SSPX Bp. Williamson’s interview Pierre Danet, extreme right French politician

The wonderful and persistent Anna Arco of The Catholic Herald has on her blog an interesting piece about SSPX Bishop Williamson.


Dinoscopus sleeps, eats and blogs: Williamson Redux

After months of sensible silence in the genteel exile of Wimbledon, Bishop Richard Williamson, the Lefebvrist bishop whose Holocaust denial caused a media ruckuss and an endless headache for Pope Benedict last year has given an interview to a minor French politician of the extreme right, Pierre Danet. The French Catholic newspaper La Croix first posted the interview today.

It was published on Daily Motion on Tuesday, only days after Pope Benedict XVI visited the Great Synagogue in Rome. There is already comment on it here The interviewer, Pierre Danet was a candidate for the European elections on the anti-zionist ticket of the right-wing French comic and political activist Dieudonne M’bala M’bala.

Bishop Williamson said that he believed that the dialogue between Rome and the Society of St Pius X, working towards reconciliation, was a dialogue of deaf people. He also said that he was sleeping, eating and blogging in his “unexpected sabbatical year”. His blog Dinoscopus (a cross of Dinosaur and Episcopus) was public until last year’s bruhaha over Bishop Williamson’s Holocaust denial broke. In the interview he gives his oppinion on the State of Israel, Muslim Christian relations, Kant (a criminal), and some basic theology. He also discloses to the interviewer that he loves Beethoven.

You’ll want to head over to Anna Arco’s Diary for video and a transcript. 

The interview is odd.   But here is a taste:

Panet: And what do you know of the latest between the negotiations between the Fraternity [Society of St Pius X] and the Vatican?

Williamson: I think it will finish by becoming a dialogue of the deaf, because of two things. One: The two positions in themselves are irreconcilable. For example 2+2=4 and 2+2=5 it’s irreconcilable. Therefore of three things, one: either they say 2+2=4 , enounce reality and say 2+2=5 –that is to say the Fraternity would abandon the truth that God forbids us to do or that those who say that 2+2=5 convert and return to the truth or the two come half-way, that means everyone decides that 2+2=4 ½ . It’s wrong. Therefore, either the Fraternity betrays itself or Rome converts, or it is a dialogue of the deaf.
Posted in Ecclesiae unitatem | Tagged
43 Comments

Planned Parenthood’s abortion industrialists capitalizing on Haiti’s suffering

This should make you angry.

From Lifesite.

International Planned Parenthood Capitalizing on Haiti Earthquake with New Fundraiser

By Patrick B. Craine

PORT-AU-PRINCE, Haiti, January 19, 2009 (LifeSiteNews.com) – Capitalizing on the compassion of developed nations towards Haiti following the disastrous 7.0 scale earthquake last Tuesday, the International Planned Parenthood Federation (IPPF) has launched a fundraising appeal in order to further their aims in the devastated pro-life nation.

Within a day of the disaster, IPPF had sent out an appeal letter, seeking “urgent” support for their Haitian affiliate PROFAMIL.

IPPF, the world’s largest abortion provider, claims that funds are needed in order to restore “basic medical services” at the PROFAMIL clinics.  According to their letter, PROFAMIL has operated since 1984, providing “low-cost, quality sexual and reproductive healthcare.”

Read more at Lifesite.

Remember that Planned Parenthood evolved from the intent of eugenicists such as Margaret Sanger of ridding the earth of black people and other undesirables.  They target the poor for a reason: they want to eliminate the ills of the world by eliminating them.

 

 

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras | Tagged , ,
9 Comments

Benedict XVI’s, the Pope of Christian Unity’s, General Audience

This is the Week for Christian Unity.

Benedict XVI is the "Pope of Christian Unity".  Refer to him in this way constantly.  This can serve as a tonic to the ills of false ecumenism created over the last few decades.

From CNA:

Pope asks for prayer to achieve visible unity of all Christians

Vatican City, Jan 20, 2010 / 03:29 pm (CNA).- Pope Benedict developed his catechesis at the general audience on Wednesday around the theme of the Week of Prayer for Christian Unity.  The Pope spoke of the importance of "visible unity between Christians," inviting the faithful to invoke the Lord’s assistance to "develop fraternal relations and promote dialogue."

