QUAERITUR: does the Seal of confession apply also to the penitent?

From a reader:

Except when he translates for or overhears another person’s confession, is a layman ever bound–like the priest–by the seal of Confession, such that he cannot mention either what he confessed or what he was told?  I was not able to determine this with certainty, but obviously it would be important to know with certainty if the answer is yes.

 

Except in the cases you mention, that is, when he may serve as a translator or when he overhears the confession of another, a layperson is not bound to keep secret what he or she says or hears from the priest in the confessional.  If a translator or "over-hearer" were to reveal the contents of a confession, they could under the Church’s law be punished with a suitable penalty.  The "Seal" which applies to the confessor does not apply in the same way to the penitent, even if the penitent is a priest.  In the case of a cleric overhearing a confession and then revealing the contents, I suppose a penalty might include dismissal from the clerical state.

But in general a person can reveal he contents of his own confession and what the priest says. 

That said, it is probably better for the penitent not to speak too much about what occurs in the confessional under normal circumstances.  The less said about concrete instances of the sacrament of penance the better. 

There are some exception to this, of course.  Off the top of my head I can think of both positive reasons and negative reasons.  For example, if a priest gave a particularly good piece of advice, perhaps that might be shared if you were not also going to reveal your own sins as a result.   Otherwise, if a priest were to do something outrageously stupid or attempt a crime or the like, the penitent could and should address himself to the priest’s superior about what happened.  The difficulty is, of course, that the priest remains bound by the seal and it could wind up being a matter of the word of penitent "A" against Fr. "B".

So, the long and the short is that a penitent in general can speak of his own confession and the advice and penance received, but in normal circumstances it is better to leave it for the most part in silence.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box | Tagged ,
24 Comments

What to do? Sunday Supper – 2

Starting to think about Sunday dinner.Julia Child

The last time I consulted you I made Boeuf à la bourguignonne.

I am inclined toward rabbit this time….

I usually make Italian coniglio in umido (and here).  This involves lots of olives and white wine and herbs.

But since I recently received from a kind reader, WH, the volumes of Mastering the Art of French Cooking, I thought I might give her Lapin au Saupiquet a chance to prove its worth.  Oddly, it is the sole rabbit entry in the books.

This would be – if I choose it – Rabbit Marinated in Vinegar and Herbs, and stewed in Red Wine. 

This would take at least 24 hours to prepare, so I had better get things together by Friday evening.

What to do? Sunday Supper - 2

So, what will it be?

{democracy:59}

The rabbit must die.

(This video is no longer available.)

UPDATE 22 May 1700 GMT:

Okay!  The poll is closed. 

I have opted for Lapin au Saupiquet and have already started the marinade!

Posted in Fr. Z's Kitchen, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged ,
78 Comments

Prayer request of Mulier Fortis!

URGENT

Mulier Fortis, an English school teacher, has an job interview which may in part depend on her pronunciation of Eyjafjallajokull.

It also involves tomato soup and cardboard.

Oh! Help!

Posted in Lighter fare |
15 Comments

Fr. Wissman in Bolivar, MO calls Pope Benedict, bishops, faithful, “faithless and hypocritical”, “whitewashed sepulchers”

Long-time readers of WDTPRS may remember that we have on at least two other occasions looked at the musing of Fr. Pat Wissman, pastor of St. Catherine Mission in Bolivar, MO in the Diocese of Springfield-Cape Girardeau.  Fr. Wissman wrote some of the dumbest things I have ever read, as a matter of fact, which you can review here and here. 

It seems Fr. Pat has moved beyond dumb to angry and hateful. 

In his parish bulletin for this coming weekend, Pentecost, 23 May, we have this with my emphases and comments:

Fr. Wissman in Bolivar, MO calls Pope Benedict, bishops, faithful, "faithless and hypocritical", "whitewashed sepulchers"Dear Parishioners,

