Alaska and Summorum Pontificum

I know Alaska is very much in the public eye right now, but here is a different angle.

I received a notice by e-mail about photos from Summorum Pontificum Alaska:

With special thanks to Archbishop Roger L. Schwietz, OMI, the Dominican Friars of Holy Family Cathedral and Fr. Armand Nigro, S.J. who offered the Requiem Mass for Anita Kimberley Syren, r.i.p. August 7, 2008.

Entrance.
Alaska and Summorum Pontificum

Fr. Vincent Kelber, O.P., chants the epistle.

Alaska and Summorum Pontificum

Dies Irae.

Alaska and Summorum Pontificum

Sermon, Fr. Armand Nigro, S.J.

Alaska and Summorum Pontificum

Offertory
Alaska and Summorum Pontificum

Alaska and Summorum Pontificum

The occasion may be somber and sad, but it is always elevating to see black vestments.

Brick by… Ice block by ice block

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments

Speaker Pelosi’s bishop now speaks

UPDATE 15:49 GMT 5 Sept:

American Papist has a fascinating observation:

AmP reader Desiderius asks:

"Note the Abp’s message was printed simultaneously in The Tidings (Los Angeles), obviously [well, reasonably – AmP] a coordinated effort. Might one conclude this suffices as Cardinal Mahony’s response to Nancy Pelosi?"

This has been a public service announcement.

And now back to our regular post:
___________________

From His Excellency Most Reverend George H. Niederauer, Archbishop of San Francisco, the ordinary of the place where Speaker Nancy Pelosi has domicile.

My emphases and comments.

 

San Francisco Archbishop George H. Niederauer addresses recent comments made by House Speaker Nancy Pelosi

By Most Rev. George H. Niederauer

September 5, 2008

Following is a statement by San Francisco Archbishop George H. Niederauer in response to recent comments on abortion, Catholic teaching on the beginning of life, and other life issues made by U.S. House of Representatives Speaker Nancy Pelosi. This statement by Archbishop Niederauer was published in the Sept. 5, 2008 issue of Catholic San Francisco, the official newspaper of the Archdiocese of San Francisco.

Last month, in two televised interviews and a subsequent statement released through her office, Nancy Pelosi, [He names her. Not all bishops did.] Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives and a Catholic residing in the Archdiocese of San Francisco, [and Washington DC] made remarks that are in serious conflict with the teachings of the Catholic Church about abortion. [solid] It is my responsibility as Archbishop of San Francisco to teach clearly what Christ in his Church teaches about faith and morals, and to oppose erroneous, misleading and confusing positions when they are advanced.  [Good for him!]

In his statement about Speaker Pelosi’s remarks, Archbishop Donald Wuerl of Washington, D.C., [the other bishop involved] expressed the response of many bishops when he said, "We respect the right of elected officials such as Speaker Pelosi to address matters of public policy that are before them, but the interpretation of Catholic faith has rightfully been entrusted to the Catholic bishops." In addition to Archbishop Wuerl, several other bishops have already appropriately and helpfully pointed out the errors in the Speaker’s remarks. Nevertheless, it is my particular duty to address them as well. Let me acknowledge even as I do so that Speaker Pelosi is a gifted, dedicated and accomplished public servant, and that she has stated often her love for her faith and for the Catholic Church. The Speaker has been supportive of legislation that helped to implement some [some] of the social teachings of the Church. However, her recent remarks are opposed to Church teaching.

[Here comes the necessary boilerplate.  Still, repetita iuvant.] In The Catechism of the Catholic Church we find this statement: "Human life must be respected and protected absolutely from the moment of conception. Since the first century the Church has affirmed the moral evil of every procured abortion. This teaching has not changed and remains unchangeable. Direct abortion, that is to say, willed either as an end or a means, is grossly contrary to the moral law." ( 2270 – 71 ) The Catechism then quotes the Didache ( also referred to as The Teachings of the Twelve Apostles ) , the oldest extant manual of church order, dating from the late first or early second century: "You shall not kill the embryo by abortion and shall not cause the newborn to perish." In 2004 the bishops of the United States, in their statement, "Catholics in Political Life," said: "It is the teaching of the Catholic Church from the very beginning that the killing of an unborn child is always intrinsically evil and can never be justified. This is the constant and received teaching of the Church. It is, as well, the conviction of many other people of good will."

