Do Catholics need a dispensation to marry “non-Catholic” SSPXers?

Interesting.  This is from a reader:

Some French Bishops, according to this, are considering marriages between a SSPX faithful and another Catholic as a mixed marriage.

Les mariages se multipliant en ces temps de printemps, il est désormais possible de découvrir le dernier cadeau déposé par les évêques de France (pas tous heureusement) dans la corbeille des jeunes s’apprêtant à convoler en justes noces.

Désormais, lorsque les deux parties seront fidèles de la FSSPX, il n’y aura pas de place dans les églises que leurs ancêtres ont bâties. En résumé, certains sont de trop dans l’Église… Certains ne doivent pas pouvoir s’y sentir chez eux, et toujours rejetés…

Lorsqu’une seule des deux parties sera fidèle de la FSSPX et c’est la grande nouveauté de cet après 21-janvier, il faudra demander une dispense pour mariage mixte. C’est ni plus ni moins, la dispense qui est demandée lorsque, dans un mariage, l’un des deux conjoints n’est pas catholique, mais protestant par exemple. En résumé, le jeune fidèle de la Fraternité est étiqueté et considéré comme un étranger à l’Église catholique. Accueillant, n’est-ce pas ? [pas!]

Telle est la procédure consistant à contredire la volonté romaine et qui s’est répétée plusieurs fois depuis le mois de janvier, papiers à entête diocésaine à l’appui, dans l’attente que les prêtres officiant refusent de signer des papiers aussi mensongers. Puisque Rome ne veut pas considérer la Fraternité hors de l’Église, alors nos évêques (pas tous) s’arrangent pour rappeler qu’à leurs yeux elle le serait encore plus qu’auparavant. On en finit par regretter la franchise prévalant Outre-Rhin.

Cela n’empêchera pas ces futurs foyers de vivre heureux et d’avoir beaucoup d’enfants…

So… if only one of a couple seeking to marry is an adherent of the SSPX (whatever that means… I am not sure) French bishops are saying that the Catholic party must have a dispensation to marry a non-Catholic.

What I cannot figure out here are the criteria by which they are sure that lay people are to be identified as not being Catholic.  One can argue it is easier to determine what the status of the clergy is: they are ordained illicitly, take salaries and directives, etc.  But lay people?  

Does going to a chapel which is not in union with the Church make someoe a non-Catholic?

If this questionable practice is a real policy of some bishops, or indeed the conference, I think people should ask the Holy See for a clarification of their status before asking to be married.

"Dear Cardinal Ry?ko, I want to marry Pierre, but Bishop Cauchon says I am not Catholic because I prefer to attend Mass at a chapel of the SSPX where I grew up.  I want to get married at Pierre’s family parish, but Pierre was told that he needs a dispensation to marry a non-Catholic. Is it that true?  Am I not Catholic?   The bishop made me cry.  My mother is still crying.  Anxiously, Pierette."

Perhaps some clarification is in order.

Does anyone else know about this?

I will leave the combox open, but I will warn you ahead of time.   Knuckle-head stuff will simply get you unceremoniously booted from the blog.

Included in knuckle-head stuff are the inevitable "BOO HOO! Poor US! SSPX is the TRUE CHURCH. VATICAN II IS EVIL!" comments.

Boring.

Folks… really… save it.  Task me not.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
60 Comments

Wedges

It seems suddenly okay that a nominee to the Supreme Court be … *GASP*  …. Catholic!

On the website of The Boston Globe comes this on the nomination of Judge Sonia Sotomayor to SCOTUS.

My emphases and comments.

Sotomayor would be sixth Catholic justice

Posted by Michael Paulson May 26, 2009 02:33 PM

Judge Sonia Sotomayor has much to distinguish her, but one element of her biography stands out in the world of those interested in religion and the public square: [Since I have been HAMMERING that topic forever, I think that includes readers of WDTPRS!]  she is Catholic, and, if approved as a Supreme Court justice, she will be the sixth Catholic on the nine-member court. That is a remarkable accomplishment for American Catholics, who make up 23 percent of the nation’s population, [And it wasn’t that long ago that people in the USA debated if Catholics should be allowed to participate in society.]  and will now potentially hold 67 percent of the high court’s seats. Two of the justices are Jewish; the resignation of Justice David Souter, who is an Episcopalian, will leave, amazingly given the history of this nation, just one Protestant on the Supreme Court, 89-year-old Justice John Paul Stevens.

