Evil and Fun Movie Villains

In the wake of stories about how Heath Ledger played the "Joker" in the new Batman movie will be one of the best/worst villains in the talkies, I started thinking about really creepy villains in movies I either have on my shelf in some form, or which immediately come clearly to my mind.

I have to separate them into humanoid and non-humanoid and just plain fun.

They have to be really creepy, evil, not just someone’s nemesis, like Lex Luthor to Superman (though the fellow in TV’s Smallville is getting there little by little).

Human and pretty much like a human:

Marquise Isabelle de Merteuil (Glen Close – Dangerous Liasons – ghastly evil wicked person – always leaves me upset, came to my mind first)

Archibald Cunningham (Tim Roth – Rob Roy – ghastly evil wicked person – always leaves me upset – really glad when he dies)

Hannibal Lecter (brrrrrrr Anthony Hopkins – The Silence of the Lambs, etc. and don’t forget Jaime Gumb… shoot him again, Agent Starling!!)

Warden Samuel Norton (Bob Gunton – The Shawshank Redemption – I would like him to go to prison, if you know what I mean, along with Clancy Brown as Captain Hadley)

… there are some wackos…

Norman Bates (Anthony Perkins – Psycho – who loves his mom, however)

John Doe (Kevin Spacey – Se7en – now this is seriously creepy – hard to top this guy)

… thugs abound …

Viktor Komorovsky (Rod Steiger – Dr. Zhivago – and dedicated Commies too, lots of them)

Michael Corleone (Al Pacino – The Godfather Part II – a deadly hypocrite)

… and, always bad, Nazis! Except when they are funny (see below) ….

Amon Goeth (Ralph Fiennes – Schindler’s List … sorry, Voldemort is not creepy enough … yet)

Dr. Christian Szell (Lawrence Olivier – Marathon Man … zzzzZZZZZZzzzeeeeeZzzzzz … ‘nuf said?)

The Wicked Witch of the West
(Margaret Hamilton – well…. you know – along with people who hate dogs in movies)

speaking of witches…

The Queen (Snow White And The Seven Dwarfs – with dishonorable mention to Maleficent)

White Witch (Tilda Swinton – The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe – and anyone else who tries to screw up Christmas – like Mr. Potter and The Grinch (see below) )

Messala (Stephen Boyd – Ben-Hur – really mean)

Nurse Ratched
(Louise Fletcher – One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest – reminds me of some women religious I have suffered from over the years, like the nun who runs a certain press office I know)

Frank Nitty (Billy Drago – The Untouchables – oh ya… Al Capone too)

… and to stay with the alliteration…

Fanny Ferras Dashwood (Harriet Walter – Sense and Sensibility – what a rhymes with witch)

Darth Vader… who needs no additional defense or specification

Non-human

The Terminator (need I say more?)

Gollum (Lord of the Rings)

The Borg Queen (Alice Krige – Star Trek: First Contact)

The Dragon (Reign of Fire)

Agent Smith
(Hugo Weaving – The Matrix)

The Cigarette Company (The Insider)

The Alien (Alien, etc. … kicks the Predator’s butt)

The Alien Egg and Really Fast Contents (Alien, etc. – perhaps the creepiest critter in any movie)

HAL (2001 – A Space Odyssey)

Stinky Telepathic Critters With Dreadlocks (Independence Day)

The Asteroids
(Armagedon and… it was a busy year… Deep Impact)

The Weather Fronts (A Perfect Storm)

The demon (The Exorcist)

Satan (The Passion of the Christ – see above)

Fun (well, aren’t they all? Except that last one?)

Sarris (Galaxy Quest)

Syndrome (The Incredibles)

Dr. Evil (Austin Powers)

Willy Bank (Al Pacino – Ocean’s Thirteen)

Khan (Star Trek… whatever it was… Wrath of Khan)

Bill (David Carradine – Kill Bill 1 & 2)

Edward Rooney (Ferris Bueller’s Day Off)

The Grinch

Major Arnold Toht (Raiders of the Lost Ark)

The Stay Puft Marshmallow Man (along with ZUUUUUL! (no relation) – Ghost Busters)

Captain Hook (Peter Pan)

Okay… there are some ideas.

I imagine you are itching to add your own really bad villains… from movies mind you.

Go ahead!  Eventually I will try to come up with my Very Worst and also Funnest lists.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
85 Comments

A fervorino

A fervorinoJesus said:

You serpents, generation of vipers, how will you flee from the judgment of hell?

(Matthew 23:33)

You who are reading this might not be a "viper"… or even an asp… but this shows that Jesus thought hell existed and that it is very possible to go there.

Yes, folks, it is possible to go to hell.

As a matter of fact, it isn’t very hard at all.

Some will reject the merits of Christ, His offering to confirm us as heirs of the Kingdom of Heaven. 

It is possible to kill the life of grace in the soul. 

When you die, you will be judged with the first judgment by the Judge who is justice itself, but who is also mercy incarnate.

His judgment we will have whether we want it or not. 

His mercy we must beg.

And He will give it swiftly.

When you go to confession and confess all your mortal sins in both number and kind, they are forgiven, removed from your soul, they are no more, they are taken away.

Though your sins be as red as scarlet, they will be made as white as snow.

Again, they are taken away by the Blood of the Lamnb.  They are not merely covered over, or set aside or over looked, as the deadly error of the Protestants has it.

When you sins are forgiven by a priest with valid orders and faculties to absolve they are no more and will never be held against you at your judgment.

"… et ego te absolvo a peccatis tuis…"

"… I absolve you from your sins…"

When was the last time your heard those words?

It may be that at death you will not have done adequate penance for the sins you committed and confessed and which were forgiven by Christ through the priest.

It may be that you have attachment for sins.

In this case, the mercy of God is even more beautifully extended to us.

Can we imagine a binary end of our lives?  Either die in absolute perfection, having done all necessary penance and having no attachment to sin or, on the other hand, die with even the smallest imperfection and therefore passing to the eternity of hell, with its perpetual physical and spiritual agony?

And so God permits those who die in His friendship but with imperfections to be purified and cleansed of their final flaws so that, when the moment is right, the soul may pass into the bliss of heaven and the beatific vision… forever.  

Once you are in hell, no one can vote you out.

But we can "vote" people out of the state of purgatory with our votive offerings and penances and into heaven by taking on some of their penance, by praying for them, by having Masses said. 

We are in this together.

What was the last time you did penance or sought an indulgence or had a Mass said for someone who died or the souls in purgatory?

Imagine the first five seconds of heaven, the greetings given you by those whom you aided to enter more swiftly in to the presence of God, all luminous in the beatific vision.

Now imagine the the first five seconds of hell… the shock of realizing where you are.

When we do things for the least of Christ’s brethren, we do them for Christ.  Souls of purgatory are also in need of your care.

During this long stretch of Sundays of Ordinary Time, of the Time after Pentecost, do not forget the basics of your Catholic identity.

We confess our sins regularly, because Catholics love God, fear hell and know neither the day no the hour of our death and judgment.

We do penance, especially on Fridays, because we Catholics pray for ourselves and others, especially the dead.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
46 Comments

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

It has been a while since I have posted on the Sabine Farm.  I have been out and around and, then, busy.

Dawn.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

From time to time the heavens open and it pours rain.

We actually wee more rain right now.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

The raspberries are coming in so fast that I can’t pick enough and stay ahead.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

Blueberries too.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

Neither a raspberry nor a blueberry.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

Sometimes a delivery truck swoops in with surprises. … often involving more to read.