This year’s Week focuses on the Bible verse, "you are witnesses of these things," which Benedict XVI meditated on through two questions: the first,  "What are these things?" and the second, "How can we be witnesses of these things?"

"The mystery of the Passion and the gift of the Resurrection" are the answers to the first question, explained the Pope, who added that "by knowing Christ we know the face of God" and "in Christ, the distant becomes close."

We can be witnesses to "these things," he continued, "by knowing Him personally, … and truly meeting Him in our life of faith, and thus we can contribute to the novelty of the world, to eternal life."

The Holy Father affirmed the evolution of the ecumenical movement in the last 100 years to its current role in promoting fraternal relations between Churches and ecclesial communities.

He also commented on the scope and success of the movement, saying, "Since Vatican Council II the Catholic Church has forged fraternal relations with all the Churches of the East and ecclesial communities of the West.” With most of these groups, he continued,  she "has been able to find points of convergence, even consensus, on various matters, thus strengthening our bonds of communion.”

"Over the last twelve months, the various dialogues have made important progress," [!] the Pope pointed out, referring specifically to the 10th anniversary of Catholic-Lutheran dialogue established within the Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification and progress in talks with the Anglican Church.  [That joint Lutheran-Catholic declaration required clarification from then-Cardinal Ratzinger.  One of the best critiques was made by Card. Dulles in First Things.]

Pope Benedict underscored that the unity of Christians is fundamental to spreading the Gospel to the non-Christian world, asking how Christians can be credible in announcing Christ as "the only Savior of the world and our peace" if we are not unified in facing a "world that does not know Christ."

The Holy Father added that much has been done to establish dialogue with the Eastern Churches and ecclesial communities in recent history and that progress "has been achieved in collaboration and in fraternity in all these years."

However, he continued, "Ecumenical work is not a linear process, the old problems that arose in another age lose their importance, giving way to problems and difficulties of our own time. For this reason we must always be willing to accept a process of purification, through which the Lord makes us capable of unity."

The Pope wrapped up his speech by reaffirming the need for a shared witness to Christ and inviting prayer "for the complex ecumenical reality (and) for the promotion of dialogue."

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

Old Mass/new Mass thoughts – part 6

Under another entry there has been some consideration of the age of Catholics who prefer the newer form of the Roman Rite, the Novus Ordo.  Old Mass/new Mass thoughts – part 6

Some suggest that people of a certain age may be more interested in the Novus Ordo, while younger people are more open also to the older form of Mass, the TLM.

So, would some of you younger folks take some time to write your thoughts about the new Mass/old Mass question?

I also invite seasoned Catholics to do the same.

Let’s see some responses.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
15 Comments

WDTPRS POLL: Your Mass preference

Someone suggested this WDTPRS POLL about your preferences for attending Holy Mass. 

What is your preference, all things being equal, for the form of Holy Mass?

Do you prefer the traditional form of the Roman Rite, or TLM?  Extraordinary Form?  The Novus Ordo?

Does it matter?

This is clearly designated for subjects of the Latin Church.

{democracy:41}

Please give your reasons in the combox.

Posted in POLLS, SESSIUNCULA |
75 Comments

QUAERITUR: Papal blessing at 1st Masses of newly ordained

 

QUAERITUR: Papal blessing at 1st Masses of newly ordainedFrom a seminarian:

I understand that in a rescript issued from the Holy See, on November 5, 1964, Paul VI granted the newly-ordained priest the privilege of offering a papal blessing on the occasion of his first Masses.

Is this still in force?

Can such a blessing still be granted at first Masses?

 

Good question. 

I am not sure.

My first impulse is to say that this probably shouldn’t be done because of the changes made to indulgences found in the Enchiridion Indulgentiarum.  The new norms replace the old norms and privileges.  In the new Enchiridion people who participate in a first Mass of a new priest can receive a plenary indulgence… which was the point of the old papal blessing.  