On the television program "Meet the Press," [therefore, scandal on a grand scale] on Sunday, August 24, 2008, Speaker Pelosi spoke of herself and the bishops of her Church in these words: "So there’s some areas where we’re in agreement and some areas where we’re not, and one being a woman’s right to choose, and the other being stem cell research." In April of this year, in a teleconference with Catholic News Service and other media she made a similar remark: "I have a sort of serenity about the issue. I come from a family who doesn’t share my position on pro – choice. The Church sees it another way, and I respect that."

The bishops at the Second Vatican Council declared that, as Catholics, we believe what the Church authoritatively teaches on matters of faith and morals, for to hear the voice of the Church on those matters is to hear the voice of Christ himself. ( Lumen Gentium, No. 25; Mysterium Ecclesiae, No. 2 ) [Let’s mention GS 51] Catholics believe that the Holy Spirit guides the Church and protects it from error. We believe that the Roman Pontiff, Pope Benedict XVI, is the successor of Peter, the Rock on whom Jesus Christ has built his Church, and is not just another man who is entitled to his opinions on faith. We believe that we are called to trust the Spirit to guide the Church, so we do not pick and choose among her teachings. Mr. Tom Brokaw, the moderator of "Meet the Press," asked Speaker Pelosi, "When does life begin?" She responded: "We don’t know. The point is that it shouldn’t have an impact on the woman’s right to choose." Later: "I don’t think anyone can tell you when life begins, when human life begins." Mr. Brokaw: "The Catholic Church at the moment feels very strongly that it begins at the point of conception." Speaker Pelosi: "I understand. And this is maybe fifty years or something like that."

Speaker Pelosi’s remarks called forth many responses, from Catholics in the pews as well as from bishops. [Not just from the pews, Your Excellency.] As a result, on Tuesday, August 26th, two days after "Meet the Press" had aired, the Speaker’s office issued a statement on her behalf. It contained this sentence: "While Catholic teaching is clear that life begins at conception, many Catholics do not ascribe[sic] to that view." That statement suggests that morality can be decided by poll, by numbers. If ninety percent of Catholics subscribe to the view that human life begins at conception, does that makes Church teaching truer than if only seventy percent or fifty percent agree?

Authentic moral teaching is based on objective truth, not polling. [Well said.] For instance, in 1861, as the Civil War began, a majority of the residents of Massachusetts opposed slavery, a majority of the residents of South Carolina approved of slavery, and in Missouri people were sharply divided on the issue. Does that mean that, in 1861, slavery was immoral in Massachusetts, moral in South Carolina, and something of a moral "wash" in Missouri? Sound moral teaching demands much more good sense than that.  [Good!  Good arguement.  This could be useful in light of the same-sex marriage controversy as well.]

Since August 24th many Catholics have written me letters and sent me e – mails in which they expressed their dismay and concern about the Speaker’s remarks. Very often they moved on to a question that caused much discussion during the 2004 campaign: Is it necessary to deny Holy Communion to some Catholics in public life because of their public support for abortion on demand? [Yes.  This is the unavoidable question.]  I want to address that question in the light of the 2004 statement of the U.S. bishops, [Uh oh…]  "Catholics in Political Life," and their 2006 statement on preparing to receive Christ worthily in the Eucharist, "Happy Are Those Who Are Called to His Supper." Both statements can be found on the bishops’ website, usccb.org, and they lead the reader to conclude that this is a sensitive and complicated question, [even, perhaps, "nuanced"?] and does not lend itself to sound bites, headlines or slogans.

