

The morning office, which has a special structure, during the Triduum is called "Tenebrae".
 
I think I will open this up to the readership.

What is going on in your parishes?

How did you get it going and what do you do?

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box | Tagged
21 Comments

Older, Smarter

From NASA comes this about one of the intrepid Mars Rovers… Opportunity:

NASA Mars Rover Getting Smarter as it Gets Older

NASA’s Mars Exploration Rover Opportunity, now in its seventh year on Mars, has a new capability to make its own choices about whether to make additional observations of rocks that it spots on arrival at a new location.

Older, SmarterSoftware uploaded this winter is the latest example of NASA taking advantage of the twin Mars rovers’ unanticipated longevity for real Martian test drives of advances made in robotic autonomy for future missions.

Now, Opportunity’s computer can examine images that the rover takes with its wide-angle navigation camera after a drive, and recognize rocks that meet specified criteria, such as rounded shape or light color. It can then center its narrower-angle panoramic camera on the chosen target and take multiple images through color filters.

"It’s a way to get some bonus science," said Tara Estlin of NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Pasadena, Calif. She is a rover driver, a senior member of JPL’s Artificial Intelligence Group and leader of development for this new software system.

The new system is called Autonomous Exploration for Gathering Increased Science, or AEGIS. Without it, follow-up observations depend on first transmitting the post-drive navigation camera images to Earth for ground operators to check for targets of interest to examine on a later day. Because of time and data-volume constraints, the rover team may opt to drive the rover again before potential targets are identified or before examining targets that aren’t highest priority.

The first images taken by a Mars rover choosing its own target show a rock about the size of a football, tan in color and layered in texture. It appears to be one of the rocks tossed outward onto the surface when an impact dug a nearby crater. Opportunity pointed its panoramic camera at this unnamed rock after analyzing a wider-angle photo taken by the rover’s navigation camera at the end of a drive on March 4. Opportunity decided that this particular rock, out of more than 50 in the navigation camera photo, best met the criteria that researchers had set for a target of interest: large and dark.

"It found exactly the target we would want it to find," Estlin said. "This checkout went just as we had planned, thanks to many people’s work, but it’s still amazing to see Opportunity performing a new autonomous activity after more than six years on Mars."

Older, SmarterOpportunity can use the new software at stopping points along a single day’s drive or at the end of the day’s drive. This enables it to identify and examine targets of interest that might otherwise be missed.

"We spent years developing this capability on research rovers in the Mars Yard here at JPL," said Estlin. "Six years ago, we never expected that we would get a chance to use it on Opportunity."

 The developers anticipate that the software will be useful for narrower field-of-view instruments on future rovers.

Other upgrades to software on Opportunity and its twin, Spirit, since the rovers’ first year on Mars have improved other capabilities. These include choosing a route around obstacles and calculating how far to reach out a rover’s arm to touch a rock. In 2007, both rovers gained the know-how to examine sets of sky images to determine which ones show clouds or dust devils, and then to transmit only the selected images. The newest software upload takes that a step further, enabling Opportunity to make decisions about acquiring new observations.

Older, SmarterThe AEGIS software lets scientists change the criteria it used for choosing potential targets. In some environments, rocks that are dark and angular could be higher-priority targets than rocks that are light and rounded, for example.

This new software system has been developed with assistance from NASA’s Mars Exploration Rover Project and with funding from the New Millennium Program, the Mars Technology Program, the JPL Interplanetary Network Development Program, and the Intelligent Systems Program. The New Millennium Program tests advanced technology in space flight. JPL, a division of the California Institute of Technology in Pasadena, manages the Mars Exploration Rover Project for the NASA Science Mission Directorate, Washington.
More information about the Mars rovers is online HERE.

Older, Smarter

In the meantime… poor Spirit….feisty Spirit….

NASA’s Mars Exploration Rover Spirit is now parked for the winter. The rover team is commanding Spirit this week to make additional preparations for the Mars southern hemisphere winter season. The team does not plan further motion of the wheels until spring comes to Spirit’s location beside the western edge of a low plateau called Home Plate.

On Sol 2169 (Feb. 8, 2010), the rover’s last drive before winter changed the angles of its suspension system, but it did not produce a hoped-for improvement to the overall tilt of the solar array for catching winter sunshine. Drives since Sol 2145 (Jan. 15, 2010) moved Spirit 34 centimeters (13 inches) south-southeastward. However, a counterclockwise yawing of the rover during the drives prevented it from reducing its southerly tilt.

Spirit will spend the coming winter tilted 9 degrees toward the south, an unfavorable attitude for the solar panels to catch rays from the sun in the northern sky. Spirit’s parking positions for its previous three Martian winters tilted northward. Engineers anticipate that, due to the unfavorable tilt for this fourth winter, Spirit will be out of communication with Earth for several months.  […]

Posted in Just Too Cool, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , ,
2 Comments

QUAERITUR: What if the congregation is having none of it?

