Prince Charles the environmentalist: “Follow the Islamic way to save the world”

A reader alerted me to his wacky tale from the Daily Mail.

My emphases and comments:

Prince Charles the environmentalist: "Follow the Islamic way to save the world"‘Follow the Islamic way to save the world,’ Prince Charles urges environmentalists

By Rebecca English
Last updated at 5:45 PM on 9th June 2010

Prince Charles yesterday urged the world to follow Islamic ‘spiritual principles’ in order to save the environment. [I am curious to know what those principles are and why they would be superior to true Christian theology of our stewardship of creation.]

In a high-profile speech, the heir to the throne [future head of the Church of England?] argued that man’s destruction of the world was contrary to the scriptures of all religions – but particularly that of the Islamic faith. [How?]

He said the current ‘division’ between Man and Nature had been caused [get this…] not just by industrialisation, technological development and the relentless pursuit of economic growth, but also by our attitude to our relationship with Nature – which goes against the grain of  ‘sacred traditions’.  [Christians track this back to sin… Original Sin in particular.]

Charles, who is a practising Christian, spoke in depth about his own study of the Qu’ran which, he said, tells its followers that there is ‘no separation between Man and Nature’  and says we must always live within Nature’s mean and limits.  [What I sense is at work here is that somewhere along the line he swallowed the error that man is not part of "nature".  He is therefore impressed by a religious assertion that man is in fact part of nature.   This is not new to well-informed Christians, of course.  Catholics especially grasp this.]

‘From what I know of the Qu’ran, again and again it describes the natural world as the handiwork of a unitary benevolent power,’ he said.  [Imagine such an idea!  God created nature!]

‘It very explicitly describes Nature as possessing an “intelligibility” [didn’t Augustine have something to say about that?] and that there is no separation between Man and Nature, precisely because there is no separation between the natural world and God. [Oppps!  God entirely transcends the natural world, which entirely depends on God for its existence.] 

‘It offers a completely integrated view of the Universe where religion and science, mind and matter are all part of one living, conscious whole. [I am reminded of a high schooler who has discovered an interesting new idea.]

‘This suggests to me that Nature is a knowing partner, [Sounds like pantheism…. a reflection of a modernist.] never a mindless slave to humanity, and we are Her tenants; God’s guests for all too short a time.’

The prince was speaking to an audience of scholars at the Oxford Centre for Islamic Studies, which attempts to encourage a better understanding of the culture and civilisation of the religion, of which he is patron.

When he accepted the role back in 1993 Charles gave a landmark speech about the need for better understanding between Islam and the West, which still has resonance today.

Yesterday the theme for his lecture, to mark the centre’s 25th anniversary, merged religion with his other favourite subject – the environment.

The hour-long speech saw Charles once again berate Man for the damage he is doing to the planet, saying: ‘Many of Nature’s vital, life-support systems are now struggling to cope under the strain of global industrialization. [He should perhaps save a few comments for British Petroleum.]

[…]’

Ho hum.  You can read the rest of the stuff over there, if you care about this ramblings.

We probably need a more clearly articulate ecological theology, something in small booklets with simple explanations.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
100 Comments

QUAERITUR: mixed choir in cassock and surplice

From a reader:

Perhaps you have already addressed this question somewhere, but as a choir director myself, I was bothered by something I saw on Corpus Christi.
 
In the midst of a trip away from home, I was worshiping at a large and beautiful cathedral blessed with an excellent choir.  The liturgy was done extremely well overall, but at the beginning and again at the end, the mixed choir — mostly women — processed into and out of the church wearing cassocks and surplices.  I was rather surprised because I’d always thought that this manner of dress was reserved to seminarians or at least to men to whom the priesthood is at least theoretically open as a vocation, but at the same time, this cathedral has a reputation for orthodoxy and orthopraxy.  So am I just uptight, or did someone drop the ball?

It seems to me that this whole scenario is a reflection of the blurring of liturgical roles of clerics and lay people.

It may be that this is something that started some time ago and they simply haven’t had a chance to deal with yet.

While I don’t think there is any legislation that forbids the use of the cassock and surplice by women, it is clearly clerical garb.   In my opinion it is wrong for females to use clerical garb at any time and for any reason.  It is something akin to cross-dressing.  Only the deeply ignorant or twisted think of or call the cassock a "dress" or compare it to women’s clothing.

