Perhaps a miracle for Venerable Pope Pius XII?

This is really going to get the roller-coaster running.

[FOLLOWUP HERE]

From CNA:

Vatican investigating miracle attributed to Pius XII

Vatican City, Jan 18, 2010 / 02:40 pm (CNA).- The Prefect Emeritus of the Congregation for the Causes of Saints, Cardinal Jose Saraiva Martins, confirmed over the telephone to CNA today that a "presumed miracle" attributed to Pope Pius XII is under investigation.  The case involves a patient cured of cancer in southern Italy.  [And the Holy Father’s visit to the Roman Synagogue was… yesterday.]

Cardinal Saraiva was quick to caution, however, that there is a big difference between a "presumed" miracle and a "confirmed" miracle.

The case comes to the Congregation for Saints’ Causes from the town of Castellammare di Stabia near Naples, Italy.  "Some months ago," the local Sorrento & Dintorni online publication reported on Sunday, a person was discovered to be cured of a form of cancer previously declared incurable after praying for the intercession of Pope Pius XII.

The doctors of the person, of whom no details are public, were unable to give a scientific explanation for the occurrence, according to the article.

According to the same news source, the story was confirmed by Fr. Carmine Giudici, Vicar General of the Diocese of Sorrento, who said, "It’s all true."  Fr. Carmine said that the Holy See was in contact with the diocese after having been contacted by a local church-goer who says that he or she received a miracle "by the intercession of Pius XII."

"The archbishop then decided to institute within days the appropriate diocesan tribunal."

The existence of the possible miracle was confirmed to CNA by Cardinal Saraiva Martins on Monday afternoon.

The prefect emeritus also said that it is impossible to estimate the amount of time it might take for the process of confirmation to be carried out.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged ,
7 Comments

I’d pay real money for this TV channel

I picked this up from the Shrine:

Sunday, January 17
 
Tonight on Mystical Theology Theater 3000

Santa Claus conquers the Maritains: Coming down the chimney one Christmas eve, good old St. Nick is surprised by the elderly Jacques Maritain and spends the rest of the night charming the theologian and his wife Raisa with his tales of beating the snot out of Arius at the Council of Nicaea. (TV-PG-XIII. Arianism and violence.)

 

THAT is funny!

IMO, their TV items are among the best on that blog.

Posted in Lighter fare | Tagged
3 Comments

Scotland: Antiquity confers solemnity in shape of Latin mass

Here is something from The Herald of Scotland with my emphases and comments:

Antiquity confers solemnity in shape of Latin mass

Cate Devine

Published on 17 Jan 2010

Attending a traditional Latin mass in Glasgow yesterday was a chilling experience.

There was no heating ["chilling"… get it?] in the Sacred Heart RC church in Bridgeton, a vast 100-year-old building in the bosom of a parish first established in 1873.

Perhaps that was because there were only 31 of us in the congregation, but being freezing cold certainly helped focus the mind. After all, they do say austerity is good for the soul.

I was curious to remind myself what mass used to be like, following a debate about how the liturgy is celebrated. This was revealed in the Herald on Saturday, and has been sparked by Pope Benedict XVI’s imminent visit to Scotland.

It was the first time I’d been at Latin mass since I was a child in the 1960s, pre-Vatican Council II, and boy did I have to concentrate. Hard. [Good.  But I suggest that it takes even harder work to stay focused during most Novus Ordo Masses.]

Although I attended a convent school, have a Latin O-Grade and studied French at University, the rhythmic delivery of our affable celebrant was difficult to follow. Yet the church was in total silence: this being low mass, there was no singing or any participation in the liturgy, apart from responding to Mgr Hugh Boyle’s familiar repetitions of “Dominus Vobiscum”.  [WRONG.  There was plenty of participation!  The writer herself said that she had to concentrate.  That is a deeper and necessary form of participation than mere outward activity.]

Traditional Latin Mass is said with the priest facing the altar rather than the congregation. [And thus toward the liturgical East.] This is to help us focus on the altar, the symbol of Christ’s perfect sacrifice to his Father’s will. [Well… close… actually Someone beyond the altar, but okay.] Thus is the mass depersonalised. [It is perhaps Personalized, in the sense of being directed to the divine Person of the High Priest Jesus Christ rather than the person of the priest.] As Father genuflects and kisses the altar more frequently than usual, the sense of reverence is palpable.