Undoubtedly, Sotomayor’s Catholic-ness will be the subject of some debate. Just how Catholic is she? Steven Waldman, blogging at Beliefnet, quotes a White House official saying, “Judge Sotomayor was raised as a Catholic and attends church for family celebrations and other important events.”  [In other words… she is… what… a CINO?  A C&E Catholic?  A “cultural Catholic”?  What does that mean?]

David Gibson, also at Beliefnet, suggests there may be a strategic reason for Sotomayor to downplay her faith affiliation:

“The (awful) question will now be, what KIND of Catholic is she? She is divorced, without kids. Heck, she may want to downplay her practice of the faith as that will be a huge target–and it’s easy to guess who’ll be lobbing most of the heavy ordinance.”  [Is that a kind of inuendo there about the number of children practicing Catholics have?]

And Cathy Lynn Grossman, blogging for USA Today, makes a similar prediction:

“Next up: Expect her nomination to re-ignite the ongoing Catholic blogosphere wars over who is Catholic enough. If confirmed, Sotomayor, who grew up in Catholic schools in the Bronx, would be the sixth Catholic on the high court. It may be that her life experiences will align her with the social justice issues pushed by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops on race, poverty, immigration and economic issues. But for some outspoken Catholics, the ‘life’ issues — abortion, family planning, so-called ‘conscience clauses’ for health workers, embryonic stem cell research and end-of-life choices — are the litmus test.”  [I ask this: If President Obama at Notre Dame used the word “children” and not just the usual “fetus”, then I would say that legalizing the choice to kill those children might make a good topic for discussion.  Also, this president vote in favor of what can only be termed infanticide.]

Over at GetReligion, Terry Mattingly wonders why the word “Catholic” is not more a part of the early press coverage, and asks if that would be different if Sotomayor were a known opponent of abortion rights:

“Her life story will be a big part of the upcoming mini-debates about her appointment. Here is my question: If she was a pro-life woman, from a Hispanic background, do you think that the word ‘Catholic’ would be appearing higher in these early (I repeat, EARLY) reports about her life and work? Just saying.”  [D’ya think?]

What does it matter if Sotomayor is Catholic? Jacqui Salmon, blogging for the Washington Post, suggests perhaps not much, at least as far as judicial decisionmaking is concerned:

“Experts have been split on what the Catholic majority has meant so far. They point out that Catholics on the bench historically have spanned the spectrum from liberal to conservative. Dennis J. Hutchinson, a court historian at the University of Chicago, noted in 2005 that one of the most liberal Supreme Court justices of the 20th century, William J. Brennan, was a Catholic, and so is one of the most conservative, Scalia.”

Manya Brachear, blogging for the Chicago Tribune, tackles the same question, and comes to the same conclusion, although also pointing out the symbolic significance:

“Cathleen Kaveny, law professor at the University of Notre Dame, said a sixth Catholic in the High Court would illustrate how entrenched the church has become in the U.S. A sixth Catholic with views like Sotomayor’s also [And here I think we are edging up to what is really going on….] would put the American church’s diversity on display.  [Watch now the Kmiec Catholic, Catholic Lite, partisan Catholic ala “Yes we can” in this next part…] ‘My guess is she’s very much operating in accordance with the commitments of the Catholic social justice tradition which is emphasizing … inclusion, solidarity, justice to those least among us,’ Kaveny said. ‘It’s strand of American Catholic teaching that is somewhat distinct from other Catholic teaching but not incompatible. [There.  She tries to shift the paradigm.  Do you remember my parsing of McBrien (“a study of the progressivist mind“) when I pointed out that the left doesn’t want to admit the real divisions in the Church? Here is an example of what I am talking about.] People emphasize different aspects.'”

Catholic groups are just now beginning to react to the nomination. Catholics United, a liberal group, reacted positively, [Dog Bites Man.  Film at 11.  This is one of the slitheriest groups I have seen, FWIW.] and said, “We call on other leaders within the Catholic community to join us in welcoming Judge Sotomayor’s nomination and to approach her confirmation hearings with civility and reason.”  [I hope that Catholics United will also make a statement about voting in favor of infantide.] I haven’t heard yet from conservative Catholic groups, but in general the reaction from the right has been critical. [Wait… wasn’t the first part of that “haven’t heard”?]  Ted Olsen, blogging at Christianity Today, reviews the early statements and headlines his post, “Pro-Life Group Consensus on Sotomayor: ‘Activist’.”