When you use my Amazon wish list, you tend to keep me buried in reading.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

The other day I was terribly down about something.  Anyway… I got in the car and took a drive around various country roads with all the windows down and the music turned up.

Eventually I made my way to a little park where the rocks and river are nice.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

Back at the Sabine Farm again, ….

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

Flowers flourish.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

I don’t know what these are, but they are cool looking.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

Someone once posted on one of these Sabine updates a recommendation that we should have a Sabine apiary.

Now we have a Sabine apiary… a very active apiary.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

Oopps… wrong century.

This was shot with a big lens.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

Bees help with the flowers and the veg, fruit trees, et al. I am sure.

I wonder about candles later… hmmm….

In the meantime, things are blooming nicely.  I cut hollyhocks for the chapel the other day.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

But the Sabine Farm, to be true to its spirit and the original inspiration by the great poet, must have some grape vines.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

PENJING REPORT!

Both Penjing and Irohamomiji are doing very well.

Penjing seems to thrive in the full sunlight of the long afternoons.  Irohamomiji, being much larger, needs to be watched, lest the shallow soil dry out too much.

An early morning constitutional.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

I have to figure out how to trim Irohamomiji soon.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

After full days, when the agenda list is pretty much complete (I go by the 8/10 rule), when the ball game is on (watching the Twins beat the White Sox last night was a pleasure, on the deck, with a cigar – I drag a TV out and patch it in to a cable or use a laptop and the Slingbox – a material proof that God loves us)…

… the vistas can be very nice indeed.

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

In any event, the day concludes with Compline in the Sabine chapel …

Sabine Update & Penjing Report

Then it’s off to read Ambrose or Augustine until late.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
33 Comments

Benedict XVI and WYD: pastoral v. intellectual – a look back

When big events in a pontificate have come and gone, it is good to return after a time and do a little analysis.  To that end there is an interesting article in the Muswellbrook Chronicle.

My emphases and comments.

 

From a theologian to Pope of the people [I have a bit of a problem with this dichotomy, but we’ll leave that for now.]
21/07/2008 12:00:01 AM

World Youth Day under Sydney’s limpid blue skies has opened a new chapter in the story of Pope Benedict XVI, one which seasoned Vatican observers describe as a turning point in his papacy.  [Hmm… well see what they have to say about this.]

The shy professor of theology turned cardinal, chief inquisitor [they just can’t resist, can they] and keeper of the Catholic faith has shown the first glimpse of a mass communicator in the making [despite the fact of having published a couple dozen books and having been a teacher, priest and diocesan bishop.  Seriously, publishing and going in front of large crowds, the size a POPE gets, are very different.] – one whose DNA may not be infused with the star power of John Paul II but who has now, even if reluctantly, embraced the need to engage directly with his 1.2 billion global followers.  [It is interesting that so many people affirm that lots of people went to see John Paul II, but they go to hear Pope Benedict.]

"It is in Sydney that this Pope has truly learnt his job," said Andreas Englisch yesterday. Englisch, a German author, journalist and member of the Vatican press corps since 1986, has written seven books, including two on Pope John Paul II and one on Benedict XVI.  [I wonder.  It seems to me that his trip to the USA may have done that, to a certain extent.  Remember that incredible address he gave to young people at Dunwoody.]

"Ratzinger is a theologian. He knows his church but he knew it through books, through his writing, from his study but not from the people. In Australia, even more than in the United States, he has learnt the church from his people … they do not want to be kept at arm’s length.  [Perhaps that lesson was learned in the USA and then put into practice in Sydney.  Also, I don’t buy the premise that the Pope didn’t know the Church "from the people".  We mustn’t forget that the Pope was a parish priest, then a teacher, a university professor, then a diocesan bishop.  Sounds like John Paul II.  But no one says JPII didn’t know the Church "from the people".  I think there is a dichotomy at work here, which we see raise its ugly head all too often when discussing the Church these days.]

"In Cologne in 2006, 1.5 mill-ion people lined the Rhine to see him. He spoke only to the young people on the boat with him … there was no effort to wave, to smile, to acknowledge all those that came out to see him … There was much criticism of him, even from his bishops. Here in Sydney it has been different, completely different."  [And the crowd about a third of the size as that of Cologne?]

Pope Benedict, born and bred in the cold of Bavaria, [?!?] seems to have thawed in Australia.

When he faced the first phalanx of television cameras and microphones on board the flight to Sydney from Rome seven days ago he looked transfixed, hesitant in demeanour and rusty in English, the language of his soon-to-be hosts in Australia.  [Okay… you get up in front of a "phalanx" of journalists, knowing you are going to have questions is various languages and see what you look like.  And, by the way, how did John Paul II handle that?  Oh right… he didn’t.  He didn’t do what Pope Benedict has done from the beginning of his pontificate: wherever he goes he holds conferences and fields questions and answers them extemporaneously.]

"He was faced by a battery of cameras and lights … he is not at his best in a crowd, he looked like a deer caught in a spotlight," another veteran Vatican specialist on board the flight said.

"But just a few days later, if you talked to those 12 kids who had lunch with him at St Mary’s, you would not know it was the same man," she said.  [For pity’s sake… of course.  Again, he spent a lot of his life teaching young people rather than hanging out in front of cameras with journalists.]

"He laughed, he relaxed, he played with the stress ball that one of the American kids gave him. Theatrics go against his nature, but he has learnt here to play his audience [Or maybe it was…. genuine?] … even to punch his applause lines, to listen, to time delivery with them." [Again, they assume he didn’t know what a joke was before?  I can tell you from my own dealings with him years back that he always had a wonderful sense of humor and could kid around.]

In the past seven days the Pope, a man of undisputed fierce intellect and steadfast theological position, has gradually allowed a different part of his personality to emerge. At last he has provided a glimpse of the man behind the mitre.  [Ah… finally.]

At Government House, during his first official outing after resting at Kenthurst, the Pope was led through a review of the troops – an Australian protocol for a visiting head of state but one that departed entirely with papal tradition. It was clear from the Pope’s demeanour that he was unsure of what was expected of him – even mildly embarrassed – as the navy, army and air force military bands waited at attention and he was led past each one.

"It is simply not a papal thing to do … I think it has only ever happened once or twice, usually in small African nations," said a senior Vatican reporter and veteran of 19 papal trips.

"He is never made to walk past like that … but it was obviously local tradition, and so he stopped each time, he waved; he obviously seemed to want to make a human connection."  [Of course.]

According to his spokesman, the Jesuit priest Padre Federico Lombardi, the previous pope, John Paul II, had come from a pastoral tradition. [Or maybe they are just different men?] "All of us see the difference in their personalities, the difference in their approach to people. You only need to watch them to see that difference. 

"I think that for John Paul II this [a World Youth Day event] was a very spontaneous thing. He also had a personal past in pastoral work with youth. He used to take canoe trips, nature walks in forests with them. His gestures, his ripostes to curious questions [from youth] were all spontaneous.

"Pope Benedict XVI was a university professor. You can see that too in the way he imparts his speeches, his relationships, the way he expresses himself and so on … he has a rapport with the young but is more shaped by his students. I think though that he has shown a great willingness to live this new pastoral experience, which he inherited from his predecessor but which he has now infused with his own characteristics, of simplicity, of humility and availability to all."  [This is good.]

Padre Lombardi said what was most visible in Sydney was the Pope’s direct participation with young people and that he allowed himself to become involved.

The changes observed in the Pope during his Australian trip are particularly significant as no cardinal of the Roman curia had ever enjoyed the celebrity status – but as an intellectual not a populist – enjoyed by Joseph Ratzinger in Europe when he was cardinal.

