Statement of SSPX Rector about priesthood ordinations on 27 June 2009

As you know, the SSPX has the German bishops in a Tizzy because of the ordinations at their German seminary in Zaitzkofen.

To be clear, the SSPX does not have permission from the Church to ordain anyone.  The SSPX are suspended a divinis.  They validly ordain, but they do so illicitly.  When the men are ordained priests, they are automatically suspended.  They do not yet belong to any recognized ecclesiatical structure which can grant them faculties.

Here is a statement about the ordinations from the rector of that SSPX seminary. A reader provided me with a translation.  My emphases and comments:

Statement of Rector Stefan Frey on the occasion of the ordinations to the priesthood on 27 June, 2009

The Seminary of the Sacred Heart of Jesus, of the Society of St. Pius X, in Zaitzkofen.

As rector, I would like to issue a statement at the beginning of today’s priestly ordinations to explain how we see today’s ceremony and how we would like them to be understood.

We regret that the public discourse about the Society of St. Pius X and about these priestly ordinations has been dominated by emotion.  [Some have actually used reason.]
 
We regret that we had to recently experience massive verbal ostracism from several German bishops. [There were rumblings of excommunication.]

It is very clear: Their position is completely at odds with the conduct of Rome.  [Remember, that the SSPX bishops were excommunicated.  The Holy Father lifted the excommunications as a kind and merciful gesture.  But the problems still remain.  Yes!  The conduct of Rome has been benevolent.]

It must be recognized that Rome has not tied the doctrinal discussions about the Second Vatican Council with the Society of St. Pius X, which will soon begin, to the condition that we refrain from dispensing the sacraments in the meantime, until a practical agreement is reached.  [So, "Rome didn’t say we couldn’t!"  Is that something like a teenager saying that "Dad didn’t say we couldn’t" after hot wiring the family car for the fourth time, taking it for a joyride, and getting his licence suspended.]

If our society were to acquiesce to the demands of several German bishops and stop ordaining priests, celebrating the Mass, and dispensing the sacraments because we are currently in a gray area with respect to canon law, then that would amount to our de factio dissolution.  [Well… not really.   Also, I bet that if they said they wouldn’t ordain, perhaps the Holy See would even grant temporary faculties to say Mass.  That is my conjecture, of course, from the purest optimism.  But large gestures on both sides should be met with expansive gratitude.]

By making these demands, these bishops have twisted the intention of the Pope in lifting the decree of excommunication into its opposite.  [This is probably right.  But don’t fool yourself into thinking that the POPE thinks that what you are doing, outside the structures of the Church, is okay!]

We wish to make clear that the Society is merely the occasion, and not the cause of the current public conflict, which more and more is starting to address the Church’s real problem.  [This is hard to follow.  Is the Society "starting to address the Church’s real problem"?  I don’t think that that is their role.]

This problem is well described by the words of the former Bishop of Regensburg, Msgr. Rudolf Graber:

"Everything is at stake. The Church is at stake. It is a matter of a gigantic revolution in the Church!" – "Protestantism was the first step. Afterwards follows modernism. It all ends in atheism." – There is a desire to "strip the Church of her supernatural character, to blend her into the world, to turn confessional coexistence into ecumenical fusion."

This is also our appraisal. We see an unprecedented crisis in the Church, even moreso today than 36 years ago, when Bishop Graber’s outstanding analysis of the crisis was released under the title "Athanasius and the Church of our Time."

The actions of the Society of St. Pius X this day can only be understood against this background. There is a crisis of faith in the Church, and a crisis of the priesthood. This is an emergency situation that has been caused, in large part, by forces inside the Church, which is endangering the faith and the eternal salvation of very many souls.

Because we love the Church, we are obligated by our conscience to continue using the 2000 year old tradition of the Church as our standard in priestly formation, which reaches its glorious conclusion in the ordination to the priesthood.  [Despite the fact that it is done in disobedience.  Is there a flaw in the formation somewhere?] We ask every person, to whom the good of the Church is truly dear, to look beyond human perils and to accept our honest and genuine desire to serve the Church. [Yes.  I do accept that.  And I really look forward to the day when some day it might be true and fruitful service]  Only an objective and honest debate, marked by mutual respect, can bring blessings upon the Church.  [Agreed!  100%]

Fr. Stefan Frey, Rector

I so hope that the SSPX leadership will honestly submit themselves to the doctrinal discussions with the necessary humility.

