WDTPRS – Saturday 3rd Week of Lent – Prayer over the people (2002MR)

WDTPRS - Saturday 3rd Week of Lent - Prayer over the people (2002MR)A great new feature of the 2002 Missale Romanum in Latin is that for Lent the "Prayer over the people" or Oratio super populum has been revived as an option.

Priests can use this prayer NOW at the end of Mass, but still only in the Latin.

Yah, I know.. I keep posting these as if they were, I dunno, interesting.

Let’s have a look at today’s:

ORATIO SUPER POPULUM (2002MR):
Praetende, Domine, fidelibus tuis,
dexteram caelestis auxilii,
ut te toto corde perquirant,
et quae digne postulant consequi mereantur
.

I found this prayer in the Liber sacramentorum Gellonensis for LXXIIII. DOMI. IIII IN XLma AD HYRVL.

The puzzling thing about this is that is tomorrow.  Today the Station is Santa Susanna.  Today in the Extraordinay Form the first reading was the story of Susanna and the unjust judges and how young Daniel saved her from death.  Tomorrow the Station is Holy Cross in Jerusalem… of course, because it is Laetare Sunday.  What I have to ask is… why not just use the prayers on the day they were originally prayed?  Is there some thematic reason?

"But Father! But Father!", you are saying, "what about the Gregorian Sacramentary?"

Indeed, you caught it.

In the Sacramentarium Hadrianum (one of the manuscripts of the Gregorian) we find for this day, Saturday, Station of Santa Susanna, this is the prayer is the Super populum.  Go figure.

Your trusty Lewis & Short will tell you that tendo is "to stretch, to extend". Praetendo, therefore, is "to stretch forth, or forward, to extend".  Postulo is basically, "to ask, demand, require, request, desire" but also "to need, require".

You know the English word "perk", which is shortened from "perquisite".  This is from perquiro, "to ask or inquire after diligently, to make diligent search for any thing". 

SLAVISHLY LITERAL TRANSLATION
Stretch forth, O Lord, toward Your faithful
the right hand of heavenly aid,
so that they might with their whole heart diligently seek You,
and may merit to attain the things they worthily require
.

God’s right hand is an anthropomorphic way of speaking about God’s power.  It is a common image in the Old Testament and therefore also in the new.  It is also a sign of God’s favor.  Those who are favored are placed on God’s right.  It was an ancient custom to place those whom you favored or acknowledged on your right.  The Risen Lord is at God’s right hand.  He is in this sense the "power" of God the Father (cf.1 Cor 1:24).

Think of this image of the outstretched hand.

It can signify the protection He places over us as His disciples.  It can be His helping hand, involved with us.

But think also of how the one who loves yearns with his heart toward the hand of his beloved.  He kisses that hand. 

The man who is drowning, grasps the hand which seeks to pull him from his doom.

Also, a hand of a parent will guide the toddler begins with first steps to a smooth path and away from the lethal fall down the long stair case.

We often in this life strive for things which really do us harm.  We get into trouble with them.

May God help us to get out of the trouble we get ourselves into and steer us to the things which are for our benefit.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
4 Comments

SCRUB ALERT: The Times reopens its bear-baiting pit

TwitterIn another entry, I said that we would see an increase in attacks on the Holy Father, attempts to implicate him personally in the cover-up of sexual abuse of minors by priests when the Pope was still Archbishop of Munich.

Hell’s Bible launched an attack, written by committee.

The Times has now opened up its own bear-baiting pit.

The Times article is by Richard Owen.  The headline is designed to make you think the Pope is guilty of something before you read the article.

Thus, the editors, for printing this headline, are scrubs. If Richard Owen wrote the headline, he is a scrub.

It will seen be impossible to track without Nexis-Lexis all the attack in the media, the unjust and unprofessional insinuations.

SCRUB ALERT: The Times reopens its bear-baiting pit

Also see Damian Thompson‘s piece.

UPDATE:

Another fairly despicable story from AP, which was again written by committee but has the usually responsbile Nicole Williams name at the top.

