A seminarian reports: A Gaudete parish nightmare

From a seminarian (edited):

Fr. Z,

Please feel free to delete this & move on. I’m sure you receive many similar missives. For me …catharsis ..or I explode!
 
I went to Mass for Gaudete Sunday at my local parish. I arrived 20 minutes early. The lady sacristan greeted me cheerfully as she scuffed by in her characteristic flip flops..
 
Our presider (Parish adm; not Pastor) processed in wearing his tailored alb and his usual large blue & white stole. He said, "now let us begin our Liturgy in the Name of the father…….,"  he then asked us, "to greet those around us by telling each other how far along we are in our Christmas preparations."
 
When the din had died down he then said, "this is Gaudete Sunday which comes from the latin Gaudeamus which means Let’s Party. That’s when the monks and priests break out the beer, the Benedictine and the Chartreuse. That’s where we get the good stuff, ya’ know, from the big orders."
 
He then went on with Mass. He began his homily with a story: For Christmas a little girl received a watch and perfume.
She was quite excited and her mother told her not to bother the priest at dinner with her gifts. Irrepressibly she nudged the priest & said, father if you hear or smell anything…it’s me.
 
At the Our father he summoned his servers up to the Altar to hold hands with him.***
 
His ushers are trained to continue shaking hands with us while we sing the Lamb of God & indeed to Communion.
 
His new wrinkle is at he Per Ipsum. He now says, "As we all pray together, Through him…….etc."
 
Of course, the wine is consecrated in a flagon & the poured into the chalices by a lay person.
 
At the final blessing, it’s the usual, may Almighty Goe bless each and every one of us, "In the name….."
 
Sometimes we plumb the depths of our musical treasury all the way back to the 1980s.
 
*** The holding hands at the Our father is a thing with him. When he 1st came to our parish, a year ago, he said he was shocked that we didn’t hold hands. One of the fellows said that the cardinal had put the kibosh on that, to which he replied, "that order came from Rome!" In point of fact, I had dinner with the cardinal and one of his classmates and hand holding came up. Mahony opined it started with marriage encounter & went back to the parishes that way. He doesn’t like it.
 
Fr. Z., if you got this far thanks for listening.

PS. We’ve had a series of unbelievable lectures from the seminary staff if. If you’re interested, let me know.

I am afraid to ask.

Do we need more reasons to implement Summorum Pontificum rapidly and everywhere?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
88 Comments

Question to WDTPRSers with Sling Box

Are there any readers out there who have a Sling Box set up and wouldn’t mind giving me some limited access?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments

QUAERITUR: Not genuflecting during Novus Ordo Mass when crossing tabernacle

From a reader:

Could you comment on part of GIRM #274, specifically:
 
"If, however, the tabernacle with the Most Blessed Sacrament is present in the sanctuary, the priest, the deacon, and the other ministers genuflect when they approach the altar and when they deaprt from it, but not during the celebration of Mass itself."
 
I know that this is a change in the 2002 GIRM, and I really have a hard time with it.  I don’t mean to be scrupulous, but I always feel conflicted about it when serving.  If I don’t genuflect (as is what used to be done, even in the previous Novus Ordo GIRM), I feel as though I am being irreverent.  Christ is present in the tabernacle whether Mass is going on or not.  However, if I do genuflect, then I feel as though I am being disobedient.
 
What should be my attitude in approaching this directive?

There is a real tension here.

First, this idea that we don’t genuflect to the Blessed Sacrament when passing before it in the sanctuary during Mass stemmed from a desire to emphasize the sacred action going on at the moment.  As a result all sorts of changes were proposed, for example, only distributing Hosts consecrated at that Mass rather than any reserved from another Mass.

While I don’t have any problem with the idea that we should stress the sacred action hic et nunc, which is an important dimension of true active participation in a fuller sense, there are some practical considerations.

You know… sometimes these high falutin’ ideas don’t take into consideration what is a matter of common sense. 

The fact is that we do see the tabernacle there and we know that the Blessed Sacrament is in there and we actually believe that this is God present in our midst.

Ignoring any of these things, from some goal of stressing the here and now seems to me problematic.  What occurs to the one who watches people troop back and forth across the sanctuary and ignored the Blessed Sacrament is… well…. perhaps just shy of scandal.  I suspect that it would undermine the respect people have for the Eucharist if they constantly seen their Eucharistic Ministers and servers, et al., ignoring the Lord.

Funny thing: Liberals always ask you to ignore the evidence of your senses.

Anyway… while this is one of those rubrics I think could be happy broken without much fuss, it is nevertheless important that we who desire that the liturgy always and everywhere be celebrated according to the rules should ouselves obey them.

QUAERITUR: Not genuflecting during Novus Ordo Mass when crossing tabernacleThe texts of the translations are dreadful.  That doesn’t mean we should just change them according to our own lights.  I am right about what I write on the prayers in WDTPRS and the lame-duck ICEL texts are jsut wrong.  But I don’t therefore change the texts.  The same goes for rubrics.  The genuflection thing is in the Novus Ordo now.  So be it.   I admit that I forget from time to time, since I don’t say the Novus Ordo all that often these days and the genuflections are by now hard wired into me.

