Great photos of traditional ordinations by the FSSP

Nowy Ruch Liturgiczny has some serious liturgical eye-candy to accompany their note about the recent FSSP ordinations.  With a biretta tip to NLM.

Click for larger version.

Great photos of traditional ordinations by the FSSP

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments

New blog urges readers and parishes to drop The Tablet

New blog urges readers and parishes to drop The TabletHis Hermeneuticalness, Fr. Finigan, directed my attention to a new blog called Ecumenical Diablog, which is worth your attention.  Here is a sample.

Monday, 5 July 2010
Catholics Don’t Take the Pill or The Tablet

There is a custom in the Catholic Church of a Month’s Mind Mass, which liturgically is the Mass on the 30th day after death or burial. As ‘The Tablet’ finally died as a Catholic magazine with its 5th June 2010 pro-abortion issue, today is it’s Month’s Mind. Others will write, and have written, long polite articles explaining The Tablet’s long and painful spiritual death. So I will focus on a couple of points; personal insulting of women and what is to be done now.

My Wife and I lost a child two years ago through an ectopic pregnancy, for The Tablet to try and use this to promote abortion (by claiming this is an example of the Church permitting “abortion”) is at best evil. This is an insult to countless couples who have had to live through this tragic situation. The only thing that could be worse than this is to think of the Priests & Bishops, under whose pastoral care we are, showing us and our deceased children nothing but contempt by reading this rag.

It is a sin to read this rag or to allow it to be sold in your Church. “But I don’t read all of it, I just like the articles by…..” To support evil financially is not okay even if you don’t read all of it. “I’m just the Curate, not the Parish Priest there is nothing I can do about it.” So ask the PP to stop selling it and if he won’t, ask your Bishop for a transfer! That may ruin your career Father, but Hell is full of the prudent who tolerate evil. “If I stop selling it that will upset some of my parishioners.” Oh dear! Human respect leads to Hell.

“What about the right to debate and free speech?” I doubt that The Tablet will print an article by Bishop Richard Williamson SSPX on World War II or Nick Griffin (BNP) on Race-Relations. No reasonable person believes in unlimited ‘free speech’.

I will stop now, the bottom line is; if you have a subscription to The Tablet cancel it today, if you read it stop today, if you sell it stop today, if you write for it stop today.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
20 Comments

The Very Model Of A Modern Seminarian

This comes from a seminarian reader.

Fr. Z:

Lot of things in the news, thought I’d send something light. I’m a seminarian and longtime reader of your blog. I also like operettas. So, while I was waiting for something the other day, I wrote a parody of the Modern Major-General’s Song from The Pirates of Penzance but about a seminarian. I don’t have the time to set this to music, so I thought I’d send you the text.

[…]

The Seminarian’s Song

To the Tune of the Major-General’s Song from The Pirates of Penzance
 
I am the very model of Catholic seminarian
I’ve information pastoral, canonical, and Marian,
I know the Popes of Avignon and Councils Ecumenical
From Nicaea to Vatican plus gatherings heretical.
I’m very well acquainted too with matters homiletical,
I’ll write a pretty sermon that is eloquent yet practical,
About soteriology I’m teeming with a lot o’ news…
Such as salvation history’s relation to the modern Jews.
I’m very open minded, I have Sunday lunch with Protestants,
I teach them our Church History and sing it in Gregorian Chants,
In short in matters pastoral, canonical, and Marian,
I am the very model of a Catholic seminarian.
 
I know my ancient languages, some Latin, Greek, and Hebrew too;
I’m smart as a Dominican, I write for The Thomist review,
I quote Thomas Aquinas and I know the Summa all by heart,
I know the arguments for God from Anselm to Rene Descartes;
I am an expert without doubt in all matters liturgical,
I’ll see the rubrics carried out in fashion demiurgical!
I can intone polyphony from every epoch, school and rank…
And sing all of the arias composed by Mister Cesare Franck.
Then I can run a bingo or a bake sale in the Parish Hall,
And sell spaghetti supper tickets at the local shopping mall:
In short, in matters pastoral, canonical, and Marian,
I am the very model of a Catholic seminarian.
 