We need these men reconciled and intergrated into the Church.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
149 Comments

Fr. Tim Vakoc, RIP

The funeral of Fr. Tim Vakoc, a priest of the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis and a Military Chaplain wounded in Iraq some years ago, took place today at the Cathedral of St. Paul.

His casket borne into the Cathedral.

Fr. Tim Vakoc, RIP

More at Stella Borealis.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
17 Comments

A Swiss bishop sounds off about Vatican II

A reader sent me the following from the website of the Diocese of Basel, Switzerland.   His Excellency Most Rev. Kurt Koch has weighed in with comments in a rather highly amped German-language speaking environment.  As you know there is a lot of tension right now in the German-speaking areas over traditional expressions of Catholicism. 

This is from the July 2009 monthly newsletter to the priests of the Diocese of Basel with my emphases and comments.

What moves me?

More honesty please! [A good way to start.]

In the last few weeks a lot of journalists, and also some clergy, have been expressing their opinions of Pope Benedict. [Surely this has to do with Summorum Pontificum  and the lifting of the SSPX excommunications.] In these opinions were also contained many half-truths, untruths, and slanders.The worst accusation asserts that the Pope wishes to go back to before the Second Vatican Council. This accusation is the worst because it implies that the very person who possesses the teaching authority of the universal Church would work to undermine the authority of the council. This verdict, however, would be completely mistaken. As a young theologian, in fact, Benedict XVI contributed very much to the council. [And, as a young theologian he also criticized some aspects of the Council’s documents.]  Anyone who seeks to understand the Pope now — not just from the media — but also by reading what he writes, would come to the conclusion that he has oriented his entire magisterium on the council. [Hmmm… interesting statement.  "…dass er sein ganzes Lehramt am Konzil orientiert".  Maybe a better way to say this is "toward the Council"?  He has grounded his own teaching as Pope in the Council documents?  Fine.  But at the same time I wonder if we would do better to say that Benedict has reoriented the Council, rather, the understanding – the interpretation – of the Council toward the entire Magisterium?] How should we then understand the accusation being made?

Many people have signed a petition for the unqualified acceptance of the council. Right from the start, the expression "unqualified acceptance" irritates me because I don’t know anyone — myself included — to whom it would apply. A few arbitrarily chosen examples will suffice:  [This is great….]

      – The council did not abolish Latin in the liturgy. On the contrary, it emphasized that in the Roman Rite, apart from exceptional cases, the use of the Latin language must be maintained. Who among the vocal defenders of the council wishes "unqualified acceptance" of that?  [Right.  Hey, you liberals out there!  Wanna sign on to that?]

      – The council declared that the Church regards Gregorian Chant as the "music proper to the Roman Rite", and that it must therefore "be given primary place." In how many parishes is this implemented "without qualification?"  [Liberals only like the parts of the Council that they like.]

      – The council expressly requested that governmental authorities voluntarily give up those rights to participation in the selection of bishops, that had arisen over the course of time. Which defender of the council advocates "without qualification" for that?  [Most liberals think that there should be popular or at least local election of bishops without interference from Rome.]

      – The council described the fundamental nature of the liturgy as the celebration the pascal mystery and the eucharistic sacrifice as "the completion of the work of our salvation." How can that be reconciled with my experience, made in many different parishes, that the sacrificial understanding of the Mass has been completely eliminated from the liturgical language and the Mass is now understood only as a meal or "the breaking of bread?" In what way can one justify this profound change by reference to the council?  [I am starting to like this bishop.]

      – No office of the Church was given more significance by the council that that of bishop. [One might actually argue that way too much significance.] How can we then understand the widespread diminishment in Switzerland of this office of the Church, which is justified by reference to the council? When, for example, Hans Kung denies completely the teaching authority of the bishops, allowing them only the office of pastoral leadership?  [ZzzzzzOT!]