Pope under fire for transfer, letter on sex abuse

  By NICOLE WINFIELD, Associated Press Writer Nicole Winfield, Associated Press Writer   – Fri Mar 12, 6:24 pm ET

VATICAN CITY – Germany’s sex abuse scandal has now reached Pope Benedict XVI: …

You are being guided to the conclusion, before you read the article, that the Pope is personally guilty of something.

The rest of the article has some interesting information, but its dwells on the word "scandal" and seems intended to paint the Church in a bad light rather than merely inform.

UPDATE:

In contrast to the other media.

CNA: Vatican: Pope was ‘completely extraneous’ to Munich sex abuse decision

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
22 Comments

CWN: US bishops oppose Senate health reform bill, clarify Politico

This morning I heard on one of those start-up-the-day TV shows (some news mixed with the mind-numbingly inane) that the Catholic bishops had in some way endorsed the proposed health care legislation for the US despite the obvious funding of abortion included therein.

"?!?!?" quoth I, incredulous.

I found this story on Catholic World News:

US bishops oppose Senate health reform bill, clarify Politico
March 11, 2010

The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops has reiterated its opposition to Senate health care reform legislation.

On March 5, Politico reported that “he [sic] Roman Catholic bishops signaled Thursday that if agreement is reached with House leaders on anti-abortion language, the church would work to get the votes needed to protect the provisions in the Senate — and thereby advance the shared goal with Democrats of health care reform.”

Responding to questions about the Politico article, the bishops’ conference issued the following statement:

Recently a reporter asked the staff of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops whether, if the House of Representatives sent a health care reform bill to the Senate that includes acceptable pro-life language like the Stupak amendment, the Conference would defend the pro-life language against efforts by members of either political party to strike it from the bill. The staff answered yes. Some took that answer out of context, and misinterpreted it as a commitment by the bishops to endorse an overall health care bill as long as it includes pro-life language. No such position has been taken. The Conference has said the Senate-passed health care bill fails our moral criteria  [Get that?] and must be changed; if changes do occur the bishops would study the new bill, then develop a position based on our moral criteria.

Source(s): these links will take you to other sites, in a new window.

so, now you know what is going on if this comes up.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, The Drill | Tagged , , ,
6 Comments

Pray for the Pope

V. Oremus pro Pontifice nostro Benedicto.

R. Dominus conservet eum, et vivificet eum, et beatum faciat
eum in terra, et non tradat eum in animam inimicorum eius.
[Ps 40:3]

Pater Noster…,  Ave Maria….

Deus, omnium fidelium pastor et rector, famulum tuum
Benedictum, quem pastorem Ecclesiae tuae praeesse voluisti,
propitius respice: da ei, quaesumus, verbo et exemplo,
quibus praeest, proficere: ut ad vitam, una cum grege sibi
credito, perveniat sempiternam. Per Christum, Dominum
nostrum. Amen.

V. Let us pray for Benedict, our Pope.

R. May the Lord preserve him, and give him life, and make
him blessed upon the earth, and deliver him not up to the
will of his enemies. [Ps 40:3]

Our Father,  Hail Mary.

O God, Shepherd and Ruler of all Thy faithful people, look
mercifully upon Thy servant Benedict, whom Thou hast chosen
as shepherd to preside over Thy Church. Grant him, we
beseech Thee, that by his word and example, he may edify
those over whom he hath charge, so that together with the
flock committed to him, may he attain everlasting life.
Through Christ our Lord. Amen.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
14 Comments

USCCB NATIONWIDE BULLETIN INSERT/ACTION ALERT

This is making the rounds.  Help it make more rounds.  I got this from the Catholic Key, the page of the newspaper of the Diocese of Kansas City, MO.

This afternoon, the USCCB contacted dioceses across the country with a new bulletin insert. As church bulletin’s are usually prepared on Wednesdays, the Conference realizes that most parishes will not be able to utilize the insert for this weekend. They have asked, however, that dioceses use every means of dissemination and social networking available to get this important action alert out, as action in the House is expected in days. You can do the same.