Yes, this is a lot more vague and far less interesting, but it is on the books now.

Perhaps someone else has found a clarification on this and can share it.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box | Tagged , ,
12 Comments

Catholics and CINO politicians

In the wake of the stunning defeat of a dem in the Massachusetts election, there is a hard-hitting entry on SERVIAM today.

What Can Brown Do For You? Scratch Another Pro Abortion CINO!

The victory by Scott Brown in Massachusetts tonight is a victory for Catholics.  Brown, a protestant, defeated Martha Coakley, the Massachusetts Pro Abortion ["Catholic"] Attorney General.  Coakley, like Nancy Pelosi and the late Ted Kennedy whose Senate seat they were fighting for, likes to call herself Catholic.  She is anything but.  CINO candidates like this must be defeated.

And while it would be nice to say (and maybe someday we will be able to) that the race swung because a couple of million Massachusetts Catholics said no to abortion and no to CINOs, [clearly not the case] this race swung on other political issues (although she did opine that maybe Catholics should not work in emergency rooms that might be called upon to provide abortion services. How considerate.)

This all leads me to an excellent post appearing tonight from Adore te Devote on the very subject of pro-abortion politicians who call themselves Catholic.

I don’t care who you are!  If you willfully and publicly dissent against and advance teachings that contradict the Faith and Morals of the Catholic Church, you have separated yourself from us all,  and therefore you may be “Catholic” in name and by baptism (for by virtue of this, there is always hope…I’m a sinner, too, and screw up a LOT), but you LOSE the right to proclaim in conjunction with a public life and advancement in the eyes of others, a Faith you obstinately REFUSE,  ESPECIALLY if  you’re using it for your political advancement to purposefully fleece those who are even more uncatechized than you!

Read the whole post here and send to your local CINO politicians and friends.

Real practicing Catholics must be active in the public square… and the digital continent.  When we find someone distorting our identity, we must make it clear that they are not with us.

Posted in Our Catholic Identity | Tagged
8 Comments

Hymns versus the actual antiphons designated for Mass in the Roman Rite

There has been some discussion here of late about the Introit v. hymn debate, as well as the general issue of the use of hymns at Mass instead of the actual antiphons designated by Holy Church for use each day.

I saw at NLM an interesting post abut this.  My emphases and comments.

The editor of GIA’s new edition of Worship [A book which I am sure many of you have in your parishes.] has some comments concerning why the core of Catholic music for the Mass – the Propers – makes no appearance in the massive book now being published for the Mass. It is a mystery, isn’t it? A huge hymnbook for Mass even though that Mass has few hymns at all as part of its structure, and those it does have are intrinsic to the rite and appear in the normative music book for the ritual, the Graduale Romanum.  [That puts it succinctly.]

 

PRAY TELL: [Which is a liberal leaning liturgy blog, our of St. John’s Collegeville, MN.  Get this question….] Traditionalism is on the rise in the liturgy, [NB: It’s an "-ism".] and some people are talking about more chant, fewer hymns, more proper antiphons, and the like. Will Worship 4 bend to meet any of these new needs?  [Or will Worship remain rigid and inflexible.]

BOB BATASTINI: Like Worship 3, there will be a fair amount of chant, but certainly not enough for those who desire to move heavily in that direction.  [Those who want to move in that direction should simply ditch the editions of Worship they have and not buy the new one.  There are other, better books.]

Regarding the hymn versus introit matter, though “some people are talking,” by far, the common practice in American parishes is, and for almost fifty years has been, to begin the liturgy with a hymn. [In spite of the indications of the Second Vatican Council that Gregorian chant as the first place and that the Church has antiphons in the Missal, and there are officially published books for those antiphons.] Worship 4 is being designed to give those parishes the best collection of hymns published since Vatican II. [Same old same old.]  In an effort to merge hymn singing with [get this…] the intent of the introit antiphons, [the "intent"?  What would that be?  The Church’s assigned antiphons can be seen, but not heard?  You can look at them in the Graduale but not sing them?  I think the Church’s intent is that they should be sung.  Am I wrong?] Worship 4 will include the most developed hymn of the day compilation ever assembled. [Gosh!] The work of fine contemporary hymn writers is being wedded to well-known tunes from throughout the hymnic tradition, offering a hymn closely tied to each Sunday of the three-year Lectionary. [For heaven’s sake.  Try the Graduale.]

