I don’t often look at these "Hitler finds out about [FILL IN BLANK]" videos, but this one is pretty funny.
If you understand German, you might have to turn the audio down a little bit so you won’t be distracted by what the Führer is really saying.
I don’t often look at these "Hitler finds out about [FILL IN BLANK]" videos, but this one is pretty funny.
If you understand German, you might have to turn the audio down a little bit so you won’t be distracted by what the Führer is really saying.
Pain is a matter of perspective and priority. You cease to think of your headache if you hit your thumb with a hammer.
After the last couple of weeks of slime in the MSM, how pleasant it seems – by contrast – to be able to post something about SSPX bishop Richard Williamson.
From AFP with my emphases and comments.
Catholic group silences Holocaust-denying bishop
Thu, Apr 15, 2010
AFPBERLIN – A breakaway ultra-conservative Catholic group ordered British [SSPX] bishop Richard Williamson not to speak in public or testify at his trial for denying the Holocaust, German media reported Thursday.
The secretary general of the Saint Pius X Society, Father Christian Thouvenot, wrote to Williamson, a leading member of the group, telling him to stop giving interviews or communicating publicly, according to the daily Tagesspiegel, which obtained a copy of the letter.
Williamson’s lawyer, Matthias Lossman, on Wednesday confirmed that the bishop, who lives in London, would not attend his trial which opens in the southern German city of Regensburg on Friday.
The society told Williamson to "stop communicating by Internet, be it by blog, forum or via his web page," the Tagesspiegel said.
He has also been ordered not to give interviews on general issues, and only to speak on matters of faith after obtaining permission from the society.
Williamson was fined 12,000 euros (S$22,473) earlier this year after giving a television interview in Germany in 2009 in which he argued that only "200,000 to 300,000 Jews perished in Nazi concentration camps" and denied there had ever been any gas chambers.
A further trial was ordered after he refused to pay, [ROFL!] although the Regensburg court does not require the bishop to be present. [Which is a not comforting.]
Denying that the Holocaust took place, or questioning key elements, is illegal in Germany and Austria.
Williamson’s comments prompted a rare comment on religious matters by German Chancelor Angela Merkel, who called on Pope Benedict XVI to "clarify unambiguously that there can be no denial" the Nazis killed six million Jews. [No evidence that anyone is getting any smarter when it comes to this.]
The pope has drawn strong criticism for reversing the excommunication of Williamson and three other bishops in the Saint Pius X Society.
I suspect Fr. Kung was getting nervous about not reading his name in the paper for a while, and so he staged another little nutty for the press.
German theologian urges bishops to pressure pope
By JUERGEN BAETZ (AP) – 3 hours ago
BERLIN — Dissident theologian Hans Kueng urged bishops on Thursday to push for reforms in the Roman Catholic in defiance of Pope Benedict XVI. [True to form. I am surprised to see "dissident"… unless in the AP’s dictionary "dissident" is a good thing.]
Kueng, an 82-year-old former colleague and friend of the pontiff, said the church was now in its deepest crisis since the Protestant Reformation after recent revelations of sexual abuse by clergy caused an erosion of trust. [Could the crisis have been exacerbated by people such as… say… Hans Kung?]
In an editorial published Thursday in daily Sueddeutsche Zeitung and other publications, Kueng said bishops should call for a new synod to discuss reforms. [He is not talking about a synod. He is talking about a Council.]
Kueng accused pope of not living up "to the great challenges of our time," saying on the fifth anniversary of Benedict’s election to the papacy that his traditionalist approach had failed. [Kung has ever thought that Vatican II didn’t create nearly as deep a break with the past as was needed (to his mind).]
Bishops should not be "actors without voice or rights," Kueng said, arguing that it was legitimate for them to press Roman authorities for reforms if the pope blocked their efforts. [Blocking efforts to do what, exactly?]
