Recent posts of interest

Lest you miss them…
Recent posts of interest
But first…

“Pray for the Pope” store – buttons and other stuff


 Twitter
Recent posts of interest

REGISTER to be able to post comments.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Recent posts of interest

comic relief

This is how I felt getting up today and thinking about the news I would read.

comic relief

An editorial cartoon… Michael Ramirez!

comic relief 

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, Clerical Sexual Abuse, Lighter fare | Tagged
9 Comments

Omnibus omnia factus sum

From a reader:

I thought perhaps you could use an anecdote today.  I have my 8th grade students researching a project on whether the priest should face "ad populum" or "ad orientem."  With this I posted a few articles from WDTPRS concerning the topic.  However, most of them were more intrigued by your animated hamster at the bottom of the the screen!  They spent most of their time playing with it rather than doing their work.  They thought it was "cute" though, and named it "Hammy."  Just thought I’d pass it on.

 

 

Posted in Lighter fare |
23 Comments

QUAERITUR: good commentary on Sacrosanctum Concilium

From a reader:

I am currently taking an Intro to Liturgy course for my MA in Theology program.  I am not entirely sure that what is being taught is orthodox.  The professor certainly seems to have a liberal bend.  We recently read Sacrosanctum Concilium, as well as some commentaries on the document written by some questionable authors.  I was wondering if you could recommend any books or articles that explain SC from an orthodox perspective.  I just feel like he conveniently left some things out.  Any other book recommendations you can provide that may help me combat any heterodoxy taught for the rest of the class would be greatly appreciated.

 

I am oppressed with other things at the moment.

Can readers help?

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
26 Comments

Is Benedict XVI a “better Pope” than John Paul II? A couple views and then Fr. Z really rants.

The Holy Spirit probably does not choose Popes.  As Joseph Ratzinger explained before his own election, the Holy Spirit guides the choice of a Pope, or a Council for that matter, so that we don’t inflict irreparable damage on ourselves.

Each pope comes to the See of Peter with his own strengths.

Hell’s Bible, the New York Times, ran an op-ed today by Ross Douthat.  I drill into it here. 

After that, I drill at a response of a kind by Rod Dreher.

My emphases and comments:

Op-Ed Columnist
The Better Pope

By ROSS DOUTHAT
Published: April 11, 2010

The world didn’t always agree with Pope John Paul II, but it always seemed to love him. Handsome and charismatic, with an actor’s flair and a statesman’s confidence, he transformed the papacy from an Italian anachronism into a globe-trotting phenomenon. His authority stabilized a reeling church; [Along with his undermining the Soviet Bloc and his writing on the human person, this is the most important thing he did as Pope: in my opinion he averted a schism.] his personal holiness inspired a generation of young Catholics. “Santo subito!” the Roman crowds chanted as he lay dying. Sainthood now!

They will not chant for Benedict XVI. The former Joseph Ratzinger was always going to be a harder pontiff for the world to love: more introverted than his predecessor, less political and peripatetic, with the crags and wrinkles of a sinister great-uncle. [?] While the last pope held court with presidents and rock stars, Cardinal Ratzinger was minding the store in Rome, jousting with liberal theologians and being caricatured as “God’s Rottweiler.” His reward was supposed to be retirement, and a return to scholarly pursuits. Instead, he was summoned to Peter’s chair — and, it seems, to disaster.

[…]

But there’s another story to be told about John Paul II and his besieged successor. The last pope was a great man, but he was also a weak administrator, a poor delegator, and sometimes a dreadful judge of character. [I think more has to be said about that.  I will say it below this piece.]

The church’s dilatory response to the sex abuse scandals was a testament to these weaknesses. So was John Paul’s friendship with the Rev. Marcial Maciel Degollado, the founder of the Legionaries of Christ. The last pope loved him and defended him. But we know now that Father Maciel was a sexually voracious sociopath. And thanks to a recent exposé by The National Catholic Reporter’s Jason Berry, we know the secret of Maciel’s Vatican success: He was an extraordinary fund-raiser, and those funds often flowed to members of John Paul’s inner circle. [I wonder if this is fair? Most of what Pope’s know about people is filtered through the intermediary of lieutenants.  In this case former Sec. State Angelo Card. Sodano was the great advocate of the Legionaries.  Let’s move on.]