By the term “Latin mass”, I mean traditional mass said in the Extraordinary Form – that is, the old rite, according to the Roman Missal of l962, before Vatican Council II. It is better known as Tridentine Mass. The version that most modern Catholics are familiar with is the Ordinary Form, or new mass, issued by Pope Paul VI in 1970.

In Scotland there has been a resurgence of interest in, and the practice of, the Latin mass,  [Do I hear an "Amen!"?] yet traditional Latin mass was effectively re-instated by Pope Benedict XVI in 2007. In his apostolic letter Summorum Pontificum the Holy Father said that there were two forms of expression of the Roman Rite of the Mass, effectively decreeing that all priests were now free to choose whether to offer the Tridentine Mass or the new mass.

However, the majority of parishes in Scotland don’t offer Latin mass, and some Scottish bishops are not in favour of it. [And their ages would beeeee…] This, say traditionalists, contradicts not only Benedict but even the late Pope John Paul II, who in 1988 asked bishops to actively support those who felt “attached to the Latin liturgical tradition”.

The anticipated visit of Pope Benedict XVI to Scotland in September therefore highlights a problem. If as expected the Holy Father will want to celebrate mass, could it be in the Extraordinary Form?  [Hmmm….]

The majority of his concelebrants, and therefore their congregations, do not know the liturgy in Latin. Unlike 73-year-old Mgr Boyle, who has celebrated Latin mass throughout his ministry, if not always in public, younger priests will not have learned liturgical Latin.

Father Stephen Dunn, the 48-year-old parish priest at Sacred Heart in Bridgeton, started saying mass in Latin only last May, having made what he calls a “concerted effort” to learn it since 2007. [NB:] Ordained in 1994, he says he feels “bullied and suppressed” by the Glasgow Archdiocese’s “reluctance to accept” the Pope’s 2007 decree, as shown in Archbishop Conti’s response to it in a letter to Glasgow’s priests on August 10, 2007, in which he questioned the need for it.

Yet as I was about to rediscover yesterday, it’s not just the fact that it’s said in Latin that makes the Extraordinary Form so different. The entire structure of the Mass is almost recognisable from what it is today.  [Ummm… I think she meant unrecognizable.  But…. go on…]

The first thing I noticed on entering Sacred Heart were the altar railings.  [Altar rails are not part of the structure of the Mass.] These are a rarity in Catholic churches, because most were removed post-Vatican II to facilitate the taking of the Host from the priest at Holy Communion and self-administering it. [NO! NO! NO!  That is NOT why they were removed.  It is actually easier to distribute Communion at an altar rail.   Rails were removed for theological/ideological reasons, not for practical reasons.  But notice her language: "taking" the Host… not "receiving".] The traditional mass, by contrast, encourages us to kneel and be given Communion as we did in the old days because it helps engender a greater sense of reverence for the sacrament, and humility to God.  [Sounds like a pretty good reason to me.]

We’re reminded that only baptised Catholics, and those in the state of grace, are invited to receive Holy Communion. This is to remind us that we are sinners and to encourage us to attend Confession.  [Dear, we are sinners after confession too.]

Nobody recites the Creed except the priest, and he says most of the Offertory quietly to himself. The Canon – the very heart of the mass, as it leads to the Consecration – is also silent. There is only one form of the Canon, though there are four options in the new mass.

There are no tambourines or guitars, and no lay church members stepping on to the altar. [Do I hear and "Amen!"?]

Everything is in the priest’s gift, which leaves us free to take from mass what we’re meant to.  [Hmmm… not quite sure what this means.  I think it means that because no one is shoving outward participation or music, etc., down your throat, you can participate more freely.  You are not compelled to be doing stuff or singing everything.  However, this is NOT about what the priest gives.  It is all about what the Priest gives, Jesus Christ.]

It does at first feel stern and authoritarian, but in the end I was humbled by Latin mass, and felt awed by its solemn simplicity. It forced me turn in on myself and to examine my conscience in a way that, for better or for worse, reminded me what being a Catholic is really all about. As soon as I returned home, I felt compelled to look out my childhood Catechism and to re-learn the fundamentals of my faith.  [Wow.  Wonderful!]

