Joseph Ratzinger and Hans Kung: compare and contrast

Be sure to check out the latest by my friend Samuel Gregg who writes for Acton Institute.  Mr. Gregg has a fine comparison of  Papa Joseph Ratzinger and Fr. Hans Kung, sparked by the coincidental release of their respective new books.  The Pope published his second volume on Jesus of Nazareth, while Kung put out his Can The Church Still Be Saved.

Results vary.

Gregg points out parallels and differences between the man who is now Vicar of Christ and the man who is now forbidden to teach in a Catholic faculty.

Here is a taste of Gregg’s look at the two authors and the two books:

But perhaps the most revealing difference between Benedict and Fr. Kung’s books is the tone. Can the Church still be saved? is characterized by anger – the fury of an enfant terrible who’s not-so-enfant anymore and who knows the game is up: that his vision of Catholicism can’t be saved from the irredeemable irrelevance into which it has sunk.

Jesus of Nazareth, however, is pervaded by humility: the humility of one who approaches human history’s greatest mystery, applies to it his full intellect, and then presents his contribution for others’ assessment.

Check out Mr. Gregg’s piece for more.

Posted in The Drill | Tagged , ,
5 Comments

Damian Thompson on birettas

From Damian Thompson‘s blog:

Bring back the biretta: why hatless priests should reclaim their heritage

By Damian Thompson Religion Last updated: March 24th, 2011

Here is a splendid new blog devoted entirely to the subject of birettas – a wonderful reproach to those Magic Circle clerics who think nothing of celebrating Mass in an Abigail’s Party-style cocktail frock “for the larger lady” but sneer at the magnificent traditional headgear of the Latin Church.

The Domus Birettarum blog [There is such a thing?] not only illustrates the wondrous variety of birettas but also makes them bespoke for those priests brave enough to wear them. And I do mean brave. I know several young clergy who would like to wear a biretta, but worry that their right-on septuagenarian PP will dob them in to the diocese for doing so.

As for their other major anxiety, I’m assured that if the biretta is placed gently enough on the crown, it doesn’t create the dreaded “hat hair”.

Is Damian is treating the biretta with the gravity it merits?

Everyone knows that the best defense against hat hair is short hair.

o{];¬)

Posted in Lighter fare | Tagged
14 Comments

A pair of pair of cuff links

As I was looking for more information on the so-called “Augustinian biretta” (which seems to be a lot taller than a Roman biretta), on Dieter Philippi’s site I ran across papal cuff links worn by Benedict XVI.

“Hmmm…”, quoth I.  “They look familiar.”

I received these as an ordination gift from a Roman acquaintance.

Great minds, and all that.

[CUE MUSIC]

And while you are contemplating that, why not enjoy a steaming WDTPRS mug of Mystic Monk Coffee?

That’s right, lifting that eye-catching mug, filled with that nose-catching infusion, is sure to raise your spirits and even allow your own cufflinks to shine.

I’ll bet the Wyoming Carmelites love Pope Benedict and admire his cuff links… even though they don’t really need cuff links of their own, come to think of it.   That’s because their sleeves are rolled up as they build their new monastery and roast that coffee!

Never mind about the cuff links.

Try the monthly subscription to their coffee of the month!

Mystic Monk!

It’s restorative!  It’s roborative!

It’s swell!

Posted in Just Too Cool, Lighter fare | Tagged ,
11 Comments

“Two hours on my knees and I should never think of it again.”

A question to you knowledgeable readers.

St. Ignatius of Loyola, founder of the Jesuits, is known to have said something about how he would accept the suppression of the Jesuits.  The quote is something like:

“Two hours on my knees and I should never think of it again.”

Can anyone come up with a citation?  Where? When?  To whom?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
23 Comments

Harvard – 25 March (Annunciation) – TLM

From reader:

The Harvard Knights of Columbus and the Harvard Latin Mass Society invite you to celebrate the Feast of the Annunciation of the Blessed Virgin Mary

Friday, March 25th, 2011, at 5:15pm.
Mass in the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite.
St. Paul Catholic Church, Bow and Arrow Streets, Cambridge, MA

Reception to Follow; All are welcome.
For more information, email HarvardLatinMass@gmail.com

Find the event on Facebook.

Been waiting for this Mass in Harvard Square for years? Want to see how Catholics worshiped for over five centuries? Then help us celebrate this momentous occasion.

Never been to a Latin Mass before? No clue what the Extraordinary Form is?
This will be the perfect introduction. English-Latin aids will also be available.

To find out more about the Harvard Knights of Columbus, see www.harvardknights.org

Let’s have a cheer for HAHVard!
Not loud enough to be vulgar,
But loud enough to be heard!

H-A-R with a V!
V-A-R with a D!

HAHVard!
HAHVard!

WEEEE!

Posted in Brick by Brick, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM | Tagged
34 Comments

When you think you’ve seen it all

Remember the post about the people in Albany who do the Stations of the Cross in clown gear?

