24 April – Washington DC – BLOGNIC

I will be in Washington, DC from Friday 23 – 26 Monday April.

People are interested in a blognic.

Some people may be in town for the Pontifical Mass at the Shrine of the Immaculate Conception on Saturday 24 April.

Remember: Blognics are not formal.  They are not sit down meals.  People come and go between the start and end times established (we still have to do that, btw).  You pay for your own drinks or food or snacks…. or for someone else’s as you choose.  No expectations other than to come and meet other people who happen to be readers of this or other blogs.

Other bloggers are warmly encouraged to participate!  This is a blognic, after all.

UPDATE:

I am getting from the combox that Saturday 24 April, some time soon after the Mass at the Shrine of the Immaculate Conception, would be the best time for the blognic.  That being the case, some place not far from the Shrine should be considered.

That said, here is a little poll.  Please respond so we can get an idea of the interest and number.

{democracy:53}

 

Posted in Blognics | Tagged
89 Comments

Card. Castrillon praised that French bishop. Why? Something missing from the reporting?

Something has been bothering me in the now viral news story about the letter His Eminence Dario Card. Castrillon Hoyos wrote to the French Bishop Pierre Pican.

You know the facts of the situation.

A French priest Fr. Rene Bissey was a child abuser.  The Bishop of Bayeux-Lisieux learned about this in 1996.  The Vicar General apparently knew about this from a victim’s mother.  At first they had the priest in some neutral assignment and then later gave him a parish.  Fr. Bissey was arrested in 1999, convicted and sentenced to 18 years in prison.  Bishop Pican was also put on trial for seemingly covering up the crimes.  This is also important because this is the first time since the Revolution that a French bishop has been before a civil tribunal.  Bp. Pican was sentenced to three months in prison.

On March 30 the French website Golias published a 2001 letter from Card. Castrillon, then Prefect of the Congregation for Clergy, to Bishop Pican in which the Cardinal wrote:

I congratulate you for not denouncing a priest to the civil administration. You have acted well and I am pleased to have a colleague in the episcopate who, in the eyes of history and of all other bishops in the world, preferred prison to denouncing his son and priest.

The Holy See pretty much threw Card. Castrillon under the bus for that.  Then last week during a conference in Murcia, Spain, Card. Castrillon said that his 2001 letter to Bp. Pican was authorized by late Pope John Paul II and the Cardinal praised Bishop Pican as a model for all bishops because he would not denounce the priest.

This certainly looks very bad.  The mainstream press and even the Holy See seems to be piling on.

But I kept scratching my head over the case, because something just didn’t seem right.

First, Card. Castrillon was the Prefect for Clergy not for Bishops.  I couldn’t get my head around how someone like Card. Castrillon would go so far as to write to that bishop and praise that bishop – who preferred to go to jail rather than denounce a priest who had really committed such terrible crimes.  Was the Cardinal merely being a zealous advocate in favor of priests because he was Prefect for Clergy?

I had the nagging sense that some element missing.

Now I read in Columbia Passport:

According to La Verdad, a regional Spaniard journal, the French bishop did not denounce the priest because he knew it by the first instance under the Sacrament of Confession. According to the Canon Law of the Catholic Church, a priest cannot denounce the matter that is given to him under the gravity of Confession. It includes crimes.

If the bishop was held to silence under the Seal, that could explain how he didn’t think he was able to denounce Fr. Bessey to civil authorities and later gave him an assignment.

When a priest or bishop is bound by the Seal he cannot reveal the contents of the confession to anyone by either word or action. He cannot act on the content of the confession.  If there was nothing else apparent and known openly in Fr. Bessey’s record that would argue against his receiving an assignment, to refuse to give him an assignment would have raised questions about why, whether there was something wrong with him that people didn’t know about.  It could have been perceived as a moral dilemma for the bishop.

It strikes me that this could in some way explain why Card. Castrillon would have penned such a letter.  Furthermore, knowing that the issue was complex, he sought the advice of the Pope before sending it.  At issue was a defense of the Seal of confession.  The French bishop was not being praised for protecting a priest, a criminal priest, but rather for upholding the Seal of confession.

I muse about this because hitherto I had not seen in news stories on this issue any mention that the French bishop had first learned of the priest’s criminal behavior under the Seal of confession.