Yes, I could warm to it. If they turned up the heating a bit.  [Indeed.  Good point.  I hope at that parish they are able to pay the bills.   Be generous in the collection, folks!]

 

Kudos.  

Posted in Brick by Brick, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , ,
13 Comments

“Just being together is not unity, but ultimately an evasion of it.”

Pope Benedict is the Pope of Christian Unity.

From a reader:

I have been noticing when I have time to check your blog the references and arguments you make about Benedict XVI being the unity pope.  Probably like yourself I have had the privilege of pursuing my entire theological career in the shadow of Ratzinger/Benedict, so having something of a continuous historical context for interpreting the Holy Father’s words has helped a lot.  Maybe you feel the same way.

"Just being together is not unity, but ultimately an evasion of it."I came across this quotation from Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger in a collection of his work for daily reflection ("Co-Workers of the Truth: Meditations for Every Day of the Year," Ignatius Press, 1992, p. 28 for January 18th) given to me by my wife for Christmas.  It first appeared in L’Osservatore Romano 7, no. 30-31 (1977) p. 13. 

The reason I am sending it to you, beyond the obvious one that he says here exactly what you have opined, is because of the date of the piece, 1977. 

So, his views on unity have been forged neither by the accidents afforded by opportunity nor by the demands forced by crisis.  [Exactly.]

I hope you enjoy it.

"The summons to the peace of Christ is not to be confused with a longing for that good nature that is, in reality, only weakness, that would like to shield itself from the vexations that arise when one openly defends his convictions.  The demand for unity in the Church is not, then, to be identified with the wish that everyone would agree about everything.  Just being together is not unity, but ultimately an evasion of it.  The admonition, ‘Be nice to one another’, is certainly not to be scorned, but it does not reach the height of the Gospel because it spares us the effort of setting out on the way to truth and so of really coming together."

Pope Benedict is the Pope of Christian Unity.

Posted in Pope of Christian Unity, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged ,
3 Comments

Pro-abortion “Catholic” group endorses pro-abortion candidate Coakley (D-MA)

Massachusetts WDTPRS readers… you decide.

Are these guys obtuse or just plain wicked?

The pro-abortion "Catholic" group called "Catholic Democrats" have endorsed pro-abortion Senate candidate Martha Coakley (D-MA).

Here is their press release:

Catholic Democrats Endorses Martha Coakley to Represent Massachusetts in the United States Senate

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
January 17, 2010

Coakley Best Represents Values of Catholic Social Justice

Boston, MA – Catholic Democrats is endorsing Attorney General Martha Coakley to fill Senator Edward M. Kennedy’s U.S. Senate seat [Please explain… was it the late Senator’s seat by divine right?  How does it qualify as being "his"?] in Tuesday’s special election. 

[Watch this weasel language:] "This is a critical election for advancing Catholic Social Justice priorities," [advancing what?] said Dr. Patrick Whelan, president of Catholic Democrats.  "Martha Coakley supports expanding access to health care, protecting our natural environment through the creation of a strong green economy, and helping to alleviate poverty through greater economic opportunity.  Her record as Attorney General demonstrates that she is a tough but fair voice for all of our citizens." [All except perhaps the unborn?  If you killed before you are born, you won’t need health care and won’t care for the "environment".]

Conservative abortion groups [What is a "conservative abortion group"?] working with the campaign of Republican Scott Brown, including Massachusetts Citizens for Life, [Perhaps they meant pro-life groups.] have targeted Catholic voters with misinformation regarding Coakley’s record. [Oh?  Tell us, then, what the truth is…]  Brown has adopted the Democratic platform to reduce the numbers of abortions.  [ROFL!  That means the promotion of abortion!  There is no other way to see that platform.]  Massachusetts Citizens for Life has leafleted cars at Catholic parishes during Sunday Mass claiming he is ‘pro-life’ because he is opposed to health care reform. [I seriously doubt that Brown is against "health care reform".  I suspect he is against forcing tax-payers to pay for abortion, abortifacients, and the removal of conscience clauses for health care workers.  Am I wrong?  Or is he simply against "health care reform"?]  Additionally, voters have received recorded calls from purported Catholic organizations distorting Coakley’s record on these issues. [What organizations?]