[… [deals with how Ratzinger rebuffed the Legionaries and wanted to investigate] ]

So the high-flying John Paul let scandals spread beneath his feet, and the uncharismatic Ratzinger was left to clean them up. This pattern extends to other fraught issues that the last pope tended to avoid — the debasement of the Catholic liturgy, [Do I hear an "Amen!"?] or the rise of Islam in once-Christian Europe. [Some people think that Benedict was ill-advised, literally, in the matter of the Regensburg Address.  I think the Pope knew what he was doing.] And it extends to the caliber of the church’s bishops, where Benedict’s appointments are widely viewed as an improvement over the choices John Paul made. [Maybe in the choice of bishops in certain areas of the world, but I think the question is more complicted, as I will explain.  I don’t think that Pope Benedict is entirely happy in the choice of some of his closest collaborators, however.] It isn’t a coincidence that some of the most forthright ecclesiastical responses to the abuse scandal have come from friends and protégés of the current pope.

Has Benedict done enough to clean house and show contrition? Alas, no. Has his Vatican responded to the latest swirl of scandal with retrenchment, resentment, and an un-Christian dose of self-pity? Absolutely. Can this pontiff regain the kind of trust and admiration, for himself and for his office, that John Paul II enjoyed? Not a chance.

But as unlikely as it seems today, Benedict may yet deserve to be remembered as the better pope.

About the issue of John Paul and his achievements, the choice of bishops today compared to the nominations made under John Paul II…

I think that when John Paul II came to the See of Peter, the Church was in the verge of splintering.  I think that one of the late Pope’s greatest accomplishments was to drag us back from the edge of schism.  One of the things he did was bypass elements of the hierarchy and appeal to people directly.  Another thing he did, over many years, was shift the balance of the world’s episcopate.  He slowly began to approve the nominations of men who were more men of the Church than men of the world.  He could not simply do his own thing in the case of nominations, in my opinion, because there was for a long while a real danger of revolt from the left, the liberal camp in the episcopate, not just in the academy or rank and file of clergy.  I think this explains in part why the late Pope seemingly inexplicably was willing to promote men he had to have known were something like enemies to his views about the direction of the Church and her teaching, especially about human sexuality.  Thus, he had to work slowly, over the decades he seemed he knew from the very beginning of his pontificate would be granted to him.  He slowly shifted the episcopate, focusing especially on regions such as the central part of the USA (in the vitally important anglophone world), and spreading outward from there.  He made incremental changes and, over time, they worked.  The episcopate and college of cardinals as of April 2005 was quite different from that of 1978.

When people suggest that Pope Benedict is better at certain things, we have to remember that Pope’s not only have different strengths, but they also have different challenges.  Also, Joseph Card. Ratzinger was a close adviser to John Paul II.  I cannot help but think that his influence figured in some of what I suggest above.

That is, in brief, something of what I think about issues raised in the piece above.

Now, let’s have a glance at Rod Dreher reacting to Ross Douthat’s column in Hell’s Bible:

Benedict: Probably better than John Paul II

Monday April 12, 2010

…at poping, that is. Ross Douthat, the non-ridiculous Catholic on the Times columnist roster, makes an important point that can’t be said often enough: though John Paul II was by far the more charismatic figure, Benedict XVI will likely be remembered as the better pope. Excerpt:

[…]

Try to imagine what would be happening today if a healthy, vigorous John Paul II were sitting on the Throne of Peter today, dealing with this latest crisis. We know what we’d get from the Pope and his inner circle: very little except more denial. [Really?  I don’t know that.  Remember how a younger Holy Father dressed down his countrymen when he returned to Poland after the fall of the Soviet Bloc.] But the public reaction would, I think, be much different. It’s easy to attack Pope Ratzinger; he’s nowhere near the rock star that Pope Wojtyla was, [True.] he’s German (it’s still shamefully easy to smear all Germans with the Nazi stereotype), he’s known to be an orthodox Catholic who takes doctrinal integrity and Church discipline more seriously than his predecessor did — something that’s very much to the good, given how standards in the institutional church had gone to the dogs over the past few decades. Indeed, I think one reason why so many orthodox Catholics have been so quick to defend the Pope in this, even to what I think is an unreasonable degree, is because he is rightly seen as the competent administrator who was going to clean up the messes John Paul left. [I keep reading this claim in various articles.  I think that is not an accurate accessment.  Papa Ratzinger is not a micromanager.  There has been administrative stumbling during this pontificate.  Pope Benedict has not in fact "cleaned up the Curia".] You cannot look at the disgusting scandal with the Legionaries of Christ that John Paul let fester, and that Cardinal Ratzinger moved to clean up, even before John Paul had died, without grasping that we are dealing with a different pontiff.

