ASK FATHER: External Solemnities… er um… hooray?

ASK FATHER: External Solemnities... er um... hooray?From a reader…

QUAERITUR:

I was very surprised this morning to discover that the regular TLM being celebrated by the pastor was that of the Epiphany rather than the Holy Name. I am not aware of any legal provision for such an “external solemnity.” He referred to his decision to celebrate Epiphany rather than Holy Name in his sermon so it was not an oversight. What say you?

Ah, “external solemnity”, my old nemesis.  We meet again.

Yes, in the traditional Roman Rite it is possible to celebrate “externally”, that is “external” to the true date, great feasts, namely, on the nearby Sunday.   This should not be an observance instead of the true day.  The feast is still to be celebrated on the actual day.  However, on a Sunday the Mass formulary – but not the Office – of nearby feast can be used.

The 1962 Rubric, provides for this in 356-361, especially 358 and 359.

The SSPX describes this  HERE:

On the Sunday after some Feasts, the feast may be solemnized in a special way with a votive Mass celebrated (the Office remains of the day); this is called an external solemnity. They are permitted but not required. The Sunday is commemorated in the Mass of the External Solemnity unless the solemnity is of a feast of Our Lord.

In the USA, the following feasts may have an external solemnity on the following Sunday: Corpus Christi, the Sacred Heart, and Sts. Peter and Paul. The rubrics allow for an external solemnity on the Sunday either preceding or following these feasts: that of the primary patron of the territory/diocese, that of the primary patron of the institute to which the church belongs (e.g., St. Pius X), and that of the titular of the church. In addition, the Mass of October 7, feast of the Holy Rosary, may be celebrated as an external solemnity on the first Sunday of October (only).

In the case of today, Holy Name,  Epiphany has a higher liturgical rank.   So, you could have the external celebration today, Sunday.

One could argue – could – that if a Bishops Conference has transferred a feast to a Sunday (which one should argue – should – is a bad idea) then there is an additional justification (to hide behind) for the “external celebration” of feast like Epiphany to Sunday, the Feast of the Most Holy Name.  Of course one should then observe Epiphany on 6 January.

So, in the Novus Ordo the Bishops can transfer a feast.  In the traditional Roman Rite there may be an observance of a feast on a nearby Sunday, while preserving the true feast day.

Therefore, oh boy, I’m really behind this permitted “external solemnity” thing!

Posted in Liturgy Science Theatre 3000 | Tagged
10 Comments

Your Sunday Sermon Notes – Holy Name/Epiphany – 2020

Was there a good point made in the sermon you heard at the Mass that fulfilled your Sunday Obligation? What was it?

There are a lot of people who don’t get many good points in the sermons they must endure.

In the traditional Roman Rite today we celebrated the Most Holy Name of Jesus.  In the newfangled calendar most people got a transferred Epiphany.  Real Epiphany, aka Twelfth Night, is tomorrow.

For my part…

Play video

Posted in Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, Sermons | Tagged
13 Comments

Fr. Z’s Kitchen – Of the Bard, Crow and Fishy Noodles

Fr. Z's Kitchen - Of the Bard, Crow and Fishy Noodles

I take a break from deep musing upon the mystery of the Epiphany to watch an episode of hilarious Upstart Crow [and UK… you probably know about this already… HERE] and have some fishy noodles.

I was going to have ale and pie, but I decided on fermented fish sauce.

Today I have enjoyed my colatura and garlic and parsley together with the show’s running commuter gags, anachronistic shots, neologisms and saucy prancings.

Fr. Z's Kitchen - Of the Bard, Crow and Fishy Noodles

Methinks, this is easy to make.  Macerate the minced garlic in the colatura.  Uncorking the tiny bottle produced a startling effect.

Cook your pasta and then chill it fast in ice water.   Dry it off well.  Toss it into your colatura with chopped flat leaf parsley.  A little grind of black pepper.

Fr. Z's Kitchen - Of the Bard, Crow and Fishy Noodles

On the Shakespeare theme, I also recently saw All Is True [US HERE – UK HERE].

Well… maybe two episodes of Upstart Crow before returning to Epiphany musings.

Play video

[Green reminds me of some vicars general I have met.]