You know…. I know about all the fancy ideas about emphasizing the immediate sacred action blah blah blah but it is just wrong not to genuflect, isn’t it?

I think people are smart enough to handle the idea that we can reverence the Blessed Sacrament in a tabernacle by genuflecting and not lose track of the fact that they are at Mass and there will be a consecration.

After all, people have for centuries been able to see that during the distribution of Holy Communion Jesus is all over the place in the church. 

And yet their heads don’t, in fact, explode.

 

So, friend, I have a hard time with that rubric also.  I understand the idea behind it, but I think there are other important dimensions the egg-headed desk liturgists didn’t consider when they implemented their pet theories in the revised rubrics.

What should your attitude be?   At least strive for resigned obedience and the patience to be consistent with the others who are serving there.

QUAERITUR: Not genuflecting during Novus Ordo Mass when crossing tabernacleAlso, you might pray for a greater return of the older form of Holy Mass where these sllly things do not vex us so.

BTW… I think every faithful and reverent genuflection and act of faith helps to Save The World and everytime people ignore the Lord or are irreverent weakens us all. 

Remember: Pope Benedict hopes that there will be a positive influence of the one use on the other.  We might start by geting rid of these sorts of things so that the newer Mass will be in greater continuity with our tradition… in which we genuflect as we pass before the Blessed Sacrament wherever and whenever because we believe It is God, Our Lord Jesus Christ, sacramentally and truly with us.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
53 Comments

A Gaudete question revisited: “Real priests wear ‘rosacea'”!

Today priests can wear "rose" vestments.  Everyone knows this.

But I do get questions about what shade of "rose" this is.  What does "rose" mean?

A Gaudete question revisited: "Real priests wear 'rosacea'"!Today I said Mass with rose vestments and to use true rosacea.

I am in good company in not wanting to wear pink, or confuse it with liturgical rose, or rosacea in Latin.

"But Father! But Father!", some of you are even now wildly typing.  "Surely you don’t wear pink, do you?"

Nope, dear readers.  Fr. Z does not wear pink vestments, unless he must sacrifice for the greater good. 

I am comfortable with myself, after all.

Sure, for the sake of distinguishing Gaudete from other Advent Sundays, I have consented to putting on a pinkish vestment when I didn’t have a good clear choice.

The good outweighs the bad, in those cases.

However, liturgical rose really is a color.  And real priests always choose rosacea for Gaudete and Laetare.

"But Father! But Father!", some of you saying with furrowed brows.  "If rose isn’t pink, then what is it?"

Here are a couple examples of what this color is.  Keep in mind that on my monitor they look just right.  On your monitor, they might not be the same.  That said,…

Here is a vestment I shot in Rome in the sacristy of Gesu e Maria on the Via del Corso.  It is too spectacular for words.  Click on it to get a close up so you can see the color better.

A Gaudete question revisited: "Real priests wear 'rosacea'"!

However, the chapel of The Sabine Farm has (that is I have) a very nice, and very old set of rosacea vestments I brought back from Rome.  They were given to me by a ultra-modernist who was getting rid of old stuff.  

Here they are.

A Gaudete question revisited: "Real priests wear 'rosacea'"!

And closer.  You can see the little Roman style pom pom on the corner of the burse.

A Gaudete question revisited: "Real priests wear 'rosacea'"!

Notice that rosacea, in both the versions I show here, are a little more on the orange side of pink, closer to the pink that is like salmon.

And now you will have a more discerning Catholic eye when Gaudete and Laetare roll around.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
34 Comments

A response from the rector of Mount Angel Seminary about TLM training

I received the following, which in justice I am happy to post.  It is a response to my entry about TLM training for seminarians at Mount Angel Seminary in Oregon. 

My emphases.

Dear Fr. Zuhlsdorf,

I would very much appreciate your printing the following response to the "report" sent into your blog from a Mount Angel seminarian.

"Fr. Z" and blog readers of the "report" regarding Mount Angel Seminary: The content of the recent blog message was imprecise and misleading on several counts.  Mount Angel Seminary will offer for the seminarians Mass according to the extra-ordinary form when it can be done properly and prayerfully and when the students are prepared by a preceding conference.  Recently those seminarians who wished were able to attend the extraordinary form of the Roman rite in a parish nearby, so they are not deprived of the opportunity.

Fr. Paschal Cheline, OSB
Interim President-Rector
Mount Angel Seminary
St. Benedict, OR  97373 USA

Remember: Summorum Pontificum is part of our landscape now.  It cannot be avoided.  It must not be avoided, especially in the training of seminarians.

I look forward to the day when all Latin Rite seminaries train their students in both uses of the Roman Rite as a matter of course.

In any event, while it sounds like use of and training in the Extraordinary Use is not formally banned, it doesn’t sound like very much is being done there.