According to John Allen, the Pope’s unauthorised biographer, the then Cardinal Ratzinger’s fame "transcended the borders of church life; [making him] a bona fide public figure with a cultural profile similar to [the conservative commentator and writer] William F. Buckley jnr’s in the United States."  [Fair enough.]

In his biography, which the Vatican did not receive warmly as it meticulously and critically analyses Joseph Ratzinger’s dramatic evolution from early libertarian theologian to arch-conservative, Allen points out that in German newspaper polls at the time he was cardinal, Ratzinger came in the top 30 of German’s most important and powerful nationals. He was placed ahead of the then head of the German central bank and even the tennis player Steffi Graf.

Allen’s final analysis rejects critics who portray the Pope as a man driven only by fear – of losing power, of women, of sex, of modernity. He argues that the very few people who know the man, and even those who disagree with his theological positions, describe him differently: "… He is a refined man with a lively sense of humour, [indeed yes] not someone working out his personal pathologies through the power of his office," [like progressivists and feminists… but I digress] he writes. When asked once, on Bavarian television, what he was afraid of, Allen writes that his quick-witted response was "I’m afraid only of the dentist".  [Sounds like a pretty good one-liner to me, and that was even before he learned in Sydney how to make jokes.]

On Sydney Harbour, during a welcome usually afforded rock stars, the Pope surprised many when he moved out of the papal entourage and ensconced himself at the front of the boat, looking as excited as the teenagers who flocked around him.

Similarly, his triumphant tournee around the racecourse at Randwick yesterday was markedly populist and warm. His security men turned a blind eye to the many babies and toddlers thrust through the open window for the Pope to kiss.  [Perhaps another things learned in the USA where the security detail was truly stiffling, I understand.]

The only real criticism of the week revolved around the complexity of his homily at the Saturday night vigil on the St Augustine’s theology of the Holy Spirit. [Here again is that ugly dichotomy.]

Some youngsters found the teachings impenetrable, and even Padre Lombardi, in a flash of great humour, admitted that he and others who had read the homily found it difficult "on first impression". [Really?]

But that, he said, was a good measure of this Pope. "It was his choice, to choose issues that invite reflection, that require work to understand, that may need you to come back and return to them to seek clarity. There are other things that he might have said that might glean greater applause … but they would not have stimulated thought."   [The best paragraph of the whole article.  Lombardi nailed it.  Well done.]

 

Here is my problem.

Often on this blog I have made the observation that there is prevalent a dichotomy between "pastoral" and "intellectual".  If you are one, you can’t be the other.

And in this dichotomy, the "pastoral" is nearly always exalted at superior, in such a way that to be "pastoral" often winds up fostering an anti-intellectual condescension.

This is a common trait in many clerics, I’m afraid.

I see Pope Benedict breaking down this dichotomy, which is causing some people to scratch their heads in confusion.

 

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
37 Comments

Recent posts of interest & thanks to WDTPRSers

Here are a few links to posts that might be of greatest interest.
Recent posts of interest & thanks to WDTPRSers
I am very grateful to those of you who have used the donation button.  Please be assured that I remember you in my prayers, as one ought to remember benefactors.

This list of links isn’t exhaustive!  God back and look around.  Enjoy!