And now that I have your attention… go here..
URGENT PRAYER REQUEST for a young priest diagnosed with ALS – #padresfight

Posted in Fr. Z's Kitchen | Tagged ,
2 Comments

“Let y’all know!” The “Noveritis” Epiphany chant announcement of 2020’s movable dates and feasts

“Let y’all know!” The “Noveritis” Epiphany chant announcement of 2020’s movable dates and feastsAt Epiphany we Latins have – traditionally – chanted a solemn proclamation of the key liturgical dates or movable feasts for the new year of salvation, just begun.

This underscores how these dates and seasons are all interconnected.

The liturgical year is a reflection of and on the mystery of our salvation.  And, never forget, the mysteries shape us. We are our rites.

Some liturgical dates are movable. For example Septuagesima, in 2019, fell on 17 February. This beginning of Pre-Lent doesn’t fall on the same date every year because the date of Easter changes each year.  In 2020 it will fall on 9 February.

“But Father! But Father!”, you libtards are surely sputtering.  “What does this chant sound like? Do it in English like the spirit of Vatican II wanted!   But you won’t because YOU HATE VATICAN II!”

We will use Latin on Epiphany, of course.

Here is what it sounds like, in case some deacon or priest out there, less familiar with chant, wants to give it a shot.  It sounds rather like the Exultet, sung at the Easter Vigil.  The Noveritis is a little awkward in parts.

You can find a printable PDF of the Noveritis 2020 HERE.  NB: It has Ascension Thursday on the correct day!

Fathers.  Here is how to sing the Noveritis for 2020, on Epiphany.  I’ll take it slowly so that you can get it into your ears.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000 | Tagged , ,
1 Comment

Send Fr. Z your snail-mail 2020 CHRISTMAS CARDS! – UPDATED

UPDATE 17 Jan:

Baldwin, NY*
Pine Island, MN (roger Pachamama)

UPDATE 3 Jan:

Ona, WV
Hamilton, OH*
Escanaba, MI
Painswick, Glouchestershire
Round Hill, VA
Prairie Village, KS
Kingsland, GA
Kansas City, MO
Zenica, Bosnia Hercegovina (thanks for the comment about the live Masses)
Manchester, England
Estes Park, CO (good memories of that place)
Toronto, ON* (very kind)

UPDATE 28 Dec:

Last day of the year, but not the last day of the CHRISTMAS SEASON!

Round Rock, TX
LaValle, WI*
Kenai, AK*
Manassas, VA
Kaneohe, HI
Leominster, MA
Garland, TX
Oranmore, Gallway (Thanks for the Masses! Prayers)
Lancaster, PA (Kid art!)
Harrisburg, PA*
Cottage Grove, MN*
Eaton, OH
Escondido, CA (cool stamp)
Hummelstown, PA*
Benton, AR*
Orland Park, IL

KID ART SECTION

Grace (4) and her brother (8) in the snow.

Send Fr. Z your snail-mail 2020 CHRISTMAS CARDS! - UPDATED

That might be a “minion” with them, or a Jesuit.  RUN CHILDREN!  RUN!

And I think we have a … spaceship?… and… affectionate robots exchanging gifts?  One of them got a new sweater.  As all good robots do at Christmas.

Send Fr. Z your snail-mail 2020 CHRISTMAS CARDS! - UPDATED

UPDATE 28 Dec:

UPDATE….

I missed a few…

Middleton, WI
Fort Atkinson, WI
Cross Plains, WI
Frisco, TX
Wylie, TX

My neighbor stopped in a the P.O. Box for me today and brought more treasures.