[…]
"It may not be silenced [That’s not an awkward translation…] that the worldwide system of covering-up of sexual offenses by clergy men was steered by Cardinal Ratzinger’s Roman Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith," Kueng said in the editorial, which also appeared in the New York Times, La Repubblica and other dailies in France, Spain and Switzerland. [Kung – unless he is simply senile – is purposely distorting the truth. He is too intelligent not to know what he is saying isn’t true.]
[…]
Germany’s justice minister, Sabine Leutheusser-Schnarrenberger, met Thursday with the head of the German Bishops Conference, Robert Zollitsch — two months after she had irked him [No translation problems there! Nosirree!] by saying she believed the church was not truly interested in clearing up all sexual abuse cases.
The justice minister has spoken of a "wall of silence" surrounding the church. [Impartial zealous advocate for justice. right?]
Some German dioceses have reported big increases this year in the number of people leaving the church. Zollitsch’s Freiburg archdiocese said 2,711 left the church in the southwestern region in March — compared with 1,058 a year earlier. [Are they just dodging the church tax?]
The Wuerzburg diocese in Bavaria said 1,233 left the church there in March — three times the 407 recorded a year earlier. The Munich archdiocese, where Benedict once served as archbishop, said it did not yet have figures for March.
Associated Press Writer Verena Schmitt-Roschmann in Berlin contributed to this report.
I made a correction to the top of this entry about what the Times wrote concerning Archbishop Nichols. A couple readers pointed out an error I made in respect the Times story. Thanks!
___
In the current number of the UK’s best Catholic weekly The Catholic Herald you will find two pieces of interest about the recent accusations leveled against the Archbishop of Westminster, Most Rev. Vincent Nichols. The Times alleged that Nichols, while he was Archbishop of Birmingham,
“… presided over a child protection system that allowed a paedophile priest to continue abusing schoolboys despite repeated complaints from victims…."
The Archdiocese of Westminster states that the claim is false. Apparently Archbishop Nichols is considering legal remedy against those who made the false claim.
For the Catholic Herald take see here and, the opinion piece, here.
For the Times.
It is pretty clear that The Times has joined its nearly homonymous counterpart in New York (aka Hell’s Bible) in the MSM campaign to undermine the Church’s moral authority. The climate of discourse in England is markedly more brutal than many Americans are accustomed to engage in. Also, the British society in general is already in a state of more advanced decomposition than in United States in terms of the rotting fruits of secularization and relativism. The US is rapidly catching up.
It should therefore come as no surprise that the UK’s MSM will ratchet up with particularly harsh attacks on the Church, particularly in advance of the Holy Father’s upcoming pastoral visit to England.
My I recommend to all my English readers that you obtain and read Aidan Nichols’s books The Realm and Criticising the Critics? I suspect that they may be a little hard to get: they won’t have been popular with the powers that be.
I digress.
Here is the newsy piece from The Catholic Herald about what the MSM is doing to Archbishop Nichols with my E & C.:
Archbishop Nichols takes legal advice over newspaper’s allegation
By Mark Greaves16 April 2010
Archbishop Vincent Nichols of Westminster is considering legal action against the Times newspaper over its allegation that he tried to protect a paedophile.
The story, published on the front page on Saturday, marked a new low in relations between the Church and the British media.
The paper alleged that the Archbishop "protected" a priest who abused children at a Benedictine school in west London – even though, as then Archbishop of Birmingham, he had no involvement in the case.
A Church spokesman said: "The attempt to saddle the Archbishop with responsibility for this tragic case is completely unfounded and is an unwarranted slur. His office is taking legal advice." [OORAH!]
Sources close to Westminster have confirmed that one of the options being considered is a possible court action for defamation.
The story came amid what has been described as a "feeding frenzy" in the press over the Church’s handling of clerical sex abuse.
Bishop Kieran Conry of Arundel and Brighton said the Times report showed "all sorts of misapprehensions" about the Church.