  • CDW’s Archbp. Ranjith on Pope Benedict’s plan with the liturgy
  • RORATE: on Summorum Pontificum, SSPX, unity – enlightening
  • QUAERITUR: Before the Council we had the TLM, so why did things go wrong?
  • Card. Kasper at Lambeth calls for a New Oxford Movement
  • More wymynpriest pretend ordination B.S.
  • What WDTPRS is aiming atRecent posts of interest & thanks to WDTPRSers
  • PCED response about TLMs for children
  • PODCAzT 67: St. Augustine on Martha, active v. contemplative lives; don Camillo (part II)
  • NYT – John L Allen’s op-ed on Humanae vitae
  • The NCR dissents from Humanae vitae, the Church’s moral teaching
  • ANGELUS: Interviews SSPX excomm’d bishops (part III: R. Williamson)
  • PODCAzT 66: don Camillo (part I): VM – advice on getting TLMs & “pro multis”
  • ANGELUS: Interviews SSPX excomm’d bishops (part II: Tissier de Mallerais)
  • Card. Diaz to Lambeth: “spiritual Alzheimer’s … ecclesial Parkinson’s”
  • Clapping in church
  • SSPX & Womenpriests: similar? dissimilar?
  • ANGELUS: Interviews with SSPX excomm’d bishops (part I: Fellay)
  • QUAERITUR: small shoulder capes on altar boys
  • Boston Globe: another article on the invalid ordination of women
  • SCHOLION: Benedict XVI’s closing sermon for WYD
  • PODCAzT 65: St. Ambrose “On mysteries”; Interview: Fr. Robert Pasley
  • SCHOLION: Pope Benedict’s sermon in St. Mary’s Cathedral – Sydney
  • SCHOLION: Benedict XVI’s address at the Vigil during WYD
  • SCHOLION: Benedict’s address to non-Catholic Christian leaders
  • SCHOLION: What’s going on in Pope Benedict’s WYD arrival address?
  • What is Pope Benedict thinking about Anglicans?
  • Ineffable irony and the USCCB
  • QUAERITUR: Visiting priest and baptism with the OLD Rite
  • QUAERITUR: A Latin among Easterners: what gives?
  • QUAERITUR: When does the “clerical state” begin?
  • PODCAzT 64: Bonaventure on Christ “the door”; Interview – Fr. Timothy Finigan
  • A blogger’s experience of the Novus Ordo in Latin
  • Pope Benedict comments on the Anglican implosion
  • PODCAzT 63: Fr. Z interviews Fr. Justin Nolan, FSSP; consecrated hands, Holy Communion and the Rite of Baptism
  • A word to biters of the consecrated hand
  • USCCB: “Dick and Jane” translation theory again triumphs for a day – Eerie
  • Stalled again: USCCB fails to pass draft translation of Proper of Seasons
  • ZENIT and Fr. Z: “Summorum Pontificum” One Year Later (Part 1 & Part 2)
  • GUEST CONTRIBUTION: Q&A with the Pont. Comm. Ecclesia Dei about SSPX, schism and sacraments
  • Benedict XVI’s sermon for Sts. Peter and Paul: be “liturgists of Jesus Christ”
  • QUAERITUR: congregational responses at TLM
  • QUAERITUR: Maniple required for TLM? “Reformed” vestments?
  • Communion on the tongue, kneeling – Benedict XVI’s good example
  • Thoughts on the SSPX opportunity
  • PODCAzT 62: Interviews with and by Fr. Z; What has Bp. Fellay really said?
  • Kerfuffle! Wisconsin parish nixes altar girls – predictable outrage ensues before sanity prevails
  • An argument for lengthening Communion fast to 3 hours again
  • Msgr. Guido Marini: Communion kneeling and on the tongue will be the standard for papal Masses
  • Tornielli: the 5 points were for Bp. Fellay IMPORTANT
  • SSPX prospects and my ruminations
  • QUAERITUR: Do SSPXers think new rites of ordination are valid?
  • QUAERITUR: abbrev. in MartRom.
  • ICEL’s Msgr. Harbert responds to Bp. Galeone’s points on the new translation
  • The Holy See’s 5 conditions for the SSPX – my comments and a prayer IMPORTANT
  • St. John the Baptist: notes and oldie PODCAzT
  • NCR: the ban on lay preaching Archd. St. Paul & Minneapolis
  • Oceanside, CA: a priest who gets it
  • “I think it’s boring” – Phoenix, AZ newspaper on the TLM
  • Bp. Rivest of Chicoutimi: I’m in charge here, not Benedict XVI – no TLM!
  • Bartholomew I to Eastern Catholics: return to Orthodoxy without breaking with Rome
  • ALERT: blog problems today – expansion over the weekend
  • QUAERITUR: Distinction of Masses, TLM and NO
  • PREVIEW: a GREAT new publication from Angelus Press!
  • QUAERITUR: Can priests refuse to say the TLM or the Novus Ordo?
  • Bp. Seratelli responds to critics of the new liturgical translations – this guy gets it!
  • Concelebration
  • How should people receive Communion? Pope Benedict sets example… again
  • UK: Card. Castrillon Hoyos – TLM in “Not many parishes – all parishes”!
  • Bp. Trautman doesn’t think you are smart enough to understand the proposed new translation of Mass
  • QUAERITUR: writing to the CDWDS and remaining anonymous
  • QUAERITUR: Acolyte as subdeacon for NO 1st Mass
  • QUAERITUR: More than one Sunday TLM in a parish?
  • Pure joy: Enjoying the fruits of Benedict’s Marshall Plan!
  • WDTPRS: 3rd Sunday after Pentecost (1962 Missale Romanum)
  • QUAERITUR: During confession what was the priest saying?
  • QUAERITUR: Female altar servers
  • QUAERITUR: What is really needed to be able to celebrate the TLM?
  • QUAERITUR: How has the Holy Father promoted the TLM?
  • Pope Benedict is changing the conversation
  • QUAERITUR: Clerical funerals
  • Corpus Christi Mass: Benedict XVI gives Communion only on the tongue to people kneeling
  • The Pope to put limits on concelebrations
  • QUAERITUR: Holy Communion at an SSPX chapel
  • QUAERITUR: Fatima prayer in Latin
  • QUAERITUR: priest drops Host, does nothing, what do I do?
  • Card. Castrillon Hoyos about the TLM on the new DVD
  • Pilgrimage to Rome with Patrick Madrid and Fr. Z – Information
  • QUAERITUR: Sequences…. Should we stand or should we sit? [PARODY SONG ALERT]
  • QUAERITUR: keeping maniples on your arm – fun!
  • [!] Italian magazine Jesus interviews Card. Castrillon Hoyos of the P.C. “Ecclesia Dei” IMPORTANT
  • What Pope Benedict is up to in Rome with the new “personal parish” alla Summorum Pontificum
  • Official: FSSP parish in Rome at Ss. Trinità dei Pellegrini
  • Need another reason for Summorum Pontificum? Be careful, this is UGLY
  • D. of Gaylord: TLM update – an amazing attitude of restriction continues
  • Time: Benedict may have killed off American Catholic liberalism
  • PCED’s Card. Castrillon Hoyos: celebrate TLM in parishes even when it isn’t requested – IMPORTANT
  • PODCAzT 55: Tertullian, again; Fr. Rutler and Fr. Z on Archbp. Marini’s book
  • What is Black Liberation Theology? Some basics.
  • PODCAzT 54: Pro-Abortion Politicians and Communion; St. Ambrose and Emperor Theodosius
  • PCED clarifies: Summorum Pontificum 6 allows vernacular readings instead of Latin
  • PODCAzT 51: Communion in the hand
  • A friendly "how to e-mail Fr. Z" reminder!
  • QUAERITUR: going to SSPX chapel when you could go to legitimate chapel
  • A testimony about kneeling for Holy Communion and Communion rails
  • Summorum Pontificum now in the Acta Apostolicae Sedis – text variations
  • A PCED clarification: stabiliter not continenter in the MP and TLM in universities IMPORTANT
  • Fr. Z’s 20 Tips For Making A Good Confession – reprise
  • TLM Training at Merton College, Oxford 28 July- 1 August
  • PODCAzT 52: CDF on valid Baptisms, Michael Davies on valid post-conciliar Orders
  • PODCAzT 49: Leo the Great on Epiphany; Lefebvre compared to Athanasius; feedback
  • A new WDTPRS store
  • The return of triumphalism
  • PODCAzT 48: Athanasius on Mary and Christ; Gamber, Schuler and turned around altars
  • NatReview: "if good music does not always save the soul, bad music never does.”
  • Manlio Sodi: just a reminder
  • Writing to the Pontifical Commission “Ecclesia Dei”: some tips – USEFUL!From another entry: during the Roman Canon “I felt intense loneliness” – INTERESTING
  • Help me work through this: Since the TLM is now back, why bother with the Novus Ordo in Latin?  HUGE ENTRY!
  • L’OssRom: Archbp. Ranjith interview on liturgy – UPDATES
  • PRAYERCAzT 09: The Prayers at the Foot of the Altar – 1962 Missale Romanum
  • The Tablet on Archbp. Ranjith’s comments about bishops who resist Summorum Pontificum
  • VOTE!

      My site was nominated for Best Religion Blog!

    Visit the WDTPRS store for your "Say the Black – Do the Red" needs!

     Buy WDTPRS stuff!

    Add the WDTPRS feed to your site:

     align=

    ↑ Grab this Headline Animator

    Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
    3 Comments

    Catholic League response to U of Minnesota’s support of publicly anti-Catholic bigot

    This is in from The Catholic League:

    July 31, 2008

    UNIV. OF MINN. CHANCELLOR ON MYERS:
    HE’S IN THE CLEAR

    On July 25, the University of Minnesota (UMN) at Morris issued a statement by its chancellor, Jacqueline Johnson, which began with the following paragraph: “I believe that behaviors that discriminate against or harass individuals or groups on the basis of their religious beliefs are reprehensible. The University of Minnesota Board of Regents Policy: [sic] Code of Conduct prohibits such behavior in the workplace—of course this includes the classroom—and I expect those who work and study here to comply with that policy.” She then proceeded to say that Professor Paul Z. Myers, who intentionally (and with malice) desecrated the Eucharist, was expressing his own views and not those of UMN.

    Catholic League president Bill Donohue issued a news release the same day, saying, “This is classic: Johnson admits Myers has violated the UMN’s Code of Conduct and then proceeds to tell us why he is being allowed to do so with impunity—it’s a matter of academic freedom.”

    Johnson faxed a letter to Donohue today saying she needed to address his “misunderstanding” of her statement. She makes it plain that because Myers posted his comments on his personal blog, he did not violate UMN’s Code of Conduct.

    Donohue sent Johnson the following letter today:

    “I am sorry for my generosity: I took it that the reason you began your statement of July 25 with a citation of UMN’s Code of Conduct as it applies to religious intolerance was your way of acknowledging Myers’ delinquency. I now stand corrected: Your comment was simply a ploy—a cute way of acknowledging that something was wrong, but certainly not anything that would demand your attention. And just so you don’t misunderstand me: You could have issued a statement saying that while UMN has no authority over what Myers says in his blog, it is morally indefensible for anyone to intentionally desecrate the Eucharist. But, no, you couldn’t even say that. Instead, you hide behind legalisms. We will let the Catholic community know of your decision.”

    Contact Chancellor Johnson at jrjohnso@morris.umn.edu

    Just doing my small part to let you know what is going on.

    Can you imagine what the U of Minnesota would do to a white professor who decided to participate in a minstrel show in black face?

    Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
    Comments Off on Catholic League response to U of Minnesota’s support of publicly anti-Catholic bigot

    CDW’s Archbp. Ranjith on Pope Benedict’s plan with the liturgy

    Today in La Repubblica there was an interview by Marco Politi with His Excellency Archbp. Malcolm Ranjith, Secretary of the Congregation for Divine Worship and Discipline of the Sacraments.