Bottesford, Leics. England*
San Francisco, CA*
Orlando, FL
San Mateo, CA (lovely block print)
Orrtanna, PA (Masses… thanks)
Houston, TX
Tiverton, RI
Carlisle, MA
Bloomington, MN
Compton, NH
St. Charles, MO
Appleton, WI
Bartlett, IL
Hammond, IN (great photo)
Waunakee, WI*
Mount Clemens, MI x 2
Letterkenny, Donegal
Powassan, ON
Hamburg, NY
Franklin, IN
New Braunfels, TX* (thanks)
BEdford, IN
Irondale, AL
Salinas, CA (thanks!)
Newman Lake, WA (kid art!)
Rochester, MN
Arlington, TX
Maybrook, NY
Sarasota, FL
East Lyons, CT
Valdosta, GA (73!)
Ottawa, ON (thanks, old friend)
Milton Freewater, OR
Carlsbad, CA (actually there was never a time in my priesthood when I DIDN’T say the TLM!)
Dorchester, MA
Austin, TX
Minneapolis, MN
Calgary, Alberta
Alliston, ON
Austin, TX* (thanks)
St. Paul, MN
Boise, ID
Tokyo (Arigato gozaimashita!)
Macon, GA
Manchester, NH
Palmer, TX
Sydney, NS
Hudson, MA
Overland, KS
Pierz, MN
England (Lewisham?)
Lodi, WI (charyut!)
Pisgah Forest, NC
Wahpeton, ND (congrats!)
Lake Mills, WI

KID ART SECTION

Send Fr. Z your snail-mail 2020 CHRISTMAS CARDS! - UPDATED

Send Fr. Z your snail-mail 2020 CHRISTMAS CARDS! - UPDATED

UPDATE 24 Dec:

Irving, TX
Eagan, MN*
Cowplain, Waterlooville, Hampshire
Åbo, Finland
Chester, VT*
Bridgewater, MA
Thousand Oaks, CA
Seaford, NY
Iowa City, IA (daily Mass viewer)
York, PA (kudos for the ordination in the family)
Fort Worth, TX
Yellowstone National Park, WY*
Reeseville, WI* (donation to the TMSM really helps)
Carlsbad, CA
Kenosha, WI*
Tignish, PE
Falmouth, NS
Voorhees, NJ
London, England
Fullerton, CA
Eastsound, WA
St. Paul, MN (Seven Sisters Apostolate!)
Knoxville, TN
Aurora, CO
Montgomery, AL
Boca Raton, FL
Watervliet, NY*
Cudahy, WI*

UPDATE 19 Dec:

The P.O. Box was stuffed in layers, fore and aft!

Clearwater, FL (very cool stamps)
La Crescent, MN
Bowling Green, KY
Palm Beach Gardens, FL
Yuma, AZ (and St. Agnes in St. Paul!)
Stamford, CT (me too)
Oxnard, CA
Round Rock, TX
Savannah, GA (nice photos – they didn’t get bent – miracle)
Wichita, KS*
Montgomery, AL
Menominee Fall, WI (kid art! YAY!)
Portsmouth, HN (more kid art! YAY!)
Indianapolis, IN
Bethesda, MD*
Saint Mary, MO (very kind words)
Wading River, NY
Millersville, MD*
Raleigh, NC*
Monteagle, TN
Shelton, CT
Peosta, IA (and kid art! YAY!)
Mount Airy, GA
Monterey, CA
Elmhurst, IL (keep working on the Latin)
Stockbridge, GA
McKinney, TX
La Jolla, CA (rather… thanks to YOU!)
Wichita, KS*
Vero Beach, FL (I would like to, but that depends on the pastor)
Fulton, MO (prayers)
Denver, CO
Windsor, ON*
St. Paul, MN
Thaxton, VA
Cashton, WI (garlic scapes!)
Knoxville, TN (gosh… brought tears… prayers)
Plano, TX (more prayers)
Algona, IA
Lakeside, CA (73!)
Near Eastbourne, England
Oshkosh, WI
Brea, CA
Port Saint Lucie, FL
Mesa, AZ
Eagle, ID*
Greenville, SC*
Las Vegas, NV*
Hollister, CA
Gravesend, Kent (bis!)
San Francisco, CA
Huntersville, NC (prayers for 6 yr old T)
Bentleigh, VIC (Australia)
Pewamo, MI*
Ashford, Middlesex, England
Rochester, MI
Moscow, ID
Chula Vista, CA
Covina, CA
Schenectady, NY (cool stamps)

A shout out and thanks to

Cody, WY
Foley, AL
Locust Grove, GA

Wow… that took quite a while.