In the insert, the Bishops again urge Catholics to contact their House and Senate members urging them to oppose the Senate Health Care Bill unless changes regarding abortion funding, conscience and immigrants are made. Here it is in pdf and inline below:

USCCB NATIONWIDE BULLETIN INSERT/ACTION ALERT
Updated 3-11-2010
Stop Abortion Funding in Health Care Reform!
Protect Conscience
Ensure Affordable Health Coverage
Allow Immigrants to Purchase Private Health Insurance

As long-time advocates of health care reform, the U.S. Catholic bishops continue to make the moral case that genuine health care reform must protect the life, dignity, consciences and health of all, especially the poor and vulnerable. Health care reform should provide access to affordable and quality health care for all, and not advance a pro-abortion agenda in our country. Genuine health care reform is being blocked by those who insist on reversing widely supported policies against federal funding of abortion and plans which include abortion, not by those working simply to preserve these longstanding protections.

• On November 7, the U.S. House of Representatives passed major health care reform that reaffirms the essential, longstanding and widely supported policy against using federal funds for elective abortions and includes positive measures on affordability and immigrants.

• On December 24, the U.S. Senate rejected this policy and passed health care reform that requires federal funds to help subsidize and promote health plans that cover elective abortions. All purchasers of such plans will be required to pay for other people’s abortions through a separate payment solely to pay for abortion. And the affordability credits for very low income families purchasing private plans in a Health Insurance Exchange are inadequate and would leave families financially vulnerable.

• Outside the abortion context, neither bill has adequate conscience protection for health care providers, plans or employers.

• Congressional leaders are now trying to figure out how the rules of the House and Senate could allow the final passage of a modified bill that would satisfy disagreements between House and Senate versions.

ACTION: Contact your Representative and Senators today by e-mail, phone or FAX.

• To send a pre-written, instant e-mail to Congress go to www.usccb.org/action.

• Call the U.S. Capitol switchboard at: 202-224-3121, or call your Members’ local offices.
Contact info can be found on Members’ web sites at www.house.gov & www.senate.gov.

MESSAGE – HOUSE:
“I am pleased that the House health care bill maintains the longstanding policy against federal funding of abortion. On the other hand, the provisions on abortion funding in the current un-amended Senate health care bill are seriously deficient and unacceptable. I urge you to work to uphold essential provisions against abortion funding, to include full conscience protection and to ensure that health care is accessible and affordable for all. I urge you to oppose any bill unless and until these criteria are met.”

MESSAGE – SENATE:
“I am deeply disappointed that the current un-amended Senate health care bill fails to maintain the longstanding policy against federal funding of abortion and does not include adequate protection for conscience. I urge you to support essential provisions against abortion funding, similar to those in the House bill. Include full conscience protection and ensure that health care is accessible and affordable for all. I urge you to oppose any bill unless and until these criteria are met.”

WHEN: Votes in the House and Senate are expected at any time. Act today! Thank You!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
19 Comments

STATIONS OF THE CROSS (audio from Fr. Z)

Many parishes and chapels will have the Via Crucis or Stations of the Cross during Lent.

What version does your parish use?  

Let’s get some titles/versions/authors and we can have a poll later on.

I have audio projects with the Way of the Cross.

Here is a reading of the Via Crucis, the Way of the Cross, composed by Joseph Card. Ratzinger, now Pope Benedict XVI, for the 2005 Good Friday observance at the Colosseum in Rome.

Also, for your Lenten spiritual warfare, here are two versions the popular Via Crucis by St. Alphonsus Liguori.  One version is plain, just my voice.  The other is the same voice recording, but with the Gregorian chant Sequence Stabat Mater interlaced between the stations.

Posted in Classic Posts, LENT, PODCAzT | Tagged , ,
39 Comments

Hell’s Bible on the attack with the help of minions

The pragmatical clinchpoops of Hell’s Bible have cobbled together an article written by committee which has no other purpose than to cast the Pope in a bad light.   No surprise.

Written by committee, surely with touching up by the editors of Hell’s bible, this is the sort of headline we will be greeted with everyday for a while.