In fact, when I know what is meant by “Molinist” and “Arian,”
When I can rise above the title of Popish sectarian,
When such affairs as wakes and confirmations I’m more wary at,
And when each sort of imperfection, sin, and fault I can combat;
When I have learnt the progress of von Balthasar’s theology,
Converted every member of the Church of Scientology—
In short, when I’ve a smattering of basic Catholicity—
They’ll say that I’m a cleric full of goodness and simplicity.
And though my Bishop is impressed by my enormous panurgy,
The man is rather wary at my love for Latin Liturgy,
But still in matters pastoral, canonical, and Marian,
I am the very model a Catholic seminarian.

Posted in Lighter fare, Parody Songs | Tagged
36 Comments

“to reconcile disputes and to renew the Church”

I have been hammering away for years now that the major goal of Pope Benedict’s pontificate is the revitalize our Catholic identity.

There is a macro dimension to this and there is a micro dimension.

With my emphases and comments comes this from CNA in which both macro and micro are highlighted:

Papal spokesman describes week of Benedict XVI’s evangelical witness to the Gospel

Vatican City, Jul 3, 2010 / 11:14 am (CNA/EWTN News).- Pope Benedict XVI’s “exquisitely evangelical witness” this week show his "personal and direct commitment" to creating communion in the Church, [He is, after all, the Pope of Christian Unity.  This applies within the Church (ad intra) and not just to other communities (ad extra).] Vatican spokesman Fr. Federico Lombardi has said, citing the Holy Father’s launch of a new evangelization of the West and his action to reconcile disputes and to renew the Church. [And now we must fit this new dicastery into thepicture.]

During his "Octava Dies" editorial aired on Vatican Television [Let me ask… did you even know this existed?  Great work on the part of the Holy See to let everyone know about it.] on Saturday morning, Fr. Lombardi remarked that in recent days the words and actions of the Pope have been “exceptionally intense and determinant for the life of the Church community."

The activity of the Pope, he continued, has been made more meaningful due to its proximity to the Solemnity of Sts. Peter and Paul. This is a feast which brings our attention back to the mission "entrusted by Christ to Peter and his successors" to support and guide the faith of believers, he explained.

For Fr. Lombardi, the announcement of the new Vatican department for renewed evangelization of areas subject to secularization stands out among the Pope’s activities this week. However, he particularly wanted to highlight the pontiff’s “personal and direct commitment to the union of the Church community.” [He is, after all, the Pope of Christian Unity.]

"The Pope has repeated many times that the dangers and the gravest temptations for the Church come from within," pointed out Fr. Lombardi. "In difficult times, such as those that we are living, the tensions induced from the outside make it easier also for tensions to emerge inside and these combine and increase confusion and uncertainty."

Papal audiences this week included two meant to bring about healing within the Church. Archbishop of Vienna, Cardinal Christoph Schonborn who has spoken out against the actions of Cardinal Angelo Sodano in the past was brought together with him and Pope Benedict on Monday. Also, on Thursday, ex-Bishop of Augsburg, Walter Mixa, who resigned this year reportedly for embezzling and physically abusing children in an orphanage, met with the Pope in the Vatican.

These events, Fr. Lombardi indicated, "demonstrate that (the Pope) is working himself … to heal the tensions and incomprehensions that afflict the community."

The Vatican spokesman quoted the Holy Father’s words from the communique reporting the content of Benedict XVI’s audience with Bishop Mixa: "In a time of contrasts and uncertainties, the world expects from Christians the harmonious witness that they, based on their encounter with the risen Lord, are able to offer and in which they help each other as also in all of society to find the right way towards the future."

Fr. Lombardi concluded by saying that "These are the sentiments of the Pope; his exquisitely evangelical witness is clear. We should follow it."

Posted in New Evangelization, Our Catholic Identity, Pope of Christian Unity | Tagged ,
12 Comments

Supreme Court about priests as Vatican employees – sky not yet falling

My email inbox suggests to me that there is a lot of anxiety out there about recent news that the U.S. Supreme Court (SCOTUS) turned down an appeal by the Holy See against a lower court ruling that U.S. Catholic priests and religious are effectively employees of the Holy See. Twitter

The sky is not falling.

