LifeSite: Obama as Provocateur of Catholic Dissention

I am sure some of you recall that during the Notre Shame debacle I repeated constantly that Pres. Obama was trying purposely to subvert the Catholic community.  Some of you said I was crying "Wolf!".

This is from Lifesite:

Architect of Betrayal?: WH Exposes Obama as Provocateur of Catholic Dissention

By Peter J. Smith and Kathleen Gilbert

WASHINGTON, DC, March 18, 2010 (LifeSiteNews.com) – White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs revealed to reporters today that President Barack Obama actively promoted the Catholic Health Association’s public break with the American Catholic bishops to support his health care legislation.  [Read that again.  Slowly.  Remember it.]

Gibbs also suggested that the CHA and the Leadership Conference of Women Religious’ (LCWR) break with the U.S. Bishops has provided legitimate political cover for pro-life Democrats to switch their votes from "no" to "yes."  [Read that again.]

"I think over the past twenty four hours we have seen strong indications from those in the Catholic Church that support our belief that the legislation is about health care reform, and that it shouldn’t and doesn’t change the existing federal law [on abortion]. [And I think that is a lie.  But… you decide.] The Catholic Health Association and the order of nun’s support [NB…]  is very important," Gibbs told reporters on the White House lawn for Thursday’s press conference.

CHA president Sr. Carol Keehan and LCWR sparked an uproar this week after they came out definitively in favor of the Senate health care bill, which top pro-life organizations such as the National Right to Life Committee and the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, in addition to countless others, have strongly condemned as unacceptable for its abortion funding provisions. Since then, in their quest to woo the final pro-life Democrat holdouts among House lawmakers, party leaders have attempted to paint CHA’s support for the bill as a bona fide endorsement from the Catholic community.  [Get that?  CHA’s support was "bona fide endoresment from the CATHOLIC community"?  This is why I wrote "A magisterium of nuns".  They have set themselves up as an alternative magisterium to that of the Church with the bishops.]

So far, the president’s strategy appears to have paid off: some lawmakers have evidently already taken the two groups’ endorsements as an excuse to switch their vote. [I hate being right about things like this.]

Gibbs cited Congressman Dale Kildee’s (D-MI) Wednesday press conference – in which he explained how CHA’s endorsement had "affected his thinking" to get him to support the bill – as a sign that [NB] Democrats may be able to get more lawmakers on board in the same way.

Gibbs said that the president had been engaged on the issue, and a reporter asked if he had reached out personally to the groups.

"The President met earlier this week with Sr. Keehan of the CHA," said Gibbs, saying the meeting took place in the Roosevelt Room, but that he "did not get a detailed run-down of the pitch that [Obama] made."

"I do know that he was effusive about her support and her as a person for making the courageous statements that she has," he said.  [And I bet he doesn’t remember her name today.]

Rep. Marcy Kaptur (D-OH), one of the pro-life Democrat holdouts against the bill, pointed out this week that, as a trade association, the Catholic Health Association (CHA) has more at stake with the bill’s passage than it may openly admit.

"I think the hospitals have a different perspective because they’re running large institutions," Kaptur said. "They have a lot of issues at stake. [Remember: Just because a nun works in a hospital, that doesn’t mean she gets to set up her own magisterium in opposition to the bishops.] They have to balance their budgets and so forth. I think that the Bishops are probably in a different position. I don’t think that they’re really managerially responsible for these institutions."

Unlike the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, [TAKE CAREFUL NOTE…] CHA is a for-profit entity, and analysts have pointed out that it would greatly benefit financially from the passage of the bill. [And?] CHA had already promised large sums of money to the Obama administration in July to help pass the legislation – before it was ever crafted.

 

I say, close their hospitals…. take the name "Catholic" away from them completely as institutions.

Posted in Our Catholic Identity, The Drill |
47 Comments

More proof that Speaker Pelosi isn’t interested in reducing the number of abortions

If we needed it, here is more proof that Nancy Pelosi isn’t interested in reducing the number of abortions.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

REVIEW: New book by Aidan Nichols: Criticising the Critics

UPDATE 20 March: I am getting emails from people asking how they can get the book I was reading on the airplane yesterday (see that entry).  I am reposting this entry for their benefit.

__________

ORIGINAL entry 7 March.

__________

Earlier this week I mentioned in these electronic pages the provocative book by Fr. Aidan Nichols, OP, from Family Publications entitled The Realm: An Unfashionable Essay on the Conversion of England. (Order from Amazon UK click HERE.  This doesn’t seem to be available on the USA Amazon now.)

