Still hacking away at the SSPX book

I am still drilling through the book The Problem of the Liturgical Reform: A Theological and Liturgical Study by the Society of Saint Pius X. Still hacking away at the SSPX book

It is just the right size for an airplane trip.

So far… it is very interesting, especially the section on the “Paschal Mystery”.

SPOILER: The SSPX doesn’t like it.

I am finding the argumentation to be pretty fast and loose in this section, frankly. I think I will have to get a couple more copies and give them to priest/theologian friends so we can discuss them.

I turned back to this to see if anything of interest presented itself as I contemplate a response to Chupungco’s dreadful piece… on the this feast of St. Ansgar. Not that I would base a response on this SSPX book, mind you. But I figured it could be helpful in understanding what thinking C. thinks he is responding to. If that makes sense.

Still hacking away at the SSPX book

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
76 Comments

Thank you for your kind attention in this matter of … great… ehem….

Thanks to all of you who have signed up on the Google Thingy on the side bar.  I am still not sure what it does, other than let you know more quickly what is going on around here and who else is reading.  It’s a mystery.

Also, thanks to those of you who voted for WDTPRS in the Blogger’s Choice Awards.  Let’s keep our Catholic blogs in the public eye!  Vote!

UPDATE:

I fixed that link.

And looking at the standings, I will reiterate that we want Catholic blogs to show well in this category!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , ,
6 Comments

Boston: diocesan effort to promote confessions

The use of the sacrament of penance, reconciliation has been horribly eroded over the last few decades.

Ven. Pius XII said once that the sin of the 20th century was the loss of the sense of sin.

Surely that pertains now even more.

Here is a nice story from CNA:

Boston, Mass., Feb 3, 2010 / 03:01 am (CNA).- Seeking to promote the Sacrament of Reconciliation, the Archdiocese of Boston has launched a new website about how to make a good confession. Its priests will also offer confessions in every chapel and church on Wednesdays during Lent. The website, www.TheLightIsOnForYou.org, describes how to prepare for confession with an examination of conscience. It also provides an act of contrition to recite before absolution.

Auxiliary Bishop of Boston Robert F. Hennessey recorded a video message on the website. In the video, he quotes Jesus as saying that Heaven rejoices more for one repentant sinner than for 99 that never needed to repent.

“Every time that someone returns to the Sacrament of Confession, Heaven celebrates. And that unbelievable experience of joy becomes ours when we are forgiven.”

 

Read the rest over there.

WDTPRS says kudos!

Does your diocese have a special effort to promote the sacrament of penance during Lent?

Does your parish?

Do you?

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Our Catholic Identity | Tagged , , ,
34 Comments

Candlemass review

As we draw to a close of this Candlemass, did you have anything special at your parish or chapel?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
42 Comments

What is your good news?

Any good news to report?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
74 Comments

A Roman in Rome for the Roman Rite

I ask for good news from you from time to time.  Here is some for you.

This is just great!

I had a spiffy e-mail the other day from a friend of many years in Rome.  He and his family have been attending the FSSP staffed "personal parish" in Rome for the use of all the pre-Conciliar rites for Mass and sacraments.

 

Today Francesco served as "ceroferario" at the 10:30AM Solemn Mass at SS. Trinità. His expression was at times so serious you’d have thought he was the celebrant!

I am a sentimental guy, but it’s hard to tell what it is for a father to see his boy serve at a TLM after all we’ve been through. I go back to 20 years ago and it seems as though I am dreaming. But I am not. God is good.

All the more because I didn’t push him at all. He asked me to join the guys and learn. Faking hesitation, I "granted" him permission on condition he would still play rugby and have all homework done within Saturday evening.

Do remember my kids in your prayers. They’re growing up in a very hostile world and these precious opportunities the Lord is providing must not go wasted.

 

I think many of you can resonate with this great news, in the midst of all our troubles in this troubled world.

But wait!  There’s more!

On the site of my friend and fellow Minnesotan John Sonnen of Orbis Catholicus we have a photo of the new "ceroferario"!