Church Abuse Scandal in Germany Edges Closer to Pope
By NICHOLAS KULISH and RACHEL DONADIO

[…]

Nicholas Kulish reported from Berlin and Rachel Donadio from Vatican City. Gaia Pianigiani contributed reporting from Rome and Laurie Goodstein from New York.

We read this sort of thing three times, not including the title:

  • "ever closer to Benedict"
  • "already come close to the pope"
  • "particularly close to the pope himself"

What Hell’s Bible is doing is trying to set in the mind of the reader that this inevitably will wind up in the Pope’s lap…. it is inevitable.

This is all designed to undermine Pope Benedict’s moral authority.

Doubt it?

"Experts said the scandals could undermine Benedict’s moral authority, especially because they cut particularly close to the pope himself."

What I found especially risible was this [my emphases]:

"Rev. Thomas P. Doyle, who once worked at the Vatican Embassy in Washington and became an early and well-known whistle-blower on sexual abuse in the church, said the [German former VG of Munich under Archbp. Ratzinger] vicar general’s claim was not credible.

“Nonsense,” said Father Doyle, who has served as an expert witness in sexual abuse lawsuits. “Pope Benedict is a micro-manager. He’s the old style. Anything like that would necessarily have been brought to his attention. Tell the vicar general to find a better line. What he’s trying to do, obviously, is protect the pope.” "

I would like to suggest that Fr. Doyle has not the slightest idea what he is talking about.  Anyone who knows Papa Ratzinger at all, knows that the Holy Father was infamously NOT a micro-manager.  He has always self-admittedly been not a great administrator, leaving things to those in key positions under him.

Furthermore, what most US priests don’t understand is that Vicars General in Germany play a far greater role in administration in German dioceses than they do in the US. Talk to German priests.  They’ll tell you that Vicars General really do handle a lot of personnel issues.

In any event, this is all going to be very unpleasant. 

Genuine cases of abuse and genuine cases of hierarchical complacence must be dealt with, but we will be treated to all sort of nonsense of this kind. 

Forewarned is forearmed.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , ,
24 Comments

WDTPRS – Friday 3rd Week of Lent – Prayer over the people (2002MR)

A great new feature of the 2002 Missale Romanum in Latin is that for Lent the "Prayer over the people" or Oratio super populum has been revived as an option.

Priests can use this prayer NOW at the end of Mass, but still only in the Latin.

Yah, I know.. I keep posting these as if they were, I dunno, interesting.

Let’s have a look at today’s:

ORATIO SUPER POPULUM (2002MR):
Implorantes, Domine, misericordiam tuam,
fideles tuos propitius intuere,
ut, qui de tua pietate confidunt,
tuae caritatis dona ubique diffundere valeant
.

"But Father! But Father!," some would be liturgists might be saying as they scratch their heads.  "Where does this pray come from?  How do you ferret out its origins?"

Books, friends.  The Corpus Christianorum Latinorum has volumes and volumes of orations.  You sort though the bits and pieces using, especially, the first few words.  And you use your Latin ear.

For example, in today’s prayer, which is I think a "shake and bake" oration, pasted together from pieces of other orations and some new composition, we find a source in this:

WDTPRS - Friday 3rd Week of Lent - Prayer over the people (2002MR)

You can see some of our old friends, for example, the Liber sacramentorum Gellonensis 387.

Where we find this on p. 47 of its critical edition.  This in the section on the 2nd week of Lent.

WDTPRS - Friday 3rd Week of Lent - Prayer over the people (2002MR)

So that takes care of the first part of the prayer… which we still haven’t translated.

The second part?  I think it was a new composition.

So, when you scan over these WDTPRS entries you now have a glimpse of a little of what I do in writing them.

Now…  who wants to take this easy prayer and make some comments after a

SLAVISHLY LITERAL VERSION?

 

Posted in LENT | Tagged
8 Comments

Card. Ruini will head a study of Medjugorje

The former Vicar of Rome for Pope John Paul II and Benedict XVI, His Eminence Camillo Card. Ruini, will head a group to study what is going on at Medjugorje.

Play video

Most of these ROME REPORTS are good, though a little too short to be terribly useful. 