I received a copy of Fr. Nichols’ new work Criticising the Critics: Catholic Apologias for Today, also from Family Publications.

Inexplicably, this is not available through amazon.co.uk … yet.  But it is from the aforementioned Family Publications.

Fr. Nichols herein describes and responds to critics both inside and outside the Church.

His chapters are:

  1. For Modernists (Modernism a Century On)
  2. For Neo-Gnostics (Challenges to Orthodoxy and Mission)
  3. For Academic Exegetes (Reading Scripture in the Church)
  4. For Feminists (How God is Father)
  5. For Liberal Protestants (How Christ is Priest)
  6. For Progressive Catholics (The Council and the Gospel of Life)
  7. For the Erotically Absorbed (on the Nature of Lust)
  8. For Critics of Christendom (Secularization: A Catholic Response)

This final chapter is a response to the critics of what Nichols proposed in The Realm.

There are end notes, though not extensive, but no index, which is a bit of a drawback.

Led by Pope Benedict we are presently engaged in a struggle concerning our Catholic identity. Those who for the last decades have controlled the narrative about what it means to be Catholic, and controlled it within a very narrow band, are giving way to a new wave of Catholics who are looking at who they are and what they believe in continuity with a far deeper tradition. 

This slim book can give Catholics with a growing awareness of who they are a way of identifying both in themselves and in others certain tendencies to which we, as children of our own epoch, are necessarily subject.  Framed as a series of brief thematic responses, Nichols’ book will also help us as Catholics in the public square, and no doubt in our families as well, respond to common objections to Holy Church and our membership in her.

Furthermore, it is instructive, far-ranging and amusing.  I suspect that you, as I, will read this with pen in hand. 

(Of course you may be making your own index as I am doing while I read!)

DIGRESSION:

Another worthy Nichols book:

The Thought of Pope Benedict XVI: An Introduction to the Theology of Joseph Ratzinger

REVIEW: New book by Aidan Nichols: Criticising the Critics

UK link to buy
USA link to buy

Nichols together with Tracey Rowland’s excellent book will give you a very comprehensive and accurate view of the methodology and thought of Joseph Ratzinger.

REVIEW: New book by Aidan Nichols: Criticising the Critics

USA link
UK link

Posted in Our Catholic Identity, REVIEWS, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , ,
11 Comments

QUAERITUR: use of iPhone, hand-held for liturgical readings

From a reader:

One sees the Magnificat missalettes in the hands of lots of folks at daily Mass nowadays. With its beautifully presented (briefer) morning/evening/night prayers from which many (like me) have gone on to the LOH or DO, plus the daily and Sunday Mass readings, and Order of Mass including the Gloria-Credo-Sanctus etc. in Latin and English, it’s arguably one of the more wholesome phenomena of the whole Novus Ordo era.

NOW HERE’S THE QUESTION: At $20/yr download versus $40/yr for the print version, this would pay for a $100 iPhone in 5 years. And in the meantime one could use it not only for morning, evening, night prayer … But also to follow the Gloria, Creed, EP, etc. at daily and Sunday Mass. And since the Magnificat includes the readings, if and when you’re the lector . . .

Would it be liturgically acceptable to can carry your iPhone up to the ambo and proclaim the first reading and responsorial psalm directly from it, rather than from the bulky and inconvenient lectionary.

 

I have from time to time jokingly prophesied the "liturgical laptop", covered with the color of the day and solemnly carried and incensed, etc., monks in choir stalls in a dark church singing their office over glowing screens.

This will probably one day come.  But it hasn’t come yet.

I don’t think the connotation of the screen versus the book has shifted enough so that such a use wouldn’t be … wrong.

Also, I am not sure why a lectionary is inconvenient if it is already on the ambo.

That said, last night during a Solemn High Mass in the Extraordinary Form, in a very traditionally constructed church just off super modern Time Square in Manhattan, during my sermon I used my iPhone to be able to reference a prayer to St. Joseph, because I could find it any other way.  There were no books available with the text of the prayer I wanted.  I looked it up ahead of time, course, and copied it to my note pad.  But – vested in my Roman vestments – I did read from it, during the sermon.

But the readings themselves? 

Not yet, I think.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box | Tagged ,
31 Comments

Pope Benedict explains the situation to the Irish

Pope Benedict explains the situation to the Irish

What Pope Benedict wrote to the people of Ireland about the sexual abuse of minors by priests.