It might be objected that non-cleric males, such as altar boys, wear the cassock and surplice.  If them, why not females?   Males, at least, could be clerics.  Women can never be.  Males, obviously, more suitably substitute for clerics in the liturgy.  Females can sometimes do so, but only as an exception to the norm.

That said, while it is true that choirs fill a liturgical role – that was why before the Council there was need for permission for women to sing! – it is far more important that the sanctuary service be attended to in this regard.

Brick by brick.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box | Tagged ,
36 Comments

WDTPRS POLL: girls serving at Traditional Latin Masses

WDTPRS POLL: girls serving at Traditional Latin MassesUnder another entry there is a discussion about the possibility or the propriety of girls serving Holy Mass in the older, traditional Roman Rite, the Extraordinary Form, hereafter TLM (Traditional Latin Mass).

I mused that I thought most traditionalists would rather not have a TLM at all if girls or women were to serve.

That was my educated guess, but it was just a guess.

Thus, I am posting this unscientific poll and I hope for a big response.

Please choose the option that best (even if not perfectly) describes your position and then give an explanatory comment in the combox.

Voting is anonymous.

Remember: This is primarily about the TLM, not the Novus Ordo.

{democracy:66}

Posted in POLLS, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM | Tagged , ,
91 Comments

Will Benedict XVI himself celebrate a TLM? Not right now, apparently.

Via our friends at Rorate we read comments of the papal Master of Ceremonies, Msgr. Guido Marini.

Msgr. Marini commented on something many people wonder about: Will Benedict XVI celebrate the traditional Roman Rite in public?

According to Rome Reports there is no direct quote but, in the interview with Msgr. Marini there is a toss away comment:

He says that for now it is not expected that the  pope will celebrate a mass according to rites prior to the Second Vatican Council.

 

I propose that if the Pontiff does not choose to be celebrant for the older form himself, he could perhaps consent to be present at a Pontifical Mass in one of the major Basilicas in Rome or, perhaps, for a pastoral visit to a parish in his diocese, he could be present at Holy Mass celebrated in the older form by the Cardinal Vicar at SS. Trinita dei Pelegrini.   The Holy Father visits Roman parishes as a matter of his pastoral solicitude.  He could visit the parish set up for the older forms of the sacraments as well.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
48 Comments

NYC BLOGNIC TONIGHT – WEDNESDAY 5:30-7:00 ANNIE MOORE’s

Readers were asking about another NYC-Manhattan Blognic.

Here’s the scoop. 

My only possibility is tonight, this evening, Wednesday evening. 

Anyone interested could meet at Annie Moore‘s between 5:30-7:00. 

Since this comes a little late, sorry, you might also take a moment to reach out by phone or e-mail to people you know in the area and just let them know. 

Google map.NYC BLOGNIC TONIGHT - WEDNESDAY 5:30-7:00 ANNIE MOORE's

Annie Moore’s is close to the western flank of Grand Central Terminal at 43rd between Park and Madison.

I am not reserving any space but there is lots of room at this pub.  The food is very reasonable. 

Blognics are entirely informal. There is no agenda other than to have a good time and chat and meet people. 

Everyone is responsible for his or her nibbles or beverages, unless of course you are feeling generous.

There is a room downstairs which perhaps they will let us use if we have a sizable crowd and if people are eating.  Otherwise, we can simply park in the ample area inside the entrance near the bar. 

We’ll be flexible. 

Here is a new poll just to get some idea of who may be interested.

{democracy:65}

Spread the word.

Otherwise, I will be at a Solemn Pontifical Mass at the Church of St. Jean-Baptiste at 7 pm on Friday evening.  There is a conference at Our Savior and Mass at Holy Innocents on Saturday where I will be one of the speakers, God and viruses willing, and also celebrant for a Missa cantata in the Extraordinary Form. 

Posted in Blognics, SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments

Priestly culinary accomplishments: Un panino di burro arachidi…

It has been said that imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.  I found this over at Young Fogeys, where Fr. Jay Toborowsky reigns supreme.

My emphases and comments.

In the life of a parish Priest (especially when you live alone), having the time to cook a meal is an almost unheard of treat. But, the other day, after reading another of Fr. Zuhlsdorf’s culinary triumphs, I couldn’t resist this:
On Sundays people should, if possible, get together for a nice meal. But after three Sunday Masses and a Corpus Christi procession, my desire for a meal is outweighed by my desire for things like a couch, The West Wing on DVD, [Good choice.] and some air conditioning.
But still, I needed to eat, so I decided to whip up one of my favorite recipes: Un panino di burro arachidi con patate fritte e ciambelline di ciocolata which is a "Peanut butter sandwich [I love those…] with potato chips and chocolate donuts".
First, I undid the twist tie on some Pane Italiano.