It would not be difficult to lengthen this litany. Even so, it should be obvious why I demand more honesty in the current debate about the council. Instead of accusing others, and even the Pope, of wishing to go back to before the council, everyone would be well advised to look over their own books and reassess their own personal position on the council. [In other words READ THE TEXTS.]  Because not everything that was said and done after the council, was therefore done in accordance with the council — and that applies also to the diocese of Basel. In any case, the last few weeks have illustrated to me that a primary problem in the current situation has been a very poor, and in part very one-sided understanding and acceptance of the council, [We might even call it a "hermeneutic of discontinuity and rupture".] even by Catholics that defend the council "without qualification." In this regard we all — once more including myself — have a lot of ground to make up. Therefore I again repeat my urgent request: More honesty please!

+ Kurt Koch
Bishop of Basel

 

Official WDTPRS kudos to Bishop Koch!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , , ,
46 Comments

Ad orientem versus

Over at NLM there is a good photo of His Eminence Daniel Card. DiNardo reading Holy Mass ad orientem.

The Mass was at the Anglican Use parish Our Lady of Walsingham in Houston, Texas.

Ad orientem versus 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
31 Comments

“aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!”

Friends from Rome are visiting the Sabine Farm. 

Alas, they must drink my poor Sabine wine rather than the Falernian and Caecuban and Formian they are accustomed to quaff.

We do, however, know how to prepare Sabine meats on the grill!

One of the kids (there are four), can’t eat beef.  He got some nice little frenched lamb chops.

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

There were some fine pork ribs with barbecue sauce.

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

And the grown ups had T-bones.

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

It was great to watch someone else at the grill and just have a beer and shoot the breeze.

It was a perfect evening, temperature-wise.  Sunny skies and a breeze.

We started our revels in the late afternoon with Holy Mass in the chapel, with the Votive Mass of Christ the High Priest.

Then we trooped out to the bee hives to bless the bees!

From the Roman Ritual:

O Lord God Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth!  Thou didst create all living things for man’s use.  Moreover, thou didst order by the ministry of thy holy Church that candles made from the industry of bees shall burn during the Sacred Mystery in which we consecrate and consume the most holy Body and Blood of Jesus Christ, thy Son.  Send thy holy blessing + upon these bees and this beehive to make them numerous and productive, and to preserve them from harm, so that their yield of wax can be turned to thy honor, and to the honor of they Son and Holy Spirit, and to the veneration of the Blessed Virgin Mary.  Through the same Christ our Lord.

Amen.

I am told there are 40k bees in each hive.

They had no comment on the whole affair.

The kids are having a great time: I believe there is a lot of frog catching going on even as I write.

I don’t think a kid has been a kid until frogs have been caught, fireflies captured and put in jars, and dragonflies pursued.

There may even be a measure of chipmunk terrorizing taking place.

I’m with Martial on this one:

Ludi magister, parce simplici turbae:
sic te frequentes audiant capillati
et delicatae diligat chorus mensae,
nec calculator nec notarius velox
maiore quisquam circulo coronetur.
cirrata loris horridis Scythae pellis,
qua vapulavit* Marsyas Celaenaeus,
ferulaeque tristes, sceptra paedagogorum,
cessent et Idus dormiant in Octobres:
aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt.

 

PENJING REPORT

Penjing has been perfectly fine during my trip eastward.  As usual.

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

What surprised me was the incredible growth shown by Penzai, the Chinese Elm.

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

Irohamomiji, the Japanese Maple, is still doing its best to bud, but this tree is pretty slow.  I am wondering if perhaps it was dropped on its head as a sapling.

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

My rosemary, which survived the winter, is blooming like mad.

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

From the feeder, there is some news.

The birds seem now to have changed some of their eating habits.  I have noticed that some birds have changed what they prefer to eat.  For example, the Goldfinches, who are getting ready to nest, have been less after the thistle but the other seeds on the other feeders.  On the other hand, the Rose-breasted Grosbeak was hanging out on the finches’ thistle socks.  Odd.

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

The Goldfinches are really arguing these days.