"This has become a national election with the outcome of health care reform in the balance.  Scott Brown says that he will work to kill the health care bill if he gets elected," [Is that the case, or was there some sentence or two left out?  Did what Brown say he will work to kill the bill if X or Y is in it? What is the truth here?] said Steve Krueger, national director of Catholic Democrats.  "It is hard to understand how killing a bill that will afford more Americans access to health care, thus lessening the estimated 40,000 people who die annually because of a lack of health insurance, is a ‘pro-life’ position."  [Because an even more fundamental social justice position must include the right to be born.]

It seems to me that some clarifications of Brown’s positions here could help us understand whether or not the people behind "Catholic Democrats" are daft, wicked or smoking weed before issuing these statements.

In the meantime, this watchdog site, On The Issues, says that pro-abortion candidate Coakley:

  • helped minors get court orders without parental consent
  • spoke out strongly in 2007 against a ban on "partial birth abortion,”
  • and supported 35-foot buffer zone at abortion clinics.

Massachusetts WDTPRS readers… you decide.

If I were a Massachusetts resident and voter, I would let nothing keep me from the polls tomorrow, and I would help people get to the polls.

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras | Tagged ,
33 Comments

Old Mass/new Mass thoughts – part 4

Under another entry there has been some consideration of the age of Catholics who prefer the newer form of the Roman Rite, the Novus Ordo.  Old Mass/new Mass thoughts – part 4

Some suggest that people of a certain age may be more interested in the Novus Ordo, while younger people are more open also to the older form of Mass, the TLM.

So, would some of you younger folks take some time to write your thoughts about the new Mass/old Mass question?

I also invite seasoned Catholics to do the same.

Let’s see some responses.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
15 Comments

Before hitting the road

Today I had a hankering for a big breakfast, which I almost never indulge in these days. I’ll probably be skipping lunch!

Before hitting the road

I have great affection for places that specialize in classic American breakfast food… short order.

I have always thought that someone who opened a small counter-style quick breakfast place in the “centro” in Rome could really clean up.

Another interesting breakfast consideration….

In Italy you will typically eat a roll of some kind, with coffee, perhaps milk in it. In Germany you might have some sliced meat and cheese. In some parts of China perhaps some fried bread and a bowl of sweet milk and rice.

What are your breakfast routines? Do you have one? I am very inconsistent when it comes to breakfast I’m afraid, though I nearly always have coffee.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
69 Comments

Chris (“thrill up my leg”) Matthews waxes nostaligic

I picked up this amusing bit about the Massachusetts Senate race from our friend Sancte Pater.

Things are looking so bad for Democrats in Tuesday’s special election for the Senate seat vacated by Ted Kennedy that MSNBC’s Chris Matthews is concerned there aren’t any left-leaning votes for his Party to buy.

“You know in the old days…if the Democrats faced this kind of a disaster in the works, you’d go back to your ones, the people you were sure are going to vote Democrat, and you’d make sure they got to the polling place,” Matthews told NBC’s Chuck Todd on Friday’s “Hardball.”

“You’d get them lunch, you’d get them a car. You’d make sure they got there, and in some cases you’d be buying people to get them,” he continued. “But I hear talking to somebody today there aren’t people up there in Massachusetts like that anymore”

Ah, the good old days.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
35 Comments

NYTimes editorials on Pius XII from 1941 and 1942

These are posted on the site of the Catholic League.  They are editorials from the New York Times in 1941 and 1942:

On Christmas Day, 1941, the New York Times, commenting on Pius XII’s Christmas Message, carried the following editorial:

The Pope’s Message

The voice of Pius XII is a lonely voice in the silence and darkness enveloping Europe this Christmas. The Pope reiterates what he has said before. In general, he repeats, although with greater definiteness, the five-point plan for peace which he first enunciated in his Christmas message after the war broke out in 1939. His program agrees in fundamentals with the Roosevelt-Churchill eight-point declaration. It calls for respect for treaties and the end of the possibility of aggression, equal treatment for minorities, freedom from religious persecution. It goes farther than the Atlantic Charter in advocating an end of all national monopolies of economic wealth, and so far as the eight points, which demands complete disarmament for Germany pending some future limitation of arms for all nations.