When you think you have seen it all… a reader comes around with this sort of thing (edited).  This is from St. Louis and the Washington University Catholic Student Center.

To be fair, it is juxtaposed with a lecture by Peter Kreeft and an ad for confessions.

A student sent me this text.  I found the advert on the website of the Student Center.

Yoga Stations of the Cross Tonight!

Wednesday, March 23rd, 7:15pm, CSC Commons

Join us for a contemporary meditative experience of the Stations of the Cross that involves body movement, prayer, meditative music & pictures, and reflections. This CSC original combines traditional images and reflections of the Stations of the Cross with a unique way of feeling the suffering of Christ’s Passion in your own body through Yoga poses that spur a prayerful experience.

All are welcome to attend, please bring your own yoga mat. No experience necessary, there will be a brief instructional time at the beginning to go through the yoga poses before beginning the prayerful experience.

Also, join us for Pi Pizza tomorrow from 11:30-1:30!

The CSC Staff

The physical dimension of yoga is not so objectionable… though … with Stations of the Cross…. iust don’t know.  That doesn’t seem right to me.

Holy Church has warned us about the spiritual dimensions of yoga in a document about various “new age” phenomena.

Yoga, zen, transcendental meditation and tantric exercises lead to an experience of self-fulfilment or enlightenment. Peak-experiences (reliving one’s birth, travelling to the gates of death, biofeedback, dance and even drugs – anything which can provoke an altered state of consciousness) are believed to lead to unity and enlightenment. Since there is only one Mind, some people can be channels for higher beings. Every part of this single universal being has contact with every other part. The classic approach in New Age is transpersonal psychology, whose main concepts are the Universal Mind, the Higher Self, the collective and personal unconscious and the individual ego. The Higher Self is our real identity, a bridge between God as divine Mind and humanity. Spiritual development is contact with the Higher Self, which overcomes all forms of dualism between subject and object, life and death, psyche and soma, the self and the fragmentary aspects of the self. Our limited personality is like a shadow or a dream created by the real self. The Higher Self contains the memories of earlier (re-)incarnations.

Follow Fr. Z on Twitter!I think it is a bad idea to join to something like Stations of the Cross an activity which has a clearly non-Christian connotation, a connotation as a matter of fact which has spiritually harmful implications for those involved with it on a spiritual level.

Clowns Stations … Yoga Station… what’s next?  Dancing with the Stations?

I now begin the countdown clock for someone to post her defense of yoga.

In the meantime, check out today’s 5 minute LENTCAzT.

Posted in Liturgy Science Theatre 3000 | Tagged
67 Comments

Prayers for Mother Angelica: UPDATED

UPDATE 22:39 GMT:

I received this from a rep at EWTN:

Dear Father,

This was just released on our Official EWTN Facebook page:

“Please be advised that contrary to some recent comments on the internet there has been no change in Mother Angelica’s condition. She is happy to have your prayers and is looking forward her 88th birthday next month”

God Bless,

Gus Federle
Manager of Volunteer Support
EWTN Global Catholic Network

WDTPRS wishes Mother Angelica warm and prayerful best wishes!

____

ORIGINAL POST:

Perhaps you readers know more, but I spotted this on Twitter.  It is all I know.

Pls keep Mother Angelica of EWTN in your prayers, death seems near, preparations underway. May comfort and peace guide her to His Arms!

I don’t know what is behind this.  No matter… it is always good to pray for someone like Mother Angelica!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged ,
18 Comments

RECENT POSTS OF INTEREST

Listen to LENTCAzTs every day!  They are only 5 minutes long.

Here are some recent posts of interest, as they scroll along.

REGISTER to be able to post comments on this blog.

Posted in Linking Back |
Comments Off on RECENT POSTS OF INTEREST

Fishwrap wants Pope Benedict to resign, the Church to change moral teachings

What sort of people work for National Catholic Fishwrap?

The sort of people who think that Pope Benedict should resign and that the Church’s teachings on sexual morality can simply be changed… and should be changed.

My emphases and comments.

Richard Sipe suggests Pope Benedict should resign

by Thomas C. Fox on Mar. 22, 2011

In an article entitled “What can Benedict do to resolve the sexual crisis of Catholicism?” author Richard Sipe and Joe Rigert, write on the Australian Catholica website:

What can Benedict do to resolve the sexual crisis of Catholicism? At the very least he could open up for discussion and study [code for “change”] the antiquated sexual teachings on such common practices as birth control, use of condoms and sex outside of marriage. Further, he could lead the way to making celibacy optional for priests and allow women in the ministry. (Would women have taken part in, or allowed, the sex abuse scandal?) [I think they should ask SNAP that.  SNAP has been going after the LCWR to get them to cooperate concerning many cases of women religious abusing kids.] And he might call for a representative church council to consider all of these basic reforms. [That means that someone other than bishops should have the care of the Church’s teaching authority.  They want a “Magisterium of Nuns” for example.  I wonder if they would be the same nuns SNAP wants to talk to.]