A Roman Rite Roman in Rome.

A Roman in Rome for the Roman Rite

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments

Benedict XVI’s talk with the bishops of England and Wales

Bishop of England and WalesFirst… read this:

In a social milieu that encourages the expression of a variety of opinions on every question that arises, it is important to recognize dissent for what it is, and not to mistake it for a mature contribution to a balanced and wide-ranging debate. It is the truth revealed through Scripture and Tradition and articulated by the Church’s Magisterium that sets us free.

On 1 Feb, today, Pope Benedict had a little chat with bishops of England and Wales, in Rome for their ad limina.

My emphases and comments. 

[…]

Your country is well known for its firm commitment to equality of opportunity for all members of society. Yet as you have rightly pointed out, the effect of some of the legislation designed to achieve this goal has been to impose unjust limitations on the freedom of religious communities to act in accordance with their beliefs. In some respects it actually violates the natural law upon which the equality of all human beings is grounded and by which it is guaranteed. [Here goes…] I urge you as Pastors to ensure that the Church’s moral teaching be always presented in its entirety and convincingly defended. Fidelity to the Gospel in no way restricts the freedom of others – on the contrary, it serves their freedom by offering them the truth. Continue to insist upon your right to participate in national debate through respectful dialogue with other elements in society. In doing so, you are not only maintaining long-standing British traditions of freedom of expression and honest exchange of opinion, but you are actually giving voice to the convictions of many people who lack the means to express them: when so many of the population claim to be Christian, how could anyone dispute the Gospel’s right to be heard?  [Note the connection between the clear teaching of faith and the need to have an impact in the public square?  The connecting term is our Catholic identity.  If we don’t have a strong identity, we have nothing of interest to offer in the public square.  This is what I have been hammering at for years regarding Pope Benedict’s plan,"Marshall Plan", for the Church.  He is trying to rebuild, revitalize our devastated Catholic identity.]

If the full saving message of Christ is to be presented effectively and convincingly to the world, the Catholic community in your country needs to speak with a united voice. This requires not only you, the Bishops, but also priests, teachers, catechists, writers – in short all who are engaged in the task of communicating the Gospel – to be attentive to the promptings of the Spirit, who guides the whole Church into the truth, gathers her into unity and inspires her with missionary zeal. [The only way to speak with a united voice is for everyone to be faithful to the Church’s cult, code and creed.]

Make it your concern, then, to draw on the considerable gifts of the lay faithful in England and Wales and see that they are equipped to hand on the faith to new generations comprehensively, accurately, and with a keen awareness that in so doing they are playing their part in the Church’s mission. [In other words, teach and be sure that catechesis and preaching are sound.] In a social milieu that encourages the expression of a variety of opinions on every question that arises, [Here is comes…] it is important to recognize dissent for what it is, and not to mistake it for a mature contribution to a balanced and wide-ranging debate. [SKADOOSH!] It is the truth revealed through Scripture and Tradition [!] and articulated by the Church’s Magisterium [!] that sets us free. Cardinal Newman realized this, and he left us an outstanding example of faithfulness to revealed truth by following that "kindly light" wherever it led him, even at considerable personal cost. Great writers and communicators of his stature and integrity are needed in the Church today, and it is my hope that devotion to him will inspire many to follow in his footsteps.

Much attention has rightly been given to Newman’s scholarship and to his extensive writings, but it is important to remember that he saw himself first and foremost as a priest. In this Annus Sacerdotalis, I urge you to hold up to your priests his example of dedication to prayer, pastoral sensitivity towards the needs of his flock, and passion for preaching the Gospel. You yourselves should set a similar example. Be close to your priests, and rekindle their sense of the enormous privilege and joy of standing among the people of God as alter Christus. In Newman’s words, "Christ’s priests have no priesthood but His … what they do, He does; when they baptize, He is baptizing; when they bless, He is blessing" (Parochial and Plain Sermons, VI 242). Indeed, since the priest plays an irreplaceable role in the life of the Church, spare no effort in encouraging priestly vocations and emphasizing to the faithful the true meaning and necessity of the priesthood. Encourage the lay faithful to express their appreciation of the priests who serve them, and to recognize the difficulties they sometimes face on account of their declining numbers and increasing pressures. The support and understanding of the faithful is particularly necessary when parishes have to be merged or Mass times adjusted. Help them to avoid any temptation to view the clergy as mere functionaries but rather to rejoice in the gift of priestly ministry, a gift that can never be taken for granted.