I would off them a suggestion, however.  Please make sure your readers know how to pronounce important words which are bound to turn up in news reports about the Church.  Words such as "vicar".   NB 0:22 of the video.  I think I would re-record that.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
23 Comments

Mr Hoopes replys to Mr Zmirak’s reply to Mr. Hoopes’s reply to Mr. Zmirak

Literature is full of re

Mr. John Zmirak started this here.  Tom Hoopes responded. Zmirak responded to Hoopes. 

My role?  just think of me as "Fr. Tom Servo" commenting on the whole thing.

I posted on first pieces and in fairness I should give equal time to the valiant Mr. Hoopes.  My emphases and comments.

My Extraordinary Friends

by Tom Hoopes

I’m going to do my best to defend the Extraordinary Form after the onslaught by John Zmirak, but he’s made it hard. I think introducing the world to two of my Extraordinary Form friends will help.

Yes, that’s right, for those who have followed this (for those who haven’t, you might want to check out some of the other fine posts on this site instead). I’m not going to defend the Novus Ordo against him. I’m going to defend the Extraordinary Form to my aghast Novus Ordo friends who have read John Zmirak’s two columns and wonder at the vitriol of it all.  [Well!  A new tactic!]

My friend John Zmirak wrote an interesting column Feb. 17 that compared the form of a Mass to a flag and defended his attachment to the old Mass. His conclusion:

“And by changing back the flag, by taking back our Mass, we are saying: Go back to Hell. Our Church belongs to Christ.”

I responded in an article and I e-mailed him the link saying:

“I feel like the scrawny guy kicking sand in the face of the muscle man, but here:

“Now he has replied, and yikes.

John starts: “Tom Hoopes has done me a courtesy rarely afforded tradition-minded Catholics: He has stooped to address my arguments, instead of airily dismissing them as the sad obsessions of half-wits, bag ladies, and yellow-eyed anti-Semites with dirty fingernails.”

… and then continues by airily dismissing my arguments as the sad obsession of a half-witted hopelessly lost Novus Ordo flunky he calls “Bridey” (he literally calls me only that throughout his post). Then he contradicts the fundamental points of his first column.  [I hope he will spell that out.]

This set his com-box supporters shivering with delight at his incredible debating prowess.  [The ad hominem approach has now been fully engaged in this exchage.]

Well, as the old saying goes: Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. It would be truly foolish to expect at this point to pretend to engage John Zmirak in a discussion. [Sooo…..]

As another blog wrote: “He’s defending against arguments Hoopes nor made nor intended, but it’s a wonderful, artful polemic and persuades me never to make an argument against John Zmirak in public.”

Exactly so. It’s fun stuff. It’s just self-contradictory, unfair and insulting. [Huh?  Why is it "unfair"?] So I will do my duty and answer, but then I’m done.

One germane item does emerge from Zmirak’s column: He discloses that he once waxed poetic about the very analogy I’m making, so I have cut and pasted that into my original post to shore it up.

Otherwise, John’s second article is a classic bait and switch.  [Which is the bait Zmirak offers, and where was the switch?]

What he promised to do in the original column [The Bait] was explain to the orthodox, Church-loving faithful “the apparent fixation [and we need to wonder about accepting that description] traditionalists have on restoring former elements of the liturgy and other Catholic practices that are not essential, and resisting innovations that are not inherently evil.”

He elaborated:  “Why insist on external things, like kneeling for communion on the tongue, male altar servers, and the priest facing the altar? None of these, I’ll admit for the 5,000th time, is essential for sacramental validity or credal orthodoxy; isn’t being a stickler on such issues a wee bit pharisaical, even prissy?”

Then he elaborated even more, by taking specific issues off the table.

I took him at his word; all that was off the table, and we were looking with purity at the question:  “Why do you people care so much about externals?”

I responded to the argument he left on the table by saying: “Um, not to put too fine a point on it, but the form of the Mass is not at all a flag.”

I proposed a different analogy, comparing our communion at Mass with the spousal union of husband and wife:

“As important as [the conjugal act] is as the ‘source and summit’ of their marital relationship, their behavior and relationship will start to look warped if they make sex the ‘center and preoccupation’ of their relationship. Their marital relationship will start to be tense and unhappy and the very unity the act is supposed to affirm will become tenuous and fragile.