From a reader:

Dear Father, I am a little exasperated at this point and wondered what you would have to say about certain matters.

I know, you know, and readers of your blog will know, that we need to return to a theocentric Christianity, with Worship that allows us to encounter the living God as totally Other, as transcendent, and as Mystery.

What is a person (or priest) to do if the congregation will simply have none of it?

Recently our parish started a Gregorian Chant choir. Three people were interested (in a parish of over 700 families!). Others told the pastor that they would leave the parish if we started using Gregorian Chant at Mass, or Latin, or Ad Orientem, or the Extraordinary Form, or male-only altar servers.

None of the other parishes around do any of those things and so these people would have many places to go (and their money and support as well).

What is a sacristan (or priest) to do when the area in which he is stationed is more focused on sports than Sunday Mass? Do you know how hard it is to have Solemn Mass (even with bad music and all in english but at least use incense, torch-bearers, an MC, etc) when all the servers are out at soccer/baseball tournaments? Not to mention that they are no allowed to miss any since they would be kicked off the team! Our 7:00pm Sunday is usually packed (and people still show up late!) because of all the people catching the "last opportunity" for Mass since they’ve now done everything else they wanted to do. I feel like there is hope here.

If the parishoners hate traditional worship that much and are willing to leave to go to the Church across the highway, then all their support goes as well. If no one cares enough to attend Mass on Sunday morning, or make sure they are on time, how is a parish supposed to have servers/musicians in order to transform the way we worship in the first place?

 

I understand your concerns.

I must start by saying that a sacristan can do nothing but pray and follow the directives from the parish priest.

One question we have to ask, I think, is whether or not implementing more faithful and/or more traditional liturgy is the right thing to do. 

If it is, then it must be done because it is the right thing to do.

That doesn’t mean that it must be done in one fell swoop.  It can be done incrementally.

Also, when we do what we must do, we must prepare and explain.  People have to have the changes explained.  That is something that a sacristan or other lay people can do, I suppose: be able to explain what is going on, why it is being done.  Whenever I have received notes that a priest has implemented some traditional practice, and he has done so with explanations beforehand, things have gone pretty well and people have accepted the changes.  

From another point of view, if people are so detached from Holy Mass if their faith and Holy Mass are that far down the list of what is important, then perhaps shaking things up a little is a good idea.  And if they leave, they are only taking their money: in the other important ways, they are gone already. 

We need to ask God to bless these projects and provide for our needs as we sacrifice for the sake of worthy worship and better engagement and active participation.

Finally, we have to have patience.  I know one priest who took over a fairly prosperous parish where the word "sin" probably hadn’t been mentioned for a very long time.  It took him years, but he got rid of the abuses and has shifted the whole liturgical practice around.  Along the way and sure there were gripers and naysayers.  No doubt some people left for other places.   Without question other people started coming because of the good changes.

None of us like conflict.  We don’t relish people going away in a huff.  But we have to be willing to hold the door open for them if they seek to impose what is wrong on Holy Church’s worship and, for the sake of their error or ego, resist correction which is well explained and prepared.

When St. Augustine of Hippo (+430) talks about how Christ, as Physician, applies sometimes painful corrections in our lives in an effort to save us and heal us, he says,

"The doctor doesn’t stop cutting just because the patient is screaming for him to stop."

Priests are shepherds, fathers, doctors of souls.  Sometimes they have to do the unpleasant parts of those roles.  The dopey sheep who get’s stuck in a muck hole doesn’t like the extraction process.  Kids don’t like being corrected.  Patients don’t enjoy surgery.

I am sure that some priests can chime in here with their own experiences and pointers.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
85 Comments

Hey bishops! Priests! A French bishop who really understands worship! Read… learn.

Around a thousand people (so it seemed at least) sent me links to and texts of a speech given by a French bishops, H.E. Most Rev. Marc Aillet, Bishop of Bayonne.  Bp. Aillet had been the vicar general of the French Diocese of Fréjus-Toulon, which you may recall has a seminary for the training of men in both Extraordinary as well as the Ordinary Form, a diocese where the men can choose with which rite, pre-Conciliar or post-Conciliar they desire to be ordained (I hope I am right about that, btw.).

Bp. Aillet has given a talk entitled, "Wounded Liturgy", found in Italian on Messa in latino and given a quick translation on NLM, who did us all a service in posting it for English readers.  I don’t have the time at the moment to work up an English version, but here is the NLM version, rough in spots, with my emphases and comments and few items tidied up.  The French is here.