In their 2006 document, "Happy Are Those Who Are Called to His Supper," the bishops begin by reminding Catholics that "the celebration of the Mass is the center of the life of the Church." The Eucharist joins each of us to the one sacrifice of Jesus Christ on the Cross, unites us with the Risen Christ, and unites us with one another in Christ. Each reception of Holy Communion looks forward to our union with Christ forever in heaven. [okay…]

The very first generation of Christians saw the need to examine one’s conscience regarding one’s worthiness to receive the Body and Blood of the Lord. Writing around 57 A.D., St. Paul told the Corinthians, "Whoever eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord unworthily will have to answer for the body and blood of the Lord. A person should examine himself, and so eat the bread and drink the cup." ( 1Cor. 11;27 – 28 ) Of course we are never fully worthy to eat the bread and drink the cup, as we exclaim at each Mass before we receive Holy Communion: "Lord, I am not worthy to receive you, but only say the word and I shall be healed." However, the unity nourished and expressed in Holy Communion can be broken by serious sin, hence our self – examination enables us to acknowledge whether we have committed such a sin, and to seek out the Sacrament of Reconciliation before eating the bread and drinking the cup.  [okay….]

The practice of the Church is to accept this conscientious self – appraisal of each person ["conscientious self"?] ( Canon 912 ). Thus, in this matter the state of the person’s awareness of his or her situation is of fundamental importance. [But… in the situation of very public figures, at the focus point of this controversy, we know that adequate instruction has been applied…. right? ] As the bishops say most forcefully in the 2006 document, " we should be cautious when making judgments about whether or not someone else should receive Holy Communion."

Nevertheless, the bishops go on to say: "If a Catholic in his or her personal or professional life were knowingly and obstinately to reject the defined doctrines of the Church, or knowingly and obstinately repudiate her definitive teachings on moral issues, however, he or she would seriously diminish his or her communion with the Church. Reception of Holy Communion in such a situation would not accord with the nature of the Eucharistic celebration, so that he or she should refrain." Why is this repudiation of Church teaching such a serious matter? The bishops respond: "To give selective assent to the teachings of the Church deprives us of her life – giving message, but also seriously endangers our communion with her."

This teaching of the bishops does not violate the separation of church and state. [Good.] That separation does not require a division between faith and public action, between moral principles and political choices. Believers and religious groups may practice their faith and act on their values in public life, and have done so throughout the history of this country. In his or her conscience, properly formed, a Catholic should recognize that making legal an evil action, such as abortion, is itself wrong.  [Ergo…. ?]

What of Catholics who find themselves questioning the teachings of the Church, or experiencing uncertainties and questions about them?  [Your Excellency.. what of those who know them and explicitly deny them on world-wide television?] The bishops answer, "Some Catholics may not fully understand the Church’s doctrinal and moral teachings on certain issues.  [Who "fully understands" mysterious things?  What we can understand fully enough are the clear teachings of the Church, repeated in many ways in many ages, especially the present.]They may have certain questions and even uncertainties. In situations of honest [honest] doubt and confusion, they are welcome to partake of Holy Communion, as long as they are striving to understand what the Church professes and to resolve confusion and doubt."  [How many times do people need to be instructed or informed before we say, "Okay, you are either invincibly ignorant or simply dissenting."]

Cardinal William Levada, Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, and my predecessor as Archbishop here in San Francisco, wrote in 2004: [Here it comes.  One wonders about the … no… let that pass…] "No bishop is eager to forbid members of his flock from receiving the precious Body and Blood of Jesus Christ, who invites us into communion with Himself and his Body, the Church, as grace and salvation." In that same year, the U.S. bishops acknowledged that pastoral sensitivity, and they endorsed the following approach to this question of denying Holy Communion: "Given the wide range of circumstances involved in arriving at a prudential judgment on a matter of this seriousness, we recognize that such decisions rest with the individual bishop in accord with the established canonical and pastoral principles. Bishops can legitimately make different judgments on the most prudent course of pastoral action. Nevertheless, we all share an unequivocal commitment to protect human life and dignity and to preach the Gospel in difficult times." From that statement I conclude that it is my responsibility as Archbishop to discern and decide, prayerfully, how best to approach this question as it may arise in the Archdiocese of San Francisco.  [With respect… you didn’t need that to know what your responsibility is.]

