Chinese Joseph Card. Zen’s Open Letter to all the other Cardinals

Chinese Joseph Card. Zen's Open Letter to all the other CardinalsThe great Chinese prelate Joseph Card. Zen has sent a letter to all of the members of the College of Cardinals.   HERE  It includes Dubia of the cardinal regarding “Pastoral guidelines of the Holy See concerning the civil registration of clergy in China”

This pontificate doesn’t have a great track record with dubia.

Here is Card. Zen’s letter, which was originally at Marco Tosatti’s place in Italian.  My emphases and comments.

27 September 2019

Dear Eminence,

Please forgive me for the disturbance that this letter will cause you. I am writing you because, in conscience, I believe that the problem that I am presenting concerns not only the Church in China, but the entire Church, and we cardinals have the grave responsibility to help the Holy Father in guiding the Church.

Now, based on my analysis of the Document of the Holy See (June 28, 2019) “Pastoral guidelines of the Holy See concerning the civil registration of clergy in China” it is absolutely clear that it encourages the faithful in China to enter into a schismatic Church (independent of the Pope and under the orders of the Communist Party).

On July 10 I presented my “dubia” to the Pope. His Holiness, on July 3, promised me that he would be interested in it, but until now I have heard nothing.  [It has only been… what?… half a year?]

Cardinal Parolin says that when we speak of the independent Church today, we should no longer mean that this independence is absolute, because the agreement recognizes the role of the pope in the Catholic Church.

First of all, I cannot believe that there is such a statement in the agreement and I still have not seen it (among other things, why should such an agreement be secret and not even given to me, a Chinese cardinal, to see it?), [?!?] but, even more clearly, the whole situation after the signing of the agreement shows that in reality nothing has changed.

Cardinal Parolin quotes a phrase from the letter of Pope Benedict completely out of context, indeed, in such a way that it is diametrically opposed to the whole meaning of the paragraph [from which it comes].

This manipulation of the thought of the Pope Emeritus is a grave lack of respect; indeed, it is a deplorable insult to the person of the very meek still-living pope.

It also disgusts me that they often declare that what they are doing is in continuity with the thought of the preceding pope, when in fact the opposite is true. I have good reason to believe (and I hope that one day I will be able to prove it with archival documents) that the accord that has been signed is the same one that Pope Benedict had, at the time, refused to sign.

Dear Eminence, can we passively witness this killing of the Church in China on the part of those who should be protecting and defending it from its enemies? Begging you on my knees, your brother

Cardinal Joseph ZEN, S.D.B.

This just makes your heart cry.

The dubia.

Perhaps he and Cards. Brandmüller and Burke should have special jackets made.

Posted in Modern Martyrs, The Coming Storm, The Drill | Tagged ,
24 Comments

ROME: NEW Traditional Mass location

News in Rome.  I was informed that the Institute of Christ the King will have an “apostolate” in Rome at the Basilica of Celso and Giuliano.  HERE   This baroque church is on the rather narrow street that points you directly up to the “Angel Bridge”.

It seems that the rector of the Church invited the Institute to be involved there.

This is not quite the same as what the FSSP has at Santissima Trinità dei Pelegrini, which is a parish with a pastor.   The ICK place has a rector of the Diocese of Rome and they will be guests there.

Nevertheless, more places are better than fewer.

If it can happen in Rome, which is seriously hostile territory, it can happen anywhere.

Another point.   This church was for many years rather hard to visit, usually closed.  The fact that the ICK has been invited is a good development.  A rector of a Roman church is thinking inside the box.

And it is always good to have healthy market forces in operation!  Up your game!

This brings me to another point for you who embrace tradition.

Do not fear the idea of another place starting the traditional Mass in your area.  “Oh no!  They can’t do that!  They’ll take people away from our place!”

Maybe yes.  Maybe no.

You should always be incentivized to work your backsides off to make your chapel or parish church the most wonderful place to be as a Catholic.  If you drift in on Sunday, ignore the collection and other parish events, and drift away again, you don’t get to complain.  Also, you are part of the problem.

Do not fear the successes of others.   There is an old image that a rising tide raises all boats, from the dingy to the aircraft carrier.  It could be that your chapel or church may lose some attendance for a while, since there are most places where the traditional Mass is being offered.  I suggest that you gripe and wring your hands and give up.

NO!

Get out there and bring in more people!

Be inviting.  Never underestimate the power of an invitation.

Be also in your person alluring through your joy at being a Catholic with the great advantages of tradition.

You have so many advantages.

Get into gear!

ROME: NEW Traditional Mass location

Posted in ¡Hagan lío!, "How To..." - Practical Notes, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000 | Tagged , ,
13 Comments

PHOTOS: Blessing Epiphany Water 2020

A few action shots from the Blessing of Epiphany Water on the Vigil of Epiphany, 5 January, at St. Mary’s in Pine Bluff, WI.