Keep in mind, as you read, that Pope Benedict has communicated in several concrete ways that we must revitalize our worship in order to revitalize our Catholic identity.  I think he has what I compare often to a "Marshall Plan" for rebuilding our identity in the wake of the devastation we have experienced as a Church for the last few decades.

Wounded Liturgy

Bp. AilletAt the origin of the Liturgical Movement was the will of Pope Saint Pius X, especially in the motu proprio Tra le Sollecitudini (1903), to restore the liturgy and make its riches more accessible in order for it to become again the source of an authentically Christian life, to underscore the challenge of a growing secularisation [which is a major concern of WDTPRS] and to encourage the faithful to consecrate the world to God. Thence, the conciliar definition of the liturgy as "source and summit of the life and mission of the Church." Against all expectations, as has often been pointed out by Pope John Paul II and Benedict XVI, the implementation of the liturgical reform has sometimes lead to a kind of systematic desacralisation, while the liturgy was allowed to become ever more pervaded by the secularised culture of the surrounding world, thus losing its own nature and [wait for it…] its identity: "This mystery of Christ the Church proclaims and celebrates in her liturgy so that the faithful may live from it and bear witness to it in the world" (CCC 1068).

Without denying the true fruits of the liturgical reform, [Don’t worry about phrases like that.  I think everyone has to use these formulaic lines.] one can say however, that the liturgy has been wounded by what John Paul II has defined as "unacceptable practices" (Ecclesia de Eucharistia, n. 10) and Benedict XVI denounced as "deformations which were hard to bear"(Letter to the Bishops on the occasion of the publication of the motu proprio Summorum Pontificum). [Thus…] Thus also the identity of the Church and of the priest was wounded.  [NB: When the text of Summorum Pontificum was released, I wrote and spoke in many places that Pope Benedict had given in this Motu Proprio a great gift especially to priests.  SP is a rare document that favors, for a change, the priest in stead of continuing to build up – perhaps in an unfettered way – the figure and power of bishops, which hasn’t always served us well.  SP has offered a priests a way to learn more about what they are doing at the altar and who they are as priests.   As priests learn and use the older forms, they will be deeply affected. This will in turn affect their flocks.  It’s all about identity, friends, and that means the priest and our worship.]

In the years after the Council, we witnessed a kind of dialectical opposition between the defenders of liturgical worship and the promoters of the opening to the world. Because the latter ultimately reduced the Christian life to social efforts alone, based on a secular interpretation of the faith [The Church reduced to an instrument of social change.] , the former, in reaction, took refuge in the pure liturgy up to "rubricism", with the risk of encouraging the faithful to protect themselves excessively from the world. [The Church reduced to a fly in amber.] In the Apostolic Exhortation Sacramentum Caritatis, Pope Benedict XVI puts an end to this controversy and reunites this opposition. [In theory perhaps.  I think we all know that the conflict is not over.] The liturgical action must reconcile faith and life. [Not quite sure what that means.   But this next part will find strong objection from, for example, some writers of the SSPX, who object to the whole "Paschal Mystery" model of for worship, especially Mass.] Precisely as the celebration of the Paschal Mystery of Christ, made truly present among his people, the liturgy gives a Eucharistic form to the whole Christian life to make it a "spiritual worship pleasing to God." Thus, the commitment of the Christian in the world and the world itself, through the liturgy, are called to be consecrated to God. [Don’t know what that meant.] The commitment of the Christian in the mission of the Church and in society find, in fact, its source and its impulse in the liturgy, up to being drawn into the dynamism of the offering of love of Christ that is made present therein.  [I get the drift here.  This is a little dreamy, but the point is that, as I take it, and I think this is borne out below, through the Church’s worship the transcendent is supposed to break into the immanent, give it the right impulse, direction, and meaning.]

The primacy that Benedict XVI intends to give the liturgy in the Church – "Liturgical worship is the supreme expression of priestly and episcopal life," [Therefore Summorum Pontificum – which frees the use of the older forms of worship – is of huge importance in Benedict’s "primacy".] he told the bishops of France gathered in Lourdes on September 14, 2008, in an Extraordinary Plenary Assembly – wants to put adoration back at the center of the life of the priest and of the faithful. Instead and in place of "secular Christianity" that has often accompanied the implementation of the reform of the liturgy, Pope Benedict XVI intends to promote a "theological Christianity" , the only one able to serve what he has called the priority that predominates in this phase of history, i.e. "to make God present in this world and to give people access to God" (Letter to the Bishops of the Catholic Church, March 10, 2009). [I wonder if it wouldn’t be better here to say "theocentric Christianity"?  Worship which presents first and foremost God as transcendent, Christocentrism uniting the transcendent and immanent. ? ?  But get this next bit…] Where, in fact, better than in the liturgy, does the priest deepen his identity, [identity!  Therefore, when the priest also gets the provisions of SP straight, his identity is touched.] so well defined by the author of Hebrews: "For every high priest taken from among men, is ordained for men in the things that appertain to God, that he may offer up gifts and sacrifices for sins."(Heb 5, 1)?