“It’s the same with the Mass. . . .”

My point was clear: “Obsession with inessentials distorts.” I hastened to say that most Extraordinary Form folks I know don’t obsess about externals, but that John’s column “comes perilously close.”  [Well… that was an odd thing to say, no? In effect, that sounded like Hoopes was saying that Zmirak did actually go over the edge into obsession about externals.]

I faced the great John Zmirak himself, on the ground he laid out.

Then he cheated. [The Switch] He shifted the ground in several important ways. Let’s count them:

1) The importance of the Eucharis

In Column No. 1, John says he understands how communion in the Novus Ordo is itself valuable:

“Having come from churches that didn’t have the Eucharist, and remaining through God’s grace flush with gratitude for the sacraments, many converts really don’t understand what the rest of us are nattering on about. … We owe these good people an explanation.”

I agree with that John. The Eucharist is a blessing, even in the Novus Ordo. So there was nothing to argue.

Well, in Column 2 John crushes me … by reversing himself and now decrying the “destructive options” in the Novus Ordo Mass such as: “ambiguous Eucharistic prayers” and “handing out Communion like a movie ticket.”

He promised to respect Novus Ordo Communion in Column 1, and sneered at it [?] in Column 2.  [ummm…. Mr. Hoopes… I think that Mr. Zmirak’s point is that "handling out Communion like a movie ticket" is an example of not showing respect to the Eucharist.  And this concerns not to whom it is being given, but rather how.  And if it can be shown that the Eucharistic Prayers to which he refers are indeed "ambiguous", that would be yet another way of not showing respect to the Eucharist.  Am I wrong?  I think this may a case of Mr. Hoopes’ misreading Mr. Zmirak.]

2)      The validity of Vatican II and the Norvus Ordo.

In Column 1, John concedes: “Adopting Lutheran or Anglican language in the Mass probably didn’t cause the current crisis of belief in the Real Presence, and cutting such language by eliminating all but the First Eucharistic Prayer might not do much to resolve it.”

Yep. Do a search. He really did say that. And I agree.

But Column-2 John doesn’t agree.

He waxes poetic about the martyrs who opposed the sacrilegious Anglicans: “It’s not for nothing that Catholics during the Counter-Reformation marched (heavily armed, to prevent sacrilegious attacks) in Corpus Christi processions through hostile Calvinist towns. The Eucharist itself was those brave Catholics’ banner, and I for one am not ashamed of them. Is Bridey?”

This is bait and switch and sucker punch all wrapped up in one. [How, pray tell, do you conclude that?]

His first column calls the form of the Mass a flag, and is careful not to malign the Novus Ordo Mass or communion. Now he asserts that the flag is the Eucharist itself. And he impugns my Eucharistic devotion, with no evidence. [Mr. Hoopes, a couple things need to be made clear.  We ought not separate the Eucharist, the Sacrament Itself, from its celebration, which is Holy Mass.  The Anglicans of the English Reformation had their "eucharist".  The target of their wrath was Holy Mass as offered by Catholics and therefore the Catholic Eucharist, which are inseparable.]

I thought I was arguing about inessentials with Column-1 John. The John from Opposite World showed up in Column 2, swapping essentials for inessentials.  [The line of thought is a bit confused here.  What I think Mr. Hoopes is saying is that the form of celebration of the Eucharist is an inessential, while the Eucharist Itself, the Eucharistic species is essential.  Am I wrong?  This is where the great divide would be.  I would respond that the Eucharist and Its celebration must not be separated in the way that Mr. Hoopes is suggesting.]

3)      Aesthetics

In Column 1, John promised aesthetics isn’t the reason he cares about inessentials: “One visit to a Sunday Latin Low Mass without music, recited soundlessly into a marble altar, should put that idea to flight.”

So I took him at his word. We weren’t arguing aesthetics. That was off the table.