It is pretty long and you would read it in the whole text on your own.  But here are salient paragraphs with my emphases and comments.  There is enough in the whole letter that, on another day, I might have made different editing choices.  But, here it is…

PASTORAL LETTER OF THE HOLY FATHER POPE BENEDICT XVI

[…]

2. For my part, considering the gravity of these offences, and the often inadequate response to them on the part of the ecclesiastical authorities in your country, I have decided to write this Pastoral Letter to express my closeness to you and to propose a path of healing, renewal and reparation.

[…]

At the same time, I must also express my conviction that, in order to recover from this grievous wound, the Church in Ireland must first acknowledge before the Lord and before others the serious sins committed against defenceless children. Such an acknowledgement, accompanied by sincere sorrow for the damage caused to these victims and their families, must lead to a concerted effort to ensure the protection of children from similar crimes in the future.  [Does anyone else catch an echo of what Pope John Paul II asked the Church to do before the 2000 Jubilee year?]

As you take up the challenges of this hour, I ask you to remember “the rock from which you were hewn” (Is 51:1). Reflect upon the generous, often heroic, contributions made by past generations of Irish men and women to the Church and to humanity as a whole, and let this provide the impetus for honest self-examination and a committed programme of ecclesial and individual renewal. It is my prayer that, assisted by the intercession of her many saints and purified through penance, the Church in Ireland will overcome the present crisis and become once more a convincing witness to the truth and the goodness of Almighty God, made manifest in his Son Jesus Christ.  [Self-examination and then intercession after penance.  Grace and elbow-grease.  Both the natural and supernatural order must be involved.]

3. […]

In almost every family in Ireland, there has been someone – a son or a daughter, an aunt or an uncle – who has given his or her life to the Church. [Which means that the recently revealed problems will be that much more painful.] Irish families rightly esteem and cherish their loved ones who have dedicated their lives to Christ, sharing the gift of faith with others, and putting that faith into action in loving service of God and neighbour.

4. In recent decades, however, the Church in your country has had to confront new and serious challenges to the faith arising from the rapid transformation and secularization of Irish society. [Pope Benedict will always bring the discussion back to our Catholic identity, won’t he!] Fast-paced social change has occurred, often adversely affecting people’s traditional adherence to Catholic teaching and values. [See?] All too often, the sacramental and devotional practices that sustain faith and enable it to grow, such as frequent confession, daily prayer and annual retreats, were neglected. [Please note: This describes most Catholic communities in prosperous countries.] Significant too was the tendency during this period, also on the part of priests and religious, to adopt ways of thinking and assessing secular realities without sufficient reference to the Gospel. [Sounds like a form of modernism.] The programme of renewal proposed by the Second Vatican Council was sometimes misinterpreted and indeed, in the light of the profound social changes that were taking place, it was far from easy to know how best to implement it. [The Holy Father continues to call for a "hermeneutic of continuity" in regard to the Council’s application.] In particular, [And now we get to a sore spot.] there was a well-intentioned but misguided tendency to avoid penal approaches to canonically irregular situations. ["well-intentioned but misguided" I believe describes the approach of some Church authorities.  Others were perhaps motivated more by a kind of cowardice or weakness of character.] It is in this overall context that we must try to understand the disturbing problem of child sexual abuse, which has contributed in no small measure to the weakening of faith and the loss of respect for the Church and her teachings.

Only by examining carefully the many elements that gave rise to the present crisis can a clear-sighted diagnosis of its causes be undertaken and effective remedies be found.[Thus, the problems can’t be reduced to a simple cause.  Thus, the solutions can’t be simple either.  There are no quick fixes.] Certainly, among the contributing factors we can include: [1] inadequate procedures for determining the suitability of candidates for the priesthood and the religious life;[2]  insufficient human, moral, intellectual and spiritual formation in seminaries and novitiates;[3]  a tendency in society to favour the clergy and other authority figures; [4] and a misplaced concern for the reputation of the Church and the avoidance of scandal, resulting in failure to apply existing canonical penalties and to safeguard the dignity of every person. Urgent action is needed to address these factors, which have had such tragic consequences in the lives of victims and their families, and have obscured the light of the Gospel to a degree that not even centuries of persecution succeeded in doing.