I regret the necessity of addressing these issues in so public a forum, but the widespread consternation among Catholics made it unavoidable. Speaker Pelosi has often said how highly she values her Catholic faith, and how much it is a source of joy for her. Accordingly, as her pastor, I am writing to invite her into a conversation with me about these matters. It is my obligation to teach forthrightly and to shepherd caringly, and that is my intent. Let us pray together that the Holy Spirit will guide us all toward a more profound understanding and appreciation for human life, and toward a resolution of these differences in truth and charity and peace. 

After all that… has His Excellency decided not to decide?

Maybe he is taking an overdue necessary step? 

I sincerely hope the dialogue goes well. 

Better late than never.

How did the dialogue go in years past?

During this conversation, will he solicit from her assent to Church teaching?

We know Archbishop Burke, as clear and bold as he is, also tried to talk personally to people.

Let us hope new ground can be covered.

In the meantime, people "in the pews" will watch where this goes and pray.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
47 Comments

A late summer supper

I had a guest tonight, to watch the convention coverage, and therefore made supper.

We started with a minestrone.

Here are some of the ingredients… fresh and Sabine.

A late summer supper

And….

A late summer supper

The setting:

A late summer supper

The first course.

A late summer supper

The second course…

Saltimbocca alla romana.

The beginning….

A late summer supper

More later… perhaps.

Posted in My View |
15 Comments

Networks

Okay… duke it out over networks.

This thread is a bit unusual for me, but I think it can be done.

Rules:

If you are nasty, I won’t only delete your comment, I will permanently block your access to this blog.

If you attack people personally, I won’t only delete your comment, I will permanently block your access to this blog.

If you are profoundly obtuse….

I think most of you know me by now.

This can also apply to networks overseas, such as SKY or BBC, RAI or… fill in the blank.

Is there media bias? 

Examples… be concrete.

Okay or not?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
33 Comments

TIGH – ROSLIN 2008!

[uc]

On The Politico I found this!

September 02, 2008

Fans of the Sci-Fi show Battlestar Galactica have previously noted that John McCain looks like Colonel Saul Tigh — a temperamental war hawk and ex-fighter pilot , who also happens to be a former POW.

And, as Jonathan Last notes, Sarah Palin looks like a young President Laura Roslin — the former Secretary of Education who became president of the human race out of nowhere after the robotic Cylons killed almost all of them in a surprise nuclear strike.

In Season One, the remaining 40,000 or so human beings worry about her inexperience, her open religiosity and her choice to ban abortion in order to keep mankind alive.

For more information on the mock ticket, check out the campaign site that’s already been set up in their name.

Life imitates art again here!

Tigh/Roslin ’08!

UPDATE:

Jimmy Akin has a GREAT piece of political analysis over at his place.  Check it out!

Here is a sample:

Many observers were impressed by Col. Saul Tigh’s selection of Laura Roslin as his running mate in the upcoming election.

Others found Roslin to be a lightweight compared to Tigh’s 40 years of service to the Twelve Colonies and his record as a war hero and former POW.

Originally, Roslin held only a minor post in the Colonial government which–while it  showcased her genuine love for children–nevertheless was a small backdrop before an unexpected and lightning rise to executive office, which she has held for only a short time.

On the other hand, her decision to ban abortion in order to keep mankind alive, her gung-ho Cylon-hunting, and her deep religious faith will surely fire up the base.