Despite being an easy target for unjust treatment by critics – and I say this as someone who doesn’t think Benedict is going nearly as far as he must to deal with the "bishop problem" – there is a sense in which people who want to see actual repentance and reform in the Church over the child sex abuse scandal, instead of show trials and theater, [Ummmm… what would that look like, exactly?  What would "actual repetence" look and sound like?  Would there not be a greater risk of "show trials" and "theater" if dramatic gestures were made rather than steady quiet reform and change?] should be pleased by the fact that the current Pope is not the charismatic figure that John Paul was. It makes it easier to see him as a man, not a celebrity "demigod" figure. Most Catholics have an enormous reverence for the person of the Pope, and this is appropriate. But JP2 was hero-worshipped to an unhealthy degree.

In the summer of 2002, reeling from the psychological shock and trauma of 9/11, and the child sex abuse scandal, which began breaking in January of that year, with the Geoghan trial in Boston, I was having enormous trouble sleeping because of residual anger and anxiety. Lots of tooth-grinding in my sleep, that sort of thing. My wife urged me to go talk to a Catholic psychotherapist about my inner turmoil. So I did. My third visit occurred after I published a Wall Street Journal op-ed saying that John Paul had failed the American church. Excerpt:

    When considering how this intolerable state came to pass, all roads lead to Rome. In Catholic teaching, the chief responsibilities of a bishop, including the Bishop of Rome, are to teach, sanctify and govern. John Paul has taught and sanctified zealously; his evangelical travels have inspired millions, and his writings about the nobility of human love are a treasure for all mankind.

    Yet this pope has largely failed to use the disciplinary authority of his office. This statement will surprise those who see the pope as authoritarian, but it is true.

    In serious matters, such as priestly sexual misconduct, abuses in the liturgy, corruption in seminary life, and the rejection of church teaching by Catholic universities and hospitals, the pope has explicitly recognized the crisis, given clear directions for its correction – and done nothing when his orders were ignored or undercut by subordinates in this country. [That is happening with this present Pope as well…. but less than before.] Over the last 30 years, faithful Catholics have found a variety of ways to make known to the Holy See their urgent concern, but most often to no avail.

    Even if it has been possible to believe that John Paul had been ignorant of the rape of children, the worst of all scandals, that is obviously no longer the case. [BTW… I remember at the time of the big blow up in 2001/2, when all the US official went to Rome, a couple people who came out of a meeting with the late Holy Father were still shaken about the loud dressing down they got with real anger at how some of them had lied to him about the state of affairs.  Anecdotal?  Yes. Verifiable from another source?  Maybe some day.  But it is stuck in my memory as a story I received from someone in the room.] The situation of Catholics in Boston is enough to make one weep. Cardinal Bernard Law claims to have offered his resignation, only to have it refused. Rome allows him to remain in office, though his mendacity and corruption are there for all the world to see, and the credibility of the church in Boston is destroyed.

    Who keeps him there, and why? Who retains in office a host of American bishops defiled by their indifference to the victims of depraved priests under their authority? Who could remove them with a stroke of his pen?  [While that it true, that is a bit of a simplification.  The men have to be replaced quickly, and the vetting process isn’t done by the Pope on his own: he depends on others who at different levels may not share his vision.  Also, what to do with the men who were removed?  We don’t advance physical euthanasia after the application of ecclesiastical euthanasia.  Get the out?  Sure.  But it isn’t just the stroke of a pen.] It is hard to judge John Paul, because we don’t know what he’s had to fight behind the scenes. [As I said.] Still, I find it impossible any longer to give him the benefit of every doubt, as is the custom of many papal loyalists. John Paul must bear partial responsibility for the catastrophe that has befallen us.  [BTW… has anyone mentioned Pope Paul VI?  He was Pope for a long time, even during the time much of the abuse was going on.  Do we talk about John XXIII?  There is a little matter of a Council that got out of control when the schemata were rejected and it was launched without a clear vision or pilot at the rudder.  What about Pius XII?  Wasn’t he in charge when some of the future child abusers were being formed in seminaries that were perhaps oppressively informed by a certain cross-section of clergy inbued with jansenist tendencies?  There is a lot of blame to go around.  I haven’t seen Paul VI brought up very often, however.]