He said: "If the Archbishop of Westminster is perceived to be the head of the Catholic Church in this country, which is a fallacy, [But probably a common assumption in England,] then everything that happens, happens on his watch. The Ealing case is an example of that. [The media] assume the Archbishop runs everything, including the Benedictines." [Similarly, editors of the secularized liberal MSM in USA foster the bizarre fantasy that the Pope pulls strings in parishes.]
In 2006 and 2007 Fr David Pearce abused a boy at St Benedict’s Abbey in Ealing even though, as a result of previous allegations, he was forbidden from contact with children. The Times pointed out that Archbishop Nichols was chairman of the Catholic Office for the Protection of Children and Vulnerable Adults (Copca) at the time. However, he was not involved in the case and responsibility for the priest lay with the Benedictines who ran the school.
Bishop Conry, a frank critic of the Church’s handling of sex abuse cases, also condemned attempts to implicate Pope Benedict XVI in abuse cover-ups.
"[The media] is clutching at straws," he said. "They are trying to generate stories that aren’t necessarily there."
The latest attempt to implicate the Pope came in a report by the Associated Press which claimed that he delayed laicising a paedophile priest because of concerns over "the good of the universal Church". [That phrase "the good of the universal Church" is constantly repeated in the MSM, but with little understanding of the force of the phrase, as a part of the curial boiler-plate common to petitions made by priests to the Holy See to be dispensed from the obligations of the clerical state. My experience is that few of the religion writers for MSM outlets have even half of a notion of what they are writing about. This present MSM coverage is a demonstration of how little they know but how determined they are to make "facts" they don’t in the least understand support their pre-determined goals. Ah, that unbeatable combination of ignorance and arrogance.]
Reports failed to note that it was the priest himself, Fr Stephen Kiesle, who asked to be laicised, therefore it was not a punishment for abuse. He had, in fact, already been suspended from active ministry, and had been given a three-year suspended sentence for sexually assaulting two boys.
Bishop Conry is one of many commentators – both Catholic and secular – to strongly criticise media coverage of the abuse scandal.
Austen Ivereigh, co-ordinator of Catholic Voices, a project training well-known Catholics to speak to the media during the Pope’s visit, said the Church was being used as a scapegoat for widespread child sex abuse. [I don’t often agree with Mr. Ivereigh, but he sure got that right.]
In an article for America magazine, he said: "The coverage has now moved into a new, irrational phase. The media have merged with the mob. They are not standing outside the crowd, coolly examining the facts. They are standing in locus vulgi [the place of the crowd]." [I will drill into Mr. Ivereigh’s piece elsewhere. It is worth your time.]
The Times, he claimed, had "led the way in promoting hysteria and distortion". He cited coverage in the Sunday Times of a plan by Richard Dawkins and Christopher Hitchens to arrest the Pope.
"Rather than report this as a publicity gimmick, or at least point out how dubious are the legal arguments, the Times reports this as if it is a perfectly sensible response to established facts, ["facts"] and even enlists a semi-Catholic columnist [Libby Purves] to agree with the idea," he wrote.
George Weigel, an American Catholic author, claimed that the "scandal-mongering had now metastasised [good image] into a full-scale assault on Catholicism itself".
He said the papal trip to Britain was "in trouble" and urged English and Welsh bishops to devote "the next four months to the most vigorous defence of the truth of Catholic faith". [And who in the UK is going to step up and do that?]
Both Mr Weigel and Mr Ivereigh pointed out that many of the recent child abuse stories had been supplied to journalists by lawyers bringing class actions against the Church. [Not to mention "retired" Archbp. Rembert Weakland.] "The interpretations which the lawyers are keen to put on them are precisely those which the media uncritically adopt," Dr Ivereigh said.
Jeffrey Steel, [Anglican convert and] a blogger and theologian who set up the Facebook group "Catholics who condemn the media’s treatment of the Pope", which now has over 2,400 members, said he had "completely lost respect" for the Times as a newspaper.
Mr Steel said: "The person who has been most responsible for trying to sort out [clergy sex abuse] is our present Holy Father. Why aren’t they trying to support him rather than look for a smoking gun that isn’t there?"