The Pontiff emphasized principles of international morality with which most men of good-will agree. He uttered the ideas a spiritual leader would be expected to express in time of war. Yet his words sound strange and bold in the Europe of today, and we comprehend the complete submergence and enslavement of great nations, the very sources of our civilization, as we realize that he is about the only ruler left o the Continent of Europe who dares to raise his voice at all. The last tiny islands of neutrality are so hemmed in and overshadowed by war and fear that no one but the Pope is still able to speak aloud in the name of the Prince of Peace. This is indeed a measure of the "moral devastation" he describes as the accompaniment of physical ruin and inconceivable human suffering.

In calling for a "real new order" based on "liberty, justice and love," to be attained only by a "return to social and international principles capable of creating a barrier against the abuse of liberty and the abuse of power," the Pope put himself squarely against Hitlerism. Recognizing that there is no road open to agreement between belligerents "whose reciprocal war aims and programs seem to be irreconcilable," he left no doubt that the Nazi aims are also irreconcilable with his own conception of a Christian peace. "The new order which must arise out of this war," he asserted, "must be based on principles." And that implies only one end to the war.

 

On Christmas Day, 1942, the Times once again editorialized on the papal Christmas Message and again praised Pius XII for his moral leadership:

The Pope’s Verdict

No Christmas sermon reaches a larger congregation than the message Pope Pius XII addresses to a war-torn world at this season. This Christmas more than ever he is a lonely voice crying out of the silence of a continent. The Pulpit whence he speaks is more than ever like the Rock on which the Church was founded, a tiny island lashed and surrounded by a sea of war. In these circumstances, in any circumstances, indeed, no one would expect the Pope to speak as a political leader, or a war leader, or in any other role than that of a preacher ordained to stand above the battle, tied impartially, as he says, to all people and willing to collaborate in any new order which will bring a just peace.

But just because the Pope speaks to and in some sense for all the peoples at war, the clear stand he takes on the fundamental issues of the conflict has greater weight and authority. When a leader bound impartially to nations on both sides condemns as heresy the new form of national state which subordinates everything to itself: when he declares that whoever wants peace must protect against "arbitrary attacks" the "juridical safety of individuals:" when he assails violent occupation of territory, the exile and persecution of human beings for no reason other than race or political opinion: when he says that people must fight for a just and decent peace, a "total peace" — the "impartial judgment" is like a verdict in a high court of justice.

Pope Pius expresses as passionately as any leader on our side the war aims of the struggle for freedom when he says that those who aim at building a new world must fight for free choice of government and religious order. They must refuse that the state should make of individuals a herd of whom the state disposes as if they were a lifeless thing.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , ,
5 Comments

NYTimes… yawn… against… yawn… Pius XII…. again… yawn

A priest friend of mine in New York says that the New York Times (aka Hell’s Bible) sole reason for continuing is to make liberals feel good about themselves.

On the day Pope Benedict XVI visits the Roman Synagogue comes an NYT piece with the usual smarmy anti-Pius XII slant.

NB: The NYT has beneath its articles links to related articles from the past.   The NYT on its editorial page has a feature of editorials from the paper’s archive.   Today the past articles are about how insensitive the Church is about Jews, blah blah, and the archive editorial concerns that significant players in modern history Conan O’Brien.

The New York Times never cites its editorial from Christmas Day 1941:

"The voice of Pius XII is a lonely voice in the silence and darkness enveloping Europe this Christmas…He is about the only ruler left on the Continent of Europe who dares to raise his voice at all."

The Gestapo in 1942 understood what Pius was talking about.  In a report they summed up: "in a manner never known before…the Pope has repudiated the National Socialist New European Order [Nazism]. It is true, the Pope does not refer to the National Socialists in Germany by name, but his speech is one long attack on everything we stand for. …Here he is clearly speaking on behalf of the Jews."

The Gestapo got it, but the present editors of the New York Times are a bit more obtuse.