The Rite is mighty powerful, involving first the singing of the Litany of Saints, the exorcism of the place, then the singing of Vespers, the exorcism and blessing of the elements of salt and water, their combination and blessing, and the Te Deum.

It was not really advertised, and it involved mostly a group of men who have a schola.  There might have been cigars and beverages involved afterwards.  Maybe.

PHOTOS: Blessing Epiphany Water 2020

PHOTOS: Blessing Epiphany Water 2020

PHOTOS: Blessing Epiphany Water 2020

 

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Hard-Identity Catholicism, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000 | Tagged
2 Comments

CNN settles with Covington Catholic student Nick Sandmann

This is interesting in the extreme!   News outlets, including Daily Wire, have something other than the retaliation of Iran.

CNN has reportedly settled with the Convington KY HS student, Nick Sandman.  You will recall that Sandman, at the time 16 years old, was caught on video being harassed and then the liberal MSM and others shamefully targeted him for the blame.  Sandman and family didn’t lie down and take it.  They fought back by suing CNN and other big dogs involved for lots of money.  $275 million v CNN, $250 million against WaPo and NBC and others.   Daily Wire gave a list of those being sued.

I really like this list.  A few of these names are deeply satisfying.

The Washington Post
The New York Times
Cable News Network, Inc. (CNN)
The Guardian
National Public Radio
TMZ
Atlantic Media Inc.
Capitol Hill Publishing Corp.
Diocese of Covington
Diocese of Lexington
Archdiocese of Louisville
Diocese of Baltimore
Ana Cabrera (CNN)
Sara Sidner (CNN)
Erin Burnett (CNN)
S.E. Cupp (CNN)
Elliot C. McLaughlin (CNN)
Amanda Watts (CNN)
Emanuella Grinberg (CNN)
Michelle Boorstein (Washington Post)
Cleve R. Wootson Jr. (Washington Post)
Antonio Olivo (Washington Post)
Joe Heim (Washington Post)
Michael E. Miller (Washington Post)
Eli Rosenberg (Washington Post)
Isaac Stanley-Becker (Washington Post)
Kristine Phillips (Washington Post)
Sarah Mervosh (New York Times)
Emily S. Rueb (New York Times)
Maggie Haberman (New York Times)
David Brooks (New York Times)
Shannon Doyne
Kurt Eichenwald
Andrea Mitchell (NBC/MSNBC)
Savannah Guthrie (NBC)
Joy Reid (MSNBC)
Chuck Todd (NBC)
Noah Berlatsky
Elisha Fieldstadt (NBC)
Eun Kyung Kim
HBO
Bill Maher
Warner Media
Conde Nast
GQ
Heavy.com
The Hill
The Atlantic
Bustle.com
Ilhan Omar
Elizabeth Warren
Kathy Griffin
Alyssa Milano
Jim Carrey

 

 

Posted in Biased Media Coverage | Tagged
13 Comments

GREAT SCHRÖDINGER’s GHOST! Research on church attendance and … CAT OWNERS

GREAT SCHRÖDINGER's GHOST! Research on church attendance and ... CAT OWNERSIn Christianity Today I read that… I can hardly bring myself to type… the horrific revelation that

Cat Owners Are Less Likely To Go To Church

This explains a lot, doesn’t it.

By Schrödinger… is anyone really surprised, much less shocked?

In other news,

Abortion was the leading cause of death worldwide in 2019, ending the lives of over 42 million unborn babies

On that note, I sense that, as the demographic sink hole is opening up under the Church, a couple of groups will probably survive and, eventually will find each other and start to mesh and mutually enrich: on the one hand charismatics and converts from evangelical Protestants groups and, on the other, traditional Catholics. When the growing throng of beige Catholics and disinterested nones – and cat owners? – drop out of even pretending to be attached to the Faith of their Fathers, who will be left? There will be some friction at first, but I am convinced that the results – which I may not see in my lifetime – will be amazing.

These groups are also having babies. They are not aborting our future. Abortion is a form of societal suicide.

I saw a note from Ed Pentin the other day that the bishops of Hungary issued a pastoral letter to emphasize what some prominent American bishops do not, namely, that life begins at conception. The Hungarians noted that since abortion was legalized in 1956 (Communists) “6 million of our compatriots have not been born”, which is “almost as many lives as the children born in Hungary in the same amount of time”. Now the Hungarian government is providing incentives for larger families. It’s working.

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras, The Coming Storm, The future and our choices | Tagged , , ,
18 Comments

New video documentary about Benedict XVI from German TV

At National Catholic Register the intrepid Ed Pentin has posted at there is a 30 minute video documentary in German about Pope Benedict XVI’s life in the Vatican Gardens.  It aired on German TV on 3 January.   HERE

It is in German, of course.