When I sat down in the chair across from the therapist (who, I should point out, was at the time affiliated in some way with the now-disgraced Legionaries of Christ, favorites of John Paul, and reported bribers of his inner circle), he tore into me for this column. He yelled at me that I was "a new Luther," that I was going to lose my family if I persisted in criticizing the Holy Father, that I was under demonic influence, and so forth. I argued back. There’s nothing quite like your therapist — a man who took you on as a patient in part because you were seeking help dealing with anger at Church officials over child sex abuse – literally screaming at you that you’re in danger of going to hell for having published a criticism of the Pope. Needless to say, that was the last time I saw that therapist, or any therapist. That shocking experience taught me how pathological John Paul II’s cult of personality could be, [It sounds as if the writer has some things he is still working out about this whole thing.  There is some pain in these words.] even among intelligent people who ought to have known better. While it pains me to see the current pope subject to cheap attacks by petty controversialists, in the end the absence of a personality cult is one reason why it’s better that Ratzinger and not Wojtyla is in charge during this crisis.

UPDATE: Just to clarify the point, I believe that prior to 2002, Ratzinger was part of the problem, not the solution. [Let’s see if he can make a solid argument for that.  I don’t buy it, personally.  But let’s see.] It has been reliably reported that the 2002 US scandals pierced the fog of denial that he and others in Rome had been living in. But you can’t relive the past, and I don’t think people should be surprised if more documents surfaced showing Card. Ratzinger taking a much softer line on pedophile priests in the past than he would today. [Is it possible that the writer hasn’t made the proper distinctions yet about what Ratzinger’s actual role in his office was?  Was the competence of his dicastery was?] If Ratzinger defenders are depending on the current pope never being linkable in any serious way to softballing a pederast priest, in the routine manner of the bishops for so many years, they are going to be doomed to making narrow legalistic arguments that will fail in the court of public opinion (which is the only one that counts). [HUH?  The court of public opinion is the only one that counts?  I beg to differ.  It is surely important, in this life, but it counts for nothing in the final analysis.  Furthermore, what some people call "narrow legalistic arguments", in a negative sense, is actually to make proper distinctions for the sake of understanding the truth of the situation.  Qui bene distinguit bene docet.] Far better for Pope Benedict to give a major speech admitting forthrightly to grave errors in the past, personally and corporately, and pledging real reform. Of course he can’t give that speech unless he actually plans to undertake some sort of house-cleaning among the bishops to show that his are not just words. [And will that be enough for the AP/NYT driven court of public opinion?  Not on your life.  They would probably just label a house-cleaning as the former Hitler Youth’s own Night of Long Knives, and shout "SEE!? Rottweiler!"  I agree that there must be a purification of the episcopate.  But it must be done with Romanità. If I were Pope, I would form a small corps of monsignori tasked to obtain some resignations…  I think I would recruit them from, say, Sicily.  They seem to know how to do this sort of thing quietly, with a smile.  "Eccellenza… our Holy Fadher isa greatly concerned fora your healt." One sits down a little too close to the bishop. The other, still standing, opens his jacket, reaches in and draws out a beautiful Waterman fountain pen and thick, folded sheet of paper. The bishop’s eye is drawn to the momentary bloody-red flash from the stone in the visitor’s cuff-link.  "You would, Monsignore, give greata consolation to da Holy Fahder were you to step down anda den… how you say Monsignore Brazzi? … shtare rinda?…"  "Stay insida you house", intones Msgr. Brazzi at the bishop’s side… never taking his eyes from the bishop’s face. "…rinda … inside… nota go out…."  "’Inside’… yes… daats eeet", repeats the standing visitor, the pleats of his pants like knives.  "You reada da Mass. You reada da books.  You eata da lunch.  You pray da Rosario.   You confessare.   Rinda.   No agitazioni.  You worka hard… tooo haaard fora too many yeers.  Time to rest.. fora your healt.  You see, Eccellenza Reverendissima, we are only concerned fora your healt. You wait quiet, maybe now and den talka to police when dey come? Giornalisti later… after polizia."  The bishop swallows hard and, trying to summon some courage blusters, "What is your name, Father!?  I will…"  The dark-haired monsignor leans over the desk toward the bishop, who falls back into his high backed leather chair. "My name is Monsignore Vito Andolini.  E chist è pe tia!"  He hands the bishop the Waterman. Meanwhile, in a different office of the same chancery, another pair of monsignori are speaking with the auxiliary bishop – infamous liturgical weirdo – about the likelihood of promotion to a soon to be created role as Apostolic Envoy to the Pirates of the Gulf of Aden.  "Who better than you? … Eccellenza?  You feeling, alrighta?"  His hand reaches past the sharp-lapel and into the inner pocket of his well-tailored jacket.  Okay, okay…. after that little day-dream I think I might need some therapy too.  But,…. you geta my pointa.  Huge public displays might not be the best approach.] Maybe he can’t bring himself to do that. Maybe he really can’t do that, in any practical sense (which would raise interesting questions about papal authority in practice, versus in theory).  [And it would demonstrate that the press forced the Church to do something.  Then… Katie, bar the door!] My point, though, is humility and repentance would be a strength to the Pope in this crisis. [and he hasn’t done that enough?  Hard to say.] I think any competent public relations expert would tell him that. But the Vatican’s PR sense is fifth-rate. You may believe that it’s beneath the Holy See to worry about PR, but you would be very, very wrong. [When the Church was still strong in its identity, it’s worship, missionary zeal, works of mercy, and did I mention worship? …  were its PR.] That’s not how power and authority works in the world today. I’ll write more about this later, when I discuss James Davison Hunter’s book, and why all this matters a lot to me personally, even though I’m no longer a Catholic. [… no longer a Catholic…]