The Court’s action is related to a state of Oregon case which names the Holy See as a defendant in a case involving sexual abuse of minors dating back to the 60’s by a now-deceased priest of the Servite Order.

On the day after SCOTUS’s action was announced, Italian national newspapers reacted with blithering panic. Headlines screamed that the Supreme Court had ruled that priests were employees of the Vatican and that the Pope was therefore legally liable in sexual abuse cases.

SCOTUS did no such thing.

What actually happened is very complicated from a legal point of view, but I will try to break it down to a few essential points according to my understanding. 

I am not a lawyer and this is complicated stuff. 

I am happy to be corrected by any lawyers who get this.

CAVEAT LECTOR

  • SCOTUS simply refused to hear an appeal by the Holy See from a decision by the 9th Federal Appellate Circuit Court, which upheld a Federal District Court ruling in Oregon that, under provisions of the 1976 Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA), employees of a foreign, sovereign state can be prosecuted for certain crimes (torts) that they commit in the U.S.
  • SCOTUS did not hand down any ruling on this question.  SCOTUS simply let stand the Appellate Court ruling. This is an important point. It means that (what the MMS in Italy and in the US are saying notwithstanding) SCOTUS did not rule that priests and Religious are Vatican employees.
  • The effect of the Federal Court rulings is to allow the case to go to trial in the Oregon state courts. Those state courts must still decide whether priests and Religious who work in the U.S. can be considered Holy See employees under the definition of employee in Oregon law. If the Oregon courts make this ruling, then lawyers for the plaintiffs will try to get the Oregon courts to hold the Holy See, the Pope, General Zod, the most Holy Trinity, liable for financial judgment in this case. That could open the door for similar legal actions against the Pope in other states.
  • But wait!  There’s more! If the Oregon court reaches this judgment, then lawyers for the Holy See can once again appeal the judgment all the way to the Oregon Supreme Court. They can also appeal the judgment back to the federal court system, this time arguing on the basis of testimony provided during the trial that the court’s judgment violates the provision of sovereign immunity under the 1976 FSIA. Subsequently, should the case reach SCOTUS, SCOTUS could decide to hear arguments from both sides and to render a decision. Only in then would we have a SCOTUS ruling on this question.

Clear?

Whew.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
34 Comments

WDTPRS: zeal and mercy – 6th Sunday after Pentecost – COLLECT

Please flip open your own trusty copy of the Liber Sacramentorum Romanae Aeclesiae Ordinis Anni Circuli edited by Leo Cunibert Mohlberg, OSB (in other words the Gelasian Sacramentary and yes, it is “Aeclesiae”.).

You will find Sunday’s ancient Collect in the second group of prayers for Sundays.  This prayer survived the scissor and paste-pot wielding liturgical experts who, under the aegis of the late Fr. Annibale Bugnini, revised and shuffled the ancient prayers for the Novus Ordo. 

With only slight changes, this prayer is still heard today on the 22nd Sunday of Ordinary Time.

COLLECT – (1962 Missale Romanum):
Deus virtutum, cuius est totum quod est optimum:
insere pectoribus nostris amorem tui nominis,
et praesta in nobis religionis augmentum;
ut, quae sunt bona, nutrias, ac pietatis studio,
quae sunt nutrita, custodias
.

In the 2002 Roman Missal it appears this way (variations underscored): Deus virtutum, cuius est totum quod est optimum, insere pectoribus nostris tui nominis amorem, et praesta, ut in nobis, religionis augmento, quae sunt bona nutrias, ac, vigilanti studio, quae nutrita custodias. But in the ancient Gelasian it is like this: Deus uirtutum, cuius est totum quod est optimum, insere pectoribus nostris amorem tui nominis et praesta, ut et nobis relegionis augmentum quae sunt bona nutrias ac uigilantia studium quaesomus nutrita custodias. (Yes, quaesomus.) However, the apparatus criticus at the bottom of the page, where variations in different manuscripts are listed, also suggests vigilanti studio. Thus, the Novus Ordo redactors attempted to restore the prayer in some respects to the version pre-dating by many centuries the “Tridentine” Missale Romanum, making also changes in style.  But they changed the conceptual grounding of the Collect by removing pietas.  
     