Happy Pentecost! The Easter Season comes to a final crescendo with this glorious feast! The Holy Spirit is the Person of the Holy Trinity which we seem to neglect. [Really?] But still, the age we live in since the Ascension is the AGE of the Spirit. [Hmmm….] It was under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit that Vatican Council II happened. History making and world shaking, the Church came up to date under the Spirit’s guidance. [I think you are getting a sense of this fellow’s age and basic formation.] The history of the Church since those moments is the successful or unsuccessful implementation of that wonderful coming together of the Church. [Here we go…] Those who have resisted the Council have resisted the Spirit. [Is that so?  Fr. Wissman knows this?  We can at least affirm that Council’s are guided by the Holy Spirit when they, with the Bishop of Rome, teach concerning faith and morals.  In Acts 15:28 we read, "It is the decision of the Holy Spirit and of us …."  But when the matter does not have to do with faith and morals, does the Holy Spirit guide a Council?  Also, the Second Vatican Council is considered a "pastoral", rather than "dogmatic" or "doctrinal" Council, even though it issued a "dogmatic constitution". What does that mean for the involvement of the Holy Spirit.] It is sad [Get this…] that the implementation did not take place in many places and that [!] has led to a great decline in true membership in the church and the increase of the powers of divergence from the Kingdom of God. [This is loaded with problems, as I am sure you have already seen.  First, the writer wants you to accept a premise: problems have come about in the Church where the Council was not implemented.  On the other hand, "Council" – especially from a liberal – could mean just about anything, including suggestions that have nothing to do with the Council’s documents.  I suspect that the shift above from the use of "Holy Spirit" to just "Spirit" in relation to inspiration for the Council was telling.  Next, what does "true membership" mean?  Is he suggesting, for example, that there is some sort of additional litmus text, known to the writer.  This smacks of gnosticism.  Notice also that phrase "powers of divergence".  I think that means any influence exerted by anyone who does not share the writer’s outdated and rigid understanding of the Council.  And note that the writer seems also to have insight not only into "true membership" but also who belongs to the "Kingdom of God".  This goes beyond pompous to dangerously judgmental.]  In the United States, however, for the most part the implementation took Fr. Wissman in Bolivar, MO calls Pope Benedict, bishops, faithful, "faithless and hypocritical", "whitewashed sepulchers"root and has made the U.S. Catholic Church very vital and a shining example of true Christianity. [Has the writer not reviewed lately statistics about Mass attendance, use of the sacrament of penance, marriage, and belief in doctrines of the Church?  Unless, though it is hard to imagine this, the plummeting statistics are what he is talking about.] The recent efforts of faithless and hypocritical people to make the church go backward are ill conceived and will fail. [So, anyone who has what Pope John Paul II referred do as a "legitimate aspiration" is faithless and hypocritical.  Benedict XVI is also "faithless and hypocritical" by the fact of the provisions of Summorum Pontificum and his statements about "continuity" and the clear explanation that what was sacred in the past is sacred also now.] What a mistake it was for the Pope (who had the best of intentions) to lift a ban on those reactionary groups who want a dead church of Latin language and a rejection of Vatican II. [Once again, the example of a liberal who invokes a Council he has never read: Latin remains the language of the liturgy, something required by the Second Vatican Council.  Furthermore, the word "ban" is inaccurate.  The writer is no doubt poorly imformed.] One of the Bishops of one group even publicly takes a stand saying that the Holocaust is a myth. [That would be SSPX Bp. Williamson.  Now get this…] These people [He is no longer talking about just SSPX Bp. Williamson…] who may appear very pious (as the Pharisees did!) are really whitewashed sepulchers (to use the words of Jesus).  [I think he just called John Paul II, Pope Benedict, every bishop who has ever granted use of the older Mass, or participated in one, every priest who uses the older forms and all the lay people who desire the opportunity to participate in the older forms… or even in the Novus Ordo in Latin… "whitewashed sepulchers".  Does that set well with you?  Does that set well with the Bishop of Springfield-Cape Girardeau?  I think I recently saw His Eminence Card. Baum at the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception on 24 April – a former bishop of the writer’s diocese – participating at a Pontifical Mass with the older form.  He must be a "whitewashed sepulcher" also.] The Holy Spirit always leads us into the future, not into the past. [What confused claptrap.  The writer pretends to know what the motions and urgings of the Holy Spirit are.  This is part of the writer’s gnostic approach.] As we celebrate this faith-moment honoring God, the Holy Spirit let us be aware that trust as well as faith is needed…trust in the leadership of the Holy Spirit, trust in the Spirit’s healing powers as well as creativity under the Spirit’s egis. [sic]