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

See?  Mrs. Grosbeak on the thistle sock.  Odd.

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

Some shots.

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

But wait!   The Grosbeak is now getting in on the Oriole’s action.

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

"aestate pueri si valent, satis discunt!"

* a very cool verb.  It is sort of the opposite of a deponent, active in form but passive in meaning.

Posted in Fr. Z's Kitchen, Lighter fare, SESSIUNCULA, The Feeder Feed |
27 Comments

QUAERITUR: Closing of Year for Priests, June 11 or June 19?

From a priest reader:

I’d like to point out a discrepancy, with the hopes that your wide outreach might bring about a clarification.

The discrepancy concerns the closing date for the “Year for Priests”.  The Holy Father says [LINK] that the Year “will conclude on the same Solemnity in 2010”, that solemnity being the same one on which it began (the Sacred Heart, which in 2009 was June 19).  In 2010, the Solemnity of the Sacred Heart will fall on June 11, 2010.

However, the Apostolic Penitentiary as far back as April 25, 2009 says [LINK] that the closing date will be June 19, 2010 (a year from the DATE of the opening).  This date has been picked up by the USCCB [LINK].

Meanwhile, the Congregation for Clergy’s site [LINK] gives the closing date as June 11, 2010.

Two dicasteries of the Holy See which are central to this special Year seem to have different dates.

I suspect that the correct date is 11 June, the Feast of the Sacred Heart, since that is what the Congregation for Clergy says and it is what the Holy Father intimated in "on the same solemnity".

If that is so, then the USCCB has the wrong date.

I hope we can get some clarity soon.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests, Year of Priests |
8 Comments

Interview with SSPX Fr. Schmidberger, Superior in Germany

Our friends at Rorate have put up an English translation of an interview by KNA (Katholische Nachrichten-Agentur) with SSPX Fr. Franz Schmidberer.  Fr. Schmidberger was once the Superior of the SSPX and he is presently the SSPX Superior for Germany.  At you probably know, there is tension in Germany right now especially among the bishops, regarding the SSPX’s intention to ordain priests soon.

Here is Rorate’s translation with my emphases and comments.  Be sure to go visit them and see what others are saying there as well.

Thursday, June 25, 2009

IMPORTANT INTERVIEW
"Similar to Opus Dei?"

Schmidberger responds: "Somewhat."

Some ordinations of new priests by the Bishops of the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Pius X (FSSPX / SSPX) took place in the United States last Saturday. New ordinations are expected for next Saturday in Germany – despite the overreaction of several German ordinaries. Amidst the controversy, the German Catholic News Agency (KNA – Katholische Nachrichten-Agentur) interviewed the former Superior General of the SSPX and current Superior for the District of Germany, Father Franz Schmidberger (source: DomRadio):

    The German Superior of the Priestly Fraternity of St. Pius X, Franz Schmidberger, has defended the ordination of new priests planned for the coming weekend. In an interview with the Catholic News Agency (KNA), Schmidberger also commented on his assessment of the Second Vatican Council and what he expects from further discussions with Rome.

    KNA: Herr Schmidberger, are you a priest of the Catholic Church?  [This question strikes me as being provocative, even hostile, from the onset.]

    Schmidberger: Of course. I was ordained to the priesthood in 1975 by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre in Econe.

    KNA: You say that without any qualifications? [See?]

    Schmidberger: Yes. I live and work in the heart of the Church.

    KNA: What does the Second Vatican Council mean to you? [More.]

    Schmidberger: There is no doubt that it was an ecumenical council, but among the 21 councils it possesses a unique status as a pastoral council. [A classic distinction.   I think this is often used when people don’t want to pay attention to the Council.] Both popes of the council declared that they wished to define no new dogmas. Therefore, the Second Vatican Council does not have the same status as the other councils.

    KNA: What about its content?

    Schmidberger: The spirit of the council has been described as an evil spirit, even by Pope Benedict XVI. There are ambiguous statements in the documents, and many others that do not agree with traditional doctrine. [I guess that would be a "no" vote, then.]

    KNA: What should the theological dialogue between the society and Rome regarding the council look like?