 

Thought provoking to be sure.

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, Clerical Sexual Abuse, SESSIUNCULA, The Drill, Wherein Fr. Z Rants | Tagged ,
122 Comments

Weigel’s piece in First Things… then Fr. Z rants

Preface: I urge priests and bishops reading this to at the very least skip to the last part if you think you don’t have time to read the whole.

_____

George Weigel has a piece in First Things which merits a reading.

I teased out a few salient points for you atention.  I will add something at the end.  My emphases and comments.

…

The realization among serious Catholics that this is not 2002 and that things have changed dramatically since 2002, has led to a far more confident effort to fight back against misrepresentations such as those the Times perpetrated on March 25. There is a danger here: to recognize that this is not 2002 cannot blind us to the fact that there are wounds that remain to be healed, reforms of priestly formation that remain to be completed, ["Amen!" to that!] bishops whose failures remain to be recognized and dealt with, new norms for the selection of bishops to be implemented, [?] and accounts rendered as to why the Vatican, prior to Ratzinger’s taking control of the issue of clerical sexual abuse in the late 1990s, was sometimes sluggish in its response to scandalous behavior by priests and deficient leadership by bishops. …

Nailing down that counter-narrative would be considerably aided if, in the coming weeks, a comprehensive and documented narrative of the case of a predatory Munich priest which was mishandled during Ratzinger’s tenure as archbishop there—the revelation of which was the European ground zero for the latest set of explosions—would be published. It would also be helpful if the Holy See would provide a user-friendly explanation of how abusive priests are laicized, and how this process has been streamlined and accelerated, again under Ratzinger’s leadership. …

In the face of all this, [UK readers take note…] the bishops of Britain must recognize that scandal-mongering has now metastasized into a full-scale assault on Catholicism itself, and ought to devote the next four months to the most vigorous defense of the truth of Catholic faith. …

Yet if 2010 is not to become 2002 redivivus, the Holy See must make unmistakably clear that it is serious about dealing with malfeasant bishops: [Do I hear an "Amen!"?] that, in addition to swift action against abusive priests, the Church is prepared to take swift and decisive action against episcopal misgovernance. …

Cynicism and irony are powerful corrosives in ecclesiastical life. [Read closely…] Yet they cannot withstand the power of radical conversion, joyful discipleship, and courageous evangelism. [More on this below.] In North America, in Great Britain and Ireland, in Germany and Austria and the Netherlands, indeed all over the world Church, these are the most effective counters to the current wave of Church-bashing and Catholic-baiting.

 

I don’t think it is too much of a stretch to connect the wave of attacks on the Church and misrepresentation to the attempt to divide and subborn Catholics – through the crack of weak-identity liberal Catholics – undertaken by the present White House administration and its willing enablers, such as the administration of the University of Notre Dame.  I think the larger view of seemingly isolated incidents suggests that there is a connection.

As a result, and picking up on what Mr. Weigel wrote at the end – about the power of joyful evangelism – I will add here below with a few edits part of my Liturgico-Political Manifesto I wrote after the the Debacle at Notre Shame.

I urge all priests and bishops who read this blog with any slight quaver of resonance or benevolence, to consider this with care:

If you sense that something quite serious and important is going on right now, for the love of God rethink your approach to how you foster Holy Church’s proper public worship.

Do all in your power and through your influence to foster a worship of God which conforms not to worldly goals – as praiseworthy as they may be in a world still dominated by its dire prince – but rather to the real point of religion: an encounter with mystery. 