Ecumenical and inter-religious dialogue assume great importance in England and Wales, given the varied demographic profile of the population. As well as encouraging you in your important work in these areas, I would ask you to be generous in implementing the provisions of the Apostolic Constitution Anglicanorum Coetibus, so as to assist those groups of Anglicans who wish to enter into full communion with the Catholic Church. [And they are traditional Anglicans.] I am convinced that, if given a warm and open-hearted welcome, such groups will be a blessing for the entire Church.

[…]

Play video

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, The Drill | Tagged , ,
28 Comments

Remember Doug Kmiec? Stiring the anthill in Malta.

Remember Doug Kmiec?  He wasn’t very well accepted in Malta.  He was nearly sycophantic in his support of Pres. Obama during the campaign and after, probably because he wanted to be the ambassador to the Holy See instead of just to Malta.

He was the one who said Catholics could set the problem of a candidate’s aggressive support of abortion aside and vote for him anyway. 

Kmiec Catholics, and others who embrace the corrosive Kmiec Compromise hold that if the candidate’s stand on other social justice issues are acceptable, then his stand on those issues outweighs his unacceptable stand on abortion.  It’s a slight of hand, really: the unacceptable position becomes acceptable.

Malta Today has something with my emphases and comments.

Doug KmiecThe curious ambassador

US ambassador and legal scholar Douglas Kmiec is curious about Malta’s constitutional neutrality. But has he overstepped his remit as an ambassador in a sovereign nation in seeking a clear interpretation?   [Curious indeed!]

James Debono

If you happen to be in church and a very polite, middle-aged American guy starts chatting with you, it very well could be the US ambassador trying to get some insights into the Maltese way of life.

I interview Douglas Kmiec against a background of folk music, which he describes as “a veritable depositary of America’s historical memory” in the tranquillity of his Attard residence, seeking to unravel the intentions of the representative of the world’s remaining superpower.
As a devout Catholic, his first knowledge of Malta was the reference to the hospitality of the Maltese towards St Paul, immortalised in the Acts of the Apostles. His appointment as ambassador came as a result of his role in Barack Obama’s campaign, as the President’s “liaison to the Catholic community” – in the midst of the campaign Kmiec even wrote a book, entitled ‘Can A Catholic Support Him?’, explaining his support, as a Catholic, for Senator Obama in spite of his pro-choice stance on abortion.  [Who called him the "liaison"?  Did Kmiec call himself that for the reporter?]
Reminiscing on his discussions at the White House prior to his appointment, he recalls the President telling him how he would “enjoy a country with 365 churches”. [Why?  I understand that the President doesn’t go to church very often on Sundays much less at other times.] Now he has committed himself to visit as many of these churches as he possibly can. “I am making an effort to get to mass in the mornings if the schedule permits… churches are a place to experience the people, culture and the different cities which make Malta.”
But churches have not been the only thing on Kmiec’s mind in the few months since his arrival to Malta. Kmiec, whose legal background includes serving in the US Attorney General’s office, is particularly proficient in constitutional matters, and has lately been seeking a clear definition of Malta’s neutrality.
I bluntly ask the ambassador whether he is going out of his remit by provoking a discussion on Malta’s constitutional neutrality. “I do not think so. Sincerely, I wanted to get the best understanding of neutrality.”
As my ear catches a hook off a Bruce Springsteen song in the background (Kmiec actually shuffled through his iPod to find something that I liked…) I present Kmiec with the hypothetical scenario of the Maltese ambassador in the US, disputing on controversial parts of the US constitutional right to bear arms. Would this not offend Americans, known for their quasi-religious devotion to their Constitution?
Kmiec makes it clear that his intention was not to interfere in Maltese constitutional matters. “Neutrality surely touches on the work of an ambassador in so far as it has an effect on diplomatic and external relations. But it is obviously not up to the American ambassador (or any ambassador, Amercian or otherwise), to tell you what your Constitution means or should mean.”
What prompted him to ask for a clear definition of Malta’s neutrality during the Mediterranean Academy of Diplomatic Studies conference was the “very expansive meaning” given to neutrality by some people. “Some people gave it a very expansive meaning and that troubled me a bit.Some interpretations of neutrality would have excluded the military training that has been going on for years very successfully between the United States and the Armed Forces of Malta, training that assists the search and rescue efforts which is so vital in saving migrant families from the sea as well as efforts to stop trafficking of human beings and drugs.”
Kmiec caused a stir in political circles by suggesting that Malta’s neutrality could be abused by terrorists when he warned that “we must not allow an interpretation of the scope of a constitutional neutrality provision to be taken advantage of by those who might wish to use a Maltese port to unleash a future terror plot, whether in London, Madrid, on a flight bound for Detroit, or for that matter, may the good Lord forbid, Valletta”.
Kmiec is now convinced that this is not the case. “I am pleased that the discussion has illustrated that this is not the case.”
Once again, he blames expansive definitions of neutrality for giving such an impression. He claims that such a definition of neutrality could have even excluded training aimed at strengthening Malta’s ability to stop terrorists from bringing lethal material into the island. “That was my concern. That was the connection. I didn’t think that neutrality meant that, but I wanted somebody to confirm my understanding… I think that the last thing that any country would want would be to have their door left open to people who would unleash this type of tragic harm.”

