Of sympathy and pageant, of aging and refreshing

The other day a priest friend brought up a line from Hilaire Belloc’s The Path To Rome, which I have not read for many a year.

This is the story of the wine of Brule, and it shows that what men love is never money itself but their own way, and that human beings love sympathy and pageant above all things.

“[H]uman beings love sympathy and pageant above all things.”

I must have read that way back when but it did not register with me then as it does now.

From time to time we ought return to good books we’ve already read.  As we change, we can glean more from them.

Thanks to the Laudator, I am able the more easily to share this timely observation by now-Blessed John Henry Newman from An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent:

Let us consider, too, how differently young and old are affected by the words of some classic author, such as Homer or Horace. Passages, which to a boy are but rhetorical common-places, neither better nor worse than a hundred others which any clever writer might supply, which he gets by heart and thinks very fine, and imitates, as he thinks, successfully, in his own flowing versification, at length come home to him, when long years have passed, and he has had experience of life, and pierce him, as if he had never before known them, with their sad earnestness and vivid exactness. Then he comes to understand how it is that lines, the birth of some chance morning or evening at an Ionian festival, or among the Sabine hills, have lasted generation after generation, for thousands of years, with a power over the mind, and a charm, which the current literature of his own day, with all its obvious advantages, is utterly unable to rival.

I was once told, as an undergrad, that I wouldn’t really start to appreciate Horace until I was older.  Too true.

In her grace-filled genius Holy Church, the greatest expert on humanity that there is, gives us a cyclical liturgical year.  She thereby takes into consideration the fact that each year we change.   Each year we can enter into the mysteries, being constantly represented to us, with a fresh perspective.  Each year we are able to gain something new that we were, even the year before, incapable of seeing.

We must return constantly to review the fundamentals of our Faith and not take it for granted that we have them down cold and don’t need to refresh ourselves.

Posted in Just Too Cool, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, Our Catholic Identity, Wherein Fr. Z Rants | Tagged , ,
15 Comments

Video of a Total Eclipse of the Sun

This is very cool.

The Sweeping Shadow – Total Solar Eclipse, Nov 14 2012,The Granite, FNQ, Australia. from Colin Legg on Vimeo.

Posted in Just Too Cool, Look! Up in the sky! | Tagged ,
3 Comments

Don’t forget The Tablet’s survey on the new, corrected translation!

Don’t forget the survey on the new translation at The Tablet.   CLICK HERE

It varies from day to day according to the results.  But.. hey!  Have some fun.

My friend Fr. Finigan suggests this music while you fill it out.

[wp_youtube]hI1nPd7hezM[/wp_youtube]

Perhaps the most annoying song ehvvverrrr.

Posted in Lighter fare, Linking Back, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000 | Tagged
30 Comments

“There is no prize for being the oldest dissident Jesuit priest.”

Dozens of people have sent me links to stories about a 90+ year old Jesuit who was suspended in the Archdiocese of Milwaukee for “concelebrating” with a fake wymynpryst… the one who had her “ordination tambourine“.  Remember her?

There is a deeper point, which I will get to by and by.

Anyway, the guy is a liberal Jesuit who thinks women should be ordained.  He “concelebrated” with her and got suspended.  One of his 75 year-old colleagues whined that his older brother in heresy was being badly treated.  Boo hoo.

As one of my correspondents put it: “There is no prize for being the oldest dissident Jesuit priest.”

This is not much of a story, actually.

But I did love the photo that went with this article:

Do you remember reading my point that these aging hippies cannot separate their identity from the halcyon days of the civil-rights and the anti-war protest movements?

This is an example of what I am talking about.

The same guy:

Posted in Liberals, The Drill, Throwing a Nutty | Tagged , ,
58 Comments

Wherein Fr. Z concedes about the “one Mass for two obligations” theory

I have written a couple times (HERE and HERE) about the possibility of attending one Mass on Saturday evening of the day of the Immaculate Conception (a Holy Day of Obligation in these USA) and, thereby, of fulfilling also the Sunday obligation.  That was my reading of can. 1248.

Remember: I am not a canonist.  Nor have I played on on TV.

Remember too: I have been saying all along that it is far better to attend two Masses, one on each day.

It seemed to me, however, that the law, interpreted as flexibly as we are asked to interpret it when obligations are involved, could permit two obligations to be fulfilled by participation at one Mass.   The Mass attended would just happen to fall in the period of about 8 hours of overlap of the two days as reckoned according to liturgical time and non-liturgical time.  And, again, we interpret law as favorably as we can when obligations are imposed.