Questions remain.

If the Vicar General knew, and told the bishop, then the bishop had an independent source of information.  Even in the case it is under normal circumstances still better for priests not to act on the content of a confession, but this was not a normal circumstance.

Why did the bishop consent to hear the confession of one of his priests?  This is a perfect example of why a superior should not receive the confessions of those immediately under his authority: the superior runs the risk of having his hands bound and not being able to act.

The bishop also could have found some other assignment than a parish for the priest, but that would not have solved the problem of having in the ranks of the presbyterate a criminal child molester.

In any event, perhaps I had merely missed the mention of the Seal in earlier reporting – in fact I haven’t followed this too closely because of other work.  Maybe some of you saw it earlier.

But I think it is an important dimension to this story which needs to be clarified.

Discussion of the “boundaries” of the Seal comes into play.

UPDATE 1607 GMT:

I found a Washington Post story here which mentions the issue of confession.

Posted in Clerical Sexual Abuse, The Drill | Tagged , , , ,
46 Comments

Bishops – read this. Deacons – read this. Hey priests…

I’m in.  I don’t know what it will be yet.  But I’m in.

Take a look at this entry at The Deacon’s Bench.  It was a proposal by a Deacon Charles Rohrbacher.  He is suggesting that while bishops say they are sorry right and left about the clerical sexual abuse of children, and their own role in that abuse, people are not entirely impressed or convinced.

The deacon has a suggestion.

Here is an excerpt, but I suggest that you read the whole piece.  I am adding a little emphases and a comment.

[…]

One repeated criticism of them has been that even in their apologies, they have resembled corporate executives rather than pastors. In a real sense, they have not yet responded, either as a body or as individual bishops in a Catholic enough way. All the more remarkable because of our rich tradition of public penance and outward signs of repentance and contrition, but unfortunately, to date, very few of our bishops have entered the public practice of our Catholic penitential tradition.

The Holy Father in the past couple of days has called us as a Church to penance, which is good and appropriate up to a point (because we are all part of the Body of Christ) but misdirected, I think, because the faithful were not responsible for the decisions that caused so much harm to victims and scandal. It is the bishops themselves who need to seek God’s forgiveness and the forgiveness of those who were harmed because of their failure to protect the most vulnerable members of their flock from abusive priests and to implore God’s mercy on behalf those clerics who molested children and young people (most of whom are unrepentant and evade all responsibility for their crimes).

So here is my question for you. What if our bishops chose to do public penance? What if they lay prostrate or knelt in front of their cathedrals as penitents before each Mass on the weekend closest to the feast of St.Peter and Paul or on the feast of the Sacred Heart of Jesus or some other appropriate day or days? Or, even better, on the first Friday of every month for the next year starting with the feast of the Sacred Heart or Sts.Peter and Paul? And what if we, as their deacons, as an order in the Church, in all humility, not only called on our bishops to do public penance, but offered to join them in it?  [OORAH!]

As deacons we invite God’s holy people to pray for mercy in the Penitential Rite. As deacons we call God’s priestly people to pray for the needs of the Church and world at every Mass. As deacons on Good Friday, it is our part to invite our bishop and priests and all the faithful to kneel in prayer.

Just as I think it is our part to call our bishops to do public penance, I think it is also our part to join them in penance as well. Clearly, our place is with our bishops: we stand at the side of our bishop during every celebration of the liturgy and the sacraments, ready to assist them.

I’m in.  I will figure out some penance to do on a regular basis.  The whole Church needs to do penance publicly. 

Bishops and deacons and priests who never committed any of those horrid crimes need to do penance as well.  We need to do this as a body.

Perhaps we can bring this to another level.

I think this is on the right track.  Along with my own proposal of a true renewal of our worship, this should be another component.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
59 Comments

Provocative piece to put the recent controversies in perspective

Take a look at this:

“There are cases of sexual abuse that come to light every day against a large number of members of the Catholic clergy. Unfortunately it’s not a matter of individual cases, but a collective moral crisis that perhaps the cultural history of humanity has never before known with such a frightening and disconcerting dimension. Numerous priests and religious have confessed. There’s no doubt that the thousands of cases which have come to the attention of the justice system represent only a small fraction of the true total, given that many molesters have been covered and hidden by the hierarchy.”