It is less clear what the effect will be of her statement that Admiral Adama’s deeply-unpopular and protracted conflict with the Cylons is a "task that is from the gods."

Some pundits viewed her selection cynically, saying that Tigh needed to choose someone like Roslin in order to shore up his standing in the party.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
22 Comments

RECENT POSTS and THANKS!

First things first.

RECENT POSTS and THANKS!As always, I want to thank those of you who have recently used the donation button on the left side-bar and on some entries.  I periodically remember your names at Mass when I offer it for benefactors, as is only fitting.  I am also grateful to you who sent me things from the amazon wish list, things useful for my work, life, and simply some joyful moments.

Here are some links to recent posts of interest.  This is not exhaustive, so look around.

  • The lefty-press did what nobody else could do
  • Hooks and conclusions
  • Another upcoming lesson from Pope Benedict through vestments
  • Card. George on human life against Catholic pro-abortion advocates
  • QUAERITUR: Roman Canon “Memento” RECENT POSTS and THANKS!of the living
  • REVIEW: Charbel Vestments: hand embroidered and beautiful
  • Newsweek/WaPo’s Stevens-Arroyo takes Planned Parenthood position
  • Recent WDTPRS Pelosi gaff entries
  • PODCAzTs on Augustine and on Catholic pro-abortion politicians
  • CDW’s Archbp. Ranjith on Pope Benedict’s plan with the liturgy
  • What WDTPRS is aiming at
  • SSPX & Womenpriests: similar? dissimilar?
  • Ineffable irony and the USCCB
  • A word to biters of the consecrated hand
  • USCCB: “Dick and Jane” translation theory again triumphs for a day – Eerie
  • ZENIT and Fr. Z: “Summorum Pontificum” One Year Later (Part 1 & Part 2)
  • An argument for lengthening Communion fast to 3 hours again
  • UK: Card. Castrillon Hoyos – TLM in “Not many parishes – all parishes”!
  • Bp. Trautman doesn’t think you are smart enough to understand the proposed new translation of Mass
  • QUAERITUR: writing to the CDWDS and remaining anonymous
  • Card. Castrillon Hoyos about the TLM on the new DVD
  • [!] Italian magazine Jesus interviews Card. Castrillon Hoyos of the P.C. “Ecclesia Dei” IMPORTANT
  • Time: Benedict may have killed off American Catholic liberalism
  • PCED’s Card. Castrillon Hoyos: celebrate TLM in parishes even when it isn’t requested – IMPORTANT
  • What is Black Liberation Theology? Some basics.
  • PODCAzT 54: Pro-Abortion Politicians and Communion; St. Ambrose and Emperor Theodosius
  • PCED clarifies: Summorum Pontificum 6 allows vernacular readings instead of Latin
  • PODCAzT 51: Communion in the hand
  • A friendly "how to e-mail Fr. Z" reminder!
  • QUAERITUR: going to SSPX chapel when you could go to legitimate chapel
  • A testimony about kneeling for Holy Communion and Communion rails
  • Summorum Pontificum now in the Acta Apostolicae Sedis – text variations
  • Fr. Z’s 20 Tips For Making A Good Confession – reprise
  • A new WDTPRS store
  • The return of triumphalism
  • Writing to the Pontifical Commission “Ecclesia Dei”: some tips – USEFUL!
  • From another entry: during the Roman Canon “I felt intense loneliness” – INTERESTING
  • Since the TLM is now back, why bother with the Novus Ordo in Latin?  HUGE ENTRY!
  • L’OssRom: Archbp. Ranjith interview on liturgy – UPDATES
  • The Tablet on Archbp. Ranjith’s comments about bishops who resist Summorum Pontificum
  • VOTE!  Voting is still open for a little while longer for this award. 

    If the blog has been useful to you, please consider giving us a hand.

      My site was nominated for Best Religion Blog!

    Visit the WDTPRS store for all your "Say the Black – Do the Red" needs!