    There is a lot here that will be familiar to readers of WDTPRS!

    "Why Ratzinger is recouping the sacred"

    Marco Politi

    The signal was unmistakable.  First Coprus Christi in Rome, then seen live all over the word from Sydney.  Benedict XVI is demanding that, before him, Communion be received on one’s knees.  It is one of many reclamations of this pontificate: Latin, the "Tridentine" Mass, celebration with the back to the faithful.

    Pope Ratzinger has a plan and the and the Sri Lankan [Archbishop] Malcolm Ranjith, whom the Pontiff wanted with him in the Vatican as Secretary of the Congregation for Divine Worship, lays out with efficacy.

    Attention to liturgy, he explains, has the objective of an "openness to the transcendent".  At the request of the Pope, Ranjith states in advance, the Congregation for divine Worship is preparing a Compendium on the Eucharist to help priests to "prepare themselves well for Eucharistic celebration and adoration".

    Does Communion kneeling aim in this direction?

    "In the liturgy one feels the necessity to recover the sense of the sacred, above all in Eucharistic celebration.  Since we believe that what happens at the altar goes far beyond what we can humanly imagine.  And so the faith of the Church in the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharistic species is expressed through adequate gestures and comportments different from those of daily life".

    Indicating a discontinuity?

    "We are not in front of a political figure or a personage of modern society, but before God.  When the presence of eternal God descends on the altar, we must place ourselves in a posture more apt for adoring It.  In my culture, in Sri Lanka, we ought to prostrate ourselves with head to the pavement as the buddhists and muslims do in prayer.

    Does putting the Host in the hand diminish the sense of transcendence of the Eucharist?

    "Yes, in a certain sense.  It risks that the communicant feel It to be as normal bread.  The Holy Father speaks often of the necessity of safeguarding the sense of "transcendence" (al di la) in the liturgy in its every expression.  The gesture of taking the Sacred Host and putting it ourselves in the mouth and not receiving It reduces the profound meaning of Communion."

    Is there a desire to oppose trends that banalize the Mass?

    "In some places that sense of the eternal, sacred or heavenly has been lost.  There was a tendency to put man at the center of the celebration, and not the Lord.  But the Second Vatican Council speaks clearly about the liturgy as actio Dei, actio Christi.  Instead, in certain liturgical circles, either for an ideology or a certain intellectualism as you please, the idea spread of a liturgy adaptable to various situations, in which one had to leave room for creativity, so that it be accessible and acceptable to all.  Then, rather, there were those who introduced innovations without even respecting the sensus fidei and the spiritual sentiments of the faithful."

    At times even bishops grap the microphone and go out to their listeners with questions and answers.

    "The modern danger is that the priest things that he is at the center of the action.  In that way the rite can take on an aspect of theatre or the performance of a television host.  The celebrant sees the people who see him as the point of reference and there is a risk that, to have the greatest success possible with the public, he makes up gestures and expressions as if he were the main character."

    What would be the right attitude?

    "When the priest knows that it is not he at the center, bu Christ.  In humble service to the Lord and the Church respecting the liturgy and its rules, as something to be received and not to be invented, it means leaving greater room for the Lord, because through the priest as the instrument He can spark the awareness of the faithful."

    Are sermons by lay people also deviations?

    "Yes.  Because the sermon, as the Holy Father says, is the way in which Revelation and the great Tradition of the Church is explained, so that the Word of God can inspire the life of the faithful in their daily choices and render the liturgical celebration rich with spiritual fruits.  The liturgical tradition of the Church reserves the sermon to the celebrant.  To bishops, to priests, and to deacons.  But not to laypeople.

    Absolutely not?

    "Not because they are not capable of doing making a reflection, but because in the liturgy roles must be respected.  There exists, as the Council said, a difference ‘in essence and not only in grade" between the common priesthood of all the baptized and that of priests".

    Some time ago Card. Ratzinger was complaining about the loss in the rites of the sense of mystery.

    "Often the conciliar reform was interpreted or considered in a way not entirely in conformity with the mind of Vatican II.  The Holy Father defines this tendency as the ‘anti-spirit’ of the Council.

    A year now since the full reintroduction of the Tridentine Mass, what is the assessment?

    "The Tridentine Mass has its very profound internal values which reflect the whole tradition of the Church.  There is more respect toward the sacred through gestures, genuflections, the times of silence.  There is greater room reserved for reflection on the action of the Lord and also for the celebrant’s personal sense of devotion, who offers the sacrifice not only for the faithful but also for his own sins and his own salvation.  Some important elements of the old rite can help also a reflection on the manner of celebrating the Novus Ordo.  We are in the midst of a journey.

    Some day in the future is there foreseen a rite that takes the best of the old and of the new?

    "That could be, … but perhaps I don’t see that.  I think that in the coming decades we will move toward a comprehensive evaluation both of the older rite and of the new, safeguarding whatever is eternal and supernatural happening at the altar and reducing every desire to be the in the limelight so as to leave space for effective contact between the faithful and the Lord through the figure, but not predominantly, of the priest."

    With alternative positions of the celebrant?  When the priest would be turned around toward the apse?

    "You could consider the offertory, when the offerings are brought to the priest, and from there all the way to the Eucharistic prayer, which represents the culminating moment of "transsubstantiatio" and "communio".

    The priest who turns his back disorients the faithful.

    "It is a mistake to speak in that way.  On the contrary, he is turned to the Lord together with the people.  The Holy Father, in his book The Spirit of the Council, explained that when people are sitting around looking at each other, a closed circle is formed.  But when the priest and the faithful together a looking to the East, toward the Lord who comes, that is a way of opening up to the eternal".

    In this view you put also the rehabilitation (recupero) of Latin?

    "I don’t like the word ‘rehabilitation’. We are implementing the Second Vatican Council, which explicitly affirmed that the use of the Latin language, except in the case of particular law, was to be preserved in the Latin Rites.  So, if room was also left for the introduction of vernacular languages, Latin wasn’t to be completely abandoned.  The use of a sacred language is a tradition in the whole world.  In Hinduism the language of prayer is Sanskrit, which isn’t in use anymore.  In Buddhism Pali is used, a language which only Buddist monks study.  In Islam the Arabic of the Koran is used.  The use of a sacred language helps us to a lived experience of "transcendence (al di la)". 

    Latin as the sacred language of the Church?

    "Of course.  The Holy Father himself speaks in his Apostolic Exhortation Sacramentum caritatis in paragraph 62: "In order to express more clearly the unity and universality of the Church, I wish to endorse the proposal made by the Synod of Bishops, in harmony with the directives of the Second Vatican Council, that, with the exception of the readings, the homily and the prayer of the faithful, it is fitting that such liturgies be celebrated in Latin."  Of course, in during international gatherings."

    What does Benedict XVI want to accomplish, giving new force back to the liturgy?

    "The Pope wants to offer the possibility of arriving at the wonder of life in Christ, a life that in the very living here on earth already leads us to sense the freedom and the eternity belonging to the children of God.  And this kind of experience is lived powerfully through an authentic renewal of the faith which presupposes a foretaste of the heavenly reality in the liturgy one believes in, one celebrates and one lives.  The Church is, and must become, the powerful instrument and the means for this liberating liturgical experience.  And it is her liturgy that makes it possible to spark such an experience in her faithful".