5. On several occasions since my election to the See of Peter, I have met with victims of sexual abuse, as indeed I am ready to do in the future. I have sat with them, I have listened to their stories, I have acknowledged their suffering, and I have prayed with them and for them. [NB] Earlier in my pontificate, in my concern to address this matter, I asked the bishops of Ireland, “to establish the truth of what happened in the past, to take whatever steps are necessary to prevent it from occurring again, to ensure that the principles of justice are fully respected, and above all, to bring healing to the victims and to all those affected by these egregious crimes” (Address to the Bishops of Ireland, 28 October 2006).

With this Letter, I wish to exhort all of you, as God’s people in Ireland, to reflect on the wounds inflicted on Christ’s body, the sometimes painful remedies needed to bind and heal them, and the need for unity, charity and mutual support in the long-term process of restoration and ecclesial renewal. I now turn to you with words that come from my heart, and I wish to speak to each of you individually and to all of you as brothers and sisters in the Lord.

6. To the victims of abuse and their families

You have suffered grievously and I am truly sorry. I know that nothing can undo the wrong you have endured. […] In [the Church’s] her name, I openly express the shame and remorse that we all feel. […]

Speaking to you as a pastor concerned for the good of all God’s children, I humbly ask you to consider what I have said. I pray that, by drawing nearer to Christ and by participating in the life of his Church – a Church purified by penance and renewed in pastoral charity – you will come to rediscover Christ’s infinite love for each one of you. I am confident that in this way you will be able to find reconciliation, deep inner healing and peace.

7. To priests and religious who have abused children

You betrayed the trust that was placed in you by innocent young people and their parents, and you must answer for it before Almighty God and before properly constituted tribunals. [Once again, the natural and the supernatural.  Here and later.  In this life and in the afterlife.] You have forfeited the esteem of the people of Ireland and brought shame and dishonour upon your confreres. Those of you who are priests violated the sanctity of the sacrament of Holy Orders in which Christ makes himself present in us and in our actions. Together with the immense harm done to victims, great damage has been done to the Church and to the public perception of the priesthood and religious life.

I urge you to examine your conscience, take responsibility for the sins you have committed, and humbly express your sorrow. Sincere repentance opens the door to God’s forgiveness and the grace of true amendment. [Human respect is one thing, but eternal separation from God in Hell, the unending "pain of loss" and its torments… another thing entirely.  In an age when not enough attention has been given to the Four Last Things – for reasons you can probably list – this is a salutary admonition from the Vicar of Christ.] By offering prayers and penances for those you have wronged, you should seek to atone personally for your actions. Christ’s redeeming sacrifice has the power to forgive even the gravest of sins, and to bring forth good from even the most terrible evil. At the same time, God’s justice summons us to give an account of our actions and to conceal nothing. Openly acknowledge your guilt, submit yourselves to the demands of justice, but do not despair of God’s mercy.  [Reminder: There is no sin that a limited, finite, mortal can commit that the infinite and Almighty God cannot forgive and cleanse.]

8. To parents

You have been deeply shocked to learn of the terrible things that took place in what ought to be the safest and most secure environment of all. In today’s world it is not easy to build a home and to bring up children. [Do I hear an "Amen!"?] […] This noble but demanding task is entrusted in the first place to you, their parents. [A good point to bring up.  Parents sometimes do not take adequate interest in the formation of their children and instead abdicate their responsibilities to others, not perhaps out of lack of love but out of the felt need to attend to the details of a ever more distracting and harried lifestyle.]  I urge you to play your part [….]

9. To the children and young people of Ireland  [of the prosperous West]

I wish to offer you a particular word of encouragement. Your experience of the Church is very different from that of your parents and grandparents. The world has changed greatly since they were your age. Yet all people, in every generation, are called to travel the same path through life, whatever their circumstances may be. We are all scandalized by the sins and failures of some of the Church’s members, particularly those who were chosen especially to guide and serve young people. But it is in the Church that you will find Jesus Christ, who is the same yesterday, today and for ever (cf. Heb 13:8). He loves you and he has offered himself on the cross for you. Seek a personal relationship with him within the communion of his Church, for he will never betray your trust! He alone can satisfy your deepest longings and give your lives their fullest meaning by directing them to the service of others. Keep your eyes fixed on Jesus and his goodness, and shelter the flame of faith in your heart. Together with your fellow Catholics in Ireland, I look to you to be faithful disciples of our Lord and to bring your much-needed enthusiasm and idealism to the rebuilding and renewal of our beloved Church.