We can imagine other versions of this Q&A. Some people are saying that houses should be made of brick to withstand the weather and last longer. What do you say? I say that all houses today are made of mud and this is why we continue to do so. [SKIDOOSH!]

I mean no offense in the analogy, truly. But it is an undeniable fact: [Perpend:] parishes are not doing the right thing as regards music in the Roman Rite. [Well said.] The Mass is not a gathering of believers united to sing their top favorite songs. [I think the little combo stuck up in the front of the church suggests something else.] There is a time and place for that, and Mass is not it. If you want to see the music for the Mass, you have to look at the Roman Gradual or some other book that contains the propers (which can of course be in English).  [Though with less success, in my opinion… so far.]

Are we seeing (to quote a friend) an attempt to make ignorance of tradition the new tradition?

Why would a Catholic publisher continue to subsidize bad praxis? [Ummm… follow the money?]  I guess it depends on the raison d’etre of the publisher. As the editor says in his last answer: "I often loose patience with the institutional church…"  [Ummm… follow the money?]

By the way, the USCCB gave this publisher the legal monopoly to the Psalms of David, which allows this publisher to charge parishes and convents and monasteries money for singing. If you don’t pay, expect a visit from the lawyers. [Yep … follow the money.]

 

QUAERUNTUR:

What does never hearing the language of our Rite mean for our Catholic identity?

What does never hearing the actual music for our Rite, with the assigned prayers in the form of antiphons, mean for our Catholic identity?

Posted in Our Catholic Identity, SESSIUNCULA, The Drill | Tagged , , , ,
24 Comments

25 March: Pontifical TLM “at the throne” in NYC

I had this nice piece of news in my mailbox today:

His Eminence Edward Card. Egan,Archbishop Emeritus of New York, accepted the invitation of the Agnus Dei Council of the Knights of Columbus in New York City to celebrate a Solemn Pontifical Mass in the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite – a Mass for Life – on 25 March 2010, the Feast of the Annunciation.  The Council’s annual Mass for Life emphasizes the special link between the Incarnation of Jesus from the moment of conception in the womb at the Annunciation and Catholic Pro-Life Values.  More information about the location and time of the Mass will be released shortly.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
17 Comments

QUAERITUR: Mass obligation and SSPX chapels

From a reader:

Does a Mass heard in a SSPX chapel fulfill the Sunday Mass obligation?

Perhaps you have answered this question before. If so, I missed it.

The 1983 Code of Canon Law, can. 1248 says:

1. "The precept of participating in the Mass is satisfied by assistance at a Mass which is celebrated anywhere in a Catholic rite either on the holy day or on the evening of the preceding day." 

The Holy See has said repeatedly that attending Masses of the SSPX fulfills the obligation according to can 1248.

However, I will add that – while this strictly fulfills your obligation, I do not recommend that this be your normal way of fulfilling your obligation.  The SSPX is not yet in manifest unity with the Roman Pontiff.  The SSPX priests are suspended and have no permission from the Church to administer the sacraments.  It can happen that people who frequent their chapels can undermine their union with the local bishop and the Vicar of Christ.

I am fully aware that in many cases what is going on at your local normal parish may seem like the childish or pagan rites of a strange cult, and that what goes on at the SSPX chapel seems entirely reasonable Catholic, our sense of ecclesial unity remains important.  With very few exceptions the SSPX priests I have met have been fine men and zealous, while many liberal/heterodox priests in good standing I have known have been ignorant, arrogant, and petty.

This should spur us to earnest and frequent prayer for the success of the theological talks going on between the Holy See and SSPX and be ready to extend a welcoming hand…. especially in this Week of Christian Unity.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box | Tagged , ,
55 Comments