Cassock Propaganda

John Sonnen at Orbis Catholicus has great shots of seminarians from the Propaganda College in their college cassocks.

Cassock Propaganda

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
28 Comments

POLL: communion in the hand

Do you believe that each particle of a Host is the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Christ Jesus, God and man?

Do you receive Communion in the hand?

A reader sent two photos.  The first is of an unconsecrated communion host rest on the palm of a black glove.

POLL: communion in the hand

This photo shows the fragments left behind.

POLL: communion in the hand

"But Father! But Father!", some of you will perhaps be howling now.  "That’s a glove, not a hand!  We don’t know that that is what happens with hosts put into people’s hands!  That’s not fair!"

I grant that we don’t know.  I grant that palms are not gloves.   I grant that there are differences.

But …

Consider the lack of care with which many receive, how they move the Host around and handle it. 

Consider that often there is a more or less properly prepared EMHC also handling the Host.

Consider the condition of the skin of the palm. 

Consider the few seconds after a person transfers the Host from palm to mouth. 

Consider that the Host has been in contact not only with the palm, but the fingers of the other hand. 

Consider.

Let me be clear: I do not think people intend to be irreverent when they receive on the hand. 

Knowing that most Eastern Catholics have a different manner of receiving in both species, here is a question for you Latin Catholics.

POLL CLOSED

How do you Latin Catholics generally/habitually receive Holy Communion?

  • Directly on the tongue (including intinction) (84%, 2,425 Votes)
  • In the hand (16%, 474 Votes)

Total Voters: 2,899

Posted in Mail from priests, POLLS |
349 Comments

QUAERITUR: Biformal priests and the gravitational pull

QUAERITUR: Biformal priests and the gravitational pullI am guessing that this might freak out a few people, but here goes.   I received this from a regular reader via e-mail. 

My emphases.

A priest who regularly celebrates both forms of the Roman rite — and while celebrating the newer form sometimes finds himself through force of habit inserting gestures from the older form — forwarded to me the following question (regarding the particular GIRM 2002 norms appended below…):

"Given that Paul VI presumably did not foresee the regular celebration by priests of both the newer order of Mass and the traditional order, and given that Pope Benedict XVI sometimes appears to follow the older rubrics in ways not clearly consistent with the new rubrics — e.g., in regard to the gestures specified in No. 148 for the dialog before the Preface — how ought a ‘bi-formal’ priest interpret No. 42 of the IGMR 2002 as he attempts to celebrate faithfully both forms of the Roman rite, given a natural tendency for one form of celebration to influence the other over time?"

He has also mentioned Pope Benedict’s insertion of extra signs of the cross, e.g., before the priest’s communion. More generally, how is "the traditional practice of the Roman rite" to be interpreted, now that the Roman rite juridically has two equally valid forms? 

I myself wonder whether Pope Benedict might actual hope that some such "mutual enrichment" will occur.

—————————————-
GIRM 2002
Movements and Posture

42. The gestures and posture of the priest, the deacon, and the ministers, as well as those of the people, ought to contribute to making the entire celebration resplendent with beauty and noble simplicity, so that the true and full meaning of the different parts of the celebration is evident and that the participation of all is fostered. Therefore, attention should be paid to what is determined by this General Instruction and the traditional practice of the Roman Rite and to what serves the common spiritual good of the People of God, rather than private inclination or arbitrary choice.

"Bi-formal"…. what a term!

This raises good questions.

My own opinion is that Pope Benedict foresees that this "mutual enrichment" will take place over time.  It must.  I use the image of "gravitational pull", because I think that the newer form will be drawn more closely to the older form, and not the other way around.  I suspect that is what the Pope had in mind as well, namely, that the older should influence the newer, more than the newer would influence the older.  

Eventually, over who knows how long, perhaps there might be a kind of tertium quid which emerges organically from the dynamic of the the two forms in one Roman Rite.

However it may go, as the ’60-’80’s crowd of priests goes to dust, the younger men – lacking the baggage of that previous generation – will carry the project forward.

But the priest who wrote the notes above puts his finger on something: in celebration of the Novus Ordo, a man accustomed to the older form, will very naturally tend to adjust the Novus Ordo in the direction of the traditional form.  But in his style, or ars celebrandi, and in certain gestures, he will "trad" the Novus Ordo.  Last night, for example, in a parish Mass – Novus Ordo/English/versus populum – I quite automatically kissed the altar at "we pray that your angel may take this sacrifice from this altar…", and I quite automatically genuflected before receiving from the chalice.  An "oops" ran through my head, but… I admit not with very much regret.  Those things were not exactly "doing the red", after all.  They were mistakes.  But are they perhaps mistakes – I don’t know – in the direction things are supposed to go?  They were mistakes … but… from the Roman Rite!