10. To the priests and religious of Ireland

All of us are suffering as a result of the sins of our confreres who betrayed a sacred trust or failed to deal justly and responsibly with allegations of abuse. In view of the outrage and indignation which this has provoked, not only among the lay faithful but among yourselves and your religious communities, many of you feel personally discouraged, even abandoned. I am also aware that in some people’s eyes you are tainted by association, and viewed as if you were somehow responsible for the misdeeds of others. At this painful time, I want to acknowledge the dedication of your priestly and religious lives and apostolates, and I invite you to reaffirm your faith in Christ, your love of his Church and your confidence in the Gospel’s promise of redemption, forgiveness and interior renewal. In this way, you will demonstrate for all to see that where sin abounds, grace abounds all the more (cf. Rom 5:20).

I know that many of you are disappointed, bewildered and angered by the way these matters have been handled by some of your superiors. Yet, it is essential that you cooperate closely with those in authority and help to ensure that the measures adopted to respond to the crisis will be truly evangelical, just and effective. Above all, I urge you to become ever more clearly men and women of prayer, courageously following the path of conversion, purification and reconciliation. In this way, the Church in Ireland will draw new life and vitality from your witness to the Lord’s redeeming power made visible in your lives.

11. To my brother bishops [Here we go…]

It cannot be denied that some of you and your predecessors failed, at times grievously, to apply the long-established norms of canon law to the crime of child abuse. [Some claim that the Church’s own structures we designed to cover things up.  That can’t be sustained if you look at what the Church’s actual law was in the past.] Serious mistakes were made in responding to allegations. [Can we add here that serious mistakes are also made now in protecting the reputations of innocent people falsely accused?] I recognize how difficult it was to grasp the extent and complexity of the problem, to obtain reliable information and to make the right decisions in the light of conflicting expert advice. Nevertheless, it must be admitted that grave errors of judgement were made and failures of leadership occurred.  [Somebody chose those bishops.] All this has seriously undermined your credibility and effectiveness. I appreciate the efforts you have made to remedy past mistakes and to guarantee that they do not happen again. Besides fully implementing the norms of canon law in addressing cases of child abuse, continue to cooperate with the civil authorities in their area of competence. Clearly, religious superiors should do likewise. They too have taken part in recent discussions here in Rome with a view to establishing a clear and consistent approach to these matters. It is imperative that the child safety norms of the Church in Ireland be continually revised and updated and that they be applied fully and impartially in conformity with canon law.

Only decisive action carried out with complete honesty and transparency will restore the respect and good will of the Irish people towards the Church to which we have consecrated our lives. This must arise, first and foremost, from your own self-examination, inner purification and spiritual renewal. The Irish people rightly expect you to be men of God, to be holy, to live simply, to pursue personal conversion daily. For them, in the words of Saint Augustine, you are a bishop; yet with them you are called to be a follower of Christ (cf. Sermon 340, 1 ["Believe me, brothers and sisters, if what I am for you frightens me, what I am with you reassures me. For you I am the bishop; with you I am a Christian.  ‘Bishop,’ this is the title of an office one has accepted to discharge; ‘Christian,’ that is the name of the grace one receives. Dangerous title! Salutary name!"]). […]

12. To all the faithful of Ireland

[…] In confronting the present crisis, measures to deal justly with individual crimes are essential, yet on their own they are not enough: a new vision is needed, to inspire present and future generations to treasure the gift of our common faith. By treading the path marked out by the Gospel, by observing the commandments and by conforming your lives ever more closely to the figure of Jesus Christ, you will surely experience the profound renewal that is so urgently needed at this time. I invite you all to persevere along this path.

[…]

14. I now wish to propose to you some concrete initiatives to address the situation.

At the conclusion of my meeting with the Irish bishops, I asked that Lent this year be set aside as a time to pray for an outpouring of God’s mercy and the Holy Spirit’s gifts of holiness and strength upon the Church in your country. I now invite all of you to devote your Friday penances, for a period of one year, between now and Easter 2011, to this intention. I ask you to offer up your fasting, your prayer, your reading of Scripture and your works of mercy in order to obtain the grace of healing and renewal for the Church in Ireland. I encourage you to discover anew the sacrament of Reconciliation and to avail yourselves more frequently of the transforming power of its grace.  [Make the whole year a "Lent" and go to confession!]