It is the Spirit who guards the church from the powers of hell. [Not content with "powers of divergence", now he refers to anyone who has a vision that differs from his own as "powers of hell".] Jesus tells us: fear not, the Father will send you the Spirit… The great and powerful God the Spirit blows throughout the universe seeking souls open to the new creation, seeking hearts open to its promptings, seeking to uphold those whose knees are weak and confirming those who seek God. And it is not just the Catholic Church that is gifted with the Holy Spirit.  Every good inspiration, every good act, every humble prayer has as its source the one and same Spirit. All religions ancient and new are impacted by the Spirit and are made ready for advancement toward truth, unity and peace.  ["Not just the Catholic Church… all religions…"]

Blessings!
Fr Pat

I think this could fairly easily be classified as "anti-Catholic".

I wonder if Fr. Wissman’s bishop agrees with this "pastor’s page".

Latin and the traditional forms of worship might not be your thing… but does this strike you as just?  Does this seem right to you?

Posted in Our Catholic Identity, Pope of Christian Unity, SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM, The Drill, The Last Acceptable Prejudice, Throwing a Nutty | Tagged ,
96 Comments

WDTPRS Skype voicemail fixed… sort of

WDTPRS Skype voicemail fixed... sort ofI have solved my skype voicemail problems …. at least in part.

I can receive my voice on only one of the computers on the network, the one that runs the Z-Cam no less.

Therefore, I can from time to time shut down the Z-Cam and collect my voicemails.

Thanks to those of you who used the number to leave prayer requests and feedback.

I need to make some choices about renewing my skype numbers in the first week of June.

If I get more voicemails (and perhaps even donations to keep the voicemail numbers in the USA and UK!), that will help my decision making process.

I am mystified as to why I cannot get my voicemails on my other desktop or my laptop with which I travel.  I am wondering if this has something to do with audio card drivers.

I have written to skype numerous times about the problem and have never received a response.  Apparently other people have this problem too.

  • My USA number is: 651-315-8191 (not my US mobile phone)
  • My UK number is: 020-3239-5957 (not my UK mobile phone)
  • My skype id is: wdtprs

Right now I have wdtprs open on the ‘puter that runs the Z-Cam.  So… if you are listening when a call comes in you will probably hear the ringtone before it goes into voicemail.

NOTA BENE: I do not answer the calls.  I have skype set up to send you directly into voicemail.

I very much enjoy getting your VMs and thank those who took the time to leave them.

I may make a PODCAzt later today and plan to include at least one of them (now that I can pull them in). 

Posted in LIVE STREAMING, PODCAzT |
Comments Off on WDTPRS Skype voicemail fixed… sort of

A “pastor’s page” against Pope Benedict and against the new translation

Sometimes people send me "pastor’s pages" from their parish bulletins.  Most of the time this is an opportunity to exercise patience.

I was alerted something written in a pastor’s page from "The Catholic Faith Communities of Saint Theresa and Saint Christopher" in
Tiverton, Rhode Island where Fr. Peter J. Andrews is pastor.

This benighted little blurb popped up,

But it is not just the sexual abuse crisis that muddies the waters of Church life and overall integrity. Liturgically we are at a cross roads, where some continue the work of reform set forth by the Second Vatican Council, while at the same time, others see reform as a return to a time and practice present for centuries before this last ecumenical opening of windows and doors. [The writer has set himself squarely in opposition to Pope Benedict.  But wait… there’s more…] Newer translations of prayers and texts, warranted in so many cases, seem to go too far in [Get this howler…] an effort to rein in our theological and spiritual understanding of faith and are becoming stilted and difficult to understand. [Lemme get this straight… more accurate translations which, by the way, haven’t yet been used, will rein in understanding of the faith?] Instead of gathering [bzzzzz] folks with a common and comprehensible language in liturgy and prayer, [What he means here is lowest common denominator of language.  Sorry, but I feel excluded by the banal evacuated version now in use.] I fear [Based on what?  Evidence of some sort?  This is fearmongering and rabble-rousing.  He is trying to spoil the effort before it begins.] there will be separation and confusion. Instead of being one with the people who make up her members, one might see the Church disconnecting from the very folk she is meant to lead.

 

The new translation is not yet in use.