[…]

 

You can read the rest there if you are really interested in what he has to say.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
21 Comments

TAC Archbp. Hepworth on Anglicanorum coetibus

In the Church Times (Issue 7663 – 29 January, 2010), an Anglican publication which is not connected with the Anglican hierarchy we find this.

My emphases and comments:

Archbishop Hepworth: took up ARCIC and “got what we wanted”

GRAHAM HOWARD

A MEETING of bishops who have petitioned the Pope to be received into full communion while retaining an “Anglican” identity is to take place in Rome in Low Week.

It would be the culmination of the response to Benedict XVI’s Apostolic Constitution (Anglicanorum Coeti­bus) to establish personal Ordinariates for former Anglicans, Archbishop John Hepworth of the Traditional Angli­can Communion (TAC), a Con­tinuing Church, said on Wednesday.

He was due in Rome in three weeks’ time for a meeting with the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF) after a series of regional TAC synods, and would then, two weeks after Easter, meet most of the bishops who had peti­tioned the Pope to make their formal response on the Ordinariates.

“The ball is in our court. We asked for this and this is what we got. This is becoming Anglican Catholics, not Roman Catholics,” Archbishop Hep­worth said, speaking from Australia.  [Anglican Catholics, not Roman Catholics.]

The letters from the Vatican replying to all those who had res­ponded to the Pope’s offer had now been received. He had followed that with a pastoral letter to TAC members last week.

“After an introduction about church unity, we talk about our original meeting with the CDF. They gave us advice and we followed it. A team of Roman Catholic bishops and scholars were helping us to reflect on unity. They provided a critique of the TAC, and we quote some of that back to them. The TAC wants to achieve communion while ‘main­taining those revered traditions of spirituality, liturgy, discipline and theo­logy that constitute the cherished and centuries-old heritage of Angli­can communities throughout the world’.

“So our way of doing theology is there, as is our way of discipline. Our group will have the right to elect our bishops. We asked the CDF for elec­tion by council. They laughed at us at first, but we got it. [!] We are also working with a commission with Forward in Faith to produce our lit­urgy. [They will have to make some adaptations.] We signed the Catechism as ‘the most complete and authentic expres­sion and application of the Catholic faith in this moment of time’.