    Schmidberger: As far as the external form goes, it could be both oral or written, but primarily it should be written. We have selected representatives from our side and Rome also has chosen its people. [Some good information there.] The discussions will consider: what is ambiguous in the council? What contradicts the traditional doctrine of the Church?  [I would love to see the SSPX’s list.]

    KNA: Frankly, do you believe that the old and new rites can continue to coexist over the long term?

    Schmidberger: Well, we will have to see how things develop. There are profound differences between the two rites; for example, the direction of the celebration. The old rite is God-centered. The new is man-centered. Many of the gestures, symbols, and rituals have been fundamentally changed. Today, the old rite is like a solid rock amidst the pounding surf, that must remain unchanged. The new rite requires radical reworking so that the sacrificial nature is once again explicitly expressed.  [Well… I don’t that last observation was entirely accurate.  I think the sacrificial nature is explicitly expressed. While it is certain that in many places the Novus Ordo is celebrated with little concept of the sacrificial dimension of Mass, the newer form can be offered in a way consistent with tradition.]

    KNA: What does the Society think of the Council’s Decree on Ecumenism [Unitatis Redintegratio]?

    Schmidberger: It says that other [Christian] denominations are means of salvation. If that is true, then there is no longer any point in engaging in missionary activity. That needs to be cleared up. [Perhaps we need a little thought experiment: Since one of the effects of baptism is that the one baptized becomes a member of Christ’s Body, the Church, and since many non-Catholic Christian denominations used valid baptism, it seems that the way to salvation is open to non-Catholic Christians even though they are not formally Catholic, though that way is much much more difficult.  But, in the main, this all has to be "cleared up".]

    KNA: What about Nostra Aetate, which concerns the relationship with the Jews? [A hot button question for this German news agency conducting the interview.]

    Schmidberger: Not only the Jews, it also concerns Islam, Hinduism, and Buddhism. These non-Christian religions are heaped with praise. This has encouraged the expansion of Islam, for example. Today there are 4.3 million Muslims in Germany. The Church has a mandate to work for their conversion, but I do not know of a single German bishop who has made any plans to do so. As far as the relationship with the Jews goes, the statements of the Council cannot be criticized in their essence. But, since the Council, the idea keeps popping up that the Jews have their owns path to salvation. That is completely opposed to the missionary command of Jesus Christ.

    KNA: And you also have problems with the description of the Jews by Pope John Paul II as the older brothers of Christians.

    Schmidberger: Certainly Abraham, Isaac, Jacob and the prophets are. [The forerunners of the New Covenant.] But the Jews of today are not, because they do not recognize Jesus Christ as the one and only redeemer. How could they then be older brothers?

    KNA: Is the impression correct, that you, with your positions, wish to set the price for unity with the Catholic Church.  [A fair question, though the interviewer still seems somewhat hostile.]

    Schmidberger: We want the truth to triumph. It has nothing to do with subjective opinions, it is all about the truth.

    KNA: As you define it.  [Fair enough.  The SSPX leadership seems not to want to submit their minds and wills to the Church’s teaching authority unless the teaching already coincides with what they want to hear.]

    Schmidberger: No, we read all of the previous statements of the Councils and the popes. Pope Pius IX spoke out against religious freedom, for example. The question is: do these false religions possess natural rights? The Second Vatican Council answers differently than Pius IX. That is a rupture. [And that needs to be cleared up.]

    KNA: Canon law requires priests to submit to the local bishop. Why is that difficult for you?

    Schmidberger: It isn’t difficult at all. But we are our own society, [Get that?  Thus, they don’t have to submit to the local bishops.] that was even praised by Rome in 1971. [Well, that was then and this is now.  Whatever permissions the SSPX originally had were removed.] Afterwards, we developed our own life. Then tensions developed because we refused to participate in the destructive protestantizing reforms. We have questions about the faith of the Church and the bishops only respond by demanding obediance. [Indeed, the SSPX has not been properly treated in this regard.  The doctrinal discussions should have been engaged long ago.] But faith is superior to obediance. [This would be a good point for discussion.]