Meanwhile, one thing that struck me in President Obama’s remarks about Sotomayor this morning was the language he used to describe the role of Catholic schools in offering children a path out of poverty. [wedge] This is what he said:

“When Sonia was nine, her father passed away. And her mother worked six days a week as a nurse to provide for Sonia and her brother…But Sonia’s mom bought the only set of encyclopedias in the neighborhood, sent her children to a Catholic school called Cardinal Spellman out of the belief that with a good education here in America all things are possible.”  [And this will – of course – for all reasonable people interested in dialogue and diversity and just getting along together be a reason to set aside any concern about statements or her record.]

Just a guess… but here is what this feels like to me.

I am pretty sure that, among other motives, this is also part of a conscious agenda. This White House, and those who seek to be its satraps, are doing their best to subvert institutions and some high profile public Catholic figures in order to drive a wedge between different groups of Catholics.  They especially want to cleave off the strong Catholic bishops from the rest of the squishy Americanized Church.  They do so by seeming to embrace an important but logically secondary set of common objectives so as to neutralize the deeper foundations of a true Catholic influence in the public square.

Granting that in this life there is no perfect politics – or much of anything else for that matter…

If politics should be about the social expression of the City of God, liturgy is the sacramental expression of the City of God.

The language and effect of the one will be in discord or harmony with the language and effect of the other.

I repeat: At this point it may be that the only way we can emphasize the hollow sound of their cymbals is through authentic Catholic worship.

You are called to arms.

Posted in Linking Back, SESSIUNCULA, The future and our choices | Tagged , , , , ,
52 Comments

QUAERITUR: Latin version of a Spiritual Communion prayer

I need help from readers for a question sent via e-mail.

I cannot find my copy of The Raccolta with Latin and English texts of prayers which at one time had been conceded indulgences.

Someone asked my for a Latin version of a prayer for making a Spiritual Communion.

I know of this prayer, which had once had the approval of the Holy See:

"O Jesus I turn toward the holy tabernacle where You live hidden for love of me. I love you, O my God. I cannot receive you in Holy Communion. Come nevertheless and visit me with Your grace. Come spiritually into my heart. Purify it. Sanctify it. Render it like unto Your own. Amen.

Lord, I am not worthy that thou shouldst enter under my roof, but only say the word and my soul shall be healed.

 

This had been approved with an indulgence by the S.C. Indulgences on 24 Nov 1922 and I found a reference to Raccolta #129.

There should be a Latin version of that prayer somewhere.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
24 Comments

QUAERITUR: taking Communion with Precious Blood out to the sick

From a priest reader:

Have you ever come across a vessel designed for bringing the Precious Blood to the sick?  I have a parishioner to whom I regularly bring communion, but she is now on an absolutely no gluten diet, so even low gluten hosts are out of the question.

A friend of mine said he had seen a priest with the kind of vessel I am looking for, so I know they exist.  Do you know where I might find one?

If such a vessel exists, don’t know about it.

It usually is forbidden to reserve the Precious Blood.  I understand that some of the Precious Blood may be reserved for Communion for the sick only.  In 1967 there was an instruction Eucharisticum Mysterium as a heading "Communion under the Species of Wine Alone".  There we find that

41 … If, however, Mass is not celebrated in the presence of the sick person, the Blood of the Lord should be kept in a properly covered chalice and placed in the tabernacle after Mass. It should be taken to the sick person only if contained in a vessel which is closed in such a way as to eliminate all danger of spilling. When the sacrament is administered, that method should be chosen from the ones given in the Rites for Distribution of Communion under Both Kinds which is most suited to the case. When Communion has been given, should some of the precious Blood still remain, it should be consumed by the minister; he will also carry out the usual ablutions.

I don’t know how this would be done, except perhaps with a small glass vial designed to be sealed very tightly.  The Precious Blood would then be administered directly by the priest from that vial, rather than transferred yet again to another vessel.

I would be happy for correction on this if I got it wrong.

It seems to me that this could open up the possibility of all kinds of abuses, first through simple accidents on the part of priests or deacons and then by laypeople helping with the sick.  This should be rare indeed and ad personam according to circumstances and done only by priests, if possible.

I believe the best solution is occasionally to celebrate Mass in the sick room and give Communion with the Precious Blood on the spot.

UPDATE:

Note that a priest posted below on his experience.  He also used an eyedropper.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests |
23 Comments

Pres. Obama and the Supremes

Pres. Obama announced his nomination to replace Justice Souter on the SCOTUS:

Judge Sonia Sotomayor of the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals.

