A Hymn to the Motu Proprio

I received this from a priest reader:

Hymn to the Motu
 
Iam enim hiems transiit;
imber abiit, et recessit.
Flores apparuerunt in terra nostra;
tempus putationis advenit:
vox turturis audita est in terra nostra;
ficus protulit grossos suos;
vineæ florentes dederunt odorem suum.
 
Vidi speciosam sicut columbam,
ascendentem desuper
rivos aquarum:
cuius inæstimabilis odor
erat nimis in vestimentis eius:
Et sicut dies verni
circumdabant eam
flores rosarum
et lilia convallium.

Would any of you like to work on what the hymn really says?

Posted in Lighter fare, Mail from priests, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM | Tagged
12 Comments

CDF examination of the LCWR

ICDF examination of the LCWRn a recent post on the site of National Catholic Fishwrap, I read that His Eminence William Card. Levada, Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, sent a letter to the Leadership Conference of Women Religious (cf. magisterium of nuns), …

… announcing the doctrinal assessment. Levada cited Vatican doctrinal concerns with the conference dating back to 2001.

The Levada letter set no timetable for further discussions or resolution of the issues involved. The outcome of the assessment could have a significant impact on the future of the conference and, in turn, the leadership of U.S. women religious communities, possibly leading to Vatican demands for new methods of communication among women religious or even new structures of leadership.

[…]

According to Levada’s letter, the Vatican study became necessary after the conference failed to respond adequately to concerns expressed by the Vatican in 2001. The Levada letter cited three areas of doctrinal concern: women’s ordination, the primacy of the Catholic faith, and homosexuality.

Levada designated Toledo, Ohio, Bishop Leonard P. Blair, a member of the U.S. bishops’ Committee on Doctrine, as the lead bishop in the study.

[…]

Levada told the women, the letter stated, that once Blair sends his final report to the congregation, his assessment will be sent for review to different groups, including “a subcommission, the American cardinals in Rome, and perhaps some others.” Levada explained he will then consult with Rodé and develop a final report that will be presented to Pope Benedict XVI.

The Fishwrap article is really about the persecution of these beleaguered women religious, who just want to help the poor, after all.

There is no mention of the fact that the LCWR has been straight-arming SNAP because of the emerging picture of female abuse of minors.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

Summorum Pontificum 3 years later: your reflections

Summorum Pontificum 3 years later: your reflectionsThree years ago, I started chilling the Veuve Clicquot. 

Fitting for the anniversary of the Emancipation Proclamation.

I got up at Oh-dark-hundred to post the text of Benedict XVI’s long-expected Motu Proprio (I had an advance copy under embargo until noon Rome time).  The click of the ENTER button was a blessed sound.  Then I stuck the Veuve into the fridge for later.

Summorum Pontificum will prove to one of the most important events of Pope Benedict’s pontificate. 

In this document he gave a great gift to the Church especially because it is such a great gift to priests.  Once priests learn the older form of Holy Mass – and this is especially true for younger priests – they never say any Mass in the same way again.  The older form teaches them something new about themselves as priests and about what and who they are at the altar.   In turn, this has a ripple effect on people around them.

Summorum Pontificum is part of Pope Benedict’s "Marshall Plan" to revitalize our Catholic identity.

Let’s use this entry for your reflections on Summorum Pontificum three years later.  The document went into force on 14 September 2007, but it was released today: 07-07-07.

Post here your reflections and observations.  Let’s not use this thread for discussion.  Just post your own points without engaging others directly
. 

And pray for Pope Benedict!

Summorum Pontificum 3 years later: your reflections

Posted in Brick by Brick, SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
78 Comments

FINAL! BLOGNIC 7 July – NYC, Manhattan 7 pm

7 July 2007 was the day Pope Benedict released the text of the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum (though it went into force on 14 September). 

We will have a blognic on the evening of Wednesday 7 July.

I will celebrate Holy Mass (Extraordinary Form) at Holy Innocents on 37th BTW Broadway and 7th at 6:00 pm.