    KNA: In connection with the Williamson scandal, Pope Benedict XVI accused the SSPX of arrogance and urged you to refrain from provocations. But the opposite has happened. How can you help to put the pieces back together?

    Schmidberger: Naturally, every man has his weaknesses and unfortunate things have been said. But we want to live together peacefully. I have written a private personal letter to the chairman of the bishops conference, Archbishop Zollitsch, but the bishops are not willing to engage in discussions. They reject any dialogue with us. Why do they demand that we obey canon law to the letter while at the same time they assert that we are outside the Church?  [I should think that is clear.  If you don’t admit that teachings of a Council, obey the law that is in part shaped by that Council and promulgated by proper authority, if you don’t obey the Pope who promulgated the law or the bishop designated to guide a diocese, then… well… why would anyone get the idea that the SSPX is outside the Church?]

    KNA: In 2005 there was a conversation in Castel Gandofo, in which, in addition to the Pope, curial Cardinal Dario Castrillon Hoyos, and Traditionalist Bishop Bernard Fellay, you also took part. What was agreed at that time?

    Schmidberger: We discussed the entire situation with the Society and agreed on the path which we are now following. The Motu Proprio of 2007 and the lifting of the so-called [I love that part.  I never tire of it.] excommunications were the first steps. Now comes the theological dialogue. Next, we have to find a canonical structure for the Society with its 500 priests. We are satisfied with the solution that Rome is considering.  [This is an important part of the interview.]

    KNA: Which is?

    Schmidberger: In the direction of a personal prelature. [There it is.]

    KNA: Similar to Opus Dei?  [I suppose there would have to be some work to figure out how the SSPX functions within dioceses.]

    Schmidberger: Somewhat.

    KNA: More ordinations are planned for the coming weekend, although Rome has said that they are illict. Why do you insist on these ordinations?

    Schmidberger: The supreme law of the Church is the salvation of souls. The faithful have a right to the celebration of the traditional form of the Mass. The point is making priests who desire to proclaim the Gospel available. The ordinations are not meant to be an affront to anybody. They are actually being done to help the Pope and the bishops. But it like dealing with patients who do not see what medicine does for their health.  [sigh… with this attitude… oh well….]

    KNA: And so you claim the role of physician.

    Schmidberger: Yes, that is true. Tradition is the only guide to bringing the Church out of the present crisis. In 1950, 13 million Catholics went to Sunday Mass. Now it is just under 2 million. That is a drop of 85 percent. In ten years, all of the Churches will be empty. [He can’t, of course, know that.] Is that what the bishops want? What is going to happen to our children? It is about preserving Christianity in the West.

 

A good interview, though I think the interviewer sounded a little hostile from time to time.

Fr. Schmidberger kept his cool and only stumbled into an unfortunate turn of phrase a couple times.  I think he was trying to be careful, but some things must be pretty ingrained over these years.  That business at the end about the Pope and bishops being sick and not knowing that they need the medicine that the SSPX is going to force on them for their own good was a bad stumble in my opinion.  The SSPXers would do well to avoid saying this sort of thing.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , ,
195 Comments

Amerika Magazine gets it wrong again

The Jesuit editors of Amerika Magazine have little clarity about both recent American history or sound theology.  This is obvious from their editorial in the 22 June issue.

Be prepared for some bad writing here.  They are getting worse.

Now we get this.  My emphases and comments.

Amerika Magazine gets it wrong againObama Going to the Vatican
Posted at: 2009-06-24 08:24:59.0
Author: Michael Sean Winters

Pope Benedict XVI will receive President Barack Obama in audience at the Vatican on July 10. Let the gnashing of teeth begin. 

Admit it, wasn’t your first impulse to call Dr. Mary Ann Glendon and ask, "If you were still the ambassador, would you show up or would you boycott?" The Cardinal Newman Society, which spent the better part of the spring telling the world that no Catholic could in good conscience share the stage with President Obama, [Isn’t this is a falsehood? The objection was not about "sharing a stage" at all.  The objection was that Notre Dame chose to honor the most aggressive pro-abortion politician we have ever seen.  What is worse, ND bestowed on him an honorary doctorate of law.] perhaps now they will start issuing press releases entitled "Pope Creates Scandal" or "Outrage at the Vatican." The Catholic News Agency, which featured the headline "Vatican announces Pope’s vacation without confirmation of Obama visit" just a few weeks ago, has nary a mention of the visit on its website this morning. Cat got your tongue? 

