Vietnamese government secretly destroys Catholic monastery

From CNA this alarming story:

Vietnamese government secretly destroys Catholic monastery

Hanoi, Vietnam, Jun 11, 2009 / 05:07 am (CNA).- The Vietnamese government has renewed its seizures of Catholic Church properties in the country, demolishing several monasteries to build hotels and tourist resorts. The move has generated fears that the government has adopted a new and “harsh” approach to Catholics.

Last week the government ordered the destruction of the monastery of the Congregation of the Brothers of the Holy Family in Long Xuyen, Vietnam. A spokesman for the diocese said the former two-story home of the priests and religious of the Holy Family Order was destroyed on June 4. The Sisters of St. Paul of Chartres’ monastery in Vinh Long was also recently destroyed.

The Brothers of the Holy Family monastery, built in 1971, was still in good condition and its destruction surprised Catholic officials, Fr. J.B. An Dang reports. The local government did not inform the diocese about its intention to tear down the building and has not announced its intention for the future use of the land.

The monastery’s altar and religious statues were all discarded in a garbage dump. Neither the diocese nor the religious order has been officially informed to go and retrieve the items.  [Sounds like my days in seminary… when the dumpster was being filled with vestments, vessels and altar stones.  Save the liturgy, save the world.]

The Congregation of the Brothers of The Holy Family of Banam was founded by Bishop Valentin Herrgott, the then-Apostolic Vicar of Phnom-Penh, Cambodia in 1931. The order moved to Long Xuyen in Vietnam after a 1970 coup against Cambodian monarch Norodom Sihanouk created security concerns.

In 1984 all brothers of the congregation were arrested and charged with “anti-revolutionary activities.” Their monastery was seized and they have been jailed for years without a trial. [Since… 1984?]

The congregation has repeatedly asked for the return of its monastery and has protested the unjust detention of its members.

Especially over the past two years, Vietnamese Catholics have sought the return of church properties confiscated by the government. They have met with defeat and frustration, Fr. An Dang says.

On May 21, Nguyen Thanh Xuan, the government’s deputy chief of religious affairs, announced that the state "has no intention of returning any property or goods to the Catholic Church or any other religious organization."

According to Fr. An Dang, the destruction of the Long Xuyen monastery and Xuan’s statement have increased concerns that the government has applied a “new, harsh policy on Church’s properties in which there would be no more dialogue.”

The government’s new policy approach might act “as if the State is the true owner with full authority on Church’ assets.”

 

Let us, who live in happier places, keep always in mind both the suffering of our brothers and sisters elsewhere and also that our liberties can be lost.  If otherwise good people simply stand by and do nothing, even as the signs of the times reveal their trend, evil triumphs.

Posted in The future and our choices |
23 Comments

Spin off

The long running hit Cheers produced another long running amusing spin off Frasier, following the character Frasier Crane.

The inexplicably popular Happy Days produced the inexplicable Mork and Mindy.

Stargate has produced Stargate and, I think, Stargate with a consistent character, I think. 

Star Trek.. something similar.

How many did All In The Family produce?

What TV series character would you most want to see spun off in a show?

For example, I would like to see The West Wing’s character Charlie spun off into his own show.

Firefly’s Mel… on another life track and ship?

Prime Suspect’s DCI Tennison post police?

And if you don’t like any TV at all, you might go find another entry to read and leave this one be.

Posted in Lighter fare, SESSIUNCULA |
71 Comments

A wonderful note from an SSPX priest

I had a beautiful note from an SSPX priest (edited):

Father, thanks for the reports on the SSPX – Rome developments.  It’s great to be able to watch your blog and Rorate Coeli to get the latest.

As this progresses, I become more and more convinced that we need time for a "warming" of the collective mentality in SSPX circles.  We can’t move fast because we are asking people to change their mental habits. 

I mean that for so many years Rome was perceived as the source of problem, and now there is a gut feeling against an agreement with Rome.  That gut feeling unfortunately has a tendency to express itself in rhetoric that can tend to sound schismatic.  It is going to take time for that mentality to come around. 

If we move too quickly we will see the falling off of greater numbers of simple faithful whose faith has become fragile because of the abuses. [Amen] One can argue with intellectual reasons all day long, but at the end of the day it was a somewhat vague "sensus fidei" and gut feeling which led people to the SSPX in the first place, and that phenomenon will need time to correct itself.  [Intellective and affective must come together and he healed.]

In the meantime are those like myself who recognize the need (and even urgency) of canonical legitimacy wrong to stay where we are?  We work for reunion from the inside in our own small way.

A poignant question.

I think this is the same question faced in many respects even my Anglican clergy who, with their flocks, would swin the Tiber. 

But that is a scary prospect, tied to identity and traditions and very important practical issues.

Every case will be different.   I would like to see priests of the SSPX come over now! 