The opening to the world called for by Vatican II has often been interpreted, in the years after the Council, as a sort of "conversion to secularisation": This attitude was not lacking in generosity, but it led to obscuring the importance of the liturgy and to minimise the need for observing the rites, which were considered too distant from the life of the world which had to be love [luv?] and with whom one had to be fully connected, up to being fascinated by it. [Engrossed in the world, that is.  The primacy of the immanent.  Sounds like the fruit of modernism tree.] The result was [NB] a grave crisis of identity of the priest ["identity of the priest"] who could no longer perceive the importance of the salvation of souls and the need to announce to the world the newness of the Gospel of Salvation. [He becomes, instead, a facilitator for the secular, this-worldly projects of the Church which becomes interpreted in the human, horizontal, sense as an entity for social change rather than the means by which we are saved for eternal life.] The liturgy is, without doubt, the privileged place of deepening the identity of the priest, called to "fight the secularization"; for, as Jesus says, in his priestly prayer: "I pray not that thou shouldst take them out of the world, but that thou shouldst keep them from evil. They are not of the world, as I also am not of the world. Sanctify them in truth. Thy word is truth." (John 17, 15-17).  [I think he is exactly right.  And I bring back here my comments about Summorum Pontificum as a gift especially for priests.]

This certainly will be possible through a more rigorous observation of the liturgical norms that preserve the priest from the requirement, even the unconscious one, to draw the attention of the faithful on his person: [The older form of Mass favors this more than the newer form, but celebrating the newer form versus Deum, ad orientem, would help immediately and profoundly.] the liturgical ritual which the celebrant is called to receive filially from the Church in fact allows the faithful to come more easily to the presence of Christ the Lord, of which the liturgical celebration must be a telling sign, and which must always come first. The liturgy is wounded when the faithful are left to the arbitrariness of the celebrant, his quirks, his personal ideas or opinions, to his own wounds. Hence also follows the importance of not banalising the rites which, [the rites…] tearing us away from the secular world and thus from the temptation of immanentism, [the rites are supposed to tear us away from the worldly and over-stressing of the immanent.] have the gift [This next part will sound very familiar to anyone who has read anything I have written or said in conferences for the last few years…] to immerse us suddenly in the Mystery [! "encounter with MYSTERY" which is fearsome and alluring!] and open ourselves to the Transcendent. In this sense, one can never stress enough the importance of the silence preceding the liturgical celebration, an inner narthex, where we are freed of the concerns, even if legitimate, of the secular world, in order to enter the sacred space and time where God will reveal his Mystery; [Think of Moses, placed by God behind a cleft in the rock in Exodus 33!] [sc. one can never stress enough the importance] of silence in the liturgy to open oneself more readily to the action of God; [i.e., active participation is active receptivity] and [sc. one can never stress enough] the appropriateness of a period of thanksgiving, integrated or not into celebration, to apprehend the inner extent of the mission that awaits us, once we were back in the world. The obedience of the priest to the rubrics is also itself a silent and eloquent sign of his love for the Church of which he is but the minister, i.e. the servant.

Hence also the importance of the formation of future priests in the liturgy and especially in the interior participation, without which the outward participation advocated by the reform [again, participation is first interior and then it comes to external expression] would be soulless and would favor a partial understanding of the liturgy that would express itself in terms of excessive theatricalisation of the roles, reductive cerebralisation of the rites and abusive self-celebration of the assembly. [self-sufficiency… the closed circle… etc.] If active participation, which is the operating principle of the liturgical reform, is not the exercise of the "supernatural sense of faith," the liturgy is no longer the work of Christ, but of men. [Another fruit of the modernist tree.] Stressing the importance of liturgical formation of priests, Vatican Council II made the liturgy one of the main subjects of ecclesiastical studies, avoiding reducing it to a purely intellectual formation: in fact, prior to being an object of study, the liturgy is living, [I think we need to use the word "worship" more often than "liturgy"…] or rather, is "to transcend one’s own life to merge into the life of Christ." It is the ultimate immersion of all Christian life: immersion in the sense of faith and in the sense of the Church, in praise and in adoration, as in the mission.