Your even trustier copy of the Lewis & Short Dictionary informs you that insero means “to sow, plant in, ingraft, implant.”  Virtutum is genitive plural of virtus, “manliness; strength, vigor; bravery, courage; aptness, capacity; power” and so forth.  Virtutum translates the Hebrew tsaba’, “that which goes forth, an army, war, a host.”  Tsaba’ is applied to hosts of angels, of soldiers, and the sun, moon and stars.   In the Sanctus of Holy Mass and in the great hymn called the Te Deum we echo the myriads of saints and angels bowed before God’s throne in the celestial liturgy: “Holy  Holy  Holy  LORD GOD SABAOTH…. God of “heavenly hosts”, or as the lame-duck ICEL version puts it, God “of power and might”.  “O mighty God of hosts” is a fair attempt at what Deus virtutum is saying.   We find in old translations of the Latin Vulgate Psalter that this address for God is rendered as: “God of hosts.”  The Holy See’s document which lays down the norms for liturgical translation, Liturgiam authenticam 51, says, “deficiency in translating the varying forms of addressing God, such as Domine, Deus, Omnipotens aeterne Deus, Pater, and so forth, as well as the various words expressing supplication, may render the translation monotonous and obscure the rich and beautiful way in which the relationship between the faithful and God is expressed in the Latin text.”  We must drill into these tougher phrases and not simply gloss over them.

Lame-Duck ICEL version (1973 translation of the 1970MR):
Almighty God,
every good thing comes from you.
Fill our hearts with love for you,
increase our faith,
and by your constant care
protect the good you have given us
.

LITERAL TRANSLATION:
O mighty God of hosts, of whom is the entirety of what is perfect:
graft the love of Your Name into our hearts,
and grant in us an increase of religion;
so that You may nourish the things which are good
and, by zeal for dutifulness, guard what has been nourished
.
 
Here are images having to do with armies and also with vine tending. On the one hand we have the God of hosts who guards the good things we have.  On the other, God grafts love into us and then nourishes it into growth.

Notice that we pray to God for an increase in “religion.” 

Ancient Roman religio is a complicated term.  The word derives from the root lig– , “to bind”, hence, religio means sometimes the same as obligatio.  As our obliging L&S explains, Romans understood reverence for God (or their gods), the fear of God, “connected with a careful pondering of divine things; piety, religion, both pure inward piety and that which is manifested in religious rites and ceremonies; hence the rites and ceremonies, as well as the entire system of religion and worship, the res divinae or sacrae, were frequently called religio or religiones.” 

Note the reference to “piety”.  This description also resonates closely with our Catholic axiom that the “lex orandi lex credendi… law of praying is the law of believing”, if we believe certain things inwardly, we are duty bound to express them outwardly in worship.  

St. Augustine of Hippo (+430) in Book X of City of God states that pietas concerns honor and service to God and that it does not much differ from religio.  The Roman sense of pietas is especially the honor we are bound to show toward our parents, especially our father, but by extension to children and the one’s fatherland, patria.  In liturgical language, when pietas is applied to us humans it is the due respect we show supremely to God the Father, but also to His children in the foreshadowing of our true heavenly patria, the Church.  When in liturgical texts we talk of the pietas of God, we are talking about His mercy.  God cannot be under obligations, as we can be, but He has made us promises.  He will be true.