Brendan O’Neill, the humanist editor of Spiked Online, described the campaign against the Pope as "a secular Inquisition". He said it had acquired "a powerfully pathological, obsessive" character in which "scaremongering supersedes facts".
Fr Timothy Radcliffe, a Dominican theologian, said the reporting of the abuse scandal had been "unjust". [Radcliffe … My list of those with whom I am surprised to find myself in agreement is growing.]
He said: "Of course we need the scrutiny of the media. They have been necessary to make us face this terrible failure. [Agreed… in the first big wave in the early 2000’s.] But often facts are misreported, innuendo is used to undermine innocent people’s reputation, as with the case of Archbishop Nichols and the Pope, in ways that are simply unjust. The media rightly demand that the Church be accountable for its failures, but the media, too, must by accountable for the way that they can undermine the very people who are doing everything possible to confront this scandal."
James Bogle, chairman of the Catholic Union of Great Britain, said the attempt to draw Pope Benedict into the abuse scandal was "irresponsible journalism".
He described recent attacks on the Pope in the Times, notably by columnist India Knight, as "sick-making".
"There is simply no evidence [of the Pope’s complicity], but that cuts no ice in a media frenzy where merely to believe in religion is sufficient basis for presumed guilt of the most awful crimes," he said. [A frenzy on the surface. It is cold and calculating underneath.] "This is not freedom, justice or liberalism. This is dark, sinister intolerance, bigotry and religious vilification of the sort that used to flourish in this country 200 years ago when Catholics were persecuted simply for being Catholic. [Do I hear an "Amen!"?] Civilised and liberal-minded people had hoped that sort of intolerance was long gone. Tragically, it seems to be making a comeback." [Which tells us something about what is going on in a society under the near complete domination of the dictatorship of relativism. The powers behind the dominant message stream in the MSM hate this Pope because he has clearly described what they are up to and the consequences of their dehumanizing of cultures and societies.]
This week the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith published online its guidelines to bishops on how to deal with abuse.
According to the Vatican commentator John Allen, the document makes explicit for the first time the need for bishops to report abuse to the police. It states: "Civil law concerning reporting of crimes to the appropriate authorities should always be followed."
Meanwhile, Vatican spokesman Fr Federico Lombardi defended Pope Benedict as a credible leader on the issue of priestly sex abuse, saying his respect for truth and transparency stood out against recent "unfounded insinuations".
A spokesman for the Times said it stood by its story. [Of course it does.]
How you can subscribe to The Catholic Herald. They also have an exemplary online version of the entire weekly, if you are, for example, not in England and are worry about lack of postal alacrity.
A reader down under said that Australia’s Sydney Morning Herald has a piece about how the Holy Father and Church have been attacked.
Let’s have a glance.
Evildoers, not Pope, to blame
April 15, 2010Miranda Devine
Sydney Morning Herald columnistThe pursuit of the Pope reached absurd heights this week with news that atheists Richard Dawkins and Christopher Hitchens have asked the Australian barrister Geoffrey Robertson to draw up a case to arrest Benedict XVI for alleged cover-up of paedophilia in the Catholic Church.
That these exhibitionist atheists should seize on the tragedy of child sexual abuse by a small minority of Catholic priests to pursue their vendetta against religion is stomach-turning. [OORAH!] Dawkins has become shrill with excitement, describing the Pope as ”a leering old villain in a frock”.
He said the Pope "should remain in charge of the whole rotten edifice – the whole profiteering, woman-fearing, guilt-gouging, truth-hating, child-raping institution – while it tumbles, amid a stench of incense and a rain of tourist-kitsch sacred hearts and preposterously crowned virgins, around his ears”. From what deep cesspool of hatred do those words spring?
But it is even more nauseating to read about the priests who abused children [I agree.]
[…]
Just to contemplate the depths of human depravity can make you wonder about the value of life at all. But it also has to be said that if paedophilia seems to be on the increase, it has been enabled by the eroticisation of our culture over decades, and even priests are not immune.