A couple canonists I have contacted agree with me. More, do not. The prevailing opinion among canonists (and I am not one) is that one Mass on Saturday does NOT fulfill two obligations. Among the dissenting (from me, that is) canonists is Dr. Peters, whom I respect greatly in matters canonical.

Now I have heard an anecdote which I must, in justice, share.

A priest friend in these USA after a retreat in Indiana recently collared His Eminence Raymond Card. Burke (Prefect of the Apostolic Signatura, and thus Holy Church’s “Supreme Court Chief Justice”).

My friend said he was in a conversation with Card. Burke yesterday afternoon when one of the other priests present brought up the disagreement on the issue of the double obligation fulfillment. My priest friend said one of the priests said, “Ed Peters takes the position that one must attend two Masses, while Fr. Z says one Mass in the evening could count for both.” He said Burke responded, “Fr. Zuhlsdorf is generally very good, but here he’s just plain wrong.

Card. Burke said that, in this matter, I am “just plain wrong”.

Well. There it is.

Card. Burke’s response is not the equivalent of an authentic interpretation of the canon as issued by the proper dicastery of the Holy See, but it ain’t chopped liver either.

All along I have said that I defer to proper authority on this one. I still don’t see the logic, but when I find I disagree with Dr. Peters AND Card. Burke, I start to question my ability to reason.

In the meantime, as I continue to scratch my head, you had all better get yourselves to Mass today and tomorrow as well.

I considered myself obliged to pass this news along to those of you who have followed the argument.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Linking Back, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, Mail from priests, Our Catholic Identity, The Drill | Tagged , , ,
68 Comments

About that survey by The Tablet… does anything strike you as a little queer?

I wrote HERE about The Tablet (aka The Bitter Pill aka RU-486 ) and their abortive attempts to get a survey right concerning acceptance of the new, corrected ICEL translation.

It has been a tough few days for RU-486, I’m afraid.  They posted the wrong texts in their poll.  They then had technical problems which required them to zero the results.  They changed – corrected – the texts.  It’s all a huge hassle, I’m sure.

One of the survey questions I really enjoy, however, is this one.  Read it carefully and then ask yourself if there isn’t something odd about it.

See it?  Yes?  No?  Yes?

The Latin text is NOT a translation.  Ordinary Form, Extraordinary Form – whatever – are Latin to begin with.

This survey thing is hard!

Follow my link, above, to take their survey… in whatever form it has taken today.

Posted in Liberals, Lighter fare, Linking Back, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000 | Tagged , , , ,
17 Comments

Alfred Hitchcock – Catholic

Who can fathom the graces God offers as death draws near to us?

Some people are given the great gift of courage not to wait too long to become a Catholic, sometimes after a long time thinking about it.

John Wayne… Oscar Wilde…

I read that Dave Brubeck, who died recently, because a Catholic later in life.

Today I read that Alfred Hitchcock because a Catholic in his end times.
The WSJ has the story HERE.

Alfred Hitchcock’s Surprise Ending
A biographer said that the director, at the end of his life, shunned religion. Not true. I was there.

By MARK HENNINGER [a Jesuit]

I remember as a young boy watching the black-and-white “Alfred Hitchcock Presents” on TV and being enthralled from the start by the simple nine-stroke line-drawing caricature of the famed movie director’s rotund profile. The mischievous theme music set the mood as Hitchcock appeared in silhouette from the right edge of the screen, and then walked into the center replacing the caricature. “Good evening.” There followed his droll introductions, so unlike anything else on television.

Such childhood emotions came over me again when in early 1980 I entered his home in Bel Air to see him dozing in a chair in a corner of his living room, dressed in jet-black pajamas.

At the time, I was a graduate student in philosophy at UCLA, and I was (and remain) a Jesuit priest. A fellow priest, Tom Sullivan, who knew Hitchcock, said one Thursday that the next day he was going over to hear Hitchcock’s confession. Tom asked whether on Saturday afternoon I would accompany him to celebrate a Mass in Hitchcock’s house.

[…]

Read the rest there.

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, Just Too Cool, Our Catholic Identity | Tagged , , , , , ,
18 Comments

The Feeder Feed: Museum Song Bird Edition

Here is an Allegory of Music by Laurent de la Hyre (+1656).