It is quite beautiful and respectful.  There are quite a few images from inside his present residence in the Vatican Garden and a good deal of information about his youth.

 

Posted in Benedict XVI, Just Too Cool | Tagged ,
5 Comments

Media Report looks at the anti-Catholic bias of Associated Press writers

Take a moment at least to scan the Media Report article about how the AP (Associated Press) writes about the Catholic Church.  HERE

Another reason why alternative Catholic, non-legacy, sites can be important.

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, Green Inkers, Liberals | Tagged , ,
Comments Off on Media Report looks at the anti-Catholic bias of Associated Press writers

ASK FATHER: Is cooking on Sunday a sin?

ASK FATHER: Is cooking on Sunday a sin?From a reader…

QUAERITUR:

I saw someone say that cooking on Sunday violates the third commandment and food for Sunday must be made before Sunday. Is this true ?

No.

As much as we honor our Jewish forbears, we do not keep their strict laws about cooking and sabbath food preparation, bishul.

We should avoid on Sunday unnecessary work, or unnecessary drudgery.  If it is necessary we do it.

However, some things that are drudgery for one are a pleasure for another.  There are some people who would rather have starving rats chew through their faces while kneeling on glass in salt water while being tormented with horseflies and rap music than do any gardening.  This is my attitude toward ironing clothes.  Others enjoy gardening, and even ironing, find it relaxing and even meditative.

People should eat on Sundays.  We don’t have to do food prep according to rabbinic laws, which permitted some continuation of heat but forbade initiating, by Jews at least, the warming of anything.   Chopping vegetables could even have been considered forbidden work.    We don’t have these restrictions.  We can prep and cook and clean up afterward.   Having a family meal on Sunday is a wonderful thing.   A measure of cooking is involved.

If one can do some of the cooking and prep the day before to lighten the load, that’s not just okay for Sunday observance, that’s smart cooking.

Frankly, while cooking a large and complicated meal is a good deal of “work”, it is work I thoroughly enjoy and find therapeutic.

Catholics can cook on Sundays.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Our Catholic Identity | Tagged
18 Comments

WDTPRS – Epiphany Collect: Liturgy should be “epiphany”

WDTPRS - Epiphany Collect: Liturgy should be “epiphany”

In the Novus Ordo calendar Epiphany (which is supposed to be 12 days after Christmas – the reason it is called “Twelfth Night”) is sometimes moved to the Sunday.  I suppose that they reasoned that more people would celebrate the important feast that way.

I say that

1) that signals that bishops think that our obligations according to the religion of virtue aren’t that important,

2) the liturgical year isn’t that important, and

3) parishes lose a collection.

In the ancient Western Church and in the East, Epiphany was more important than the relative latecomer Christmas.  Epiphany is from the Greek word for a divine “manifestation” or “revelation”.  There are many “epiphanies” of God in the Scripture.  Think, for example, of the burning bush encountered by Moses.

The Latin Church’s antiphons for Vespers reflect the tradition that Epiphany was thought to be not only the day the Magi came to adore Christ, but also the same day years later when He changed water into wine at Cana, and also when He was baptized by St. John in the Jordan.  In each mysterious event, Jesus was revealed to be more than a mere man: He is man and God.

The Epiphany Collect was in the 1962 Missale Romanum and in ancient sacramentaries.

Deus, qui hodierna die Unigenitum tuum stella duce revelasti, concede propitius, ut qui iam te ex fide cognovimus, usque ad contemplandam speciem tuae celsitudinis perducamur.

Stella duce is an ablative absolute not the name of a movie star or pop tart.  The adjective hodiernus means “of this day, today’s”.  In older Latin, celsitudo is “lofty carriage of the body”. In later Latin it is used like the title “Highness”.  In our liturgical context it is a divine attribute, God’s transcendent grandeur, glory.

SUPER LITERAL VERSION:

O God, who on this very day revealed your Only-begotten, a star as the guide, graciously grant, that we, who have already come to know You by faith, may be led all the way unto the beauty of Your glory to be contemplated.

OBSOLETE ICEL (1973):

Father, you revealed your Son to the nations by the guidance of a star. Lead us to your glory in heaven by the light of faith.

NEW CORRECTED ICEL (2011):

O God, who on this day revealed your Only Begotten Son to the nations by the guidance of a star, grant in your mercy, that we, who know you already by faith, may be brought to behold the beauty of your sublime glory.