Why, for instance, should the Dutch be surprised by the launch in 2006 of a paedophile party, the Charity, Freedom and Diversity (NVD) party, which wanted to cut the age of consent from 16 to 12. Since dissolved, it was just another step in the continuum of social disorder in which the taboos and social norms protecting children break down.
In a similar vein were moves in 2003 by psychiatrists at an American Psychiatric Association conference to stop classifying pedophilia as a mental disorder, thus normalising it as just another sexual preference.
It is the Catholic Church which has been most vocal about the breakdown of moral order, from paedophilia to abortion. And this has made it a target of those who object to moralising they regard as an infringement of their freedoms.
You can read the rest over there.
In the future, when we are discussing the present controversies with people, we must be well-informed, ready to explain.
From the gentlemanly Sandro Magister comes this:
After an Accusation, Here is What Happens at the Vatican
The guidelines of the congregation for the doctrine of the faith on the steps to be taken when sexual abuse against minors is alleged
by Sandro Magister
ROME, April 13, 2010 – As of yesterday, the document reproduced below has been available on the Vatican website, summarizing the procedures in use for a few years in the Catholic Church in cases of sexual abuse against minors by persons in holy orders.
By minors is meant persons under the age of 18, while by acts of pedophilia is meant abuses committed against children who have not reached puberty. [What is missing here is the distinction about ephebophilia.]
Of the approximately three thousand allegations sent to the congregation for the doctrine of the faith from 2001 until today, of abuse against minors committed over the past fifty years, the cases of pedophilia strictly speaking are 10 percent of the total. 60 percent of the cases are of sexual attraction for adolescents of the same sex, [ephebophilia, right?] while the remaining 30 percent involve relations with teenage girls.
Most of the cases examined have ended with administrative and disciplinary sanctions against the accused: a faster and more effective procedure than an actual legal trial. [Because of the changes to procedures which Card. Ratzinger strove to have implemented.]
For reporting abuse to the civil authorities, the Holy See orders that local laws be followed. This means that in countries with an Anglo-Saxon legal culture and in France, criminal charges are obligatory. Where this is not the case, the Holy See encourages the victims to approach the courts themselves.
The changes announced in the last paragraph of the document specifically concern the abolition of the statute of limitations, which since 2001 has been 10 years, starting from the victim’s eighteenth birthday. Even now, however, the statute of limitations is not binding, and allegations are also accepted for actions that occurred longer ago.
So here is the text of the guidelines, in its official English version:
_______________
Guide to Understanding Basic CDF Procedures concerning Sexual Abuse Allegations
The applicable law is the Motu Proprio "Sacramentorum sanctitatis tutela" (MP SST) of 30 April 2001 together with the 1983 Code of Canon Law.
This is an introductory guide which may be helpful to lay persons and non-canonists.
A: Preliminary Procedures
The local diocese investigates every allegation of sexual abuse of a minor by a cleric.
If the allegation has a semblance of truth [then] the case is referred to the CDF. The local bishop transmits all the necessary information to the CDF and expresses his opinion on the procedures to be followed and the measures to be adopted in the short and long term.
Civil law concerning reporting of crimes to the appropriate authorities should always be followed.
During the preliminary stage and until the case is concluded, the bishop may impose precautionary measures to safeguard the community, including the victims. Indeed, the local bishop always retains power to protect children by restricting the activities of any priest in his diocese. This is part of his ordinary authority, which he is encouraged to exercise to whatever extent is necessary to assure that children do not come to harm, and this power can be exercised at the bishop’s discretion before, during and after any canonical proceeding.
B: Procedures authorized by the CDFThe CDF studies the case presented by the local bishop and also asks for supplementary information where necessary.
The CDF has a number of options:
B1 Penal Processes
The CDF may authorize the local bishop to conduct a judicial penal trial before a local Church tribunal. Any appeal in such cases would eventually be lodged to a tribunal of the CDF. [If there is a local trial, the appeal goes to the CDF.]