Obama’s Catholic critics need to re-calibrate their message and it is difficult to see how they will compete with the pictures of Obama in the frescoed halls of the Vatican, his beautiful wife and children in tow, shaking hands with the Holy Father.  Actually, in addition to shaking hands, it is traditional that the Pope will present a gift to the President. Does that count as an "honor" of the kind forbidden by the bishops’ document "Catholics in Political Life"? [Puhleeze] Notre Dame, of course, has a tradition of conferring an honorary degree upon every new president that pre-dates presidential visits to the Holy See.  [So what?  Does that make it right to do in the case of this president?  Does this writer seriously think that the gift a Pope gives to a head of state is the same as an honor?  An honorary doctorate for law?]

More importantly, and as mentioned yesterday while considering the new document on Catholic health care and labor unions, there are ways to work with people who do not agree with us on certain matters. [Here we go.  Start pouring the koolaid.] Let it be said again and again: The Church’s commitment to human dignity, and concern for the protection of the unborn, is not just one issue among many. It is, in a certain sense, foundational to both our moral concerns and to our sense of the right ordering of our nation’s constitutional guarantees. In saying we must work with President Obama we are not suggesting breezily that we should "agree to disagree" and move on. We are saying that we can better witness to our beliefs by engaging the President. [Engage is one thing and honor is another.  Perhaps a better witness to our beliefs would have been to decline to honor him.] We are saying that if we spend time in the trenches with him fighting for the rights of workers, the rights of immigrants, and the rights of citizens to health care, our testimony on behalf of the unborn will be more persuasive to this President and his party which is otherwise so dedicated to the vindication of rights but here, on this issue, has a horrendous blind spot.  [Riiiiight.  President Obama is going to alter his position if the Catholic Church does the heavy lifting on the rest of the President’s list of things to do.]

It was the collective failure of the U.S. bishops to find a way to be represented on the stage at Notre Dame’s commencement, to express their ambivalence about the President, to do what Father Jenkins did, which was to tell the President to his face that we admire him so much but we disagree profoundly with him on abortion and embryonic stem cell research. [It was not a collective failure.  It was a collective victory.  Had there been bishops there, the scandal would have been far worse.]  No single event focused the nation’s attention – live coverage of a commencement address! – on the relationship between the President and the Church, and the bishops spoke only with their absence which is a difficult message to hear.  [Why, yes.  Indeed it is.]

Next month, Pope Benedict will send a different message. He will undoubtedly address the Church’s concern for the unborn and her opposition to embryonic stem cell research. He will also discuss the economy, and health care, and peace in the Mideast. He will hold the President’s large hands in his small hands, [blech] he will gather Sasha and Malia into the folds of his white cassock, he will treat the President with respect and humanity. Pope Benedict, like the Master, is not afraid to sit down with the publican because, in his wisdom, the Pope knows we are all publicans.

Popes meet with people.  Bishops meet with people.  No one has said that bishops or His Holiness shouldn’t meet with President Obama or be seen together in public.  We are in favor of the Pope meeting with President Obama.  This is what Popes do.   They meet with all sort of people, even heads of state, good and criminal alike.

John Paul II met with Fidel Casto and Yassir Arafat.

Paul VI met with Idi Amin Dada.

So, Pres. Obama goes to the Vatican.  The Pope gives him a gift, some trinket, maybe a blessed rosary or… a little vase.  Is that suppose to be the equivalent of an honorary doctorate?

When Popes gives something to heads of state who visit, the gift means little more than "Thanks for coming to my house." 

The Pope won’t bestow a formal honor on President Obama.

Do you remember the reasons given by Notre Dame for bestowing this great honor on the aggressively pro-abortion President?