     

    Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
    27 Comments

    Video: Pope Benedict with his brother on vacation

    There is some nice video from Stefano Maria Paci and SKY TG24 of the Holy Father on vacation in Bressanone, Italy with his brother Msgr. Georg Ratzinger, later joined by the other Msgr. Georg, the private secretary.  The three of them joke around a little.

    In the video the Pope and his brother during their stroll stop before a small and very old statue of Mary and Child.  Mary is teaching Jesus how to bless.  Sweet.

    Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
    12 Comments

    RORATE: on Summorum Pontificum, SSPX, unity – enlightening

    Our friends at Rorate have posted a very interesting interview with Prof. Luc Perrin at the Univ. of Strasbourg about the state of the question of the SSPX, Summorum Pontificum, unity, a year after the Motu Proprio and twenty years about the SSPX split with the Catholic Church.

    My emphases and comments.  Not my translation.

     

     A Historian observes the Catholic moment

    One year of Summorum Pontificum and the SSPX

    Luc Perrin is a professor at the University of Strasbourg, where he teaches History of the Church. Perrin, widely known in Traditionalist circles in France, has written several works on the History of the pre-Conciliar and post-Conciliar trends in the Catholic Church, including on the so-called "Traditionalist Question", such as L’affaire Lefebvre (The Lefebvre Affair) and Paris à l’heure de Vatican II (Paris at the time of Vatican II).

    We have interviewed Professor Perrin twice in the past, and have asked him a few questions on the Catholic moment one year after Summorum Pontificum and on the future of the negotiations of the Holy See with the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Pius X (FSSPX / SSPX).

    ______________________________

    Q: As a historian and as an observer of the Catholic Church in the past decades, do you believe that the motu proprio Summorum Pontificum has been relevant for the universal Church? Has its impact been what you expected when it was published one year ago?

    PERRIN:    First of all, it is important to underline that this 2007 motu proprio can have a major impact only on the long term for various reasons. The vast majority of the clergy and the episcopate worldwide has been trained to see the Ordinary Form of the Roman rite as "the" Rite per se, a so-called "restoration" of a pretended Early Christian times liturgy and "the" liturgy promoted by The Council, the only council they know or want to know [Good point.] i.e. Vatican II. They have a sort of Berlin Wall in their mind that keeps them protected from any interference from the Liturgical Roman tradition. This mental wall is extremely thick and resistant.

        We can see how entranched the neo-liturgical lobbies are at every level (Roman Curia, episcopal committees, diocesan Curia, seminaries, parishes) with one example regarding the Ordinary Form. In most vernacular Masses (English, Italian etc.), "pro multis" is abusively translated into "for all", instead of "for many". John Paul II, with "Liturgiam Authenticam" in 2001, specifically mentioned this abuse, to no effect. Five years later, cardinal Arinze, prefect of CDW [the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments], sent a letter to the bishops where the false translation is currently used asking them to make a "necessary catechesis" of the people within "one or two years" so the change finally comes true. One year passed, a second year is nearly over and guess what … nothing happened. Thus the neo-liturgical establishment has been powerful enough to block the change of … two words during 7 years. The "pro multis" movie is going to stay on the screen for a while : cardinal Arinze recently approved the new translation but for the USA only and he is giving a new … delay to prepare the faithful that should have been prepared during the past two years. But without any specific date. So don’t expect that in one year any substantial change of attitude regarding the Extraordinary Form could have taken place.  [I too am frustrated about the perpetual delays.  However, I think Perrin’s analysis is not entirely fair.]

        Besides, some episcopal attitudes [He means "some bishops"!] have made it clear from the start: the German, Swiss and Polish bishops took a stand of frontal opposition after the release of the document during Fall 2007. In France, episcopal opposition was very vocal before the motu proprio, especially in 2006, but the majority of French bishops adopted a more quiet attitude after July 2007. Wisely, the French Conference of bishops abstained to edit abusive guidelines like in Germany. In general, French bishops refrained to publish anything like open restrictions added to the provisions of Summorum Pontificum, like a few American or Italian bishops initially did. But a "containment policy" is implemented under the leadership of cardinal Vingt-Trois, archbishop of Paris, elected president of French bishops in 2007, especially for his subtle opposition to the pope’s will to free the Traditional Latin Mass. The aim of this policy is to retain a 1984-1988 regime [In other words, pretent that Summorum Pontificum never came out and that we are still living under the provisions of Quattuor abhinc annos and Ecclesia Dei adflicta.] in spite of Summorum Pontificum: bishops want to stay those who allow or not the celebration of the Extraordinary Form, superseding the faculties granted by the pope to the parish pastors and chaplains. Only a minority of French bishops is really open to a generous implementation of the Motu proprio.

        Some facts are illustrating this containment policy: not a single personal parish (article 10) has been erected in France in a year; the 3 existing personal parishes were erected in 2005 and 2006. Not a single seminary has scheduled to systematically train the future priests in the celebration of the Extraordinary Form: in the best cases, like in Toulon under very benevolent Bishop Rey, the eventual volunteers are allowed to attend a training given by local traditionalist priests. One of the most hostile bishops, Archbishop Jordan of Rheims, granted a Mass but for two Sundays per month … The reluctance to call for traditional Institutes is obvious, although it’s not a general rule. In Paris, the cardinal-archbishop is refusing to negotiate a status for the Good Shepherd Institute which has a small conference center (Centre Saint-Paul) and traditional institutes have not a single diocesan apostolate. The contrast is striking with the former president of French bishops, cardinal Ricard, who has in his diocese of Bordeaux two FSSP chapels, one ICR-SP chapel and signed an agreement with the Good Shepherd for Saint-Éloi church in February 2007. So the increase of TLM locations is slow in France though it happens in spite of all these obstacles. According to some observers, around 40 new locations have been added to those existing under the Ecclesia Dei canonical provisions.

        The situation is similar in most European countries, except maybe in Italy where apart from a very hostile lobby, several bishops look at the Motu proprio with an open eye, like Archbishop Bagnasco their president. I have not heard, so far, of a great echo either in Latin America (except for Brazil) or Africa and that was utterly predictable. On the contrary, as for the Ecclesia Dei motu proprio of John Paul II, implementation in the USA and Canada is much more encouraging both from the bishops and clergy. If we remember the hostile position of cardinal Lehmann (Germany), the negative attitude expressed by cardinal Murphy O’Connor (England), the containment policy of cardinal Vingt-Trois, it is amazing to see the benevolent policy of cardinal George, president of USCCB. In his diocese of Chicago (USA), he blessed the Canons of Saint John Cantius (who are celebrating with both Forms) and then invited the Institute of Christ the King (TLM only); the Liturgical Institute founded by the Cardinal is adding a mandatory course on the Extraordinary Form in its program and sessions of training have been organized for volunteers to learn how to celebrate with the Canons and in presence of Bishop Perry, the African American auxiliary Bishop of Chicago, who is known for his attachment to Liturgical tradition.