Particular attention should also be given to Eucharistic adoration, and in every diocese there should be churches or chapels specifically devoted to this purpose. I ask parishes, seminaries, religious houses and monasteries to organize periods of Eucharistic adoration, so that all have an opportunity to take part. Through intense prayer before the real presence of the Lord, you can make reparation for the sins of abuse that have done so much harm, at the same time imploring the grace of renewed strength and a deeper sense of mission on the part of all bishops, priests, religious and lay faithful.  [Note my comments about reparation and prayer in my piece about that phrase "Save the Liturgy – Save The World".]

I am confident that this programme will lead to a rebirth of the Church in Ireland in the fullness of God’s own truth, for it is the truth that sets us free (cf. Jn 8:32).

Furthermore, having consulted and prayed about the matter, I intend to hold an Apostolic Visitation of certain dioceses in Ireland, [And the Visitation of women religious continues in the USA… but i digress…] as well as seminaries and religious congregations. Arrangements for the Visitation, which is intended to assist the local Church on her path of renewal, will be made in cooperation with the competent offices of the Roman Curia and the Irish Episcopal Conference. The details will be announced in due course.

I also propose that a nationwide Mission be held for all bishops, priests and religious. It is my hope that, by drawing on the expertise of experienced preachers and retreat-givers from Ireland and from elsewhere, and by exploring anew the conciliar documents, the liturgical rites of ordination and profession, and recent pontifical teaching, you will come to a more profound appreciation of your respective vocations, so as to rediscover the roots of your faith in Jesus Christ and to drink deeply from the springs of living water that he offers you through his Church.  [Penance, confession, Adoration, visitations, missions… is sounding familiar.  I wonder when the first liberal will spout off that the Pope thinks that the way to deal with Ireland is to "turn the clock back!"  Instead, they will counter that we need women priests, no hierarchy or at least locally elected hierarchy, new sacramental celebrations for getting married to your "partner" or your dog or lawn-mower, that the Church’s teachings should conform to the present felt interior presence of God in the heart of a mature modern person, etc.]

In this Year for Priests, I commend to you most particularly the figure of Saint John Mary Vianney, […]

[…] Since the time when the gravity and extent of the problem of child sexual abuse in Catholic institutions first began to be fully grasped, the Church has done an immense amount of work in many parts of the world in order to address and remedy it. While no effort should be spared in improving and updating existing procedures, I am encouraged by the fact that the current safeguarding practices adopted by local Churches are being seen, in some parts of the world, as a model for other institutions to follow.

I wish to conclude this Letter with a special Prayer for the Church in Ireland, […]

From the Vatican, 19 March 2010, on the Solemnity of Saint Joseph

BENEDICTUS PP. XVI

 

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
19 Comments

Good clear talk about health care debate issues – useful!

I complained the other day that neither side in the Catholic field, the USCCB nor the dissidents, had adequately explained the presumed barrier – or lack thereof – or unacceptable weakness thereof – between federal money and the procuring of abortions.

From CNA with my emphases and comments.

USCCB’s policy expertise exposes Senate bill’s abortion provisions, Doerflinger reasserts

Good clear talk about health care debate issues - useful!Washington D.C., Mar 20, 2010 / 07:58 am (CNA).- The Catholic bishops’ conference has better policy expertise on the health care bill than any other Catholic organization, Richard Doerflinger has said. [In other words the dissident liberal sisters of the CHA and LCWR don’t have adequate expertise.] He warned about “reassuring” claims that prevent “honest and candid debate” on abortion provisions that Congressmen have a moral responsibility to change.  [Keep in mind that, in the matter of the vote on the health legislation, we are in the nebulous cloud of contingent, prudential judgments.  Therefore, real clarity of the facts of the legislation is vital.]

Doerflinger, associate director of the Secretariat of Pro-Life Activities for the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB), said that the present Senate version of health care reform frees up “billions” of dollars for abortion. [Get that?] It also creates a “stunning” problem by forcing health plans that cover abortions to collect a separate monthly payment from enrollees to pay for others’ abortions.  [The claim is that if people want their policies also to cover abortion, they must pay for that coverage in some way separate from the support given by federal money.]

“This actually bans conscientious exemptions. It makes the situation worse than it is now,” he continued.

His remarks came at a Friday press conference with several pro-life leaders. Multiple questions centered upon Catholic groups which support the legislation despite the well-known opposition of the USCCB.

CNA asked him about a letter endorsing the Senate bill which was wrongly reported to represent 59,000 religious sisters.