The 2002MR has the return of the oratio super populum for Masses during Lent.  It has, for example, a Vigil of Ascension (Thursday, of course).  So, in the formularies and calendar, there have been adjustments back toward Roman elements even before Papa Ratzinger was elected.

Benedict XVI, Papa Ratzinger, did not implement Summorum Pontificum so that he could create discontinuity between two separate forms of the Roman Rite.  Think about it.

Based on what I remember of my conversations with him about this very topic years ago, he foresees that this will jump start the organic process of a living liturgical develop which was so brutally interrupted by the artificial/academic pasting together and then imposition of the Novus Ordo in Advent 1969.

The question remains: Is living, organic development in the Church’s liturgical life possible without violations of the codified rubrics? 

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
83 Comments

There is no rosacea of such virtue!

His Hermeneuticalness has blessed a new set of rosacea vestments… and not just any, but a Roman solemn set, including the cope. 

I think they should have the tablets of the law on the back, so that everyone will see the tablet when Father "turns his back to the people".

Well done Fr. Finigan!  Laetare indeed!

 

There is no rosacea of such virtue!

The servers who come on Saturday morning for Mass and Benediction had some fun today opening up the new rose vestments and putting them so that I could show you a photo. Above is the shot where the servers didn’t quite manage to be solemn.

Mass was offered this morning for all the benefactors who have paid for these vestments in response to kind appeals by Damian Thompson on Holy Smoke and Fr Zuhlsdorf on What Does The Prayer Really Say. I will write to everyone who has contacted me but it will take me a little time. Thank you all very much indeed. Next Sunday’s Mass will be a High Mass so I’ll make sure there are some photos of the vestments in use. This morning, I blessed them.

There is no rosacea of such virtue!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
36 Comments

A Pauline Pilgrmage

Where better in N. America to make a Pauline Year pilgrimage than the Cathedral of St Paul in St. Paul, Minnesota?

One of the great cathedral churches of the continent.

A Pauline Pilgrmage

A Pauline Pilgrmage

A Pauline Pilgrmage

A Pauline Pilgrmage

A Pauline Pilgrmage

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
32 Comments

What about your good news?

It is nice to hear good news and even how grace is working in people’s lives.

How about it?

‘Sup?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
83 Comments

“Benedict’s Vatican II Hermeneutic”

On the site of First Things, Fr. Edward T. Oakes, S.J., who teaches theology at the University of St. Mary of the Lake, the seminary of the Archdiocese of Chicago, has a piece on "Benedict’s Vatican II Hermeneutic".

Read the article and discuss!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
50 Comments

PODCAzT 81: Benedict XVI’s Letter on SSPX excomms; your voicemail

A fast PODCAzT this time.

I am so grateful to the folks who sent the new microphone and the boom.  They really help.

In this session I read Pope Benedict’s Letter to Bishops on the lifting of the excommunications of the SSPX bishops and add some of my own comments both before and after.

Then I delve into your wonderful voicemail!

  • A question about the older, traditional form of Sacrament of Penance.
  • A big family devours eggplant.PODCAzT 81: Benedict XVI's Letter on SSPX excomms; your voicemail
  • A priest talks about woes in Austria and implementing Summorum Pontificum.
  • A father uses my PODCAzTs to keep his kids quiet.

Wonderful!

In the meantime, I think the iTunes feed is working as long as this blog entry doesn’t scroll off the feed.  At least that is my present theory.

 

https://wdtprs.com/wp-content/legacy/audio-archive/podcazt/09_03_13.mp3

Posted in Brick by Brick, Mail from priests, PODCAzT, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM | Tagged , , , , ,
10 Comments

Fr. Finigan thanks his supporters in the best way

his Hermeneuticalness posted this notice:

Many thanks to all of you who have sent in contributions for vestments for the Sacred Liturgy via Damian Thompson’s Holy Smoke blog, and Fr Zuhlsdorf’s "pound Fr Finigan" campaign on his blog What Does the Prayer Really Say?. Tomorrow morning’s Mass (EF) will be offered for your intentions.

 

Lovely.  Thanks, Father!

Posted in Just Too Cool, Mail from priests |
8 Comments

J’accuse! L’Osservatore Romano’s editor points a finger, Fr. Z comments

When the wheels come off a train, people get hurt and the capital of an organization is threatened, someone gets blamed.  Someone must pay.