"At the 164th Commencement The May Exercises The University of Notre Dame Confers the degree of Doctor of Laws, honoris causa, on the 44th president of the United States, whose historic election opened a new era of hope in a country long divided by its history of slavery and racism. A community organizer who honed his advocacy for the poor, the marginalized and the worker in the streets of Chicago, he now organizes a larger community, bringing to the world stage a renewed American dedication to diplomacy and dialogue with all nations and religions committed to human rights and the global common good. ["common good"] Through his willingness to engage with those who disagree with him and encourage people of faith to bring their beliefs to the public debate, he is inspiring this nation to heal its divisions of religion, culture, race and politics in the audacious hope for a brighter tomorrow.  [Great… if you are already born.  Er um… but no!  Wasn’t there something about denying medical care to some people who were born despite attempts to the contrary?]

On Barack H. Obama, Washington, District of Columbia"

John Paul II describes the "common good" in Evangelium vitae.

72… Laws which authorize and promote abortion and euthanasia are therefore radically opposed not only to the good of the individual but also to the common good; as such they are completely lacking in authentic juridical validity. Disregard for the right to life, precisely because it leads to the killing of the person whom society exists to serve, is what most directly conflicts with the possibility of achieving the common good.

Want more?

101… It is impossible to further the common good without acknowledging and defending the right to life, upon which all the other inalienable rights of individuals are founded and from which they develop… Only respect for life can be the foundation and guarantee of the most precious and essential goods of society, such as democracy and peace.

BTW… Arizona State University didn’t give Pres. Obama an honorary degree because, as they reasoned it, he had not yet earned one.  

Don’t you just hate it when a secular university gets it right and the Catholic university gets it so very wrong?

Amerika doesn’t have a clue.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, The Drill | Tagged , , ,
79 Comments

Clergy and music revisited

Remember the question about deacons and music ministry?

Vultus Christi had an interesting photo of a group of priests of the Diocese of Tulsa singing Gregorian chant during a Mass.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, Linking Back |
30 Comments

QUAERITUR: Novus Ordo Lectionary with the older Mass, TLM

From a reader:

Is it okay to attend Mass in the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite when the readings are in the vernacular and taken from the Lectionary for the Ordinary Form? I know this was expressly prohibited before Summorum Pontificum and seems to need clarification since.
 
I ask because there is a small Mass that does this locally. I love Latin and would like to attend, but it seems… fishy… Your advice would be very much appreciated!

A couple things must be clarified.

First, it is indeed "okay" to attend an EF Mass when the readings are in the vernacular from the new Lectionary.

Second, you say that it was expressly prohibited to use the new Lectionary with the older form of Mass.  That is not accurate.  It was expressly permitted.  The Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei issued guidelines in 1991 which said:

5.Following upon the "wide and generous application" of the principles laid down in Quattuor Abhinc Annos and the directives of the fathers of the Second Vatican Council (cf. Sacrosanctum Concilium, nos. 51 and 54), the new lectionary in the vernacular could be used as a way of "providing a richer fare for the faithful at the table of God’s Word" in Masses celebrated according to the 1962 missal. However, we believe that this usage should not be imposed on congregations who decidedly wish to maintain the former liturgical tradition in its integrity according to the provision of the motu proprio Ecclesia Dei. Such an imposition might also be less likely to invite back to full communion with the Church at this time those who have lapsed into schismatic worship.

So, it is permitted, even now, to use the newer Lectionary, but this is not to be done if the sensibilities of the congregation would be against it.

The Motu Proprio of Benedict XVI Summorum Pontificum says.

Art. 6  In Masses celebrated in the presence of the people in accordance with the Missal of Bl. John XXIII, the readings may be given in the vernacular, using editions recognised by the Apostolic See.

We have discussed this point before on the blog, and come to a conclusion that this refers to the use of the newer Lectionary being used with the older Mass, the readings during Mass being read a single time by the priest in the vernacular from the new Lectionary.

So, from the point of view of the congregation, yes, it is okay to attended these Masses.

However, from the point of view of the priest, it might not be a good idea to do them in this way, if the congregation would be against it.  This would surely be a matter of real controversy.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
50 Comments