From what I am hearing and reading, she seems pretty far to the left.  She is certainly not an originalist.   There are indications that she sees the role of judge at these higher levels as activist.  Also, she seems to view the work of judges from the view of identity politics.

Will/does she interpret law or attempt to legislate from the bench?

What is the role of a judge/justice?

As things stand now, there is almost no chance that she will not be confirmed.

Her appointment will not really change the composition of the court, as I understand Sotomayor’s record.

The confirmation process must therefore shape what will happen in the next round of nomination/controversy/confirmation.

This may be a good opportunity for the opposition to define themselves and learn how better to communicate how they differ from the dominant left.

Justice Souter is leaving the Court at 69 years of age, perhaps young for a Supreme Justice to retire.  Judge Sotomayor is only 55 years of age.

NB: Pres. Obama, when he was a Senator, voted against Chief Justice Roberts and Justice Alito.

Posted in The future and our choices |
60 Comments

turn down the lights and just listen

Last evening I listened to part of an audiobook, a recording by Simon Vance of one of the Aubrey/Maturin series, the 5th in the series, Desolation Island.

This book has a few of the best passages in the entire series.  I marvel at this writer’s prose and character development.

I very happily recommend these books.

Start with Master and Commander.

If you want an audio version, Simon Vance recorded the whole series on Blackstone Audio, though he hits his stride in the second recording, Post Captain.

But what I heard tonight was part of Desolation Island…

It is sometimes a great pleasure to turn down the lights and just listen when the reader is good and book excellent.

Posted in Just Too Cool, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , ,
12 Comments

New blog for video reflections in Mandarin

Eternal Light is a new blog, originating from the Holy Land. It provides reflections in Mandarin Chinese.

Posted in Just Too Cool |
1 Comment

Brick by brick at Mission San Juan Bautista

From a reader comes a 1st Holy Communion photo at Mission San Juan Bautista in California.

Brick by brick at Mission San Juan Bautista

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
17 Comments

Philadelphia TLM news

From a reader some helpful information about the availability of TLMs in the Philadelphia area this summer.

Helpful for travelers too.

Traditional Latin Mass at the Monastery of Our Lady of Mercy
6398 Drexel Road
Philadelphia, PA 19151
on First Fridays and First Saturdays
Omitted during June and July, 2009

Fr. Joseph K. Horvath, O.de M., will be in Rome, Italy for a worldwide Conclave of the Order of Mercy. First Friday and First Saturday TLMs are expected to resume at the Monastery in August.

The Traditional Latin Mass will continue to be offered weekly at the nearby parish of

Our Lady of Lourdes
63rd Street and Lancaster Avenue
Philadelphia, PA   19151
7:30 A.M. on Sundays as usual.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments

Sunday afternoon

It was a nearly perfect afternoon at the Sabine Farm today.

Sunday afternoon

Sunday afternoon

I had a friend over to enjoy a leisurely late lunch of trouts, a fennel au gratin, sweet corn with a little garish of roasted red peppers.

I prepared the trout on a bed of the fennel greens with slices of orange.  For liquid I used fish stock, white wine and ginger.

Sunday afternoon

It went into the 350F oven.

Sunday afternoon

Sunday afternoon

Sunday afternoon

I made a sauce from the reduced cooking liquid which I rapidly cooked down with cream.

After, we had espresso and ice cold limoncello.

Birds and bees had lunch as well.

Blue Jay dines alone, as you can imagine.

Sunday afternoon

Sunday afternoon

Sunday afternoon

And here… at a distance… is Mr. Bluebird.

Sunday afternoon

Sunday afternoon

Sunday afternoon

I found another Robin in the act of pulling a worm.  The other pics, however, didn’t come out well.

Sunday afternoon

The bees are really at the apple blossoms.

Sunday afternoon

Sunday afternoon

Sunday afternoon

PENJING REPORT

Penjing had nothing to say to lunch, but rather enjoyed sunshine and lots of water.  There were visitors, however.

Sunday afternoon

Sunday afternoon

A pair of scholars took some shade for a discussion, master and pupil.

Sunday afternoon

Sunday afternoon

As the shadows lengthened toward evening, some time in the chapel for vespers and rosary.

Sunday afternoon

I look forward to the morrow.

The flag is ready to be hung in its accustomed place.

Posted in Fr. Z's Kitchen, Lighter fare, SESSIUNCULA, The Feeder Feed | Tagged
27 Comments