The liberals of the secular press and the progressivist element of the Catholic media latched on to the Holy Father’s admission that mistakes were made in the lifting of the SSPX excommunications.

Their common accusation is that the Holy Father failed to consult widely enough, he is to blame, or that Card. Castrillon with the Pontifical Commission he heads was a loose cannon, and he is to blame.  They energetically advance that the future fusion of the Pontifical Commission "Ecclesia Dei" to the CDF is truly an acceptance of this blame. They rejoice in their vindication.

On the other hand, Giovanni Maria Vian, the revolutionary editor of the Vatican’s newspaper  L’Osservatore Romano printed an editorial in which he identifies his own candidates for blame.

The first part of the editorial chews over facts we already know.  The meat of the piece comes well along.

Here is my translation of the paragraph conveying Vian’s central point:

The clarity of the Pope’s analysis does not sidestep open and difficult questions, such as the need for attention and a more prepared and timely communication in a global context where information, omnipresent and superabundant, is continuously exposed to manipulations and exploitations, among which are so-called leaks, which only with effort cannot be called wretched –  even within the Roman Curia, an organism historically collegial and which in the Church has the obligation of being exemplary.

The part beginning "even within the Roman Curia" is actually a stand alone sentence fragment, but it is clearly an extension of the sentence before. I associate them with a hyphen, rather than divide them with a period as in the original Italian, to help make better sense of the point in English.   Vian, writing in Italian, made that last part a fragment so that it wouldn’t be missed.  It is intended to stand out, to scratch your already sore eyeball.

In fact it was not missed by the observant in the Italian press.  Say what you will about the Vatican-hostile, SSPX-allergic Marco Politi of La Repubblica, he is astute.  He caught Vian’s drift immediately and wrote: "In a column Giovanni Maria Vian castigates the ‘manipulations and exploitations’ also within the Roman Curia…".  Politi caught the real point of Vian’s editorial.

Vian says the Vatican’s portion of the blame lies on the backs of some workers of the Roman Curia. 

The point: These negationists took advantage of the situation to hurt the Pope and prevent positive developments with the SSPX. 

So set are they against such a rapprochement, and its implications for how we read and apply the Second Vatican Council, that they would harm to Pope’s moral capital in the world and with Jewish groups, damage the Holy See’s relations with states, and foment chaos in Holy Church’s internal harmony.

A close reading of that paragraph shows that information leaks, intended to fuel a rumpus, were only one dimension of the "manipulations and exploitations".  There were other dealings, subtle and confined to hallways and offices.

I believe these deeper manipulations are behind the present scapegoating of Card. Castrillon and the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei.

The Holy Father desires to reintegrate the SSPX.  Doctrinal discussions are the next logical step, now that Summorum Pontificum has taken root and the excommunications have been lifted.  The Commission’s mandate must naturally be adjusted to this new situation.   But the negationists are busily spinning the Pope’s intention to place the Commission under the umbrella of the CDF as a sure sign of defeat for the Pope, for the Commission and Card. Castrillon, and for the pro-Lefevbrites in the Curia who, as Politi frames them, shamelessly used leaks to create an unrealistically rosy picture of the SSPX.

The last thing progressivists want is a Pope determined to reintegrate the SSPX, with their dangerous ideas, or an effective Cardinal as President of the Commission who might actually take seriously the Commission’s mandate to reconcile the SSPX. In fact, the Holy Father’s projects have gained frightening momentum. 

The liberals now coo that, at long last, the connection of the Commission with the CDF will allow the "consultation" of many many interested well-informed parties from the corners of the globe with differing points of view. 

In reality they hope that as the consultation brodens the Pope’s project will grind to a halt.

There are in the Curia, in key positions, men who would prefer that Paul VI’s official pontifical portrait was still framed upon their beige walls.  They patiently endured the hard years of the Polish Pope, put in their time, and climbed inexorably upward.  Then came the German Pope with his dangerous ideas about continuity, his penchant for the fait accompli, his pesky intelligence and annoying happiness.  They are vexed.  

Quite a few heads of dicasteries have reached the famous age limit and will most likely be moved along.  The men in the next tier down would normally have expectations of moving up.  But as Paolo Rodari pointed out in a recent series of commentaries, not a few of the old guard, at first disposed to support this new Pope’s efforts in the expectation that they would eventually be raised to the next level, have discovered to to their dismay that this Pope isn’t going to promote them.  They have turned on him now that they know they will not be.   They have fished out their stilettos from the back of the desk drawer.

Traditionally Curial changes are announced in the spring and the fall. 

Blame has been apportioned. Accounts are being settled.

We must watch the appointments.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
29 Comments