We are therefore called to a true "Sursum corda". The phrase from the preface, "lift up your hearts", introduces the faithful to the heart of hearts of the liturgy: Christ’s Passover, that is, his passing from this world to the Father. The meeting of the Risen Jesus with Mary Magdalene on the morning of the Resurrection, is very significant in this sense: with his "Noli me tangere" Jesus invites Mary Magdalene to "look to the realities of the highest", making her realise in her heart that he is not yet ascended to the Father and requesting her to go and tell his disciples that he must go up to his God and our God, his Father and our Father. The liturgy is exactly the place of this elevation, this stretching towards God which gives life a new horizon, and thereby its decisive orientation. Provided that we do not regard it as material available to our all too human manipulations, but that we observe, with filial obedience, the prescriptions of Holy Church.

As Pope Benedict XVI stated in the conclusion of his homily on the Solemnity of Saints Peter and Paul in 2008: "When the world as a whole will have become liturgy of God, when in its reality it will have become worship, then it will have achieved its goal, then will it be safe and sound.

 

WDTPRS kudos to Bp. Aillet.

Imagine how alone he is in his conference.

Support him with a prayer before clicking away from this page?

Posted in Brick by Brick, Our Catholic Identity, SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM | Tagged , , ,
22 Comments

What did Rep. Stupak really say?

Is this what Rep. Stupak really thought all that time he was giving the impression that he was fighting for the life of the unborn?

This video is from a town hall meeting in November 2009.

Play video

Biretta tip    o{]:¬) to The Sacred Page.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
51 Comments

Fr. Blake responds to Mr. Warner

Yesterday I posted Gerald Warner’s fulmination against bishops and Vatican II.  

My friend Fr. Ray Blake, pastor of St. Mary Magdalen in Brighton, has a response to Mr. Warner.

 Yesterday, Gerald Warner created a bit of a stir by provacatively claiming that sexual abuse was a post Vatican II problem.

    How could clergy transgress so gravely against the doctrines of the Church? What doctrines? These offences took place in the wake of Vatican II, when doctrines were being thrown out like so much lumber. These offenders were the children of Paul VI and “aggiornamento”. Once you have debauched the Mystical Body of Christ, defiling altar boys comes easily.

    The “neglected” sacraments and devotional practices that the Pope says could have prevented this did not just wither on the vine: they were actively discouraged by bishops and priests. In the period when this abuse was rampant, there was just one mortal sin in the Catholic Church: daring to celebrate or attend the Latin Tridentine Mass. A priest raping altar boys would be moved to another parish; as for a priest who had the temerity to celebrate the Old Mass – his feet would not touch the ground.

In order for him to uphold his thesis he would have to prove that sexual abuse either didn’t happen before the VII or was much, much rarer. I don’t think that is possible to prove. Indeed many of the cases now coming to light in Germany and Austria are cases where the alleged clerical perpetrator is now dead, some of them happened in the 1950s, before the Council and many of the abusers were trained and ordained before Council.

The Pope has linked this "filth" to a loss of faith, secular commentators have linked it to celibacy, Warner links it to "trendy bishops". All three are right.

The Pope of course is the most right. I watched a video recently in which an Irish priest famed for his work amongst street children said of conversion, "we’ve moved beyond all that". I suspect he meant: we are concerned with making a better world but without personal Salvation. [Which would actually make the world more dangerous.]

It is not VII, it is the loss of the centrality of Christ in the Church that is the heart of the problem. [At this point, I think some would suggest to Fr. Blake that the documents of Vatican II are not always clearly Christocentric.] I think that it would be provable that the crisis is the fruit of Modernism, a direct result of the dethroning of God, a violation of the first commandment. Modernism saps belief in the power of Grace. It destroys any understanding of the Church’s mission. It transforms holy dynamic celibacy into self-serving bachelorhood. It robs the priesthood and religious life of any transcendent meaning and can so often reduce it to empty loneliness. [Well said.]

The great exeunt from the Church after the Humanae Vitae was a crisis greater than this present one, seems not to have been a crisis over the restatement of the traditional doctrines of the Christian faith but a dam break of pre-Concilliar liberal Modernist thought.

Warner is wrong to lay this crisis at the door of VII but I suspect he is not wrong to lay it the door of "the spirit of VII". [Qui bene distinguit bene docet.] Certainly the "rupture" with the past brought about an undermining of the spirituality of the Church, cutting many off from the roots that not only gave nourishment but also support.