        In short, Summorum Pontificum’s practical implementation is a replica of Ecclesia Dei’s expansion and limits. [Well… yes and not.  It is less than a year that Summorum Pontificum is in force.  It takes time to build.] So far, PCED [the Pontifical Commission ‘Ecclesia Dei’] has not used its new authority – articles 7,8 and 12 -, just like the Pontifical Commission was not enforcing the provisions of the previous Motu proprio. [There is a lot to consider here.  What would a policy of "enforcement" involve?  Also, what obstacles have been – at least in the past – placed in front of the PCED within the Curia itself?  These obstacles probably still give shape to the interior policy of the Commission.] We have also to remind that it’s not easy, even with a welcoming parish pastor and bishop, for a group of lay people to be constituted in countries like France, where Catholicism is in sharp decline. Moreover, the TLM is very demanding in energy, financial contribution and time for lay people. [I am not so sure about this.  It need not be.  Perhaps in some places where there is literally nothing left of decent things for Holy Mass, or they have to support a priest to do it, this is the case.  I have in mind the Diocese in the USA where the bishops established a place and chaplain for the older Mass but said that he would support it as long as people paid the bills.  People got angry because they were asked to support it financially.  So there are problems to be sure.]   In many aspects, the "active participation" of lay people in the Extraordinary Form Mass communities is superior to what it is in the standard Novus Ordo parish. You need more than one year to build a community.  [Right.  But I get the impression that that realization doesn’t inform all of the comments made here.  But let’s read on.]

        However we should consider two facts that need time to be fully received by the Church. First fact: the status of the traditional Roman rite (Extraordinary Form) has been firmly settled as never before. [But some will complain that it isn’t becaues Benedict XVI changed the Good Friday prayer.  They are wrong, of course, and this guy right.  But that doesn’t change the grousing.] On the very long term, it could help to influence the liturgical studies and consequently the teaching in seminaries and Faculties (see the examples of Mundelein and Kenrick-Glennon seminaries for Chicago and Saint-Louis which are magnets for vocations). The second fact is nearly impossible to evaluate: how many priests, especially young priests in Europe and Northern America, will have a spiritual benefit from article 2? [This is what I maintain is perhaps the single greatest point of importance of Summorum Pontificum.] It could be very interesting to have an inquiry to know the impact of the private celebration in the Extraordinary Form among priests.

        I have constantly drawn attention to the structure of the motu proprio: the extension of the celebration in the parishes comes with article 5 but the right to celebrate privately for priests comes with article 2, i.e. the clergy is the main target of the document. [YES! Excellent! (Has he been reading WDTPRS from the beginning?)] Those who deeply refuse any move in the liturgical field toward Tradition are betting on the 3 year delay mentioned by the pope in his letter to the bishops. They are perfectly aware that Summorum Pontificum requests years and years, decades, to have a serious impact and bears its fruit so the "containment policy": in 2010, they will pretend the motu proprio is a failure and ask it to be rescinded.  [This is really really really important.]

    [Now we switch gears…]

    Q: What are the similarities and the differences in the attitude of the FSSPX [SSPX] and the Holy See in the negotiations of May-June 1988 and of June-July 2008?

    PERRIN:   [Here is a status quaestionis.]  Let us recall the whole process was in three, not two steps: the negotiations of 1988, the second attempt in 2000-2002 that ended with a declaration of Bishop Fellay saying the talks were stalled then the new talks that started after the August 2005 short encounter between pope Benedict XVI and Bishop Fellay.

        We can find some similarities between the 1978 election of John Paul II, who chose to meet Archbishop Lefebvre very quickly after his election and the election of Benedict XVI. But the situations are very different: there was [was] probably still a serious chance to reach a sound canonical agreement in 1988, although it was already difficult at that time like the events of May 5 and 6, 1988 showed. Fr. Tissier de Mallerais was then a member of the SSPX delegation and was urging the Archbishop to sign; [Interesting!] today he is the most vindictive [!] among the four bishops of the Society. He expressed, several times in 2007-2008, a true wrath against pope Benedict XVI, saying that the "horror" [!] of the pope’s theology is letting him "speechless", [Would that that were literally true.] if we can say so for a bishop who has gone very vocal these days. He is now raising the threat of new episcopal consecrations.  [Watch the splintering begin.]

        Archbishop Lefebvre was constantly seeking a canonical status that would give his priests the possibility to "make the experience of Tradition", as he said in 1975-1976. From 1969 to 1975, when the SSPX was suppressed by Bishop Mamie, this was after all the situation of the Society, in full communion with the Holy See, with a statute that was far less favorable than the 2000 proposal of a personal apostolic administration. However the failure of the 1988 agreement was an indication this path was quite dead like Bishop Galarreta said in June 2008.

        In 2000, cardinal Castrillon Hoyos tried to reopen this canonical path: clearly the reluctance was strong on the SSPX side but Bishop Fellay was positively impressed by the open hand of the Holy See. Just like the pope was positively impressed by the decision of the SSPX to participate to the Great Jubilee, in the dioceses and with a big pilgrimage in Rome. But a few months later, Bishop Fellay put the ball in the Roman side with the two prerequisite questions: freedom for the TLM, the excommunications to be lifted. It was a subtle way not to say "yes", without clearly saying "no". [!] This was the beginning of the "in between" policy chosen by Bishop Fellay in order to restore a sense of Romanity within the SSPX: [Interesting.] with years passing by, most Society priests have got only a vague idea of what a "pope" and "Rome" are. [Exactly!  After all this time, there is a whole new generation of followers and now members of the SSPX who have never known anything but conflict and separation, hostility and suspicion in regard to the Pope and Rome.  We have said this here before on WDTPRS.]  So when Bishop Tissier de Mallerais is saying, "In Rome, a new Pope? Really, if he would become worse, there is no need" (The Angelus magazine, interview, July 2008) -, he is probably the voice of many young SSPX priests.

        Pope Benedict XVI is well aware of this feeling and he mentioned the danger of a prolonged schismatic attitude in his 2007 letter to the bishops sent with the Motu proprio and his intent to fight it : "one has the impression that omissions on the part of the Church have had their share of blame for the fact that these divisions were able to harden". His election in 2005 allowed a renewal of the talks with Menzingen but, in spite of the Motu proprio or because of it, this phase inaugurated 8 years ago may come to an end.  [Sad, if his assesment is accurate.]

      [Watch this and keep in mind what I have written about the leadership of the SSPX trying to play to their base when there is any talk of greater unity with Rome.  This is really interesting.]  Regularly, when the SSPX is getting closer to a reconciliation, the leadership breaks up and a period of "cold war" against Rome begins. For example, from 1988 to 2000, there were very few contacts, if any, between Menzingen and Rome. The lack of permanent structures for a negotiation between the Society and the Holy See is most likely one major reason for the regular failure of the talks. It is impossible to work seriously on complex doctrinal matters when you meet briefly at irregular moments.

    Q: What do you believe that the future holds for the Fraternity of Saint Pius X? Is there any hope of reconciliation if not in the Benedictine Pontificate?

    PERRIN:    The bishops of the Society are now saying that "a certain discouragement is coming back" (Bishop Fellay), to quote the most polite statement. Both Bishop Fellay and Bishop Tissier de Mallerais are openly talking of a 30 year delay, and the latter is even excluding frankly any "reconciliation"; Bp Tissier de Mallerais is using words so offensive that he is coming very close to Sedevacantism, [Wow…] though he still refrains to say so. It’s easy to see why there is, to quote Bishop Tissier de Mallerais, "a hardening of the hearts, a blindness of the minds".

        Pope Benedict XVI is strengthening the efforts made by his predecessor to interpret Vatican II "in the light of Tradition", which is exactly what Archbishop Lefebvre was requesting in 1978, [!] after his meeting with the Polish pope. The thorny question of the traditional Roman Missal was, during a long time, an obstacle but with Summorum Pontificum, this obstacle is de jure – as Bishop Fellay acknowledged in the July issue of The Angelus – removed; there are still many problems to make it real within Church life and parishes, but the legitimate status of the 1962 missal, the Extraordinary Form of the Roman rite, is now established.  [Excommunication remains an issue too, though easier to resolve in some ways than some of the doctrinal points.]