That said, let’s have a look at what Hell’s Bible has to say with my emphases and comments:

Pope Quiz: [yuck yuck… get it?] Is Every Pontiff a Saint?
By DAVID GIBSON
Published: January 16, 2010

When Pope Benedict XVI approved a decree last month that nudged nearer to sainthood his controversial wartime predecessor, Pius XII, he sparked another round of the sort of Jewish-Catholic disputations that have marked his papacy  [That is not what has marked this papacy, btw, unless you are in the sphere of the NYT.  What is marking this Pope’s papacy is a developing theology of the environment, and of course his work as the "Pope of Christian Unity". ] and even cast doubt on whether his trip to Rome’s main synagogue, set for Sunday, would go on.  [It didn’t cast much doubt.]

The Vatican paired the announcement of Pius XII’s “heroic virtue” — the step before beatification, which would be followed by canonization, or sainthood — with a similar declaration about Pope John Paul II, who was considered a great friend to the Jews. No matter. Jewish leaders were furious, [I am forced to ask, once again, when do Jews consult the Church about, say, who should be declared a righteous gentile?] though Rome’s Jews decided to go ahead with the papal visit.  [Of course they did.]

Pope Benedict’s decision of course renewed the longstanding debate over Pius’s World War II legacy (was he “silent” or even complicit in the Nazi extermination of the Jews?), [This is the sort of thing to which I alluded at the top.  He tosses this smelly question out here and it will hang in the reader’s mind like a sock on a shower rod through the rest of the article.  He could have asked the question, "Was Pius XII the quiet rescuer of thousands of Jews during the war?] but there is another question here that goes beyond Pius:

Should any pope be made a saint?  [It is hard to fathom why you would ask this question unless you were, say, anti-Catholic.]

The church counts less than a third of all 264 dead popes as saints, and most were canonized by popular acclaim in the first centuries of Christianity, often because they were martyrs. Only five were canonized in the entire second millennium, and when Pius X, who died in 1914, was made a saint in 1954 — by Pius XII — he was the first pope so honored in nearly 400 years.

Now nearly every recent pope is on the canonization track. John Paul II beatified Pius IX, the 19th-century pope who is a polarizing figure because of his belief in the power of the papacy and his views on Judaism. [Remember… just as for the writer the papacy of Benedict XVI is about Jews, so too was the papacy of Pius IX.] But like Benedict, John Paul did a little ticket-balancing. He simultaneously beatified the popular John XXIII, who convened the liberalizing Second Vatican Council in 1962. The canonization process for Paul VI, who followed John XXIII, is underway, and there is a campaign to beatify John Paul I, who reigned a mere 33 days before his death in 1978.

[This is where the writer goes even more seriously off the rails.] This trend, by some accounts, is creating several problems. One is that it can dilute the meaning of sainthood; [Ummm… no, actually not.  The cause of a well-known is actually an opportunity for people to learn more about what the Church teaches concerning holiness, and demonstrates that it is possible to live a good life.] all who die and go to heaven are saints, but those officially recognized as such by the church are exalted as worthy of veneration and imitation. [Ridiculous.  The causes of saints don’t give the impress that all go to heaven.  If there were anything we as Catholic do these days that give that impression it must be the insipid funeral practices we have veered into since the Council.] Is every pope such an exemplar? Moreover, by canonizing predecessors a reigning pope elevates the throne he himself occupies and practically ensures that his successor one day will declare him a saint as well — as if sanctity were an award for becoming pope.  [Silly.  But I think the writer, to color your view, is trying smear the whole process of a cause, suggesting that this is somehow shallow or corrupt, or blend of politics and vanity such as might have been displayed by Julio-Claudian emperors.]

[The writer’s narrow view of the material is made even more funnel-like now.  Notice which rickety hobby-horses he trots on now.] This overlooks the reality that the cardinals in a conclave are electing a leader to govern the church. [That’s not a non sequitur, is it.] As the German theologian Karl Rahner put it, if a pope turns out to be a wonderful Christian, that’s “a happy coincidence,” just as when the president of the chess club is also a great player. It is not necessarily relevant, however, to the health of the chess club — or the church.  [Here we can agree with Karl Rahner.]