Warner blames post-Concilliar liturgy as being an important constituent part of the crisis, which is worth considering. One of the things that has been going through my mind recently, is the Pope’s expression, "the closed circle" describing "ad populum" celebration of the Mass. [Do I hear and "Amen!"?] If that is the constant presentation of the image of the Church in its public worship, it is easy to juxtapose this image with cover-up. The "closed circle" tends to be self serving and self interested, it tends to look to itself and be self-preserving and self congratulatory. If the priest, when he prays is constantly looking to the congregation, is he not likely to be concerned with the congregation’s validation.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , ,
34 Comments

NYC – 25 March – Solemn Mass for Life – Holy Innocents Church

I received this PRESS RELEASE:

CARDINAL WILL PREACH AT SOLEMN MASS MARKING 15TH ANNIVERSARY OF PRO-LIFE ENCYCLICAL

New York, March 21, 2010 – New York’s Agnus Dei Council of the Knights of Columbus announced today that Edward Cardinal Egan would attend and preach the homily at a Solemn Mass for the Feast of the Annunciation but that he would not celebrate a Pontifical Mass as planned and announced.  This Mass will mark the 15th anniversary of Evangelium Vitae (The Gospel of Life), the pro-life encyclical by Pope John Paul II issued on March 25, 1995.
In a brief statement received last week, the Cardinal asked that his celebration of the Pontifical Mass “scheduled for March 25th at Holy Innocents Parish be postponed to a later date.”  The statement to the Knights explained the reason for postponing the Pontifical celebration:

“Because of so many commitments over the last several weeks, the Cardinal has not had time to prepare for the Mass properly.  He looks forward to arranging another date with the Knights of Columbus . . . whose invitation he deeply appreciates.”

His Eminence will nevertheless attend and preach the homily at a Solemn Mass for the Feast of the Annunciation according to the 1962 Missal celebrated by Fr. James Miara of the Archdiocese of New York.  The Solemn Mass begins at 7:30 PM at the Church of the Holy Innocents, 128 W. 37th Street, in Manhattan, home to New York City’s Shrine of the Unborn.  Before Mass, there will be a Rosary for Life at 7:00 PM.

WHAT:    Solemn Mass for Life, Edward Cardinal Egan, Homilist
WHERE:  The Church of the Holy Innocents, 128 W. 37th Street, Manhattan
WHEN:  Thursday, March 25th; Rosary for Life, 7 PM; Solemn Mass, 7:30 PM

For more information, call (212) 569-1252 or visit www.traditionalknight.com.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

Gerald Warner’s thunder about the abuse scandal and what caused it

The Telegraph offers this by Gerald Warner (Gerald Warner is an author, broadcaster, columnist and polemical commentator who writes about politics, religion, history, culture and society in general.)

My emphases and comments:

Catholic sex abuse scandal: time to sack trendy bishops and restore the faith

By
Gerald Warner

It has become fashionable to claim that the sex abuse scandal currently afflicting the Catholic Church is “its biggest crisis since the Reformation”. Oh, really? Tell me about it. The abuse issue is just a small part of the much larger crisis that has engulfed the Church since the Second Vatican Catastrophe and which is more serious than the Reformation. [And we’re off…!]

Abolish clerical celibacy? The last thing a priest abusing altar boys needs or wants is a wife. There is no compulsory celibacy in the Church of England, but that has not prevented vicars and boy scouts furnishing gratifying amounts of copy to the tabloid Sunday papers for the past century. Celibacy goes against the grain of today’s “unrepressed”, “non-judgemental”, let-it-all-hang-out attitude to sex; its continued existence is a reproach to the hedonist Western world; [actually… everything Catholic is that… not just celibacy…] so Rome must be persuaded to abolish it [not "persuaded", but "intimidated", "beaten-down", "badgered"] – likewise its condemnation of divorce, abortion, contraception, homosexuality and all the other fetishes of liberal society. Dream on, secularists.

“Irish abuse victims disappointed by Pope’s letter.” Of course they are. They were disappointed by it before they had read it, before it was even written. [NB:] Any other response would diminish the power they find themselves wielding against the Church.[!]  Have they a legitimate grievance? In most cases, yes. They have a ferocious grievance against the “filth” (Benedict XVI’s term, long before he came under public pressure) who defiled them and treated them like animals.

How could clergy transgress so gravely against the doctrines of the Church? What doctrines? These offences took place in the wake of Vatican II, when doctrines were being thrown out like so much lumber. These offenders were the children of Paul VI and “aggiornamento”. Once you have debauched the Mystical Body of Christ, defiling altar boys comes easily. 

The “neglected” sacraments and devotional practices that the Pope says could have prevented this did not just wither on the vine: they were actively discouraged by bishops and priests. [This is where I need to intervene.  I am sure that some of the more traddy stripe are crowing as they read.  I would remind them to supress that reptilian brain-stem a little and recall – before reading the next self-affirming quote – that we are all in this together.  When clergy and lay people of the Church fall down, every one suffers.  The whole Church needs to help the fallen to rise again.  We need to do that by raising the level of holiness, of penance, and worthy worship, just as a rising tide raises every boat.  Read on, now, and feel that affirmation…] In the period when this abuse was rampant, there was just one mortal sin in the Catholic Church: daring to celebrate or attend the Latin Tridentine Mass. [And that is pretty close the the truth!] A priest raping altar boys would be moved to another parish; as for a priest who had the temerity to celebrate the Old Mass – his feet would not touch the ground. [They were – and in some places still are – treated in much the same way.]