But can anyone deny that if they come over as a whole group the witness for unity in the Church would be immense in this troubled times? 

Can anyone deny that were they to have a structure in the Church their collective experience could be of even greater aid?

I am both patient and barely able to contain my hope that reunion will be healthy, complete and swift.

Perhaps a middle ground is possible.  Perhaps members of the SSPX might do their very best to start reaching out in friendly and fraternal ways to local clergy, seeking points of common activity and contact… and vice versa.  Off the top of my head, inviting them to parish events even though some of those things might not be entirely by the traditional books.  Perhaps gatherings of priests at rectories and for other occasions.  

Ice must be melted block by block.

Posted in Brick by Brick, Mail from priests |
54 Comments

Archbishop Robert Carlson now in St. Louis

His Excellency Most Reverend Robert J. Carlson is now the Archbishop of St. Louis.

In your charity will you pray for him?

Here is his first sermon as Archbishop in case you missed it.

 

Posted in Year of Priests | Tagged , ,
15 Comments

His Hermeneuticalness on the upcoming new ICEL translation

WDTPRS has had something to do with the issue of liturgical translations.  But we do like to see the good observations made by others. 

His Hermeneuticalness has posted a good entry over at his place.

Many of us will be profoundly grateful once the new ICEL translations are allowed to be used for the celebration of Mass. (Have a look at this post to see why.) It will be a blessing to be able to say the prayers of the Mass using a reasonably accurate translation instead of the poor version that I have had to use since my ordination 25 years ago.

It has been slightly puzzling therefore, [indeed] to see so many official sources speaking of the need for catechesis and training before these translations are brought into use. The very wording of the new ICEL will itself be a great catechetical improvement on the poverty of language that we have been forced to put up with for so long. [What if we get out of the way and just say the black words and do the red words?]  Let me once again quote my favourite example:

Latin text
accipens et hunc praeclarum calicem in sanctas ac venerabiles manus suas

Old ICEL
he took the cup

New ICEL
he took this precious chalice into his holy and venerable hands,

So what is the training for? Do some people [priests] perhaps need to be taught how to pronounce "them fancy words" like gibbet or wrought? 

The other day I was speaking to someone who had been to a training day and had come back with the impression that ICEL has written a collection of new texts and virtually composed a new Missal. [wellll…… ] Since this might well become a widespread misunderstanding, here are some points for catechesis:

1. The original text of the Missale Romanum of Pope Paul VI is written in the Latin language. [Sadly, people need to be reminded of this.] This is the "typical edition", that is to say, the edition which Missals in the other languages are supposed to reflect accurately.

2. The ICEL translation that we have been using for so many years is unsatisfactory. [there’s a word for it] It does not accurately translate the Latin text and therefore the Holy See has insisted that a better translation be provided.

3. The new ICEL translation is a much better translation and at last we will be able to hear the richness of the Church’s liturgical prayers when Mass is celebrated in English.

Training or catechesis that does not get across these essential points risks misleading the People of God.

 

Good work Fr. Finigan!

Posted in Brick by Brick, WDTPRS | Tagged , , ,
40 Comments

Flicker!

A new visitor to the feeder, whom I have not ever seen.

Flicker.

Flicker!

Flicker!

Flicker!

Posted in The Feeder Feed |
16 Comments

Catholic New Media Awards – 2009

Catholic New Media Awards - 2009The Catholic New Media Awards are underway.

We have been nominated for several categories.

VOTING has begun.

Will you help WDTPRS?

  • People’s Choice Blog
  • Best Blog by a Cleric
  • Best Blog by a Religious
  • Best Blog by a Man
  • Best Written Blog
  • Most Spiritual Blog
  • Most Informative Blog
  • Funniest Blog
  • Most Entertaining Blog
  • People’s Choice Podcast
  • Best Podcast by a Cleric
  • Best Podcast by a Religious
  • Best Podcast by a Man
  • Most Informative Podcast
  • Best Produced Podcast
  • Most Spiritual Podcast
  • Best New Podcast [Should I be in this category?]
  • Funniest Podcast
  • Most Entertaining Podcast
  • Best Video Podcast
  • Best Catholic News Website
  • Best Overall Catholic Website

WDTPRS is usually the last or close to the bottom of the list in each category.

You will have to register, which is a small step to keep us going strong!

Posted in Lighter fare, PODCAzT, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
Comments Off on Catholic New Media Awards – 2009

QUAERITUR: marriage validity question

In most cases I refer people with questions about the validity of their marriages directly to a real live parish priest who will be in a position to help them work out any problems they may have.

This question, however, is about a situation which is fairly common.

I post it here to help inspire any of you in a similar situation who may have doubts or questions about the status of your marriage you seek clarity and resolution.

Sometimes, most of the time, the resolution can come pretty easily.