KID ART SECTION

Send Fr. Z your snail-mail 2020 CHRISTMAS CARDS! - UPDATEDSend Fr. Z your snail-mail 2020 CHRISTMAS CARDS! - UPDATEDSend Fr. Z your snail-mail 2020 CHRISTMAS CARDS! - UPDATEDSend Fr. Z your snail-mail 2020 CHRISTMAS CARDS! - UPDATED

ALL better than the Vatican Nativity scene.

UPDATE 14 Dec:

I picked up another batch.

Everson, WA
Louisville, KY
S. St. Paul, MN
Elkton, MD
Malone, NY
Cavillo, Ags. C.P., Mexico
Lubec, ME
Uppsala, Sweden
San Antonio, TX
Maria Stein, OH
San Antonio, FL (very interesting reading)
Waltham, MA
Roseville, MN*
Columbia, GA*
Gravesend, Kent
Flushing, NY
Indianapolis, IN (cool stamps)
Cincinnati, OH (very cool stamps)
S. Windor, CT

UPDATE 09 Dec:

I received my first Christmas card today!

And so I begin the list of locations…

Arbor Vitae, WI*
Anchorage, AK
Berkey, OH*
Leawood, KS*
Fayetteville, AR
Santa Fe, NM
Bend, OR
Tokyo
Hopewell, NJ*
Menomonee Fall, WI
Middleton, WI
Floral Park, NY
Dubuque, IA*
Kuna, ID
Ocala, FL
San Jose, CA?
Delmar, NY

 

 


Send Fr. Z your snail-mail 2020 CHRISTMAS CARDS! - UPDATEDIf you would like to send me Christmas greetings or cards, please send by snail mail, if possible with really cool stamps.

Remember mail?

As I have done in years past, I’ll try to post all the places whence they were mailed from around the world.  Keep in mind that if you don’t include your address, I can’t easily do that.

I have a US PO BOX address.

Fr. John Zuhlsdorf
733 Struck St.
PO BOX 44603
Madison, WI 53744-4603

That is the P.O. Box of the Tridentine Mass Society of Madison

PAST ADDRESSES ARE VOID

If you need to send anything that requires a signature, such as gold bars, a Bugatti Chiron, bearer bonds, cases of Pappy Van Winkle, complete Pontifical Mass vestment sets … you know, the usual stuff, get in touch with me for an alternate address.

Please! DO NOT send perishable food items. I am sure they would be wonderful, and neither poisonous nor hallucinogenic… mostly. But, please, just don’t.  I can’t get to the P.O. Box everyday.

If you put glitter in the card, I’ll recite the Maledictory Psalms against you. No. Really.  I will.

If you send something threatening or illegal, I will turn it in to law enforcement.  I’m sorry I have to write that under such a cheery topic, but this is the world we live in, especially in this dreadful year of 2020 with the craziness going on.

I always enjoy the Christmas cards.  The notes and letters which describe the year people have had are interesting and, often, moving.  I read them all.

And drawings by kids are a hoot.

I look forward to seeing your cards!

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Lighter fare | Tagged
Comments Off on Send Fr. Z your snail-mail 2020 CHRISTMAS CARDS! – UPDATED

Distraught woman grabs Francis’ hand and pleads. What did she say? – UPDATED

UPDATE 3 Jan 2020:

What’s this all about?

Is there a pattern here?

UPDATE 1 Jan 2020:

Meanwhile, as the mainstream media has picked this up, in the irritating Crux mail today, I saw this:

Distraught woman grabs Francis' hand and pleads. What did she say? - UPDATED

UPDATE 1 Jan 2020:

I still want to know what she said.  I’ve gotten confirmations that she is not speaking Mandarin or Cantonese, nor Japanese or, seemingly, another common related language.

Originally Published on: Dec 31, 2019

Being a public figure has drawbacks. Being a hugely visible and sought after public figure has lot’s of drawback, including getting grabbed when you really don’t want to be grabbed.

This woman is clearly distraught. She sounds desperate.  I am reminded of the wretched woman who touched the hem of the Lord’s cloak.  On the other hand…

On Twitter we find…

One of my correspondents remarked: “If he had been on the sedia gestatoria this would not have happened.”

I can’t make out what she is saying.

Can you? Seriously. Don’t just guess.