So, in our prayer is a strong conceptual link between pietas and religio.  It is fair to take religio to be the virtue of religion.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church defines religion in the glossary toward the back of the newer English edition, “Religion: a set of beliefs and practices followed by those committed to the service and worship of God. The first commandment requires us to believe in God, to worship and serve him, as the first duty of the virtue of religion. (Cf. also CCC 2084 and 2135)   Religion is the virtue by which men exhibit due worship and reverence to God (St. Thomas Aquinas, STh, 2-2a, 81, 1) as the creator and supreme ruler of all things, and to acknowledge dependence on God by rendering Him a due and fitting worship both interiorly (e.g. by acts of devotion, reverence, thanksgiving, etc.) and exteriorly (e.g., external reverence, liturgical acts, etc.).  The virtue of religion can be sinned against by idolatry, superstitions, sacrilege, blasphemy, etc.”  

In sum, we must recognize God and act accordingly both inwardly and outwardly.  When that comes easily for us and is habitual, then we have the virtue of religion.  A virtue is a habit.  If it is hard to do something virtuous (be prudent, be temperate, be just, etc.) you don’t yet have the virtue.  

Notice also that this petition of the Collect directly follows from the desire that God graft love of His Holy Name into our hearts.  Our thought in this prayer moves from the title given to God by the angels and saints in heaven in their unending liturgy: “HOLY”, they say again and again.  Then we ask for love of the Holy Name of God.  Then we want all good things nourished in us by God increasing in us the virtue of religion, the proper interior and exterior action that flows from recognizing who God truly is for us.
 
I find interesting the choice to change the phrase with pietatis in the “Tridentine” version of the Collect to vigilianti studio. 

The 1962 version says, “…by means of zeal for dutifulness/mercy, you may guard the things which have been nourished.”  The 1970 edition says, “by means of vigilant zeal.”  We should also decide if the prayer is talking about God’s zeal or about our zeal, resulting from God’s increase of our religion.  From the Latin it is not entirely clear whose zeal it is.  

Certainly in all ages and everywhere the powers of hell attack the Christian and attempt to pervert his soul. 

It is always necessary to attend to one’s soul dutifully, striving to acquire and to practice the virtue of religion. 

I get a somewhat greater sense of urgency in “vigilance” than I do from “duty”. 

Consider the image of the soldier at a sentry post. 

In peacetime he carries out his duty and is vigilant.  In wartime he is intensely vigilant. 

Think of 1 Peter 5: 8-9, so long the chapter for every night at Compline in the Roman Breviary:

“Be sober and vigilant (vigilate): for your adversary the devil is going around like a roaring lion seeking whom he might devour: whom you must resist, strong in the faith.  But you, O Lord, have mercy (miserere) on us.”

Posted in WDTPRS |
1 Comment

A priest explains: “Why the Old Form thrives in my parish”

On the site of the Catholic Herald, the UK’s best Catholic weekly, (it has a great new look) there is an article you will want to see, with my emphases and comments.

Why the Old Form thrives in my parish

On the eve of the third anniversary of Summorum Pontificum Fr Gary Dickson says it is unfair to accuse the bishops of obstructing liturgical reform

By Fr Gary Dickson on Thursday, 1 July 2010

Three years ago, in July 2007, the Holy Father published Summorum Pontificum giving parishioners the canonical right to have their parish priest celebrate the Old Form of Mass (the Extraordinary Form) for them alongside the New or Ordinary Form. In places Summorum Pontificum is resisted, and it is important to recognise and address the causes.

Some say the obstruction comes from bishops, but this is unfair. The problem seems to lie within the Church as a whole, being an aversion to formal, God-directed worship in favour of a liturgy that entertains with cheerful hymns, is undemanding to follow and casual in celebration. This aversion harbours resistance not only to Summorum Pontificum but even to the new translation of the New Form. [I think he is right.  But there is active and direct resistance from some priests and bishops.] As the end of the three year period of assessment on how the implementation of Summorum Pontificum has gone approaches, I offer a reflection from one of the several parishes which celebrate in the Old Form every Sunday.

In scheduling the Old Form, objections came mainly from those who experienced the heady days of the Church’s surge into change after Vatican Council II and who saw change and informality as the order of the day. It is understandably hard for them to welcome back their heritage when it evokes things considered long gone and appears to undo what was established by priests they have loved. But honesty compels us to acknowledge that we all abandoned things the Council decreed we retain, [exactly] while loyalty demands we recover them by authentic catechesis on both the Council and the Ordinary Form.