Our worship must become more and more focused on the one who is Other.  Seek what is truly above in your rites and raise people to encounter mystery.

You will be challenged and reviled, blocked and attacked as you do.  You will be worn down and afraid under the weight of resistance.

But I think that to save the world we must save the liturgy.

The present round of attacks on the Church, which suggest a deeper agenda, confirm this.

Secularist and secularizing forces can’t compete with the fullness of Catholic liturgy and sound preaching.

Reforming the liturgy along the lines Pope Benedict has proposed may be the most loving and effective option we have in these ever hotter times.

People will have to keep working very much in the sphere of the secular.  Of course!  Our inward Catholic Christian identity must find outward expression and bring concrete fruits.

But I think the real work now – where we will make some effective headway – must be done at the level of our public worship.

In the present circumstances, we are not going to argue most people out of danger or error.  But together we can draw them in and along and back through worship.

So long as we remain doctrinally faithful and active in works of mercy both spiritual and especially temporal, if we get our public worship together we will have a mightier argument against error. 

Holy Catholic worship will be an attractive force for conversion.

We need to foster worship which stuns, which leaves the newcomer, long-time practicing Catholic, above all the fallen-away simply thunder stuck.  Worship must at some point leave people speechless in awe.  We need language and music and gesture which in its beauty floods the mind with light even while it swells the heart to bursting.

The more people encounter mystery through liturgy, the more hollow will clang the false or incomplete messages of those who have strayed from the good path, either to the left or to the right.  

Our goal must be that which is good and beautiful because it is true, that which reflects what is of God, not man’s image merely.  Give us mystery, not fabrications smacking of the world, fallen and transitory.

Fathers, and you Reverend Bishops, if anything of alarm has sounded in your hearts and minds of late, rethink your approach to our worship.  Examine your approach with an eye on the signs of the times.  Take a new approach. 

The approach we have had least last few decades isn’t getting it done.  Really … it isn’t

Going neither left nor right along the road toward the Lord, even as He comes to us, take the flock now deeper, now higher on that path, but always to encounter the mystery which distinguishes truly Catholic liturgy… and therefore true Catholics.

Lines are being drawn, sides taken, choices made.

More than ever we need what Christ, the true Actor of our liturgy, desires to offer us through Holy Church’s worship.

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, Clerical Sexual Abuse, Our Catholic Identity, The future and our choices, Wherein Fr. Z Rants | Tagged ,
21 Comments

Time For Some Fair and Balanced Reporting on Clerical Sexual Abuse

logoWe’ve all seen that for weeks now, and especially during Holy Week, Catholics have been subjected by the secular and liberal catholic media to yet another onslaught of old stories about the Catholic Church and clerical sexual abuse.

Once again, op-ed pieces such as this, this and this have argued that

  • mandatory celibacy and an
  • all-male hierarchy

are responsible for the high numbers of Catholic priest child sexual abusers.

Television and print media outlets incessantly advance the image of the Catholic priesthood as an exclusively male club of pedophiles presided over by bishops and a Pope eager to protect their dirty secrets.  

We’ve heard critics complain that

  • if priests could marry and
  • if the Catholic priesthood were open to women,

this crisis would never have happened.

But celibacy and an all-male priesthood are not responsible for clerical sexual abuse in the Catholic Church. Period.

The proof is easily available for all to see.

The people behind the mainstream media (MSM) attacks on the Church have certain goals, short-term and long-term.  Among their immediate objectives is to distort the view of the average person about the Church to the point where the Church will be forced to ordain women and, for the Latin Church, eliminate mandatory celibacy.

They want to twist the Church way from being faithful to her conviction that a male ordained priesthood is of divine origin and away from the counter-cultural sign of clerical celibacy. If the Church caves in to save its image in a secular sense, it’s game over.

Clerical sexual abuse of children is simply the convenient club which which they hope to beat this message into the heads of the people in the street.

Therefore, they are hammering into you that both ordination for men only and celibacy produce a pederast priesthood.  That is fallacious. Period.

I think that there are members of the Catholic hierarchy who are going to be affected by this onslaught. They need to straighten their backs and get some facts.

During the past week I have done an internet search about child sexual abuse among Protestant ministers in the USA, most of whom are married.

I was, I think you will be, stunned by the results, though we wouldn’t be shocked had the MSM reported fairly about clerical sexual abuse of children across the denominational spectrum!

Try this out for yourselves. It’s not hard and doesn’t take a lot of time.