There was a determined resolve among the bishops to deny any meaningful catechesis to the young. That is the generation, wholly ignorant of the faith, that in Ireland achieved material prosperity in the “Celtic Tiger” economy. Initially it still attended Mass (or what passed for Mass) out of social conformity. Then the sex abuse scandal gave Irish post-Vatican II agnostics the perfect pretext for apostasy: tens of thousands who had never been abused, nor met anybody who had, found an excuse to stay in bed on Sunday mornings.

The abusive priests are not the only hypocrites. [This is so common today…] “I am so shocked by the abuse scandal I am leaving the Church.” Right. So, the fact that some degenerates who should never have been ordained violated young people – in itself a deplorable sin – means that the Son of God did not come down to earth, redeem mankind on the cross and found the Church? This appalling scandal no more compromises the truths of the Faith than the career of Alexander VI or any other corrupt Renaissance Pope.  [Tell that to people with increasingly thin critical thinking skills and who are slaves of the mass media.]

Should bishops be forced to resign? Oh yes – approximately 95 per cent of them worldwide. [!] These clowns in their pseudo-ethnic mitres and polyester vestments with faux-naïve Christian symbols, spouting their ecumaniac episcobabble, [whew!] have presided over more than sexual abuse: [here it comes] they have all but extinguished the Catholic faith with their modernist fatuities. [Do I hear an "Amen!"?] They should be retired to monasteries to spend their remaining years considering how to account to their Maker for a failed stewardship that has lost countless millions of souls.

Benedict XVI should take advantage of a popular wave of revulsion against the failed episcopate to sack every 1960s flared-trousered hippy who is obstructing Summorum Pontificum. It is a unique opportunity to cull the hireling shepherds and clear away the dead wood of the Second Vatican Catastrophe. It is time to stop the apologies and reinstate apologetics; to rebuild all that has been destroyed in the past 40 years; to square up to liberals and secularists as so many generations of Catholics did in the past; to proclaim again the immutable truths of the One True Church that, in the glory of the Resurrection, can have no legitimate posture other than triumphalism.

Okay!  I am sure you are all ready to suit up and ride into battle now.

And that is a good idea. 

But the triumphalism he suggests will be empty unless we all do penance, also for the sins of others.

We must also have a revitalization of Holy Church’s worship.  What we have been doing for the last few decades is not working.

Something of my "manifesto" after the Notre Shame Debacle could be relevant here.

I urge all priests and bishops who read this blog with any slight quaver of resonance or benevolence, to consider this with care:

If you sense that something quite serious and important is going on right now, for the love of God rethink your approach to how you foster Holy Church’s proper public worship .

Do all in your power and through your influence to foster a worship of God which conforms not to worldly goals – as praiseworthy as they may be in a world still dominated by its dire prince – but rather to the real point of religion: an encounter with mystery. 

Our worship must become more and more focused on the one who is Other.  Seek what is truly above in your rites and raise people to encounter mystery.

You will be challenged and reviled, blocked and attacked as you do.  You will be worn down and afraid under the weight of resistance.

But I think that to save the world we must save the liturgy.

The Church’s enemies, the Church’s deeply confused, can’t compete with the fullness of Catholic liturgy and sound preaching.

Reforming the liturgy along the lines Pope Benedict has proposed may be the most loving and effective option we have in these ever hotter times.

People will have to keep working very much in the sphere of the secular.  Of course!  Our inward Catholic Christian identity must find outward expression and bring concrete fruits.

But I think the real work now – where we will make some effective headway – must be done at the level of our public worship.

In the present circumstances, we are not going to argue most people out of danger or error.  But together we can draw them in and along and back through worship.

So long as we remain doctrinally faithful and active in works of mercy both spiritual and especially temporal, if we get our public worship together we will have a strong bastion against error. 

Holy Catholic worship will be an attractive force for conversion.

We need to foster worship which stuns, which leaves the newcomer, long-time practicing Catholic, above all the fallen-away simply thunder stuck.  Worship must at some point leave people speechless in awe.  We need language and music and gesture which in its beauty floods the mind with light even while it swells the heart to bursting.

The more people encounter mystery through liturgy, the more hollow will clang the false or incomplete messages of those who have strayed from the good path, either to the left or to the right.  

Our goal must be that which is good and beautiful because it is true, that which reflects what is of God, not man’s image merely.  Give us mystery, not fabrications smacking of the world, fallen and transitory.