The CDF may authorize the local bishop to conduct an administrative penal process before a delegate of the local bishop assisted by two assessors. The accused priest is called to respond to the accusations and to review the evidence. [This is streamlined.] The accused has a right to present recourse to the CDF against a decree condemning him to a canonical penalty. The decision of the Cardinals members of the CDF is final. [It is unclear to me if this means the plenary meeting of the Cardinal members of the Congregation, or the smaller groups which meet regularly during the year. Also, you would think that the POPE has the final word. But this is the way it is set up under the direction of this Pope. Also, you should know that a Congregation isn’t just a building: it is the body of the members appointed who are gathered together "congregated". This includes Cardinals and also other prelates from around the world. The members in Rome have regular meeetings. This is why these curial appointments, such as that of Archbishop Burke, is important. Some Cardinal or other prelate might come to Rome once in a while, but those who are there have their influence in the actual day to day workings of the other dicasteries to which he is appointed. Archbp. Burke is the head of the Segnatura, but he belongs also, for example, to the Congregation for Bishops. But I digress.]
Should the cleric be judged guilty, both judicial and administrative penal processes can condemn a cleric to a number of canonical penalties, the most serious of which is dismissal from the clerical state. The question of damages can also be treated directly during these procedures. [It is unclear to me what these "damages" might include. I am not sure that this is monetary.]
B2 Cases referred directly to the Holy Father
In very grave cases where a civil criminal trial has found the cleric guilty of sexual abuse of minors or where the evidence is overwhelming, the CDF may choose to take the case directly to the Holy Father with the request that the Pope issue a decree of "ex officio" dismissal from the clerical state. There is no canonical remedy against such a papal decree.
The CDF also brings to the Holy Father requests by accused priests who, cognizant of their crimes, ask to be dispensed from the obligation of the priesthood [That is the best way to express this: dispensed from the obligations that come from being a cleric.] and want to return to the lay state. The Holy Father grants these requests for the good of the Church ("pro bono Ecclesiae"). [Remember this phrase and this context when people criticize then Prefect Cardinal Ratzinger for speaking about "the good of the Church" when dealing with the case of the priest in California who was requesting to be dispensed from the clerical state.]
B3 Disciplinary Measures
In cases where the accused priest has admitted to his crimes and has accepted to live a life of prayer and penance, the CDF authorizes the local bishop to issue a decree prohibiting or restricting the public ministry of such a priest. Such decrees are imposed through a penal precept which would entail a canonical penalty for a violation of the conditions of the decree, not excluding dismissal from the clerical state. Administrative recourse to the CDF is possible against such decrees. The decision of the CDF is final.
C: Revision of MP SSTFor some time the CDF has undertaken a revision of some of the articles of Motu Proprio "Sacramentorum Sanctitatis tutela," in order to update the said Motu Proprio of 2001 [NB:] in the light of special faculties granted to the CDF by Popes John Paul II and Benedict XVI. The proposed modifications under discussion will not change the above-mentioned procedures (A, B1-B3).
Now you know something more about the procedures.
Just nones and vespers.
The bit rate is pretty low. Perhaps I should increase it.
No frills… I just turned on the mic when I said my office.
You all know about the contumacious antics of Fr. James Scahill, a priest of St. Michael’s Parish in East Longmeadow, MA in the Diocese of Springfield.
Father Scahill says, "The church will not have myopic obedience from me like the myopic obedience of the soldiers of Hitler."
He accused Pope Benedict of lying and has called for the pope to resign. Fr. Scahill states the pope is lying about his own involvement in covering sex abuse of children. The comments were made as a part of Fr. Scahill’ sermon.
A past story about Fr. Scahill.
A statement was released by Springfield Bishop McDonnell.
“There is a sad irony in that Father Scahill’s remarks were delivered on Divine Mercy Sunday,” said McDonnell, adding the church has expressed “tremendous sorrow, sadness and shame” about clergy abuse cases.