On your own computers, right now, do a Google search using this string: “Protestant ministers child sex abuse”. Or vary the string with “Anglican ministers child sex abuse”, “Baptist ministers child sex abuse”, “Presbyterian ministers child sex abuse.”

Don’t take my word for it.

See for yourselves what the media have been hiding from you for years!

You can easily find out on the web about married Protestant ministers, Eastern Orthodox priests and Jewish rabbis who have sexually abused children, and about their denominational cover-ups.

Sound like a familiar story line? But this time it’s not about everyone’s favorite punching-bag, the Catholic Church and its all-male, celibate priesthood.

This is the story you won’t hear about from the mainstream media. Nor will you hear about it in the NCR, America, US Catholic and other liberal, Pope-hating, so-called Catholic journals that want you to think that celibacy is responsible for this crisis.

I want to state here and now my profound respect for some very fine Protestant publications that have led the battle in their own denominations to report the story about Protestant ministers and pedophilia that the mainstream media has played down. They deserve everyone’s gratitude.

In writing about this, I am not attacking other religious communities.  I am not excusing abuse by Catholics.  I am not engaging in Schadenfreude (“delight at another’s misfortune”).

I am not writing about this so that Catholics can feel relieved in the knowledge that clerical sexual abuse of minors happens in all the other churches.

I have only one reason for writing about this.  We must debunk the premise being pushed by the MSM and their Catholic allies in the Church.

Time For Some Fair and Balanced Reporting on Clerical Sexual AbuseThe MSM, for reasons all too clear, has focused on celibacy and on the male priesthood as the causes of this crisis. The only way to debunk this argument is to show how widespread this crisis is among married clergy in denominations where women are ordained and where they take part in church government.

But don’t take my word on this. Check for yourselves. Google it.

In the meantime, consider the following.

  • Writing a comment following a blog posting here, on April 3, 2010 at 11:32 am, Bob said, “I was molested and raped by my Lutheran minister, who also is my father. He molested and raped all of his sons, and at least 30 children in his flock. People above him were aware of the allegations, and did nothing! I’m not alone, I just wish the media would cover all victims of abuse, and how all institutions handled it in the 20th century.”
  • Time Magazine ranked the Southern Baptist Convention’s refusal to establish a database of clergy sex offenders one of the most under-reported news stories in 2008. The story was also reported here by Bob Allen, writing on December 17, 2008, for the Associated Baptist Press website, one of the most forthright sources of news about Protestant clergy pedophilia.
  • Incidentally, there is some evidence on the Internet that child sexual abuse committed by women has also been under-reported. In a story I found here dated November 9, 2009, a British charity agency claimed that reports of women carrying out sex attacks on children have soared in the last five years. ChildLine said there had been a 132 percent rise in reports of female sex abuse made to its telephone helpline, compared to a 27 percent rise in abuse by men in the same five-year period. “Most sex abuse calls to ChildLine come from girls saying they were assaulted by a male,” Sue Minto, head of the helpline, said. “But a growing number of callers now say they were sexually abused by a female. Many would find it shocking that any woman – let alone a mother – can sexually assault a child. But they do.” This reports concerns women in general, not women ministers, but the article suggests that there is a time lag in people reporting child sexual abuse committed by women, and that these reports are only now beginning to escalate in number. So clerical sexual abuse of minors may not turn out to be an exclusively male crime after all.
  • On June 18, 2007 the Insurance Journal (here) reproduced a report stating that the three companies which insure the majority of Protestant churches in America say they typically receive upward of 260 reports each year of young people under 18 being sexually abused by Protestant clergy, church staff, volunteers or congregation members. The report went on to comment, “the Catholic Church has revealed that there have been 13,000 credible accusations against Catholic clerics since 1950.” This report prompted one blogger here to comment, “Responding to heavy media scrutiny, the Catholic Church has reported that since 1950, 13,000 ‘credible accusations’ have been brought against Catholic clerics (about 228 per year.) The fact that this number includes all credible accusations, not just those that have involved insurance companies, and still is less than the number of cases in Protestant churches reported by just three insurance companies, should be making front page of The New York Times and the network evening news. It’s not.”

This is the kind of media bias I am concerned about, the kind that makes it look like, among ordained ministers, pedophilia is found predominantly within the secretive, closed ranks of the all-male, celibate Catholic clergy.

This bias is unfair and it works to undermine confidence in clerical celibacy.

And these instances of bias are just the tip of the iceberg.