Therefore the writer is just talking out of his hat.

With no evidence at all, he is purposely trying to turn people against the new translation before it is implemented.

So… what does this mean for that parish when the new translation goes into force?  How much whining will his people have to endure then?

Furthermore, while the translation seems to be the main object of his attack, do not forget that he placed himself firmly in opposition to Pope Benedict. 
 
Finally… if the pastor doesn’t like the new translation, he can always use Latin.

Posted in Throwing a Nutty |
27 Comments

About “jumping the gun” with the new ICEL translation – WDTPRS POLL

About "jumping the gun" with the new ICEL translation - WDTPRS POLLThe other day my good friend Fr. Ray Blake of Brighton posted an entry on his blog St. Mary Magdalen about ad experimentum use of the new ICEL translation for Holy Mass.  

He has some corrections to make in an interesting blog entry with my emphases and comments:

Following my report on using the new ICEL translation I have had a number of emails from different parts of the world but mainly from the UK, from laity and priests, saying that the new ICEL translations of the Eucharistic Prayers are already being used to a greater or lesser extent in their parishes. [But… should they be?] Priests who are not normally innovators tell me they have waited too long [Do I hear an "Amen!"?] and would be doing their parishioners a serious disservice by continuing to use the old inaccurate translations. [And so I have often thought as well.] I have every sympathy with them, however our UK bishops have not yet sought Rome’s permission for them to be implemented, so technically these priests are celebrating illicit Masses.  [Yes, indeed they are.  As well-meaning as they are, they just don’t have permission yet to do this.]

[And now the £64 question.] How serious is this willful act of dissent?

Well, it is the intention of the lawmaker, the Holy See, that these translations should be implemented, permission has been given for their use already in other parts of the world. A great deal of liturgical innovation has already been introduced by deliberate and willful disobedience to the mind of the Church, the vernacular during the Council, communion in the hand after it, the use of lay persons to distribute Holy Communion, then later women and girls serving Mass, in the scheme of things jumping the gun with the new translation seems very small beer, especially as it is very much according to the mind of the Church that they be implemented. [Is this the argument: "Other people did wrong things – contra legem – for the wrong reason.  Why shouldn’t we do right things – contra legem – for the right reason?"]

A wise bishop would do well to try and stop other abuses in the liturgy rather than stomp on the pre-emptive use of texts, which with some minor adjustments, will become standard in the English speaking world. Indeed if I were a bishop I would welcome experimentation in preparatory catechesis for their introduction.

 

I wholly agree with Fr. Blake: bishops would do well to stop clear and harmful liturgical abuses.

Is using the new translation a liturgical abuse?

But I think we all know that the usual pattern is that bishops tend to let liberals do as they please while coming down hard on more traditionally-minded priests.

I suspect that the reason is that they know that the traditionally-minded priests will strive to obey without making a nasty scene, while the liberals will throw a public nutty and defy the bishop to his face.

Sound right?

I can hear it now…

"But Father! But Father!", some will be saying as they wag their finger at the screen.  "It is clear wrong when liberals depart from the approved texts.  Priests don’t have the authority on their own to change texts.  If a priest starts using the new ICEL text without permission, isn’t he doing the same thing the wackos do?  Can you justify doing something against the Church’s law for a good reason?"

I know several good priests who change words here and there "on their own authority".  And I know their reasons for doing so.

Just for jollies, anima caussa as we say in Latin, let’s have a little poll.

Please vote after pondering the situation and then share your reasons in the combox.

{democracy:58}

UPDATE 2320 GMT

I closed the poll.  I think we have a good sense of the trend.

Posted in POLLS, SESSIUNCULA, WDTPRS | Tagged , ,
120 Comments

A new sodality for servers of the Traditional, Extraordinary Form

A new sodality for servers of the Traditional, Extraordinary FormA while back I called for those groups who do training for priests and seminarians for the older forms of the Roman Rite, the Extraordinary Use, also to provide more training for lay people who will be called upon to serve those liturgies.

The provision of Summorum Pontificum make it clear that all Latin Rite priests have the right to say Holy Mass also with the Extraordinary Form.  Most priests today did not grow up with that older, traditional form.  This means that they did not learn the older liturgy from the ground up, as it were.  They didn’t learn what to do as servers in different roles.  Therefore, when it is time to implement Summorum Pontificum in the parish, they have a gap of knowledge when it comes to training servers.  Inevitably there is a layman around – at least in my experience – who know the older form pretty well and can be of great help. 