     Buy WDTPRS stuff!

    You can add the WDTPRS feed to your own site:

     align=

    ↑ Grab this Headline Animator

    Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
    Comments Off on RECENT POSTS and THANKS!

    The lefty-press did what nobody else could do

    After the attack on Pearl Harbor, Admiral Yamamoto is alleged to have said:

    "Gentlemen, we have just kicked a rabid dog."

    Put another way, as popularized in the movies:

    "I fear all we have done is to awaken a sleeping giant."

    My deepest thanks to the mainstream liberal media.

    Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
    13 Comments

    Hooks and conclusions

    When I speak to groups or congregations I will sometimes start with "hooks" people can hang ideas on as a hermeneutic, interpretive principle, for what follows.

    Hook 1: Candidate Barak Obama, speaking without notes, referred to an unplanned baby as a punishment.
    Hook 2: Candidate Sarah Palin last night explicitly spoke of special-needs children.
    Hook 3: The liberal-left media is attacking Palin as a good candidate because she has five children.
    Hook 4: Speaker Pelosi had five children and managed to be a Representative.
    Hook 5: Candidate Biden was a senator and a single-parent.
    Hook 6: Candidate McCain adopted a dying child from Bangladesh.

    I turn now to a piece from the site of First Things with my emphases and comments:

    A Vote for Sarah Palin

    By Suann Therese Maier
    Wednesday, September 3, 2008, 7:51 AM

    Three memories [Her version of "hooks" for her interpretive principles of this event.] have shaped my approach to this year’s general election.

    Here’s the first. In the late 1970s, during a two-year break from teaching to raise our second son, an adopted child, I found myself at a Los Angeles dinner party filled with DINKs, the “double income, no kids” crowd who were just emerging as a self-aware and upwardly mobile social group. I fell to talking—or more accurately, listening—to a chatty young female attorney who said she was putting in eighty hours a week as a junior associate on a variety of important cases.

    After twenty minutes or so, she finally noticed my silence and asked me what I did with my own time. So I told her. I told her about the young couple that had asked my husband and me to adopt their baby if we covered their hospital expenses. I told her about waiting outside the delivery room for our son to be born. I told her about the bureaucratic maze that came with finalizing the adoption of a newborn. I told her about borrowing money from friends so we’d look more solvent than we actually were to Social Service inspectors who checked our accounts.

    “That’s wonderful dear,” she said. “You’re so lucky not to have a real job.”

    Here’s the second memory. I remember my fourth child, our son Dan, being born one winter evening, purple and struggling for breath. I remember my husband pouring water over his head as we baptized him in my arms. [A gesture of Christian hope in the midst of heart-rending, life-verifying challenge.] I remember the young Filipina doctor rushing Dan to intensive care. I remember the ten days of his fighting for life. And I remember Dan’s diagnosis, when it finally came in: Down syndrome.

    Here’s the third memory. I remember my father, a successful young Chicago attorney, telling me why the Democratic party was the party of “our people,” and why so many Catholics were Democrats, and why the party stood for the little guy, the poor and the defenseless. I remember listening as a young girl in our kitchen as Saul Alinsky [!] organized my parents’ Catholic friends on racial and economic issues [sound familiar?] in our Chicago living room. And I remember the night in 1992 when Pennsylvania’s governor, Robert Casey, was denied a chance to talk against abortion at the Democratic national convention.

    As I draw on those memories now, [her hermeneutical hooks] I reach certain conclusions. As a woman, mother, wife, and lifetime professional educator, I will vote, enthusiastically, for Sarah Palin as vice president this November. Even if the media pressure forces her from the ticket, I will vote against the Democratic party—partly because I respect John McCain and believe him to be the better candidate, but equally because I’m tired of the intransigence and condescension of the Democratic leadership on the abortion issue.  [Good.]