You might be interested in a post by Italian journalist Massimo Introvigne on Mercator.

That quote at the top of this entry is at the top of Introvigne’s piece.  

Read and then discuss.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

POLL ALERT! (Not really) POLL ALERT!

This was from CMR about POTUS and SCOTUS:

CNN Poll: 39% of Americans Drunk Right Now

Shock poll. A CNN poll released Wednesday indicates that 61 percent of the public expect the president to nominate a liberal to replace John Paul Stevens on the Supreme Court.

That clearly means that 39% of Americans right now are drunk, concussed, or just plain stupid.

Seriously, who’s answering these questions?

Posted in Lighter fare, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged ,
8 Comments

Should seminarians still keep their heads down about being, say, Catholic? Still?

TwitterIn my US seminary days, we had to hide going certain places, such as parishes where the priests believed in One God, Creator of heaven and earth, etc.  One of my classmates was thrown out because he had a statue of Our Lady of Fatima in his room ("exaggerated Marian devotion").   Latin liturgy?   Ha.  In my Rome seminary days, it was anything having to do with the older form of Mass.  Some men were yelled at because they went to St. Mary Major and visited the tomb of St. Pius V … on the feast of St. Pius V, the new calendar’s feast of St. Pius V. 

In many ways times are changing, and they have been for a long while.  But there is still a long way to go.  It is better in some places than other.  The restoration, the "Marshall Plan" is taking effect, after the devastation.  It will work, but there is still resistance in some places.

From the blog of Damian Thompson:

English seminarians who follow Benedict are keeping their heads down

By Damian Thompson

This isn’t news to English seminarians, but perhaps other Catholics are not aware of a situation I find rather shaming.

If you’re a seminarian or prospective seminarian who wishes to implement the liturgical renewal inspired by Pope Benedict XVI, it’s best to keep fairly quiet about it. Things aren’t as bad as they were a few years ago, when any seminarian caught reading Ratzinger would be tested for “psychological immaturity” by a feminist. [That’s the sort of thing that was happening in my US seminary over 20 years ago.  If that is going on in English seminaries, still, they are … how do you say this delicately … a little behind the curve.] The worship in certain seminaries has moved on from the 1960s to the 1980s (hence the discreet shoulder pads sewn into those zip-up albs) [LOL! ZOT!] and staff have reluctantly accepted that tomorrow’s priests will be more conservative than they are (not difficult, in truth). But it’s still not safe to express too much enthusiasm for the Extraordinary Form, lest you identify yourself with fringe Catholics like, um, the Pope.

Oh, and don’t be caught reading this blog.

There is a list of blogs they shouldn’t be caught reading, or books.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Our Catholic Identity, Pope of Christian Unity, SESSIUNCULA |
45 Comments

No brainer from Germany: 44% would go to the OLD, traditional Mass

In order to have a clear, effective voice in the world, Catholics need to have a clear understanding of who they are and what they believe. 

In order to have a strong Catholic identity we must revitalize our Catholic worship.

In order to revitalize our Catholic worship we must reconnect our worship to our tradition – restore continuity.

With a biretta tip to Sancte Pater who lead me to Eponymous Flower via PaixLiturgique we have this… which does not surprise me in the least.

"But Father! But Father!", you may be saying.  "Why?  Why are you not surprised?"

Because dear readers people aren’t stupid.

Paix Liturgique Exclusive Survey: in Germany, 44% of practicing Catholics would regularly attend the traditional Mass if the Motu Proprio was applied!

At least 44% of practicing Catholics in Germany would regularly participate in an Old Mass, if the requirements of the Motu Proprio ‘Summorum Pontificum’ were established in their country.

This was reported by the French organization ‘paixliturgique.org‘ today in an article.

The organization maintains, that a great part of the German hierarchy is hostile to the liturgical rapprochement desired by the Pope.

The Bishops are at pains to disparage the numbers of requests for the Use of the Motu Proprio.

Indeed, now ‘paixliturgique.com’ has launched a representative poll with the US opinion research institute ‘Harris Interactive’. [Perhaps more professional than what US Catholic did recently?]