Doerflinger said many of the signatories, organized by the group NETWORK, were religious superiors who later clarified [LATER… after their intended damaging impression was given.  I am guessing they knew full well that they would later have to make a clarification, but that after the initial media splash, and the religious cover they intended to provide "Catholic" dems, whatever subsequent clarification they would offer would make little difference.] they didn’t necessarily speak for all the sisters in their orders.

“59,000 is the total number of nuns in the US. There’s already another major organization, the Council of Major Superiors of Women Religious, which represents many orders, that has put out a statement defending what the bishops are doing on this bill.”  [And those are the sisters who still act as if they have a clear Catholic identity.]

In long run, he continued, Catholics have to have “a lot of discussions in the Church about how to stand together on these things, rather than trying to neutralize each other. Especially when one organization in particular has the role of speaking for the moral voice of the Church in these matters.”  [Indeed.  Though other Catholic groups should be able to speak as Catholics so long as they don’t pretend to set up their own parallel and conflicting magisterium.]

That organization, the USCCB, also has “policy expertise” about the acceptability of legislation to the Church’s convictions in matters of life and justice. [Sorry, but I don’t think this expertise has been yet adequately forwarded in the media.  They may have it, but more people need to know about it.] The Conference has focused on explaining the flaws of the Senate bill, documenting its case in order to show it is “not just an interest group that has an opinion.”

“We’ve actually researched the facts. [Explain them.] We know how bad it is. That’s something that no other Catholic organization really can do with the depth that we’ve done.”

While Doerflinger did not mention Catholics United by name, the pro-Obama group has charged that the USCCB is opposing the Senate bill legislation despite “overwhelming evidence” allegedly refuting its “mistaken belief” that the bill expands public financing of abortion.

Catholics United is also running advertisements that pressure Congressmen to vote for the Senate bill. Its campaign in a West Virginia district was criticized by the local diocese for “misleading” and “confusing” Catholics.  [It is time for the USCCB to make unambiguous statements about that group and for the bishops of their leadership to take some action.]

At the Friday conference one questioner pressed Doerflinger about whether the Catholic bishops have capably informed Congress and other Catholic groups about the effects of the Senate bill.  [Good question.]

“It’s not a matter of not communicating, [?] it’s that there are things about the bill that people don’t believe or don’t want to believe. [NB] Unless they’ve been immersed in this policy work on abortion, they don’t necessarily understand that the rules on abortion are different than almost any other thing."

Supporters of the legislation “sincerely and with some reason [I agree] believe that it’s going to help a lot of people,” in Doerflinger’s view, and have not let themselves focus on the abortion aspects. 

“The USCCB’s focus is not to dismiss other concerns, but to say ‘you cannot do this kind of evil on this kind of level’.”  [Right.  But we must add you cannot do evil on any level.  But the evil is compounded when it is on this scale.]

In a prior question [This is good, and it addresses something I have brought up here.] at the conference a reporter from CNSNews.com asked whether a member of Congress can morally vote for health care reform if the Senate bill’s abortion provisions are not changed.

The USCCB official said it depends on the exact action of the Congressman. If he reviews the legislation, sees “all the ramifications” and concludes it will greatly expand funding for taking an innocent human life, that person should “morally see it as his or her responsibility to demand change.”  [So… it really is a question of communication, isn’t it?]

“It’s wrong for public figures to deliberately and knowingly promote and provide funding for that kind of taking of life.”

In response to a question from Julia Duin of the Washington Times, Doerflinger acknowledged that there have been “confusion” and “victims of confusion” in the debate.

He noted that Secretary of Health and Human Services Kathleen Sebelius had reassured some supporters that regulations were in place and that the Obama administration did not want to fund abortion.

That sounds “really lovely” to someone without a policy background, but is “totally irrelevant” because federal statute trumps federal regulation, [!] Doerflinger commented. Abortion has a court mandate “unless Congress stops it specifically.” [!]

[NB] “The Hyde Amendment doesn’t cover this bill, so it is irrelevant. But you have to have a certain amount of background and training and experience in this to know that.  [Communicate that better!]

“Some people are just believing statements on their face that look reassuring, but are actually being used to prevent honest and candid debate.”

Though Catholics must deal with “frayed nerves” and divisions on policy, in Doerflinger’s view divisions on moral teaching weren’t at the root of most of the differences in the present debate.

Tom McClusky, the senior vice president of the Family Research Council (FRC), who also addressed the press conference, was less conciliatory.