Your peace of mind is worth any "inconvenience".

My wife was baptized as a Catholic but, soon after, her parents divorced and she was raised by her father (an agnostic). Even though her father never took her to church, she spent a few weeks one summer staying with her devoutly-Catholic grandmother who, during her visit, took my wife to the priest for catechesis and made sure that she received her first Holy Communion. She was about eight years old. When my wife and I met in highschool, we began attending a Presbyterian church together (I was not Catholic at that time). We joined the Presbyterian church our senior year of high school and, after college, were married in that church. Within a year of being married, we went through RCIA and joined the Catholic Church. We have been Catholic ever since.
 
My question is whether or not our marriage is sacramental. We have never had our marriage "blessed" in the Catholic Church, and the priest who brought us into the Church through RCIA did not think it was necessary to do so. Our current priest is not so sure. I would greatly appreciate your insight and opinion on this matter.

So, the man was not Catholic at the time of the marriage.   The woman was baptized in the Catholic Church and she received first Holy Communion.  At that time they would have made sure she had been baptized or received properly.  Thus, she was bound by the Church’s laws about the proper form of marriage.

I am rather puzzled about the process of RCIA which they participated in so as to bring him into to the Church.  You would have thought that at that time the priest would have tried to help them get their marriage situation straightened out. Oh well. Perhaps there were reasons to wait.

It seems to me, from what information we have here, that this can be resolved fairly easily.   The couple has definitely made good moves to demonstrate that they want to participate in the life of the Catholic Church.  But their marriage is irregular: she was bound by the Church’s law to marry in the way the Church prescribes.  They did not do so, it seems.

However, the marriage can be validated by a fairly simple procedure.  I encourage them to get together with the priest at their parish very soon and start working that out.  He will know precisely what to do to help them in the process, which will probably be fairly quick.  Each priest will handle these things differently.  Sometimes they want a demonstration that the couple is practicing their faith together for a reasonable period.  But… if this guy and/or his wife are reading this blog… I suspect a measure of interest in the Catholic Church is present.

Folks, if you have questions about your marriage, doubts, rather than write to some guy via e-mail, don’t be afraid to approach a real live priest at the parish!   Just lay out the facts, bring the documents you have, and answer his questions.  Unless he is a wacko, he’ll know how to proceed and you will feel better about life.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged ,
38 Comments

A new Motu Proprio from Benedict XVI about the PCED

Here is an interesting report of the intrepid Andrea Tornielli in my translation (edited):

In the next weeks there will be published a Motu Proprio of Benedict XVI which makes the Commission Ecclesia Dei … an organism of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.  Pope Ratzinger had already announced this last March, in the letter sent to all the bishops of the world dedicated to the Williamson case and the revocation of the excommunication of the prelates consecrated by Lefebvre.  Next 4 July Darìo Card. Castrillòn Hoyos, present President of Ecclesia Dei, will turn 80 years of age and will leave his post for reasons of age.  The Commission will then be presided over by the Prefect of the ex-Holy Office, the American William Joseph Card. Levada.  The Vice-President Msgr. Perl will remain in his place while there will be named a new Secretary to replace the [recently] deceased Msgr. Mario Marini.  Just this morning, the French agency I.Media revealed that in the "feria quarta" meeting the cardinal members of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith put together a first platform for the beginning of dialogue with the Lefebvrites.  …  Meanwhile, as Il Giornale anticipated a few days ago, this Saturday there ought to be announced the nomination of the Secretary of the Congregation for Divine Worship [Archbp.] Malcom Ranjith Patabendige Don as Archbishop of Colombo.  In his place there will be designated the present Undersecretary of the ex-Holy Office the Domincan DiNoia.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
14 Comments

Relics returned – remembrance of saints past

This last weekend I recovered some relics which a friend had had for some years.

Included are

St. Leo the Great
St. Thomas Aquinas
St. Dominic
St. Ignatius Loyola

Relics returned - remembrance of saints past

They are all first class relics, from bone.

They join the other great saints in the Sabine Chapel, including St. Paul, whose special year we are still celebrating.

The four matching reliquaries which house the reacquired relics now were a recent acquisition.

Also recovered is an old reliquary given to me long ago with a sliver of the Cross of Our Lord.

Relics returned - remembrance of saints past

I don’t have documents for this, but because of the wax seals on the back and the manner of its preparation I have little doubt that it was prepared by someone who was authorized.

This later reliquary, in the shape of a pectoral cross – which I assumed was used by a religious of some sort, was given to me in a box with many other things around the time of my conversion to Catholicism.  For a long while, years, I had no idea that it was a reliquary and didn’t pay much attention to it. Then one day when I chanced across it, I discovered that this Cross unscrewed at the top and slide open.

Imagine my surprise at what I found inside.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , ,
20 Comments