But in column 2, aesthetics and female altar servers (which Column-1 John called a non-essential) is the first place he goes: “At least we Trads aren’t scarfing down lame Catholic knock-offs of already-pitiful Christian ‘rock,’ or training our daughters to be altar servers for the next World Urban Youth Day . . . bless their hearts.”  [Which, in Zmirak’s view would be irreverent toward the Eucharistic because they are wrong to do in Its celebration.]

Yes, I was foolish … for believing Column-1 John was really taking that off the table.  [But they are not off the table when they are wrong.  It isn’t a matter of preferring one form of good sacred music to another, for example, a Mozart Mass versus de Victoria.  It is a matter, if I read Zmirak right, of not accepting music which has no place at Mass at all.  At least I think that is how you sort out the aesthetics distinction here.  Am I wrong?]

4)      Latin

In column one, John claims he’s keeping Latin off the table: “While the universal language of the Church is still to be revered for all the reasons that Vatican II prescribed in Sacrosanctum Concilium, it isn’t Why We Fight.”

In column 2, the Latin — the right Latin — is one of the essentials:

“As Michael Davies noted long-ago, the Anglican and Lutheran-inspired changes in the Novus Ordo Missae in the original Latin were intended by the committee that crafted them to fudge the differences among the churches — in the hope that an ecumenical liturgy would promote Christian unity.”

Boy, I walked right into that one. By believing John.  [No no, Mr. Hoopes.  What you don’t understand here is that Zmirak is saying that Anglicans and Lutheran concerns influenced the LATIN texts, the content of the Novus Ordo orations in the original Latin.  He in that case isn’t talking about the Latin language, but rather what was done to change the content of the Latin.  That is why, if I understood Zmirak, he said that Latin "isn’t why we fight".  Had the theology of the prayers not changed, and had the translation of the Latin not been so horrible, the language wouldn’t be problem.  The alterations to content of the prayers revealed in the changes to the Latin and in the bad translation… those are the problems.  Am I reading this wrong?]

5)      Even the Ordinary Form itself.

Column-1 John says the Ordinary Form or Extraordinary Form isn’t the point: “The liturgy is miraculous, but it doesn’t work like magic: Rev. Teilhard de Chardin had said the Tridentine Mass for decades even as he invented Catholic Scientology; conversely, his sometime housemate at New York’s St. Ignatius Loyola, the holy Rev. John Hardon, obediently switched missals with every tinkering that came to him from the bishops.”

But Column-2 John helpfully clarifies what he’s talking about when he says “And by changing back the flag, by taking back our Mass, we are saying: Go back to Hell. Our Church belongs to Christ.” The Hell Mass here is: “the Ordinary Form as ordinarily celebrated, in some 99.9 percent of parishes outside Vatican City.”

Yikes. Column-2 John sends “back to Hell” probably every Mass you’ve ever been to.  [Well.  That is his position.  But I think he explained himself along the way, agree with him or not.  It may be that Mr. Hoopes was shocked to consider (for the first time, perhaps) that maybe all this time… he has been cheated out of something he ought to have been able to have all along?  A Mass that evinces something other than muddled Catholic identity?  Is that what is going on?  In my personal experience, I recall the outrage expressed to me when they read my first WDTPRS columns in The Wanderer and learned, for the first time, that the ICEL translation we are still sadly using is dreadfully inaccurate and often distorts beyond recognition the content of the original Latin prayer.  They shot at me, the messenger.  How dare I suggest that the prayers were… were… were…. How dare I!  It may be that something of this is perhaps behind Mr. Hoopes reaction to Mr. Zmirak.  But in respect for Mr. Hoopes, whom I don’t know, I will happily stand corrected.]

The silly way John branded me “Bridey” then swept back onto the table everything (except nostalgia) that he had taken off of it has caused friends to tell me it was stupid to start the discussion at all.  [I don’t think it was stupid at all!  Faith, friends, seeks understanding.  Pope Benedict gave us Summorum Pontificum for the purposes of "mutual enrichment", among other things.  Pope Benedict’s style has always been to engage, to bring it on, as it were, respectfully but with your best shot.  I grant that Pope Benedict would not in his present role have chosen the tone of this exchange, but he did from time to time blast certain theologians in no uncertain terms in his books and articles.]