    I will vote for Sarah Palin because I don’t need the Democratic platform’s belated affirmation of motherhood. Thanks, but I already know that motherhood is good, several times over. Moreover, the party’s rediscovery of motherhood seems rather cynical in the current news cycle, while Democratic-friendly bloggers and media types bash Palin about her daughter’s pregnancy and her own busy schedule while bringing up children. [QUAERITUR:] How can a real sympathy for motherhood come from the same people who wrote a platform that hardens the party’s addiction to a phony right to kill the unborn?

    I will vote for Sarah Palin because she has guts. We’ve never met, but I suspect I know something about her life, and so do a great many other women. I know what it means to have a son with Down syndrome. I know what it means to talk a good line about religious faith and then be asked to prove it. I know what it means to have a daughter pregnant and unmarried.

    In fact, while we’re on the subject, I also know what it means to have two grandchildren born out of wedlock, a son struggling with alcohol, two grandchildren with serious disabilities, putting myself through graduate school while simultaneously caring for a husband and children and teaching full time—and a whole lot more. This is the stuff of real human love; [There it is.] this is the raw material of family life. And those who think that Palin’s beliefs and family struggles are funny or worth jeering at, simply reveal the venality of their own hearts.

    I will vote for Sarah Palin because she is intelligent, tenacious and talented. Nobody made her rise easy, and no one is making it easy now. And—is it only moms who notice this?—unlike Senator Biden, she does seem to act consistently on her beliefs about the sanctity of life, at considerable personal cost.

    I will vote for Sarah Palin because she doesn’t come from Washington or New York or Chicago or anywhere else the political and media aristoi like to hang out. In fact, I especially like the idea that the state she governs actually produces something—like some of the oil that powers the hair dryers and klieg lights at MSNBC.

    I will vote for Sarah Palin because Roe v. Wade is bad law, and it needs to fall. I don’t doubt the intelligence and character of men like Doug Kmiec, the younger Bob Casey, and others who sympathize with the Obama campaign. But I do doubt their judgment. At the end of the day, the Democratic party in 2008 has conceded nothing to pro-life Democrats. The fact that Sen. Obama listens respectfully to pro-lifers without calling them reactionary dunces does not constitute progress. [Look instead at his record in Illinois.] Results and behavior are what matter. On both those counts, the party has again failed to show any real sensitivity to pro-life concerns. In that light, high profile Catholics who support Obama are simply rationalizing their surrender on Roe.

    Finally, I will vote for Sarah Palin, not because I’ve left the Democratic party of my youth and young adulthood, but because that party has left me. In fact, it no longer exists. And no amount of elegant speaking, exciting choreography, and moral alibis will bring it back.

    That’s the real tragedy of this election.

    Suann Therese Maier, the mother of four and former director of non-profit support organizations for pregnant women and children with disabilities, is a teacher in Colorado.

    Some of the reasons she gives, quite personal, such as "she’s tough" or "she’s been there", are good, but not in my book as compelling as some of the other reasons she gives.

    However, another important dimension of this article is that many people out there on both sides or no side of the lines of political parties have the very same set of memorable hooks.

    Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
    38 Comments

    Another upcoming lesson from Pope Benedict through vestments

    Our friends at Rorate are still on top of interesting things.

    We are now informed that Pope Benedict, … well… read on:

    In the Mass he will celebrate in Paris, the Holy Father will don vestments which belong to the Abbey of Sainte-Madeleine du Barroux, the most famous Traditional Catholic abbey in France.

     

    Keep in mind that the Abbey at Le Barroux famously returned to unity Rome at the time of the 1988 act of "separation" by Archbp. Lefebvre.   They live a Benedictine life, and with rigor.  As a result, the monastery is stuffed with vocations.  Years back they published a fine Latin/French hand missal for the old Mass… with a preface by Joseph Card. Ratzinger. 

    The Holy Father has been chosing vestments to make a statement.  His use of historical cuts of vestments, especially the marvelous taglio filipino, is a concrete lesson in continuity.