But more resources are needed.

I was interested to find in my mailbox today a note from the Latin Mass Society in England and Wales.  Something for your "brick by brick" file.

PRESS RELEASE FROM THE LATIN MASS SOCIETY
For Immediate Release

19 May 2010

LATIN MASS SOCIETY LAUNCHES NEW SODALITY FOR TRADITIONAL ALTAR SERVERS

On Saturday 15th May 2010, at Blackfriars, Oxford, the Society of St Tarcisius, a sodality of servers of the Traditional Latin Mass (Extraordinary Form), [I am reminded of the Archconfraternity of St. Stephen.] was founded during a training day for altar servers, arranged by the Latin Mass Society. Thirty servers were present, with the training being delivered by Fr Armand de Malleray FSSP, Br Lawrence Lew OP, Mr David Forster, and Mr Richard Hawker. The day began with an address from Fr de Malleray on the importance of the service of the altar. The servers were divided into two groups of the less and more experienced for training. Some people travelled long distances to attend – one as far as Preston, Lancashire. 

   The two groups each had an experienced MC and a cleric to guide them: the less experienced group was led by Fr de Malleray and David Forster; the more experienced group by Br Lawrence Lew and Mr Richard Hawker. The day was interspersed with prayers and ended with Benediction of the Blessed Sacrament.

A new sodality for servers of the Traditional, Extraordinary Form   The Society of St Tarcisius has been founded to encourage servers of the Traditional Mass in their work on the altar, to provide training for new servers and the more experienced, to promote a high standard of reverence and accuracy, and to form a network through which servers can stay in touch and share resources.

   The Society of St Tarcisius is sponsored by the Latin Mass Society, though membership is open to all who wish to serve the Traditional Mass. Saint Tarcisius was a Roman acolyte who was martyred while defending the Holy Eucharist from profanation during the fierce persecutions of the third century. The sodality has taken “Fidelis usque ad mortem” – Faithful even unto death – as its motto, and seeks to inculcate in servers an intense devotion and reverence for Our Lord in the Eucharist, as well as a precise attention to the ceremonies of the Mass.

   The society’s website is www.saint-tarcisius.org.uk. Servers wishing to join the sodality should contact the Secretary, Mr David Forster, at secretary@saint-tarcisius.org.uk.

   Photographs of the training event on Saturday 15th May can be seen at www.lmschairman.org/2010/05/server-master-class-report.html

   The Latin Mass Society and the Society of St Tarcisius will be holding a residential training course for lay servers at Downside Abbey, Somerset, from Tuesday 10 August to Friday 13 August. This will run alongside the LMS’s Downside training conference for priests to learn the Extraordinary Form. Full details are available from the LMS.

Posted in Brick by Brick | Tagged
10 Comments

Our Lady, Queen of Giant Puppets

Via Mulier Fortis comes this great image from Acts of The Apostacy:

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
26 Comments

The fruits of excommunication

From the site of Chicago Public Radio via Sancte Pater, to whom I tip my biretta.   o{]:¬)

Catholic Church Denies Female Priest a Catholic Burial

A woman who challenged a Catholic ordination ban has died. ["Ban" is the wrong word.  "Ban" implies that somehow the situation could be changed.  Just stop "banning".  Impossible.] The Catholic church will not allow her to be buried at a Catholic parish.

Janine Denomme was [not] ordained a priest in April by a group called Roman ["]Catholic["] Womenpriests. She had been battling cancer and yesterday she died in her Edgewater home. [RIP]

The Catholic church never recognized Denomme’s ordination. [That’s because it didn’t occur.] The Archdiocese of Chicago says Denomme automatically separated herself from the Church when she participated in "the simulation of the sacrament of Holy Orders." The diocese says she knowingly and willingly participated in the simulation and brought excommunication upon herself. And because of that Denomme is denied a Catholic funeral. The Archdiocese says Denomme would only be allowed a Church burial if she gave "some sign of repentance before death."

Denomme’s funeral mass will be held at First United Methodist Church in Evanston.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
64 Comments