Here is an audio file, which has full speed, then slower, then slower still.

19_12_31_woman_slower

Posted in The Drill | Tagged
123 Comments

From the Seven Sisters Apostolate about distraction during prayer

From the Seven Sisters Apostolate about distraction during prayerI have written about the Seven Sisters Apostolate on other occasions.   It is a great pleasure to know that there is a group organized for my poor person.   As a matter of fact, lately I have wondered on a few occasions if something that happened, or didn’t, was due to their prayers.

In my email this morning there was a message from the Seven Sisters Apostolate which had some good advice to the women involved about prayer and prayers enemy: distraction.  It seems good to pass it along.

Some pointers …

Blessed Christmastide into Epiphany to dearest Sisters in Christ. Happy and prosperous New Decade of the Lord 2020. Truly, the best is yet to be! He makes all things new (Rev 21:5).

Our noble and good work as Seven Sisters does not shield us from the shared experience of anyone who prays: distraction. And how utterly distracting to be distracted when we are so earnestly offering that prayer for another’s benefit! While such disturbances can appear as a huge hindrance in our prayer efforts like Hokusai’s looming Great Wave, they can also serve as an opportunity for growth in humility, trust and perseverance.

The Catechism devotes one of its four parts entirely to prayer. It brims with information and inspiration alike, reminding that prayer is both a gift of grace and a determined response on our part … that always presupposes effort (2725). It is a work of heart, and often a battle of heart.

Following is an abridged version of a talk I recently presented in Bismarck, ND, of Seven Strategies for Harnessing Distractions in Prayer. May it serve to deepen and direct our prayers.

#1 & #2. Pray with and from a place – outside and in. Sources of distraction are exterior (dog barking, whirring fan) and interior (to-do list, wandering thoughts, worries). The Catechism encourages the use of a prayer corner or “little oratory” in one’s home. Seven Sisters practice the discipline of going to a public oratory: an Adoration Chapel or to a sanctuary before the Tabernacle. This sacred space lessens, albeit does not eliminate, distractions. An interior preparation fortifies one’s resolve against distraction. St Teresa of Avila, entitled the Doctor of Prayer, taught it essential to call to mind one’s relationship as beloved in Christ whenever initiating a prayer time. She believed this strengthened an interior focus that in turn affected the whole of the prayer time. St Ignatius of Loyola, likewise reminded for similar results, to pause before prayer and remember that God is already waiting for us and beholding us: “Consider how the Lord my God looks upon me.”

#3. Pray with a Pen. Two ways: (a) writing thoughts that are wandering through your mind (to-do lists, competing images/ideas), and (b) intentional journaling of thoughts/prayers. Both can convert the distraction into opportunity. Jotting down drifting thoughts helps curb temptations to linger in them and ‘records them’ so one could return to them later (grocery item, remembering to attend to something at home, etc.). In intentional journaling, the concentration required to write generates a mindset less likely to succumb to distraction. An added benefit is returning to notes, even years later, to gain perspective/insight on how God is working in one’s life.

#4. Pray with Fasting. An empty stomach can remind one to earnestly pray, “Lord, fill my soul!” Fasting sharpens an interior vision and listening. Scripture reminds that some things come about by prayer and fasting only. A fruit of the Apostolate is the initiative of Fasting Brothers where groups of six men have risen up alongside various Seven Sister groups. Each man chooses a day to fast (excepting Sunday, a day of feasting) and offers this alongside a Seven Sister who is offering a Holy Hour that day. Intentionally refraining from social media, radio, conversations or the like, in preparation for a Seven Sister Adoration Hour is another aspect of fasting. Too much information can clutter one’s consciousness and reduce an ability for the disciplines of meditation, reflection and interior quietness. Being scattered and distracted in prayer may find its genesis in being scattered and distracted outside of prayer. A form of fasting may serve as remedy.

#5. Pray with the company of Saints. Gaining wisdom from Saintly examples of resolute prayer practices is invaluable. Soliciting their help (especially in moments of distraction) always meets with reward. Our Lady’s model and active assistance in your Holy Hour is sure.