    Some thought to brush the vestment lessons aside.

    They are dead wrong.

     

    Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
    2 Comments

    Card. George on human life against Catholic pro-abortion advocates

    In the wake of the Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s calculated televised attack on the Catholic Church’s teaching on when human life begins, some very prominent US bishops have issued corrective statements, making it clear just how wrong she is, and how scandalous were her remarks.

    His Eminence Francis Card. George, Archbishop of Chicago, has made a strong statement in a letter posted on the website of the Archdiocese.

    My emphases and comments.

    Card. George on human life against Catholic pro-abortion advocates
    Office of the Cardinal

    September 2, 2008

    Dear Brothers and Sisters in Christ,

    In the midst of a lengthy political campaign, matters of public policy that are also moral issues [pretty much all public policy issues are moral issues, but this one trumps all others] sometimes are misrepresented or are presented in a partial or manipulative fashion. [In other words, in a deceptive manner.] While everyone could be expected to know the Church’s position on the immorality of abortion and the role of law in protecting unborn children, it seems some profess not to know it and others, even in the Church, dispute it. Since this teaching has recently been falsely presented, [by Speaker Pelosi on Meet The Press, to a huge audience] the following clarification may be helpful.

    The Catholic Church, from its first days, condemned the aborting of unborn children as gravely sinful. Not only Scripture’s teaching about God’s protection of life in the womb (consider the prophets and the psalms and the Gospel stories about John the Baptist and Jesus himself in Mary’s womb) but also the first century catechism (the Didache or Teaching of the Twelve Apostles) said: “You shall not slay the child by abortions. You shall not kill what is generated.” The teaching of the Church was clear in a Roman Empire that permitted abortion. [A good reminder.] This same teaching has been constantly reiterated in every place and time up to Vatican II, which condemned abortion as a “heinous crime.” [Gaudium et spes 51: "Vita igitur inde a conceptione, maxima cura tuenda est; abortus necnon infanticidium nefanda sunt crimina".]  This is true today and will be so tomorrow. [This teaching will not change.]  Any other comments, by politicians, professors, pundits or the occasional priest, are erroneous and cannot be proposed in good faith. [Contradict the Church’s clear teaching, you are not in good faith.]

    This teaching has consequences for those charged with caring for the common good, those who hold public office. [Read: pro-abortion Catholic politicians] The unborn child, who is alive and is a member of the human family, cannot defend himself or herself. Good law defends the defenseless. Our present laws permit unborn children to be privately killed. Laws that place unborn children outside the protection of law destroy both the children killed and the common good, which is the controlling principle of Catholic social teaching. One cannot favor the legal status quo on abortion and also be working for the common good.  [Pro-abortion Catholic politicians are working against the common good.]

    This explains why the abortion issue will not disappear and why it is central to the Church’s teaching on a just social order. The Church does not endorse candidates for office, but she does teach the principles according to which Catholics should form their social consciences. The teaching, which covers intrinsic evils such as abortion and many other issues that are matters of prudential judgment, could not be clearer; [and if you (or Speaker Pelosi) says the Church’s teaching is not clear, you (or Speaker Pelosi) are a liar undermining the common good] the practice often falls short because we are all sinners. There is no room for self-righteousness in Catholic moral teaching.

    The Conference of Bishops in this country and the Bishops of Illinois have issued statements about Catholic social teaching and political life. They are available in our parishes. All of us should keep our country and all the candidates for office in the next election in our prayers. God bless you and your families.

    Sincerely yours in Christ,
    Card. George on human life against Catholic pro-abortion advocates
    Francis Cardinal George, O.M.I.
    Archbishop of Chicago

    The Cardinal does not say explicitly that pro-abortion Catholic politicians should not receive Communion, but that is the logical conclusion.  He doesn’t not say that pastors of souls should deny Communion, but that is the reasonable conclusion.

    WDTPRS kudos to Cardinal George.

     

     

    Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
    8 Comments