Priestly culinary accomplishments: Un panino di burro arachidi...
[Note the twist tie!] … unscrew the lid on your peanut butter …
Priestly culinary accomplishments: Un panino di burro arachidi...o{]:¬)

You can read the rest of this fine recipe over there and spike his stats!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
20 Comments

NYC: 11 June Pontifical TLM and Conference for Sacred Heart and Year of Priests

For those of you in the NYC area:

PONTIFICAL MASS FOR THE FEAST OF THE SACRED HEART MARKS THE END OF ‘YEAR FOR PRIESTS’

New York, N.Y., June 8 – As Pope Benedict XVI’s “Year for Priests” comes to a close, New York Catholics will mark the year’s conclusion with a Solemn Pontifical Mass (Extraordinary Form) for the Feast of the Sacred Heart.  Haiti’s Archbishop François Gayot will celebrate the Pontifical Mass at the Church of St. Jean Baptiste in Manhattan on Friday June 11th at 7 PM.

Archbishop Emeritus of Cap-Haïtien, Haïti, Archbishop Gayot was ordained a priest in 1954 for the Missionaries of the Company of Mary (the Montfort Missionaries).  He was ordained a bishop in 1974 and became an Archbishop in 1988.  He retired as Archbishop of Cap-Haïtien, Haïti in late 2003.

The choir at the Church of St. Jean Baptiste, under the direction of organist and choir master, Kyler Brown, will sing Victoria’s Missa O Quam gloriosum est regnum  along with several motets, including Messiaen’s O Sacrum convivium.

The next day, on Saturday, June 12th, there will also be a Conference on Devotion to the Sacred Heart at the Church of Our Saviour in Manhattan.  Conference speakers include Fr. John Zuhlsdorf, Dr. Donald Reynolds, Fr. Joseph Koterski, SJ, Fr. Kenneth Baker, SJ, and Fr. Michael Barone.

For more information, call (212) 569-1252.

From last year:

NYC: 11 June Pontifical TLM and Conference for Sacred Heart and Year of Priests

Posted in The Campus Telephone Pole |
4 Comments

More on the killing of Bp. Padovese

The strange case of the assassination of Bp. Luigi Padovese in Turkey,  – by his Muslim driver – becomes curiouser and curiouser.

Bp. Padovese, Apostolic Vicar of Anatolia and President of the Turkish Bishops’ Conference, was stabbed eight time by his driver, who then dragged him outside and decapitated him before heading up to the roof to shout "Allahu Akbar".

Now we read in an EWTN/CNA story that Bp. Padovese canceled his trip to Cyprus for the papal visit because he feared that his driver might attempt an attack on Pope Benedict XVI during his stay on the island.
 

Analyst Fr. Fillippo di Giacomo, who writes for publications such as L’Unitá and La Stampa, revealed that “hours before Padovese was killed, the Turkish Government called him to say that his driver, who they themselves had put in his service four years before, had gotten out of hand. That is to say, he had embraced the fundamentalist cause.”

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
27 Comments

Bagel Breakfast

My Manhattan bagel research continues.

This morning I headed off to Murray’s Bagels on 8th between 23rd and 22nd.

Bagel Breakfast

A great old-fashioned interior.

Bagel Breakfast

Upon entrance you are assured that the bagels, but only the bagels, are Kosher.

Bagel Breakfast

Murray’s does not toast their bagels.

I opted for the Ordinary Form: plain bagel with butter and small coffee: $2.75.

Bagel Breakfast

This bagel is mighty fine, I must say. 

That said, I have so far been most impressed by the bagels at the little shop at the corner close to the parish house.  I enjoy all these other exempla but I find I am constantly comparing them to the little shop on the corner.

And so life goes on.   I am fueled up for another writing day.

Bagel Breakfast

Posted in On the road, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
20 Comments

After writing…

… I am on my way to meet a friend for supper. it’s a very pleasant evening.

After writing...

After writing...

My favorite tall building in Manhattan.

The top is actually stylized hubcaps!

After writing...

After writing...

This is a nice plate of skate, with lemon and capers.

After writing...

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
16 Comments