He charged that some advocates of the Senate health care bill were repeating 2008 election tactics to attract support from undecided Christians. [And I think he is right about that.]

“All they needed to do was plant the seeds of doubt and not worry about the facts so much, and attack those who disagree with them.

“Richard himself has been a victim of some of those attacks, and the USCCB certainly has been.”

Thank you CNA for this good article.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, The Drill, The future and our choices | Tagged , ,
3 Comments

Prayer request

I ask some prayers when you think of it over the next few days.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
13 Comments

A magisterium of nuns

In this matter of contingent, prudential judgments, whose judgment will in time prove to have been the more prudent?A magisterium of nuns

The Catholic bishops with pro-life groups or their opposition, the LCWR and CHA and NCR, etc?

I happen to think the bishops are right and the CHA and NCR and LCWR are wrong.  I think the bishops are right this time, not because they are bishops, by the way, but because they happen to be right.  Even if there really is a barrier between federal money and the procuring of abortions, a barrier which might allow a Catholic legislator in this byzantine tangle to vote for the bill, is that barrier going to stand?

Or will it – as I fear it will – open the gates to direct federal funding for abortions?

At this point I doubt many people are going to change their minds about their positions.

Therefore, I have this to say to those Catholics who support the passage of this bill.

I am speaking especially to the women of the LCWR and the CHA and the dissenters of the NCR.

No one is going to forget that you supported this bill when, in years to come, your barrier did not hold and children are being killed with tax-payer funding.

In years to come, you will be held accountable by Catholics on the street.

You will be held responsible for this and you will be made to answer for this down the line.

You will be responsible for federal funding of the most extreme form of child abuse.

You are in for a Dante-esque contrapasso in decades to come.

Dear readers, think about how these same people scream for the heads of bishops and priests who years ago harmed innocent children.  Today those who support this legislation have in the past also relentlessly pursued bishops and priests who, 40 years ago, showed compassion – rightly or wrongly – in trying to rehabilitate priests who harmed children.

“If we only knew then what we know now…”, people will say in years to come, just as they do now about child abuse in years past.

“What harm we could have avoided if we, moved by compassion, had made a different prudential judgment!”

When federal funding for the extreme child abuse of abortion starts to flow, I suspect people will find you, Sister – Reverend Mother – Sister “President” – in the same kind of nursing homes in which various groups have searched out priests who abused children decades ago.

Organizations will be formed, seek you out, and extract your public mea culpas because of your “prudential” judgments today.

Sisters… what you are doing is WRONG.

Your magisterium of liberal nuns has told us that if only women had been priests or had been in power positions, then maybe there wouldn’t have been a crisis today with sexual abuse of children.

Is that so?   Perhaps if there were men in power positions in the LCWR and CHA we might avoid the abuse to come.

You tell us, Sisters, that out of compassion for the poor we ought to take the risk that federal funds, in a worst case scenario, might go to pay for abortion.

I think that is the wrong prudential judgment.

The bishops are right and you are wrong.

They are right, not because they are bishops, but because they are neither naive nor governed by false compassion…nor false motives.

And I think we must, Sisters, question your motives.

This moment, Sisters, will come back to haunt you.

Posted in Classic Posts, Magisterium of Nuns, Our Catholic Identity, SESSIUNCULA, The Drill, The future and our choices, Wherein Fr. Z Rants | Tagged , , , , ,
90 Comments

Pelosi invokes St Joseph for her bill

Did I understand this right? Did Speaker Pelosi REALLY invoke St. Joseph for the passage of this health care legislation? From NO online:

Friday, March 19, 2010 Oh Dear, Saint Joseph [Kathryn Jean Lopez] Correct me if I am wrong, but the outrage of this isn’t that she’s praying to Saint Joseph for the passage of her life-threatening health-care legislation (bad enough) but that she comes as close to claiming his endorsement as she can get away with: [THE VIDEO DIDNT PASTE… Sorry] UPDATE: Yes, as I mentioned on Twitter, she’s also off on what feast day it is today. 03/19 02:49 PMShare

Some one please post a link to the YOUTUBE clip. NB: Pelosi says today is St Joseph the Worker. Fail. Double Fail.

UPDATE:

The video… you decide.

Play video

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
75 Comments

In Manhattan again

On my way to a symposium on science and faith, two NYC landmarks.

In Manhattan again

UPDATE:

I am in the Time-Life Building.

In Manhattan again

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments