When there is a wound, steps must be taken to heal it.

Excerpted from my weekly offering at One Peter Five:


Priests have the right to say three Masses on Christmas even without the canonical tolerance of them doing so on other days for pastoral reasons. And because the Gospel of the Mass in the Day is the same as the Last Gospel, the Prologue of John, at the end of the third Mass the priest omits a Last Gospel. Once upon a time, a Last Gospel from Matthew 2 was read, but by the time the 1962 Missale Romanum came out, I guess they figured that, after three Masses with three different formularies, Father could give it a rest.

That said, what a tragic loss it has been for so many priests who do not know or celebrate the Traditional Latin Mass, the Vetus Ordo, not to have had the formative experience of saying the awesome Prologue of John at the end of every Mass, day in and day out, year in and year out, decade in and decade out. No one was clamoring for the Last Gospel to be cut from the Mass. The Fathers of the Second Vatican Council mandated that no changes be made unless they were for the good of the Church and that no changes be made that are not in keeping with previous liturgical forms (Sacrosanctum Concilium, 23). How was removal of the Last Gospel for the good of the Church? Both of those mandates were severely violated in what was eventually produced in the name of the Council.

When there is a wound, steps must be taken to heal it. What happened after the Council produced a wound, a wound in the Church’s very heart, her sacred liturgical worship. A wound in every Catholic, because we are our rites. Benedict XVI took steps to heal the wound. What Benedict did in no way marred the post-Conciliar reforms. He placed the two Rites side-by-side in an irenic way to influence each other through “mutual enrichment.” Benedict wanted to “jump start” the natural, organic, patient development of the Church’s sacred liturgical worship that was wounded and interrupted by the forced imposition of an artificially pasted together Rite. What Benedict did was working. That’s why certain people are attempting to kill it, ironically in the name of the Council whose violated mandates gave us our liturgical heart problems to begin with. What they are doing won’t work. I believe that the wounded liturgical heart of the Church that Benedict defibrillated, converted, will now keep beating with an ever clearer and stronger traditional rhythm, countering the arrhythmia introduced in the 1960s, again being forced today so as to disunify the heart’s chambers even more, and to serve a larger agenda. But I digress.


About Fr. John Zuhlsdorf

Fr. Z is the guy who runs this blog. o{]:¬)
This entry was posted in Benedict XVI, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, Save The Liturgy - Save The World and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.


  1. Not says:

    Interesting that Pope Francis and his minions are using the “ways of the world” to enforce their edicts. People who have taken oaths to uphold and defend are told not to if they don’t take the jab. Police told not to arrest, Judges not to hold criminals, Teachers tell students not to tell parents.
    Priest and religious have taken vows before Almighty God. No earthly threat will deter them. PRAY FOR PRIEST.

  2. IaninEngland says:

    As I write, there is a rainbow outside my window, against the backdrop of dark clouds which formed earlier this morning.
    God is true to His promises.

  3. Angelo Tan says:

    From the same document, they will quote SC no. 21 and 50 for it. Couldn’t they just say “Ugh, this ‘Last Gospel’ is soooo tiresome to read. It’s repetitive. Let’s abolish it.”

    Moreso, I can’t stand the hypocrisy of Rome. They want the traditional community to respect the Modern Roman Rite, but guess what, they clamp down on these golden and ancient rites but the Holy See can’t address and properly regulate the Liturgy against these grave abuses in the OF. They want uniformity but every parish doesn’t do what the rubrics say. With these in mind, how can we say that the Modern Roman Rite unifies people? It became so fluid to the point every priest can do whatever he wants on the altar! No one listens to Rome anymore, no one even reads the GIRM/post-Conciliar liturgical documents. Everybody had become lords over the liturgy, instead a servant of it (as JP2 noted).

Comments are closed.