#6. Pray with Purpose. Let us pray with the heart of Nathaniel, one without duplicity. Distraction flourishes with ambiguity and a divided heart. The primary purpose of praying for the highest good for the priests (sanctity) both fortifies and forms the Holy Hours. Many Seven Sister intercessors share that they are not “fitting this Holy Hour into their day’s schedule”, but rather a distinction of “allotting this time within their life of prayer” for this purpose. One Seven Sister shared that after her first weekly Hour was offered, she was able to claim this as the first Holy Hour she ever finished… “I had a mission, a purpose – and it was accomplished!”

#7. Pray with Confidence. Responding to Our Lord’s call to this type of prayer, assures His help. His grace is sufficient… His strength made perfect in weakness (II Cor 12:9). Reality dictates that some Hours offered may meet distractions the likes of Hokusai’s wave. Even the wave has its course. It dissipates. While another may rise, it too will pass. Scripture firmly reminds, “Do not throw away your confidence, which has a great reward.” St Teresa of Avila helps us: “Prayer is an act of love… even if sickness distracts from thoughts, all that is needed is the will to love.” Indeed, the strength of His love compels our hearts (II Cor 5:14). With all said, a Seven Sister can offer the suffering of distractions for the benefit of the priest. Only in the marvelous perfection of Divine economy can there be such dividends! St Alphonsus Ligouri offers a word of support, “If you have many distractions at prayer, that prayer of yours may well be upsetting the devil a great deal.” Let us remain of good heart, dear Sisters in Christ, and persist, united, with great confidence, in that to which we are called!

The Seven Sisters Apostolate is terrific and deeply needed right now.  I hope that this good initiative will grow in the coming year.

Perhaps some of you will want to contact them.

HERE

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Priests and Priesthood | Tagged , ,
5 Comments

More nutty from a bishop. Yes, a German bishop.

At Novena News which leads to Kathpress.at we read:

Bishop of Limburg Georg Bätzing made the observation about the Church’s oppression of women and boycott from ordained office in a New Year’s Eve message.

The prelate admitted that he must “take seriously as a bishop that the exclusion of women from ordination offices is perceived as fundamentally unjust and inappropriate in a social environment that has long equated women and men in their rights”.

I’ll tell you what’s unjust.   Hearing this garbage from a bishop – anywhere.  Hearing nutty stuff from Germany constantly is oppressive.

As far as taking something seriously, alas it is hard to include anything that bishop says or thinks.

From Kathpress there’s more nutty.

Bishop of Limburg, Georg Bätzing, also criticized the fact that women in the Catholic Church are excluded from ordination. He must “take seriously as a bishop that the exclusion of women from ordination offices is perceived as fundamentally unjust and inappropriate in a social environment that has long equated women and men with their rights,” said Bätzing.  [One has the sense that he missed that class on ecclesiology.]

Osnabrück’s bishop Franz-Josef Bode wishes the Catholic Church in Germany to be returned to its origins. He could also imagine greater participation by women and priests with families. The church must go back to where people live, love and suffer.  [To which I respond: Kirchensteuer.]

Germany.

Posted in Blatteroons, Liberals, Pò sì jiù | Tagged ,
22 Comments

ASK FATHER: A priest gave me a penance in confession that was too hard

ASK FATHER: A priest gave me a penance in confession that was too hardFrom a reader…

QUAERITUR:

Long ago I went to confession and was given and reluctantly agreed to\ a rather onerous penance not required by justice. I didn’t end up doing it after thinking about it for a while and went to a different priest and asked for a new penance and reconfessed. I told the new priest that I figured he had the power to release me from my older penance. He seemed unsure what to do and just did what I asked. He agreed the penance was extreme. My question: was this legitimate and legal per cannon law or moral theology? Ideally I probably should have gone back to the same priest but did not.

You did the right thing.   First, you didn’t just blow it off, as it were, for being too hard to do.  You checked with another confessor.  In the confessional a confessor can commute another confessor’s suggested penance.

Priests must give penances to penitents and penitents are obliged to fulfill penances themselves (can. 981).  Penances ought to be doable.

People should understand that they can ask the priest for a different penance.  This can be done when in a couple situations.