“The church leadership knows how difficult it is for those who have suffered abuse at the hands of clergy who should have been signs of God’s love rather than inflictors of pain,” the bishop said.”Here in the Diocese of Springfield, as in trouble throughout the United States and beyond, we are vigilant in the efforts undertaken to ensure such tragedies can never happen again.”
So… is Fr. Scahill still in his parish?
Does Pres. Obama desire the USA to slide into mediocrity? Neil Armstrong, Jim Lovell and Eugene Cernan raise the question.
From Politico with my E & C.
Armstrong: Obama hurting Space effort
Former astronaut Neil Armstrong has issued a strongly worded rebuke of President Barack Obama, criticizing the president for proposed revisions to the U.S.’ space program.
Armstrong, along with astronauts James Lovell and Eugene Cernan, called the proposal “devastating” in a letter obtained by NBC News. Read below for the full text:
"The United States entered into the challenge of space exploration under President Eisenhower’s first term, however, it was the Soviet Union who excelled in those early years," the letter begins."Under the bold vision of Presidents Kennedy, Johnson, and Nixon, and with the overwhelming approval of the American people, we rapidly closed the gap in the final third of the 20th century, and became the world leader in space exploration. …
"When President Obama recently released his budget for NASA, he proposed a slight increase in total funding, substantial research and technology development, an extension of the International Space Station operation until 2020, long range planning for a new but undefined heavy lift rocket and significant funding for the development of commercial access to low earth orbit.
"Although some of these proposals have merit, the accompanying decision to cancel the Constellation program, its Ares 1 and Ares V rockets, and the Orion spacecraft, is devastating. [Do I hear an "Amen!"?]
"America’s only path to low Earth orbit and the International Space Station will now be subject to an agreement with Russia to purchase space on their Soyuz (at a price of over 50 million dollars per seat with significant increases expected in the near future) [?!?] until we have the capacity to provide transportation for ourselves. The availability of a commercial transport to orbit as envisioned in the President’s proposal cannot be predicted with any certainty, but is likely to take substantially longer and be more expensive than we would hope.
[NB:] "It appears that we will have wasted our current ten plus billion dollar investment in Constellation and, equally importantly, we will have lost the many years required to recreate the equivalent of what we will have discarded.
For The United States, the leading space faring nation for nearly half a century, to be without carriage to low Earth orbit and with no human exploration capability to go beyond Earth orbit for an indeterminate time into the future,[NB:] destines our nation to become one of second or even third rate stature. [Is that what POTUS wants?] While the President’s plan envisages humans traveling away from Earth and perhaps toward Mars at some time in the future, the lack of developed rockets and spacecraft will assure that ability will not be available for many years.
Without the skill and experience that actual spacecraft operation provides, the USA is far too likely to be on a long downhill slide to mediocrity. [Is that what POTUS wants?] America must decide if it wishes to remain a leader in space. If it does, we should institute a program which will give us the very best chance of achieving that goal.
Neil Armstrong
Commander, Apollo 11James Lovell
Commander, Apollo 13Eugene Cernan
Commander, Apollo 17
Forty years ago today, Jim Lovell and the crew of Apollo 13 were struggling for their lives trying to return to earth. Failure was not an option.
Apparently failure is now an option.
Via the Laudator:
Po Chü-i (772–846), Spring Outing (tr. Burton Watson):
I mount my horse, ready to go out the gate;
out the gate, pause in uncertainty,
turn my head to speak to my wife,
sure she must be puzzled by all these spring outings.
I know I go on a lot of spring outings,
but what can an old fellow do,
when the ruddy face of youth is fading, fading,
and white hairs continue and continue to appear?
You have ten fingers—use them,
tally up my friends for me.
Say age one hundred is the outside limit—
how many make it into their seventh decade?
Now I am sixty-five
and speeding downhill like a wheel on a slope.
Supposing I should last to seventy,
that leaves me only five springs more.
Faced with spring, not to go out and enjoy it,
one would have to be a fool!