It seems to me that sound training for seminarians today, to present them as competent candidates for ordination, should include training in how to celebrate their proper Rite, depending on which Church they belong to.  Priests of the Latin Rite should know how to celebrate the Latin Rite.

Is that too much to ask?

I’m just askin’

In any event, I am grateful to Fr. Cheline for the note.

Posted in I'm just askin'..., Mail from priests, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
22 Comments

Question to readers who know WordPress

It seems that when I change the wordpress theme, I lose my stats being counted through sitemeter etc.

hmmm… any ideas?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

D. of Metuchen – TLM report

From a reader:

I saw the piece on the Dio. of Alt-J and TLM on your blog and it had me wondering if folks knew that in the Diocese of Metuchen, NJ we have a shrine chapel where TLM has gone from once a month to every day! The former St. Bernard parish church in Raritan, NJ was no longer used because the parish moved to a bigger piece of property and a larger church. The diocese turned the church into the Shrine Chapel of the Most Blessed Sacrament for daily all-day adoration and Confessions. It has served in the capacity for over a decade now.

Every day mass is celebrated in the morning in the Novus Ordo (in English and Latin ad orientem) and then the Blessed Sacrament is exposed. There are Confessions heard every day. Each evening there is Benediction of the Blessed Sacrament at 6:45, pm followed by TLM at 7:00, pm. On Sundays TLM is celebrated at 11:00, am and there is Benediction in the afternoon. The bishop has also given his permission for those who request it to have other Sacraments (like Baptism) celebrated at the Shrine in the extraordinary form and to have funerals there if they desire to have a funeral in the extraordinary form. It is not a parish church but it is a sort of "quasi-parish".

Brick by brick!

Posted in Brick by Brick |
9 Comments

A nice Christmas note from an old priest

From a reader:

From a beloved priest, almost 90 years old, almost blind, who has served missions in rural Kentucky and Arkansas all his life.  He is only semi-retired and will on occasion happily celebrate the 1962 Mass when needed.  An amateur apiarist, he lives alone in a bee-loud glade in the Ozarks:
 
CHRISTMAS ‘08

To those Who Love Christmas:

     During the long election season we heard much about change.  Actually, most of us don’t really like change.  We usually sit in the same chair, park in the same parking spot (if available), are upset when our schedules are interrupted, get into a daily routine, etc.  And often, change is for the worse, not the better.

     But we do welcome change when it is for the better – so we welcome it when a tooth stops hurting, a friend drops in, a rainy day is succeeded by a sunny one, etc.

     Most of us have set traditions for the Christmas season – the Christmas tree, the Christmas Carols, the Christmas dinner, to whom we give gifts.  We tend to keep Christmas much the same way each year.  Yet Christmas is all about change – change for the better.

     The Lord Jesus came to lift us from our despondency, to gladden our hearts, make clear the goal of life.  Jesus came to reveal God to us.  He is the face of God, as Pope Benedict says.  He came not only to show us why God created us, but also to lead us to the Eternal Home He made for us.  He puts an entirely new face on everything.  He shows us that God loves us and works constantly to draw us to Himself.  As Scripture says, “See, I make all things new.” (Rev. 21:5).  No wonder we sing, “Joy to the World” at Christmas time.  All our hopes, all our joys, all our peace rest in Jesus.  So we celebrate His birth with exceedingly great joy, for He was born to help us change from the old to the new:

             From Greed to Generosity,
             From Selfishness to Love for Others,
             From Thoughtlessness to Thoughtfulness,
             From Despair to Hope,
             From Inner Confusion to Peace,
             From Despondency to Joy,
             From Fear to Trust in God,
             From Ingratitude to Gratitude
             From being Earthbound to being full of Desire for Heaven

     We must–we absolutely must–celebrate Christmas.  In her Liturgy, Holy Church teaches us how to do this – How to prepare for it (Advent), How to celebrate it in the three Christmas Masses and in the Christmas Feasts of the Holy Innocents, the Holy Family, Mary Mother of God, the Epiphany, and the Baptism of the Lord.

     Whatever you may be suffering, whatever your disappointments, whatever the state of your health, whatever the state of your prayer life, let the peace, joy, and hope of Christmas fill you through and through.  If something has happened to alienate you from Jesus, use the season to make it right with Him.  He loves you and is waiting for you. 

May the Lord Jesus fill you with deep consolation.

           In the Lord Jesus, Fr. Venantius Preske, Horseshoe Bend, Arkansas

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

Playing with themes today

I am fiddling around with themes.

Don’t freak out.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
18 Comments

Brick by brick in D. of Altoona-Johnstown

From a reader:

I thought you might be interested to learn of the formal public status of the TLM in Patton, PA, in the Diocese of Altoona-Johnstown.  You might recall that Bishop Adamec was very opposed to the Motu Proprio around the time it was first issued.  Brick by brick.

 

Brick by brick in D. of Altoona-Johnstown 

Posted in Brick by Brick, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
17 Comments