“We did that to put our commit­ment beyond dispute, but we did not have to agree to Apostolicae Curae [which declares Anglican orders ab­solutely null and utterly void], be­cause that is not in the Cate­chism.”  [!]

A consultation was taking place on “reordination in the TAC con­text”. “We separated from the Angli­can Church. Some left because of sacramental and doctrinal issues, and have got lost. We chose to take up ARCIC [the Anglican-Roman Catholic International Commis­sion], and we have got what we wanted. People who said we could not are having to eat humble pie, and I am sinfully enjoying that.”

The Archbishop said that he was issuing TAC’s original 2007 petition to the CDF at the same time as his pastoral letter.

In his letter, he writes: “Re-ordination is an issue because the Church requires absolute certainty in the matter of future sacramental life. I have been told that the TAC should understand this because we ourselves moved beyond the Angli-­can Communion in order to ensure the validity of sacramental life. Rome is now seeking the same assurance.”  [Reasonable.  Entirely]

The Apostolic Constitution “speaks of Anglicans entering into full communion with the Catholic Church. There at the outset are the three critical factors: Anglicans, full com­munion and Catholic Church.”

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , , ,
44 Comments

Benedict XVI to the Church’s jurists and tribunals: “shun pseudo-pastoral claims”

Benedict XVI and judges of tribunalsFrom CNS about the Holy Father’s address to the jurists of his tribunals.

The Italian text of the Holy Father’s address is here.

Desire for sacraments not sufficient reason for annulment, pope says

By Cindy Wooden
Catholic News Service

VATICAN CITY (CNS) — True pastoral charity and concern can never lead the church to grant an annulment to a Catholic whose marriage is valid according to church law, Pope Benedict XVI said.

"One must shun pseudo-pastoral claims" that look only at the desire of divorced Catholics to return to the sacraments, the pope said Jan. 29 in his annual speech to officials of the Roman Rota, a tribunal that mainly deals with appeals filed in marriage annulment cases.  ["Occorre rifuggire da richiami pseudopastorali che situano le questioni su un piano meramente orizzontale…"  Consider how many things that are wrong are done in the name of being "pastoral".  I am delighted that Pope Benedict uses this phrase: "pseudo-pastoral".  When only the "horizontal" is considered at the cost of the "vertical", the solution cannot be authentically pastoral.]

The pope said helping Catholics be able to go to confession and receive the Eucharist is important, but it cannot be done without taking into account the truth about their church marriage.

The church cannot act charitably toward its faithful without upholding justice and truth, he said.

Charity without justice is "only a forgery because charity requires that objectivity that is typical of justice and which must not be confused with inhumane coldness," the pope said.

For the Catholic Church, he said, a marriage celebrated with the full consent of the couple and following the correct form is always presumed to be valid, and a valid marriage is indissoluble.  [Pretty clear, right?  Apparently not in all tribunals, especially in the USA.]

Pastors and those who work in church tribunals must beware of "the widespread and deeply rooted tendency" to see justice and charity as totally competing values, the pope said.

Within the church, he said, the idea leads some to think that "pastoral charity could justify any step" taken to grant an annulment for a couple who wants to return to the sacraments.

Defending the permanent bond of a valid marriage is a matter of both justice and love, he said, because it is designed to protect the human and spiritual good of the couple and "the public good of the church," which teaches that marriage is forever [No, marriage is not forever.  It is just until the death of one of the spouses.] and does not use annulments as a sort of church-sanctioned divorce.

"It would be a fictitious good, and a serious lack of justice, to nevertheless smooth the way toward their reception of the sacraments," the pope said

Pope Benedict told members of the Roman Rota that those who work on church marriage tribunals must cultivate the virtues of prudence and justice, but especially the virtue of fortitude, especially "when the unjust way appears easier to follow because it means condescending to the desires and hopes of the couple."

"Both justice and charity require love for the truth and essentially lead to a search for the truth," he said.

Posted in The Drill | Tagged , , ,
65 Comments