The poll was held from the 18th to the 25th of February. 2,611 Catholic households in Germany with ages above 18 were questioned. Here are the questions and answers:

First Question: Do you go to Holy Mass?

Every Week: 5.9% [Holy cow.]
Once a Month: 4.1% [Remember this stat too.]
For a big Holy Day: 18.9%
Occasionally (e.g., weddings, funerals): 42.3%
Never: 28.8%

Second Question: Do you know, that the Pope has allowed two forms of Mass, a modern one with the people facing the priest and communion in the hand, and the traditional latin, with the priest facing the altar and Communion orally received on the knees?

Yes: 43.1%
No: 56.9%  [WHAT?]

Third Question: Would it be normal, if both forms were regularly celebrated in your community?

Normal: 50,6% [TA DA!]
Not Normal: 24.5%
No Opinion: 24.9%

[HERE WE GO…] Fourth Question: Would you attend the old Mass, even if the new Mass were also celebrated nearby?

Answer of regular or monthly Massgoers:

25 percent would participate every week.
19 percent would participate once a month
. [44%]
9 percent would participate by great feasts.  [Which means many more.]
40 percent would occasionally [wow] participate.
 7 percent would never, [ever?] attend. [wow, only 7?]

The organization ‘paixliturgique.com’ maintains, that every fourth German who practices would attend the Old Mass every Sunday, if he had the opportunity in his community.  [1 in 4]

A further 19 percent would at least attend the old Mass once a month. That gives a total figure of 44 percent.

In Germany 1,185,310 Catholics go to Mass every Sunday. A further 823,690 visit Church services at least once a month.

‘Paixliturgique.com’ informs, that this investigation in Germany yielded similar results in Paris, Versailles, Italy and all of France. [So… all the blather from liberals that there isn’t much interest is … what… blather?]

Opposition against the Old Mass is, with 25 Percent of all Catholics, in a decisive minority.

Catholic Knight reports similar numbers for the States, here.

The key is marketing.  The key is word of mouth.   Word of mouth is very power.

I would like to make recommendations.

  • If you not are attending Holy Mass regularly on Sundays and feasts, get off your rear ends and go.  Especially if other depend on you.  If you are not going regularly, you are endangering your soul.  Hell is real and forever. A couple hours of your precious week isn’t too much to give to GOD.
  • If you have found a church with Holy Mass that really appeals to you, invite people to go.  You all know people who have fallen away or who are falling or who have a hard time going.  Just do it.
  • If you are regularly attending Holy Mass in a traditional form, start inviting people to go with you to experience what you experience. 
  • If you are regularly going to Holy Mass, but not in the traditional form, and if you don’t know it: find a way to good.  Experience this important facet of the Roman Rite.

Never underestimate the power of your invitation.

You have an incredibly power tool at your disposal. 

Everyone appreciates an invitation.  They might not accept (at first), but they will be flattered that you made it.  You might need to invite 10 people until 1 comes, or 1 person 10 times.  But invitations are powerful.

What would happen to a community were everyone to start inviting people?  Evangelicals do this.  Can’t we?

I think we have a moral and spiritual imperative to help fallen away Catholics return to their faith, and help people who are confused find clarity.

It may be that people don’t like what they experience.  At least they will make an informed decision.  We should not be afraid of their reactions.  At the same time, do everything in your power to make sure that their experience is of Holy Mass and not … well… jerks.

More tips:

  • Show joy.  Few things you show others when you invite them are going to be more attractive to others.
  • Don’t run down what they are regularly experiencing.
  • Be ready to give reasons for… what they are about to experience.
  • Don’t be jerks.
  • This applies to how you approach priests whom you hope to have celebrate Holy Mass in a reverent and Catholic manner.

Get out there and start inviting.

 

Posted in "But Father! But Father!", Brick by Brick, SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
42 Comments

Former Vicar General in Archd. of Munich denies taking the fall for the future Pope

A reader alerted me to this.

In Suddeutsche Zeitung the former Vicar-General of the Archdiocese of Munich-Freising under then Archbp. Ratzinger, Msgr. Gerhard Gruber, says that Card. Ratzinger did not, in fact, know about the appointment of "Fr. H" to an assignment in Munich who had abused children in Essen.

Some people suggested that Msgr. Gruber had simply been directed to take the fall for a culpable future Pope.