WDTPRS will continue to drill at this in time to come (or you can just check out the Internet yourselves).

It’s time we stand up and begin to form something like another Tea Party Movement, this one aimed at anti-Catholic media bias as represented in the under-reporting of Protestant clerical pedophilia.

I know that others before me, like the courageous Bill Donohue of the Catholic League, have been out in front on this issue. I want all of us to join their ranks. “We’re mad and we’re not going to take it anymore!”

We need action.

Get your friends and Catholic organizations involved! Let me suggest for starters that the next time you see a report about Catholic priest pedophilia that is not coupled with a report about Protestant clergy pedophilia, contact the media in question and tell them that each time they do this you will change the TV channel or not read their paper, and that you will contact their commercial sponsors about this anti-Catholic media coverage. And tell them that if their journalists are too stupid or too lazy to find instances of Protestant clergy pedophilia, all they need to do is to look for it on the Internet!

Let the media oppose cover-ups involving all clergy, not just Catholic clergy!

Posted in Clerical Sexual Abuse, SESSIUNCULA, The Drill, The future and our choices, The Last Acceptable Prejudice |
50 Comments

Catholic League’s full page ad in the New York Times

The Catholic League has weighed in with a full page ad in the New York Times (aka Hell’s Bible).

The text:

GOING FOR THE VATICAN JUGULAR

Catholic League's full page ad in the New York TimesRecent accusations against the Vatican deserve a response.

• Fr. Lawrence Murphy apparently began his predatory behavior inWisconsin in the 1950s, yet the victims’ families never contacted the police until the mid-1970s. After an investigation, the case was dropped.

• The Vatican did not learn of the case until 1996.

• Cardinal Ratzinger, now the pope, was the head of the office that was contacted. There is no evidence that he knew of it. But even if he did, he would have had to allow for an investigation. While the inquiry was proceeding, Murphy died.

• The Times questions why Murphy was never defrocked. But only the Vatican can do that, and since it never learned of the case until he was dying, it was never a realistic option.

• The Times says the Vatican’s canonical inquiry was done in secret. Correct. The proceedings of internal investigations—even in organizations like the Times—are never shown on C-SPAN.

• The Times says repeatedly that Church officials did not report accusations of abuse to the police. The common response of all organizations, secular as well as religious, was to access therapy and reinstate the patient (I prefer the term offender). Today it is obvious that a more hard-line approach is necessary, though therapy is still popular in many quarters.

• The Times continues to editorialize about the "pedophilia crisis," when all along it’s been a homosexual crisis. Eighty percent of the victims of priestly sexual abuse are male and most of them are post-pubescent. While homosexuality does not cause predatory behavior, and most gay priests are not molesters, most of the molesters have been gay.

Here’s what’s really going on. The Times has teamed up with Jeffrey Anderson, a radical lawyer who has made millions suing the Church (and greasing professional victims’ groups like SNAP), so they can weaken its moral authority. Why? Because of issues like abortion, gay marriage and women’s ordination. That’s what’s really driving them mad, and that’s why they are on the hunt. Those who doubt this to be true need to ask why the debt-ridden Times does not spend the same resources looking for dirt in other institutions that occurred a half-century ago.

Bill Donohue
President

CATHOLIC LEAGUE for Religious and Civil Rights
450 Seventh Avenue, New York, New York 10123
(212) 371-3191 Fax: (212) 371-3394
www.catholicleague.org

UPDATE: I like the Curt Jester’s observation via Twitter: The NYT rejected Archbishop Dolan’s response but accepted a paid ad from Catholic League: at the NYT you have to pay for balance.  Kudos to the Jester.

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, Clerical Sexual Abuse | Tagged ,
17 Comments

In fairness to writers in America Magazine

A couple things:

In America Magazine, Sean Michael Winters, who is wrong about most things, got something right about the ghastly MSM recent coverage clerical sexual abuse of children.  He is a bit late in his examination of the case in California, but he makes some good points…. a few of them new, as well.

Furthermore, Fr. James Martin, SJ, in the America, has a solid offering which must be read – especially reading this.  Fr. Martin’s piece is called "Celibacy does not cause pedophilia".   And he got something posted in the Huffington Post … which will surely draw thought and balanced reactions in that combox.  I think he underplayed the homosexual factor in the abuse cases, but he made a solid argument.

I bring these to your attention out of fairness.  They got this right.

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, Clerical Sexual Abuse | Tagged , ,
4 Comments

Do you have any good news?

I think we could all use GOOD NEWS!

What is your good news?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
65 Comments