Yes, yes, yes! It was stupid. I was stupid. I wish I never had. [Don’t be.]

But worse, it has caused one to tell me: “Now you know to avoid that nasty little tribe.” [Well… piffle to that.]

That I can’t abide. Because I know too many Extraordinary Form guys who are, well, extraordinary.

I meant what I said in my column:

—The Extraordinary Form Mass is a giant blessing for the Church after the Council. [Do I hear an "Amen!"?  But that leaves the question open for Mr. Hoopes: Why?]

—I believe my traditional Mass friend who wants to write an article about her experience called “Surprised by Beauty.”

—I believe that “Most of us — in both the Ordinary and the Extraordinary camps — know the externals should be right, but don’t obsess too too much about them”.  [But there are some "externals" that are essential.  So, we need to clarify that.]

[At this point Mr. Hoopes ceases to engage directly and heads in another direction.]

But I didn’t mention two of the most impressive Extraordinary Form guys I know.

I’m sure they don’t want to be named here, given the reaction I’m getting from the com-boxers in their community. I’ll make them as anonymous as possible. I’ll just say one is a guy who through an apostolate has given my family and many others a gift that will bear fruit in 1,000 ways throughout our lives. He has one of the finest families I’m personally aware of.

He is a man fed by the Extraordinary Form — deeply, truly appreciative of it — but, like most, not obsessed by it. [It would be good to know just what "obsessed" means.] So is the other man I’m thinking of who is making an incredible, large scale contribution promoting character formation.

These aren’t weirdoes hanging out at the “muttered Mass” at the “insane asylum” John Zmirak describes; they are robust Catholic men putting the faith to work in the world.

Which, to my mind, means they are Catholic men of our times — and men of the Church of all times.

They know what I know: The Church is our mother. She can be trusted. She understands the problem with the liturgy, and she has made it a major priority.

The Church is heading in the right direction. My extraordinary friends know this; I suspect John Zmirak knows it too.

Together, as a Church, we have much to be proud of. [There is a flip-side to that.]

Catholics have founded seven new universities in the past decade faithful to the magisterium, and have renewed many more along canon-law-mandatum lines. We are the Church of World Youth Day, which is changing the trajectory of countless lives. And not just that; we are the Church of the National Catholic Youth Conference, whose 20,000 teens marched in Eucharistic procession through Kansas City in November.

Because of those colleges, and because of our youth movement, the most recent generation of young men formed by the post-Council Church are increasingly choosing the seminary. The Major Superiors of Women Religious, an organization formed by Pope John Paul II, is rapidly growing, and is populated by habited orders of nuns (ordinary and extraordinary formers) whose members’ average age is 35. Their vocation crisis, as they remind us on their fundraising letters, is that they don’t have enough space.

Our Church’s ordinary and extraordinary formers are at the heart of the pro-life movement that has dramatically turned around the numbers such that a majority of Americans now call themselves pro-life. We are a Church of a revitalized body of bishops who are coming up with practical ways to promote life … and the sacraments and Catholic truth. Even Time magazine noticed “Confession’s Comback” in our Church.  Extraordinary formers and ordinary formers keep the perpetual adoration chapel going in my parish and in more than 800 others, a number that continues to grow.

We’re one Church together. And we’re not “going back to hell” [Ouch.  I think that misreads what Zmirak was saying in the initial piece.  Which leads me back to the supposition, which I will happily adjust, that something Mr. Zmirak wrote perhaps unsettled Mr. Hoopes’ foundation a little.] – we’re headed, we pray, to the Heavenly Form liturgy where Pope John Paul II, Mother Teresa and Cardinal John O’Connor await us, in the Father’s house.

I want to stress to Mr. Hoopes that this was not an exchange to regret.

People of good will don’t regret something which sought understanding in the way this exchange has sought it. 

Tough knocks?  Sure!  But there is rough and tumble in the seeking of understanding.

Kudos for getting into the ring.

Posted in Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, SESSIUNCULA, The Drill | Tagged ,
52 Comments