For example, the “full, active and conscious participation” of the people (Sacrosanctum concilium #14) is a call of the Council frequently misunderstood, [Let’s see where he goes with this!] for the word translated “active” is actuosis; an engagement beyond mere “activity” (actives). Indeed, external activity is but participation in the liturgical rite, and can be present without internal, conscious participation in the Mystery of Faith. [I wonder if the writer has been reading WDTPRS!] Significantly, the Council began its teaching on the liturgy by stating that the Church is “present in the world as a pilgrim [and is] so constituted that in her the human is … subordinated to the divine; … action to contemplation”. The Sacred Congregation of Rites confirmed this contemplative element in 1967: “This participation is first and foremost internal” (Musicam sacram #15). [YES!  And it goes back before that as well.  Good work!] Still, to externalise the internal, participation by word and gesture remains important. Sadly, the loss of focus on internal participation has resulted in [horrors…] the imposing of drama, dancing – even puppet shows – on to the rite. To be recovered here, then, is the core of participation; that lifting up our hearts to the Lord, and actions required by the Missal: striking the breast in the Confiteor; bowing during the Credo etc.

TwitterUndoubtedly the lay ministry of Lector (Reader) was built into the New Form so as to facilitate lay activity in the rite itself (Extraordinary ministry is not built-in; it was established for use only in exceptional circumstances), but this seems to have created a sense that unless one has a ministry one does not participate. [Right! In fact, it leads to a worse sort of clericalism than that of which liberals accuse those of a more conservative stripe.] This is clearly wrong since it would mean 95 per cent of Catholics never participate. It is necessary, then, to recover an awareness that active participation consists not in mere activity but in “raising the mind and heart” in “full, active, conscious” attention expressed by heartfelt responses, postures and singing.

Next we must acknowledge the Council’s decree that “Latin is to be retained” (Sacrosanctum concilium #36). Latin all but vanished following the Council’s permission to use the vernacular for the readings and commonly called “bidding prayers” with authorisation to extend its use, yet the Council limited that extension by decreeing: “Never the less, care must be taken to ensure the people be able to say or sing in Latin those parts of the Mass that pertain to them” (cf Sacrosanctum concilium #54). [How many times have I quoted that, I wonder.]  Gregorian Chant, which was to have “pride of place in liturgical services”, was also lost, yet its use was reaffirmed by Pope Paul VI in 1974 when every Bishop was sent a copy of On the minimum repertoire of Gregorian Chant. Accordingly, use of Latin – which demands a conscious, active attention the vernacular does not – must be recovered if we are to be genuinely formed by Vatican II.

Again, having the priest face the people was not mentioned by the Council but given as an option in the Ordinary Form (cf 1970 General Instruction #262). [The option overran the norm, which was the objective of the innovators.] In fact, the rubrics of that Form direct the priest to alternately face the people (#133) and the altar (#134). The Congregation for Divine Worship noted that even the phrase “which is desirable whenever possible” in reference to facing the people remains an option, not an obligation. [He is talking here about GIRM 299, about which I have written many times. Here is one entry.  The English translation provided by the USCCB, for example, and I am sure elsewhere, is wrong.  The Latin was even clarified by the same CDWDS, but few liberals want to acknowledge that.  Instead, they persist with their bad translation as more congenial to their agenda.] Thus for faithfulness to the Ordinary Form, the altar-facing position too needs some recovery. Practised correctly, it accounts for only a quarter of the entire Mass. [Good point.]

Acknowledging that things frequently cited as contrary to Vatican II are in fact decreed by the Council (Latin) and directed by the Missal it generated (the altar-facing priest) their more regular use should be promoted in order to make genuine our claim of being faithful to Vatican II and eliminate misinformed resistance to the Old Form and the new translation. [And here we get to it…] How then did our parish facilitate reception of the Extraordinary Form in a pastoral way?

We began by educating the parish in the actual decrees of Vatican II, the rubrics of the New Missal and the reasoning behind them. Once aware of what the Council and Missal actually said, most were well disposed toward implementing the Council and New Missal in a more authentic manner.