It is important to understand – and this is something that people who are set against the truth of the matter – that Vicars General in German dicoese handle personnel matters and that Papa Ratzinger is not, has not been, a close micro-manager.

Ex-Generalvikar wehrt sich

München – Der ehemalige Generalvikar des Münchner Erzbistums, Gerhard Gruber, hat gegenüber der Süddeutschen Zeitung Berichten widersprochen, wonach ihn das Erzbistum gedrängt habe, die Verantwortung für den Einsatz des pädophilen Priesters H. auf sich zu nehmen, um den heutigen Papst Benedikt XVI. aus der Schusslinie zu nehmen. Es sei tatsächlich seine Entscheidung gewesen, H. im Jahr 1980 in einer Gemeinde einzusetzen; er habe sie gemeinsam mit dem inzwischen verstorbenen Personalreferenten Friedrich Fahr getroffen, aber nicht mit Erzbischof Joseph Ratzinger besprochen. Auslöser für die Berichte ist offenbar ein Rundbrief, den zwei Freunde Grubers verschickt haben. Gruber sagt, er habe mit einem Freund telefoniert, der Inhalte des Gesprächs "wohlmeinend, aber unglücklich" weiterverbreitet habe. Der Brief enthalte "Ungenauigkeiten und gravierende Falschmeldungen". Er habe dem Freund zu verstehen gegeben, dass er unter Zeitdruck gestanden habe. Aber weder sei ihm ein vorgefertigtes Schriftstück zur Unterzeichnung vorgelegt worden noch sei er ins Erzbischöfliche Ordinariat zitiert worden. mai

 

UPDATE:

Translation by a German native speaker, from a comment below:

Munich – The former vicar general of the archdiocese of Munich, Gerhard Gruber, in the Süddeutsche Zeitung objected to reports [mad, as far as I know, in the left-leaning SPIEGEL Magazine] that he had been pressed by the archdiocese to take on himself the responsibility for the employment of the pedophile priest H. in order to take the current Pope Benedict XVI out of the firing line, stating it had in fact been his decision to employ H. in the year 1980 in a parish, which he had made together with the since deceased Friedrich Fahr, the Personnel Officer, but not discussed with Archbishop Joseph Ratzinger.
These reports were apparently triggered by a circular letter sent by two of Gruber’s friends. Gruber said he had spoken on the telephone with a friend who then, “with the best intentions but infelicitously”, passed on some contents of the conversation. The letter, he said, contained “inaccuracies and serious misreporting.” He had made it clear to the friend that he was under time pressure. But he never had been presented with a prepackaged document for his signature, nor had he been summoned to the Archdiocesan chancery. mai

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, Clerical Sexual Abuse, Pope of Christian Unity, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
15 Comments

23-26 April – Washington DC – BLOGNIC?

I will be in Washington, DC from Friday 23 – 26 Monday April.

I am wondering if anyone might be interested in a blognic.

There may be some people in town for the Pontifical Mass.

Posted in What Fr. Z is up to |
Comments Off on 23-26 April – Washington DC – BLOGNIC?

Bishops in Virgina urge support of amendment to restrict funding of abortions

From CNA comes this:

Virginia bishops: Budget amendment offers chance to end state-funded abortions

Richmond, Va., Apr 20, 2010 / 06:06 am (CNA).- The Virginia Catholic Conference (VCC) [The Catholic bsihops in Virginia] has urged the passage of a proposed budget amendment to restrict state funding of abortions, saying it is an “unprecedented opportunity” to eliminate the vast majority of state-funded abortions.

Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell proposed the amendment, which will be considered by the Virginia General Assembly on Wednesday.

A press release from the VCC said that Virginia has funded abortions “for reasons that go well beyond even what federal and state statutes require.”

The Catholic bishops of Virginia “strongly support” the amendment, urging Catholics to ask their legislators to vote in favor of the amendment and to alert other Virginians to the need to pass it. Its website provides a form for Virginians to contact their legislators.

The VCC said “countless lives” can be saved, possibly more than 100 per year.

“In prayer and in public, your voices are urgently needed to bring Gospel values to bear on decisions that literally determine life and death!” the Conference said.

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras | Tagged
5 Comments