FINAL! BLOGNIC 7 July - NYC, Manhattan 7 pmWe will then go about less than 10 minute walk to an Irish pub –

Tir na nOg
tirnanognyc.com

5 Penn Plaza
(8th Ave at 33rd St)
212-630-0249.

I picked Tir na nOg instead of Annie Moore’s because it is closer to Holy Innocents (shorter walk in the hot afternoon.)

You can come to Mass, or go to the pub a little early, but we are thinking 7:00-9:00 pm.

Buy your own drinks and your own snacks. Come and go as you please.

This is easy to get to, for sure… right across from Penn Station.

If you have not indicated your intention to come yet, using the poll below, please do.

It would help a lot if you could add a note about your participation in the combox, below, so that we can get a good picture.  Chime in again, even if you chimed in before.

{democracy:71}

Posted in Blognics | Tagged
41 Comments

The Feeder Feed: sacred arts edition

The Feeder Feed finds me again at the Metropolitan Museum… the air-conditioned Metropolitan.

Eucharistic Dove in gilded copper with enamel and glass beads from Limoges from 1215-35.

The Feeder Feed: sacred arts edition

This would have hung over the altar.  There is a tear shaped door on the back where there is a cavity where the Eucharist was preserved.

Also, we see here an embroidered 18th century chasuble from Italy.

The Feeder Feed: sacred arts edition

There are birds.  One we can identify quickly.

The Feeder Feed: sacred arts edition

This one… not sure…

The Feeder Feed: sacred arts edition

Posted in The Feeder Feed |
3 Comments

Pont. Comm. “Ecclesia Dei” letter about Communion in the hand

Pont. Comm. "Ecclesia Dei" letter about Communion in the handEven yesterday I had a conversation about the thorny issue of just what Summorum Pontificum (the 3rd anniversary of its release is tomorrow, blessed day) might have revived.

Take the situation of the distribution of Holy Communion.

In the old days before the conciliar reform of the liturgy it was unthinkable – unless you were a heretic or Protestant – that people would receive Communion in the hand.  There was no need for specific decrees about such a normal practice as reception of Communion, which was always given on the tongue to people who knelt if they could.

Today, however, there is (sadly) legislation which permits Communion in the hand under some circumstances.

Summorum Pontificum did not revive the old decrees of the long-gone Sacred Congregation of Rites or automatically resurrect the practices of yore.

Or did it?

I have always held that priests need to respect the laws in force about Communion today, even in the celebration of Holy Mass in the older form.   Of course they can also do all they might to discourage Communion in the hand and promote a more reverent manner of reception.   At the same time, it is unlikely that many who go to the older Mass will want to receive Communion in the hand.

I received from a friend in England the following very interesting news.  This is on kreutz.net.

The Pontifical Commission “Ecclesia Dei” – remember them? – sent a response to a person making an inquiry about reception of Communion at the older, Extraordinary Form. Translation:

“Dear Mr. XXXX In reference to your letter of 15. June, this papal commission would like to point out that the celebration of Holy Mass in the extraordinary form envisages the reception of Holy Communion while kneeling, as the Holy Host is laid directly on the tongue of the communicant. There is no provision for the distribution of Holy Communion on the hand in this form of the Holy Mass. With blessings,”

Pont. Comm. "Ecclesia Dei" letter about Communion in the hand

I note from the graphic that there was no Protocol.

There is a stamp on the letter rather than a signature.

This is a form letter.

It is therefore more than a curiosity, but it is a great deal less than the final word.

We are still left with questions about Communion during the Extraordinary Form.

If people insist on receiving in the hand, are they to be denied based on the argument that in 1962 there was no permission to receive in the hand?

And on an additional note, keep in mind THIS.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , ,
74 Comments

New CDF procedures for cases of clerical sexual abuse of minors

I saw this at Paolo Rodari’s blog (in my rapid translation):

[Msgr.] Charles Scicluna, promoter of justics for the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, should return to the Vatican around this time after some days of vacation.

With his return rumors are revving up about the imminent release of new regulations against pedophilia.

It it said that they foresee the removal from parish duties of any suspected priest, a streamlined course for reduction to the lay state, the obligation of the local bishop to denounce to civil authorities, an end to the prescription in canon law for crimes against minors, immediate remanding to Rome of the documentation gathered in the diocese.