But it is unlikely that any of these reforms will happen as long the aging pope and the old men of the Vatican [You would think that a journalist would know how to avoid a cliché.] persist on retaining their power and control. They must be willing to share their authority and then undertake a Sexual Copernican Shift in their basic assumptions about sexual teaching and discipline, a shift recognizing that [watch this…] our core sexual nature is a bio-diverse reality, not a theological construct. [I think that means they think the shared authority Copernicanly shift in assumptions will lead to an okay on sex with farm animals.] Only then will the pope and his men begin to address the crisis now inundating the church.  [These people are obsessed with sex.]

And now we get to the hard part[The hard part is coming up?  We were just at the impossible part.  The insane part.  What is harder than that?] the need for a courageous act. The pope could initiate this change by resigning from the papacy and calling for the resignation of all the other bishops, like him, who were complicit in the abuse scandal. [Watch this.] (In Ireland, the archbishop of Dublin proposed such action, and five bishops offered to resign.) [First, they are saying that the Pope is complicit.  Second, they are placing themselves in the position of authority.  In their analogy, the Primate of Ireland makes a suggestion and some bishops offer to resign.  Here the dissidents, probably also heretics too given their view of the Magisterium, make the suggestion and the Vicar of Christ and bishops are supposed to offer to resign. Third, I thought liberals thought the bishops in their dioceses were the problem?] Other popes have quit. In centuries past nine [?] of the 265 Roman Catholic popes have resigned or been forced out of office for the good of the church. [And after Celestine we got Boniface VIII.  These heretics should be careful what they wish for.] The most recent was Gregory XII who abdicated in 1417 to help settle the claims of three competitors for the papacy.

Perhaps they were high when they wrote this.  More probably they want additional conference engagements.

And I wonder how the sexually liberal religious groups are doing.  Flourishing, are they?

Posted in Throwing a Nutty |
55 Comments

QUAERITUR: What sort of “wine” is valid for Mass?

From a priest:

Are there any rules or traditions about the type of wine used the chalice? I know it must be fermented grape juice – but must or can it be it be red, white, sherry, port?

It is of divine institution that the only valid substances for transubstantiation are, for the Body of the Lord bread made from wheat and, for the Precious Blood, wine made from grapes or raisins (dessicated grapes).  But the grapes also have to be ripe, which rules out “wine” such as verjus (I actually have some, for ancient Roman and Medieval recipes). It can be red, white, dry, sweet, whatever.  Some prefer red because it resembles blood.  Some prefer white because it is easier to clean the linens.

Sometimes questions come up about the use of wine which has very low alcohol content, called mustum, a wine which had the fermentation process halted by means of rapid freezing.  That is a valid substance because it is from grapes and the natural fermentation process began, making it wine.  It has an artificially low alcohol content, but mustum is consider valid wine.

However, there is the other end of spectrum to consider: wine which has an artificially high alcohol content.  Sometimes alcohol distilled from wine is added to wine in order to preserve it against spoiling, changing to vinegar.  In this case we have “fortified wine”.  The usual types of “fortified wine” we encounter are port, sherry, madeira, marsala, and vermouth.

Unreconstructed Ossified ManualistLong ago it was established that fortified wines are valid matter so long as the wine-spirit added was distilled from grapes, that the quantity of alcohol added, together natural content from the fermentation, does not exceed 18% and that the additional alcohol is added during the process of fermentation.  You can read a good, brief article on altar wine in the Catholic Encyclopedia.  Also, because we are at heart Unreconstructed Ossified Manualists, we want to check our old manuals.  Unreconstructed Ossified ManualistWhat could be better than checking Tanqueray’s Theologia Dogmatica?

Again, we learn that it has to be from ripe grapes, it can be of any color, not corrupted, not frozen at the time of consecration.  Citing the Missale Romanum we are warned against wine that is turning bad.  As a matter of fact, if the priest is doubtful about it, he sins gravely by consecrating it.  “Si fuerit aliquantulum acre, ait Missale, conficiens graviter peccati.”

By the way, the coffee mugs are not at the moment filled with any of the beverages mentioned in this post.. until now… try some Mystic Monk Coffee!  It’s swell!

I would rule out vermouth, because herbs and so forth are added.  I would not go for sherry because, if I am not mistaken, the addition of the spirits takes place after fermentation.  Marsala seems to be okay, so long as it is 18% or less.  Vin Santo, from dessicated grapes, is fine.  As the name implies, it is wine for the altar! Port is valid, 18% or under.

Perhaps some people knowledgeable in the ways of port (making, not drinking) and marsala (not just cooking) can chime in.

Furthermore, this is a good reason why there are ecclesiastically approved makers of altar wines.  If you have a doubt, don’t screw around with anything that may not be valid.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Just Too Cool, Mail from priests | Tagged , , , , , ,
27 Comments