First, if the penance is so vague that you don’t know if you’ve done it or not.  “Be nice to someone today.”  That’s too vague.   Get a penance that is concrete and doable in a reasonable amount of time after you’ve made your confession.

Second, if the penance is so onerous that you are not sure you can do it.  “Say 200 chaplets of the Rosary while crawling around the outside of the church in the rain with hands and legs tied up with cinctures.”    Nope.  “Not gonna do that.   How about 1 chaplet, while kneeling in the church?”

What is a reasonable amount of time?  Hard to say.  If forced to take a stab at it, I’d say… before Communion of the next Mass scheduled in that place.

Another thing people have to be clear about.  Our mortal sins open up a vast gap between us and God.  Nothing that we can do on our own is proportioned to what it takes to close that gap.  God does it, we don’t.  Hence, every act of penance that the confessor assigns is arbitrary.   We need to do penance, out of justice, but our penance isn’t what bridges the divide.

Furthermore, while we are obliged to do penance as part of our reception of the Sacrament of PENANCE, the validity of the absolution is not dependent on the penance.  We must have a firm purpose of amendment and a desire to do the penance.   But when you are absolved, you are absolved.  You don’t become absolved after doing your penance (i.e., some time later, soon or not).  If you, during your confession did not intend to do the assigned penance and didn’t pipe up, that would be a problem.

And for you priests out there: Don’t be dopes.  Give reasonable penances and use the FORM of Absolution exactly as it is published.  Consider using Latin.

I hope that helps.

And I hope, as we begin a new year, this also helps everyone….

GO TO CONFESSION!

Get this year off to a good start.

GO TO CONFESSION!

How long has it been?

GO TO CONFESSION!

This could be not only your last year, but your last DAY breathing.

GO TO CONFESSION!

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Canon Law, GO TO CONFESSION | Tagged ,
7 Comments

ASK FATHER: Why do Catholics hold their hands open and turned upward during Mass?

From a reader…

QUAERITUR:

I have seen a certain posture at Mass:

Sloppy Orans

Why do you think people do this? Why do they choose this non-Roman posture instead of the orans posture?

And what posture should I do at home? Just stand but with hands doing nothing? and at Mass? Do nothing with the arms and hands?

That photo, in the email, is from Amerika.

I suppose we might call that “I’m So Pious” posture or “Sloppy Orans”.

You will see this more in some places than others, probably because there were liberal priests and/or “liturgists” who told them that this was more meaningful than folded hands because it was more … well… Protestant.

There could also be a measure of imitation of the priest at the altar (versus populum, of course).   Priests are required to use the orans posture at certain times during sacred liturgical worship.  Lay people who are present are not.

To be clear, there are no rubrics for lay people concerning what they do with their hands during Mass… with the exception of the reception of Communion (quod Deus avertat!) on the hand.

Neither this nor the hand-holding things (blech) during the Our Father are prescribed.

There is a little more to be said about Sloppy Orans, however.

Back in 1997 the Holy See’s Pontifical Council for the Laity issued a document entitled Instruction On Certain Questions Regarding the Collaboration of the Non-Ordained Faithful in the Sacred Ministry of Priests.

We read:

Liturgical Celebrations

§ 1. Liturgical actions must always clearly manifest the unity of the People of God as a structured communion.(89) Thus there exists a close link between the ordered exercise of liturgical action and the reflection in the liturgy of the Church’s structured nature.

This happens when all participants, with faith and devotion, discharge those roles proper to them.

§ 2. To promote the proper identity (of various roles) in this area, those abuses which are contrary to the provisions of canon 907 are to be eradicated. In eucharistic celebrations deacons and non-ordained members of the faithful may not pronounce prayers — e.g. especially the eucharistic prayer, with its concluding doxology — or any other parts of the liturgy reserved to the celebrant priest. Neither may deacons or non-ordained members of the faithful use gestures or actions which are proper to the same priest celebrant. It is a grave abuse for any member of the non-ordained faithful to “quasi preside” at the Mass while leaving only that minimal participation to the priest which is necessary to secure validity.

Hence, Sloppy Orans shouldn’t be used.   As a matter of fact, it should be discouraged through proper liturgical catechesis.

 

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000 | Tagged
45 Comments