In Latin prayers species (three syllables) often means “beauty”. It is also a technical, philosophical term about the way the human intellect apprehends things.  Species has to do with the relationship between the thing known and our knowing power.  A species transforms the mind of the one perceiving a thing.  The object we consider acts upon our power of knowing.  Simultaneously, the knowing power acts upon the object known.  Our knowing power’s active and passive aspects meet in the species and the object of our consideration is known directly, without intermediaries.  Easy. Right?

This is what we are praying for, hoping for, living our earthly lives for: to see God face to face, directly and immediately (without intermediaries).

In this life we know God only indirectly, by faith, our reason aided by the authority of revelation and by grace.  This is St. Paul’s “dark glass” (1 Cor 13:12) through which we peer toward Him in longing.

Christ is the visible image of the invisible God.

He is the Father’s Beauty.

He is Truth and Beauty and Glory itself.

St. Hilary of Poitiers (d 367) conceived God’s divine attribute of glory as a transforming power which divinizes us by our contact with it.  After Moses talked with God in the tent of the Ark, he wore a veil over his face, which became too bright to look at.

We pray today, literally, to be brought “all the way to the beauty of glory (species celsitudinis)” of God “which is to be contemplated”.

His beauty will act on us, increase our knowledge of Him and, therefore, our love for Him … for all eternity.   We will be, all the more, the images He intended.

Christ could be understood to be the species celsitudinis of this prayer. Contemplate His truth and beauty.  Christ is the true speaker and spoken truth of every prayer of every Mass.

If eternal Beauty transforms us, “divinizes” us, then beauty in this life changes us too.

Could a fostering of beauty in our churches help us reach people today in a way that arguments or other appeals may not?

Our liturgical worship of the Most High God must lead us to encounter beauty, truth, transcendent mystery.

Holy Mass requires the finest architecture, vestments, music – everything – we can summon from human genius, love and labor.  What we sing and say and do in church, and the church itself, ought to presage the liturgy of heaven, where the Church Triumphant enjoys already the Beatific Vision.  Liturgy should be “epiphany”, wherein we encounter transforming mystery.

We read today from Leo the Great in the Office of Matins:

Honorétur ítaque a nobis sacratíssimus dies, in quo salútis nostræ Auctor appáruit: et quem Magi infántem veneráti sunt in cunábulis, nos omnipoténtem adorémus in cælis. Ac sicut illi de thesáuris suis mýsticas Dómino múnerum spécies obtulérunt, ita et nos de córdibus nostris, quæ Deo sunt digna, promámus.

Let all observance, then, be paid to this most sacred day, whereon the Author of our salvation was made manifest, and as the wise men fell down and worshiped Him in the manger, so let us fall down and worship Him enthroned Almighty in heaven. As they also opened their treasures and presented unto Him mystic and symbolic gifts, so let us strive to open our hearts to Him, and offer Him from thence some worthy offering.

Let us celebrate every Mass in such a way that we become shoeless Moses before the burning bush which is never consumed.

Let Mass make us Magi with sight and mind fixed in longing upon the beautiful, true and yet speechless Word, in whom transcendent glory was both hidden and revealed.

Posted in Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, Patristiblogging | Tagged
4 Comments

ASK FATHER: A sick child and fulfilling Mass obligation

ASK FATHER: A sick child and fulfilling Mass obligationFrom a reader…

QUAERITUR:

I attended an Extraordinary Form Mass this morning [Sunday] so I could stay home with a sick child while my husband and older children went to a later Novus Ordo Mass at our parish. I forgot until I was almost there that Mass would not be said for the Epiphany. Should I go to an Extraordinary Form Mass tomorrow for Epiphany? The priest said we should do our best to attend the Epiphany Mass tomorrow, so I do not think I am obligated to. It is possible for me to go, but it would be inconvenient for the family, especially since my son is sick. Thank you, Father.

If your son is sick and needs your care, you do not have an obligation to fulfill, Sunday or not.  Your obligation is to your son.

However, you fulfill your Mass obligations according to what is laid down in the 1983 Code of Canon Law.   The Code says that you fulfill your obligation by attending Mass on the day of obligation itself or on its vigil.   If you went to Mass on Sunday you fulfilled your obligation regardless of what Mass formulary was used.

Also, Epiphany, 6 January, which this year falls on a Monday, is not a Holy Day of Obligation in these USA.   (All Sundays are, of course.)

If you are in England, Epiphany has been reinstated as a Holy Day of Obligation.  When Epiphany falls on Saturday or Monday, in the Novus Ordo calendar it is transferred to the Sunday (which is always of obligation).  If Epiphany falls not on Monday or Saturday, in England Epiphany will be of obligation.

Again, if you are impeded from attending Mass because of sickness, or sickness in the family, or bad weather, or invasion by aliens, forest fires, sneak attacks by Cylons, floods and the like, you do not have an obligation to fulfill.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Canon Law, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000 | Tagged , ,
7 Comments