John Allen wrote about this here: “Vatican set to issue changes in sex abuse rules“.

Giacomo Galeazzi here: “La Santa Sede prepara nuove regole per fermare gli abusi dei sacerdoti“.

Allen wrote:

…sources say the revisions also contain two new wrinkles: They extend the statute of limitations in canon law, known as prescription, for bringing a charge of sexual abuse of a minor from ten years from the victim’s eighteenth birthday to twenty. For the first time, the revisions also identify child pornography as a “grave offense” subject to the doctrinal congregation.

Posted in Clerical Sexual Abuse |
6 Comments

OUTRAGEOUS Mass in Vienna

What on earth is going on in the Archdiocese of Vienna?

Check out the video on Gloria TV, which I noted on Rorate.

The video is in German, but the message is clear.

A "Western" themed "Mass", which was if it was anything sacrilegious.  

This is going to make you angry.

This was done with the "blessing of the Cardinal" Archbishop of Vienna, Card. Schoenborn.

The ashtrays were an especially ghastly touch.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
54 Comments

SCOTUS scourings

The other day I posted this:

Supreme Court about priests as Vatican employees – sky not yet falling

Now, via Fr. Finigan, I found an entry on Religion Law Blog about the same question, offering analysis.

Doe v Holy See – Not as Important as it appears

The author notes, as I did, that the MSM is throwing a little nutty about the decision of SCOTUS not to hear the case. 

An excerpt:

Firstly the US Supreme Court has not made any decision for or against the Vatican, or The Holy See as it is more properly termed, what the Court has done is to refuse to review a decision made by a lower Court namely the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals and this is simply reported on the Supreme Court website as “Certiorari Denied” along with a large number of other refusals of “cert”. I will deal with the implications of the Supreme Court refusing cert later but for the moment will look at the 9th Circuit decision itself Doe v Holy See No 06-35563

Take a look for more analysis.

In other news about SCOTUS, I found a couple engaging pieces about Elena Kagan’s hearings on Creative Minority Report.

First, there is this: Kagan Evades Catholic Question

… Senator Lindsey Graham asked a good question whether the Catholic Church would’ve been barred from Harvard Law’s campus since it would be considered discriminatory just as the military is considered to be.

Kagan essentially told him they sure would but obfuscates and couches it in legal speak as if her hands were tired. And then there’s very little follow up. I don’t get it. How about a question about the role of freedom vs. inclusiveness? Does she believe the Catholic Church is discriminatory?

In the end I’d bet she wouldn’t answer these questions….

Also, in 2012 and The Supreme Court there is this bit:

Some good news, some bad news. The good news is that Justice Anthony Kennedy is going to stay on the court. The bad news is that Justice Anthony Kennedy will stay on the court.


Posted in Emanations from Penumbras, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , ,
11 Comments

Not so cool in Manhattan

On the flight coming in to NYC last night I was able to do some work online, with the airplane’s wifi.

In this moment I was tracking the flight on a non-liturgical iPad.

Not so cool in Manhattan

I was given when they came out and I am as yet undecided about what I want to use it for.  This iPad does not have 3G, so it is less helpful on the road.  But I have put a few books on it.  Also, I have figured out how to transfer files to it across my network.  I can also use it when connected to wifi to watch my SlingBox (which is one of the greatest inventions ever).

As we were landing the fireworks for the 4th of July were starting up around New York.  Alas, none of my photos turned out from the plane.

By the time I get from the airport to the west side where I generally stay, the show was still going.

Here is a bad shot down the street in front of the rectory.

Not so cool in Manhattan

I went with a friend who picked me up to a favorite place on 9th and 24th for a quick bite of Chinese dumplings.

Not so cool in Manhattan

Not so cool in Manhattan

Better than the ramen I ate at home before my flight.

Not so cool in Manhattan

And a special treat was seeing one of these on the way home!

Not so cool in Manhattan

Back in NYC, where it is hot hot hot today.  Right now…. 99F (37C).  It is not too humid.

I am in today, stuck at a desk working on an article, but later tonight I will sally forth.

Posted in Lighter fare, On the road, SESSIUNCULA |
14 Comments