Fathers, and you Reverend Bishops, if anything of alarm has sounded in your hearts and minds of late, rethink your approach to our worship.  Examine your approach with an eye on the signs of the times.  Take a new approach. 

The approach we have had least last few decades isn’t getting it done.  Really … it isn’t

Going neither left nor right along the road toward the Lord, even as He comes to us, take the flock now deeper, now higher on that path, but always to encounter the mystery which distinguishes truly Catholic liturgy… and therefore true Catholics.

Lines are being drawn, sides taken, choices made.

More than ever we need what Christ, the true Actor of our liturgy, desires to offer us through Holy Church’s worship.

Posted in Our Catholic Identity, The future and our choices | Tagged
60 Comments

Pro-life Democrat voting stats on healthcare bill

From Jill Stanek:

# The only pro-life Democrat to change his vote from a yes to a no due to the failure to include the Stupak-Pitts amendment was Rep. Dan Lipinski (D-IL), …. (Lipinski is the congressman for the district in which Christ Hospital, my [Jill Stanek’s] former employer, is located. His father, Congressman Bill Lipinski, was a co-sponsor of the Born Alive Infants Protection Act.)

# Other pro-life Democrats who had previously threatened to change their votes from a yes to a no, agreed to an Executive Order reiterating the Senate bill’s accounting scheme in exchange for their votes at the last minute. 20 of the Members who were urged to change their vote from a "yes" to "no" on pro-life grounds, but failed to do so are: Carney (PA), Costello (IL), Dahlkemper (PA), Donnelly (IN), Doyle (PA), Driehaus (OH), Ellsworth (IN), Hill (IN), Kanjorski (PA), Kaptur (OH), Kildee (MI), Langevin (RI), Mollohan (WV), Oberstar (MN), Ortiz (TX), Perriello (VA), Pomeroy (NC), Rahall (WV), Stupak (MI), and Wilson (OH)….

# 19 pro-life Democrats voted against the Senate bill and for the motion to recommit. They are Altmire* (PA), Barrow* (GA), Berry* (AR), Boren (OK), Bright (AL), Chandler* (KY), Childers (MS), L. Davis (TN), Holden (PA), Lipinski (IL), Marshall (GA), Matheson (UT)*, McIntyre (NC), Melancon (LA)*, Peterson (MN), Ross (AR)*, Shuler (NC), Skelton (MO), and Taylor (MS). (* denotes Members with a limited or mixed pro-life voting record.)

# Representatives Costello (IL) and Donnelly (IN) both voted for the Senate bill, but also vote for the motion to recommit.

# Representatives Artur Davis (AL), Lynch (MA), Space (OH), and Tanner (TN) voted against the Senate bill, but also voted against the motion to recommit despite having voted for a similar amendment offered last fall.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
43 Comments

QUAERITUR: priest gives horrible, erroneous counsel in confession; to whom do I turn?

From a reader:

Christ has given me the heavy cross of same sex attractions to carry (I’m 26). Today I confessed matter regarding same sex activity and I was [get this] told by the Priest that I should get a Boyfriend and settle down with him, [Total fail.] he told me he knows of homosexual couples active in the church and that they receive communion, times have changed and attitudes towards homosexuals have as well. The Priest was in his late seventies.  [And he had better get worried about standing befor God and receiving a horrible judgment for his failure to teach the truth and for confusing the faithful.]

So I have another Priest who I wont go to confession to due to his lack of orthodoxy. I have informed the Archbishop … of being told similar advice in the past and he doesn’t want to know the name of the Priest, although he did apologise to me for it.

Who is the proper authority in the Church that I should write to, to inform them of this kind of nonsense?

I now know why the scandal in Ireland took place.

The problem with writing to the Holy See about something like this is that it is a matter of the internal forum, that is, the priest cannot talk about it since it is a matter of the confessional and therefore under the Seal.

When you write to a dicastery of the Holy See, you really need to present something concrete they can work with.  Best are actual church bulletins, photos, written documents, recordings of talks, sermons, etc.

 

You took steps to inform the local Archbishop.  That was the best thing to do.  At this point there isn’t much else unless you start hearing from other people similar problems about what he is saying in the confessional.

The office of the Holy See that would deal with this sort of thing would have to be the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.  If there were any aspect of the case that would require the aid of another Congregation, they would take care of that.

Again, just saying to them that you heard this in confession isn’t going to help much.  Even if they did contact the bishop or priest, the priest is bound by the Seal and could very rightly refuse to speak about the situation one way or another.

In the mean time, I apologize for that jackass move of his and pray that you will not be discouraged both in your personal spiritual warfare and suffering.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box | Tagged
46 Comments