In fact, conclaves have often looked for a pope who could govern firmly and defend the church in a dangerous world because that’s what a pope usually had to do. But in modern times, as popes became, first, “prisoners of the Vatican” after the unification of Italy in 1870, and then globetrotting media stars a century later, they also became the universal face of Catholicism. [So?] “Before that, most Catholics would be hard pressed to name the pope and almost none would know what he looked like,” said Christopher Bellitto, a church historian at Kean University in Union, N.J. “After 1870, with cheap printing and his prisoner-of-the-Vatican status, the pope’s face became recognizable and a rallying point for those who wanted to see the world as standing against the church.”  [Ummm…. the world was standing again the Church.]

[This next part should sound familiar to people who keep up with liberal cant against Roman centralization, etc.] This “papalization” of the church means that every pope must now be seen as a holy man, indeed the holiest man in the church, [silly] even if there are pressing issues of governance that would require more savvy than piety. Although John Paul II is a lock for sainthood, serious questions about his administration of the church are emerging as the clergy sexual abuse scandals reveal how he neglected the mundane but critical tasks of being pope. [Again, the chance to smear.  The Church is a pretty big and far-flung organization.  Who can actually govern it in the manner he suggests?  Is it possible?  And should a pope attempt to govern in the manner he suggests, he would be labeled as a despot by the same liberals who whine that he didn’t do enough.]

The Rev. Richard McBrien, [surprise!] a theology professor at Notre Dame and author of “Lives of the Popes,” [Is that the book in which he has his "borrowed" material?] suggested that canonizations may be a defense against criticism of popes, and he said the church would do better to canonize more saintly lay people — parents and grandparents and regular holy folk “with whom the overwhelming majority of Catholics can identify.”  [Has that been done?]

“The only one of the recent batch of papal candidates for canonization who is at all credible is John XXIII,” [ROFL!  That’s it?] Father McBrien wrote in an e-mail message. “But I would gladly trade John XXIII’s candidacy for the suspension of procedures on behalf of the other recent popes.”  [Retire.]

Yet to avoid canonizing John Paul II or any pope at this point could come off as an insult, or a knock on the papacy. That forces promoters of papal canonizations, and defenders of Pius XII in particular, to create a false division between official actions and personal piety. [?  So, it a Pope makes a mistake in judgement, that means that he was not holy?  I guess that wouldn’t help the cause of John XXIII.  Say what you want about the Council, but if we look at what has happened in the last few decades no one can say that the choice to have a Council … and a Council without a clear agenda at he opening, btw,… didn’t cause upheaval and confusion redounded into our own day.  It was at least controversial and questionable.  If that is the case, then his holiness must also be at question.] As a papal spokesman said in defending Benedict’s decision on Pius, “the evaluation essentially concerns the witness of Christian life that the person showed … and not the historical impact of all his operative decisions.”  [The development of the Gregorian Calendar was of great benefit for the world, but that benefit did not necessarily mean that Gregory XIII was thereby holy.]

But as Mr. Bellitto said, “based on this formula, plenty of nice people who did awful things would qualify for sainthood — and they’d hardly be models for the rest of us.”

Such a restricted view of sainthood also easily dismisses the realities of a pope’s job — and the debatable record of Pius XII. Hans Küng, [surprise!] the dissident Swiss theologian, recalls an episode during his days as a student in Rome in the 1950s when the private secretary of Pius XII, Father Robert Lieber, visited the seminary. Father Küng and the other young men pestered Father Lieber about whether the aristocratic Pius was a saint: “No, no!” the priest insisted. “Pius XII is not a saint. He is a great man of the church.”

It’s a verdict that makes Pius XII neither villain nor plaster icon, but neither does it answer the question of what a modern pope should be — a leader of the church or a model of sanctity?  [What an absurd question.  Of course a Pope ought to be a model of sanctity.  So should your spouse, teacher, neighbor, football coach and boss.]

David Gibson, author of a biography of Benedict XVI, writes on religion at PoliticsDaily.com.
A version of this article appeared in print on January 17, 2010, on page WK4 of the New York edition.

Dreck.

From the New York Times Christmas Day editorial of 1942:

Pope Pius expresses as passionately as any leader on our side the war aims of the struggle for freedom when he says that those who aim at building a new world must fight for free choice of government and religious order. They must refuse that the state should make of individuals a herd of whom the state disposes as if they were a lifeless thing.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
25 Comments