        So we are left to face all the other thorny questions as listed by Bishop Tissier de Mallerais: religious liberty, ecumenism, Christian spirit of sacrifice, social kingship of Christ; curiously, the problems raised by inter-faith dialogue is not cited. But to be able to work with Roman theologians on these crucial issues, the SSPX would need some qualified experts and to be able to evaluate the achievements of the Church in the past decades with something more accurate than "John Paul II did nothing to rebuild the Faith" or, speaking of Ecclesia Dei communities, "These poor people (priests, religious, lay people) are liberals and pragmatics" (Bishop Tissier de Mallerais). These conditions are hardly met by the Society today.  [Right.  This is one of the most important things Prof. Perrin has pointed out so far.  He puts it well.  The SSPX just doen’t have anyone at the level needed to undertake the sort of doctrinal discussions the SSPX demands.  I raised this point in other entries when examining the SSPX’s claims.  Do they really think that they could go into a theological discussion with Benedict XVI or those whom he would appoint?  Really? If so, they have better put on their big boy underwear and eat their Wheaties, because they will have very hard days indeed.]

        Bishop Fellay spoke recently of a "road map" to guide the relationship between Rome and Menzingen and this was an excellent idea, keeping open the eventuality of a reconciliation but as a distant goal and with several steps … in between. [Reasonable?  Perhaps.] Cardinal Castrillon Hoyos’ five conditions of June 2008 were a way to request from Bishop Fellay to make a first move, at least a symbolical one. [A very important one, too.  There were theological underpinnings: Who is Peter to the SSPX?  What does "Rome" mean for Catholics?] The June-July 2008 decisions are apparently – the response of Bishop Fellay to the Cardinal has not been published, only an official statement by Fr. Lorans – to store the "road map" in a drawer. [Another period of détente in the Cold War?] When is Bishop Fellay or his successor going to reopen the drawer and give a serious attention to the road map? Will the papal visit to France in September be a providential occasion to do so? What would be the next step if the excommunications are to be lifted ? Providence will tell us. Maybe a Week of Prayer for … Catholic Unity could help.

    And excellent piece.  Very informative.

    Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
    26 Comments

    QUAERITUR: Before the Council we had the TLM, so why did things go wrong?

    I received this from a reader. 

    Good questions are raised in the wake of Summorum Pontificum and "Save the Liturgy Save the World", as well as "Say the Black Do the Red" and many other of the points I raise on this blog and elsewhere.

    I write this note in all sincerity, being a convert of 25 years. I have still never been to anything other than a Novus Ordo Mass but after spending so much time on your site, I am close to finding one to attend. The recent interviews with Fathers Finigan and Paisley were quite compelling. [They will be pleased to know that.]

    Even after following so many discussion threads on WDTPRS (over which my eyes often glaze, esp. concerning the status of the SSPX) I have to ask a question about the cultural assumptions your readers make. You, your guests and your readers all posit that when there is a better translation of the Mass, the priest returns to his stance ad orientem, and the liturgy is offered with reverence, devotion and integrity, the laity will revive and the Church will be strengthened. I understand the theory and how grace works.

    But…. Didn’t we have all of this before the Council? Strengthened by all these things, the bulk of the flock still embraced the sexual revolution with abandon and jettisoned years of this very foundation that your readers propose to be the answer. In fact, speaking primarily with women over the last 20 years, I find that the older women are the ones still whispering to their granddaughters to “be safe,” delay marriage, to get advanced degrees and mark out their independence. I repeat, it’s not the mothers so much as the grandmothers in so many cases, and they were the ones with a better education, more exposure to the old Mass, and time to mature before the real recklessness gained speed.

    One could argue that the Council rattled the faithful at the very time that they needed to stand firm in age-old truths, but the rejection of Humanae Vitae by such a widespread Catholic population (then and now) seems to weaken the case that a better liturgy carries the weight that its worthy supporters propose.

    I don’t mean to be irreverent, but I cannot see that it’s a “silver bullet” [okay] to save us from our current trajectory whose coordinates seem to be self-indulgence and willful blindness. Perhaps I’m of a darker mindset, but I rejoice over the restoration of the EF (from afar) realising that we have the potential to carry a better liturgy (and a host of excellent priests prepared to offer it) into the new catacombs, for sustenance in the coming years.

    It will take repeated attempts to address this before we get something like clarity.  There are tough theological questions at stake.

    Keep in mind that this question will keep popping up:

    • If the TLM was so great, why did things fly apart so fast? 
    • If the Church was so great in the 50’s, why did the 60’s tear her apart so fast? 
    • If Catholics were so well formed, liturgically and otherwise, why did so many dissent and quit and lapse?

    Different ways of phrasing it.  All the same question.

    Critics of Pope Benedict and Summorum Pontificum make fundamental errors when they criticize the derestriction of the TLM based on what happened after the Council.  So do traditionalists.

    Let’s start by responding that the questioner got one point right.

    Absolutely correct is the fact that the TLM is not a "silver bullet".  It is not the cure-all for all the ills of the Church.   I have never made that claim on this blog, in sermons, talks or in my weekly column.  Don’t think when I say "Save the Liturgy Save the World" that I think that the TLM is the only perfect liturgical solution. 

    There is far more at issue.  And at the core of the issue are theological questions.

    We have to make essential distinctions.

    This is all about ecclesiology, that is, our theological understanding of the nature of the Church.   Ecclesiology is itself at the intersection of Christology (who is Christ?) and anthropology (who is man?).

    Throughout history we have had to deal with the errors that result when people forget that Holy Church is a communion of saints and sinners.  St. Augustine said in the midst of the bitter ecclesiological battle that was the Donatist controversy, that the Church is ecclesia permixta malis et bonis… a Church mixed through with good people and bad.  The Lord of the Harvest will sort this out at the end of time. 

    The upshot is that we mustn’t be surprised if we find out that there are sinners in the Church.  We mustn’t be surprised or shocked that bad things happen, or that mistake are made.  We shouldn’t lose a grip on reality and think that just because we enjoy the fullness of membership in Christ’s Church that we are therefore not going to sin any more.

    Seems obvious put like that, no?  But people fall into this trap all the time, through history and also today, in the trad camps and amongst the progressivists.

    We mustn’t be shocked that even though before the Second Vatican Council we had the TLM, full seminaries, the Baltimore Catechism, orders with habits, etc. etc. etc., when we got to the 1960’s things flew apart.  The Church is mixed through with good and bad.  At the heart of who the Church is, there is who man is.  Man is a sinner.

    Also at the heart of who the Church is is who Christ is. 

    Our experience of the Church is shaped in many ways, but the principle and probably most important way is through her official, public, communal prayer which is the liturgy of Mass. 

    Who we are must be experienced in the Mass and who Christ is must be experienced in Mass.

    Let us never forget that before the Second Vatican Council, Holy Church was not Shangri-la, a perfect harmonious entity without sinners.  Mass was often not celebrated with care and reverence.  Often it was. 

    But that really isn’t the point. 

    If we experience Christ as Savior in Holy Mass that experience doesn’t remove the reality of who we are – sinners.

    It doesn’t matter which liturgy we are participating in, TLM or Novus Ordo or Divine Liturgy or Anglican Use, Holy Church will remain a communion of saints and sinners.  Holy Mass can be "perfect" in form or style or execution, but that will not change the fact the nature of man.

    Whether the Church is "exalted" in this world or it goes into the catacombs, the fundamental nature of man will not change.

    The form of liturgy, however, is critically important because it directs our thoughts about who we are and who Christ is.

    I will be writing and speaking on these issues a lot in the future.

    Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
    42 Comments