Secondly, when celebrating the Old Form, several pastoral supports are utilised.

First, the readings are – as proposed and recommended by Vatican II – proclaimed in the vernacular with use of a free-standing microphone. [In place of the Latin?  At the same time as the Latin?] Since God is speaking to the people at this point it makes sense that they be able to understand without difficulty.

We also sing three vernacular hymns: at the Entrance, Offertory and Recessional as permitted pre-Vatican II (cf De Musica sacra et sacra liturgia #14, Sacred Congregation of Rites, 1958). This allows for continuation of both the characteristic silence of the Old Form and the verbal contribution of the people in a manner to which they have become accustomed. [People like to sing hymns.]

We also supply missalettes with the people’s responses highlighted so as to enable participation in the rite itself. Missalettes for children are picture booklets showing the varying positions of the priest and servers at specific points, enabling the children – and adults new to this Form – to more easily follow the rite.

Finally, we ensure that those who wish to receive on the hand may continue to do so in accord with current canonical rights and obligations. Receiving in the hand while kneeling poses no problem, while those who cannot kneel make the required act of reverence by receiving on the tongue. [This will be controversial for many adherents of the TLM.  I think he is right in his upholding the Church’s present law.  Please understand that I dislike Communion in the hand enormously.  It should be phased out.  People should be moved away from it.  But while it is the law of the Church to permit this (bad) option, priests must uphold the (bad) law.]

There are some who still resist solemnity in celebration; the use of Latin and the altar-facing priest. [Minimalists.] Yet these unintended losses in the New Form are not difficult to recover: if we can lose them overnight after centuries of use we can recover them after only decades of loss. Such recovery is not “going backwards”, or doing a U-turn, since the Ordinary Form will continue in use. Rather, it is a halting of the train to retrieve what has fallen from the carriage before our continuance. Many folk seem unable to grasp the distinction.

It is important to say that attendance at our Extraordinary Form accounts for a third of our weekly Mass numbers. Some who said they would never attend do so occasionally, and with decreasing prejudice. Further, the parish is not divided by differing liturgical preferences – friendships and working relationships remaining unaffected. [See my Rules of Engagement.] Finally, as with the Ordinary Form counterparts, those who attend the Extraordinary Form display great devotion to Christ in the Eucharist and personal prayer; a concern for social justice by running coffee mornings to support SPUC, Aid to the Church in Need and Let The Children Live, and engage in collaborative ministry as catechists, extraordinary ministers, Legion of Mary and finance committee members.

I believe we can no longer refuse the Extraordinary Form and for two main reasons. First, [1] because the Church declared it to be sacred, and while the Church has all authority to forbid what is evil she has no authority to forbid what is sacred; her authority is “to build up rather than destroy” (1 Cor 13:10). Second, [2] this Form is the rightful heritage of future generations; one to which we have no moral right to deny them access. Use of the Extraordinary Form is then a matter of recognising and promoting the holy, and an act of justice towards future generations.

Fr Gary Dickson is parish priest and Sacred Heart and English Martyrs, Thornley, Co Durham

 

WDTPRS kudos to Fr. Dickson.

Posted in Brick by Brick, New Evangelization, Our Catholic Identity, SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM | Tagged ,
33 Comments

Archbp. Wenski on CHA support of Obamacare

This is an excellent entry from the blog of newspaper of the Diocese of Kansas City-St. Joseph… never to be confused with a certain fishwrap produced in the same region.

From The Catholic Key:

Quote of the Day – Archbishop Wenski

Miami Archbishop Thomas Wenski has some choice quotes today on CHA and "Obamacare". Explaining the bishops’ position, he tells Catholic News Agency:

"we weren’t willing to go for health care reform under (just) any conditions. Basically we have said that health care reform means that it should be accessible to everybody and nobody should be killed. And this Obamacare does not make it accessible to everybody and it allows for people to be killed, mainly unborn children at the taxpayer’s expense."

See the whole story including the Archbishop’s comments on CHA over at CNA.