20121207-145050.jpg
The figure is playing a theorbo, or chitarrone, probably a symbol of musicaartificiale“. They had drone strings and produced a rather symphonic effect. On the other hand, the little bird is probably a symbol of musicanaturale“.

20121207-145436.jpg
The music is actually readable.

20121207-145513.jpg
Tweet!
UPDATE:

And simply because she is so beautiful.

20121207-151727.jpg

20121207-151802.jpg

Thank you Filippino Lippi!

UPDATE:

For St Ambrose on his feast!

By Giovanni di Paolo.

20121207-154845.jpg

UPDATE:

By the way, we don’t know what exact piece is in the manuscript in the painting. However, so that you know more about the theorbo, here is a great video that shows it from many angles.

The being played is by Kapsberger, who did in 1651 in Rome. The painting is from 1647.

[wp_youtube]CpQw0UH-YV4[/wp_youtube]

And this piece, with a touch in Piccinini, is a little more groovy.

[wp_youtube]GFJnJsPgss8[/wp_youtube]

Posted in The Feeder Feed, What Fr. Z is up to | Tagged , , , ,
6 Comments

Promoter of women “deacons” can’t speak in Archdiocese of Philadelphia

NB: The Deacon in question posted a comment, below.  Be sure to check it out.

The Fishwrap is having a little nutty these days about the ordination of women.

First, there is an editorial openly declaring that women should be ordained as a matter of “justice”. It is fun. If you bother with it, note how Fishwrap creatively hijacked Bl. John Henry Newman on conscience and papal teaching. The Catholic Herald‘s William Oddie has a sharp piece about that HERE.

Second, there is a piece at Fishwrap about a permanent deacon who was recently told he could not speak at a church event in the Archdiocese of Philadelphia. The deacon in question, Rev. Mr. William Ditewig, once worked in the office of the USCCB for deacons. He co-authored a book promoting the ordination of women deacons. His co-author was Fishwrap columnist Phyllis Zagano. Remember her? She doesn’t like me very much, I’m afraid. (She actually has a fairly decent column this week about the secular and materialistic enervation of the Christmas season.)

Fishwrap has been having a pretty bad innings when it comes to promoting weird and invalid ordinations. Their darling Roy Bourgeois was recently dismissed from the Maryknollers for pushing women’s ordination to the priesthood. Now, Rev. Mr. Ditewig is not given a chance to talk in Philadelphia. Ditewig says that he wasn’t going to talk about women’s ordination, but giving him a platform might look like an endorsement of his unorthodox notions.

“But Father! But Father!”, some will declare. “Ordinatio sacerdotalis says women can’t be ordained as priests…. as prieeeeests. Get it? Can’t you read? It doesn’t say anything about deacons! There were deaconesses in the ancient Church. So there!”

Piffle. Are we going to disconnect the diaconate from the sacrament of Holy Orders? Ordination of women to the diaconate is nothing other than an attempt to promote the ordination of women to the priesthood. And if there were female “deacons” in some century in some corner of some church somewhere, the phenomenon was a) not anywhere near universal and b) swiftly stamped out as wrong.

Just because something happened occasionally way back when, that doesn’t mean that what happened was acceptable then or legitimate today.

In any event, women are not going to be ordained deacons.

Posted in "But Father! But Father!", Liberals, Our Catholic Identity | Tagged , , ,
46 Comments

ACTION ITEM! POLL ALERT – The Tablet about the new tranzleshun

UPDATE 7 Dec: The Tablistas finally found the correct texts for their poll about the new translation. Go back and give it another try! NB: As a sweetener, there is a question about preference for the Ordinary or Extraordinary Forms.

Click HERE.

PS: They ask for your email address but you don’t have to give it in order to complete the poll.

UPDATE 7 Dec 1631 GMT:

A couple people have written to me saying that the Tablistas may be blocking people coming from this blog.  I doubt that, but it is fun to imagine.  If you can’t get in, it is probably a cookie/history issue because you already did their survey.

Here is another link.

http://thetablet.co.uk/page/survey 

_____

Original posted Dec 2, 2012 @ 11:52

A priest alerted me to a poll about the new, corrected ICEL translation of the Roman Missal being conducted online by the UK’s ultra-liberal dissenting catholic weekly The Tablet (aka The Bitter Pill). HERE.

You know what to do.

Be mindful that there are text errors in the poll!

HA HA HA HA HA!

Posted in Liberals, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, POLLS | Tagged , ,
63 Comments