 

 

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras | Tagged
11 Comments

The key purposeful error in the NYTimes new attack on Pope Benedict

There is a key problem with the recent article in Hell’s Bible (aka New York Times) attacking the Pope.

As a preamble I must say that people have already made up their mind about the Catholic Church and the clerical sexual abuse problem.

I emphasize: the problem in the past which wasn’t handled well.  The Church has dealt with this problem in the present, though there are still problems with the way it was handled in the past.

At this point new media muckraking will rarely change minds about the Catholic Church.  There is media saturation by now.  When I see BP’s underwater oil gusher video live on TV, I am disgusted momentarily and then I turn the channel.  I’ve already made up my mind about oil gusher.  It’s nasty and I hope it gets cleaned up, the sooner the better. And in justice someone needs to pay to for it.
Twitter
So, we are not in the least impressed that Hell’s Bible has another article this month.  We aren’t happy about it, but there are no new lessons.  The New York Times is in bed with lawyers who want more money and with liberal Catholics who want to crack the Church’s tradition on celibacy and male priesthood.  Ho hum.  People aren’t going to be moved again until they start covering the real stores that have been sidestepped: women religious, the magisterium of nuns, covered up their problems and married Protestant ministers abused children also.

But for us insiders, you who read blogs, a couple things must be said about this latest attack.  Like serious observers of a ball game, we are compelled to keep score, point out runs, hits, errors, double-plays, bench-clearing-brawls. 

There are errors in the New York Times attack.

Theirs is a scatter shot attack. There are boring stabs at Apostolos suos, Liberation Theology, etc.  Ho hum.

The real problem is that a absolutely get wrong the 1962 document Crimen sollicitationis.

And because the editors of Hell’s bible aren’t stupid, they are getting it wrong on purpose.

Two points.

1) As is clear from Crimen sollicitationis 1-2, the jurisdiction of the then Supreme Sacred Congregation of the Holy Office (SSCSO, the name of the present Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith or CDF until 1965), only covered solicitation in the context of confession/internal forum, and not other delicts.  That is why there are relatively few cases handled at the SSCSO and CDF until the whole system was overhauled.

2) The jurisdiction of the SSCSO/CDF was not immediate. The first instance or immediate jurisdiction remained in the diocese. The SSCSO would only have called a case to Rome if their were some compelling reason, for example, depending on whether the Holy Office even knew about it, or if the diocese couldn’t deal with it.  The dioceses had immediate jurisdiction.

I suppose you could object that Rome should have wanted to deal with every case.  Consider that back then is not right now.  Tools of communication are very different now.  Given the reasonable principle of subsidiarity, there was great reason to leave the cases in the dioceses.  As the situation, and communications, changed, Rome could get more directly involved and informed.  But, until the Church’s procedures were changed, that was how they handled things.

These points are crucial, for on them rests the mantra that "all along Ratzinger and the CDF did nothing".

This is insider baseball, of course.  But you insiders who read this sort of thing, need to be able to explain the situation when the topic arises with colleagues or loved ones or strangers.

UPDATE 2033 GMT – BATTLE OF THE FISHWRAPS!:

I believe the temperature in hell is dropping or that the Cubs are going to win the World Series.  An article in the National Catholic Fishwrap appears to attack Hell’s Bible.  The key purposeful error in the NYTimes new attack on Pope BenedictThe nearly always wrong Sean Michael Winters explains that the writers of the NYT don’t understand what they are talking about. 

At the end of his piece, however, he expresses an opinion that:

"As for the import of the 1922 and 1962 documents, about which the story makes so much, the Times acknowledges that there was confusion about who did and did not have authority to deal with the crime of sex abuse until 2001. That confusion reigns still. This morning I consulted two highly respected canon lawyers. One said that the documents did give the CDF authority in the disputes. The other said the documents only gave CDF authority over the crime of solicitation in the confessional. Again, check in with Jack McCoy."

I recommend that he ask the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith about this.  If he does, he will get what I explained, above.

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, Clerical Sexual Abuse, SESSIUNCULA |
46 Comments

1st Friday Reminder

Don’t forget that today is First Friday.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments